Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Muppets is Certified Fresh

Plus, Arthur Christmas, Hugo, and three others also Certified Fresh -- a new record!

by | November 22, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a record six Certified Fresh movies, including a Muppet caper (The Muppets, starring Jason Segel and Amy Adams), a special delivery (Arthur Christmas, with voice work from James McAvoy and Hugh Laurie), and a cinematic fantasia (Hugo, starring Asa Butterfield and Chloe Moretz). What do the critics have to say?

The Muppets


It’s been more than a decade since the Muppets were in multiplexes, but critics say it was worth the wait: they find The Muppets to be a joyous musical comedy that preserves the sunny spirit of Jim Henson’s creations while managing to bring the gang into the 21st Century. Kermit, Miss Piggy, Fozzie, and the rest of the Muppets are coaxed out of retirement by Walter (as well as non-Muppets Gary (Jason Segel) and Mary (Amy Adams), a huge fan who’s afraid their old theater is about to be destroyed by shady developers. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Muppets was clearly a labor of love for writer and star Segel, and his respect for the Muppets combined with smartly self-reflexive storytelling results in a movie that should please old fans and young viewers alike. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down all of Jim Henson’s movies, and find out Kermit and Miss Piggy’s Five Favorite Films.)

Arthur Christmas


The good folks at Aardman have made plenty of delightfully offbeat animated films, and critics say the trend continues with Arthur Christmas, a sweet and eccentric dose of yuletide cheer. It’s the story of Santa Claus’ son Arthur (James McAvoy), who must deliver a present to a sad little girl after Papa Noel neglects to visit her house. Along the way, we learn about Santa’s state-of-the-art headquarters up at the North Pole. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Arthur Christmas is endlessly inventive, filled with witty sight gags, wonderful vocal performances, and an unconventional but undeniable sense of holiday cheer.



Martin Scorsese made a family movie? In 3D? He sure did, and critics say Hugo is a dazzling affair, visually rich and emotionally heartfelt in equal measure. Hugo (Asa Butterfield), and orphan living in a Paris train station, teams up with some new friends on a quest to find a secret left to him by his father. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Hugo is an extravagant, elegant fantasy with an innocence lacking in many modern kids’ movies, but it’s also an intensely personal film for Scorsese, one that emanates an unabashed love for the magic of cinema.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Freeform TCA 2017 Adult Swim Sci-Fi Extras Animation discovery FOX Lionsgate Ghostbusters WGN Mystery police drama FX comiccon Oscars Fall TV Rock ABC crime drama Set visit OWN MSNBC 24 frames Watching Series TCM DirecTV American Society of Cinematographers Thanksgiving Writers Guild of America BET APB CMT Trailer Super Bowl Drama serial killer Netflix A&E BBC Sundance Election The CW science fiction Countdown TV Land Musicals Character Guide HBO Crackle LGBTQ Rocky TIFF Disney Marvel Box Office Music Bravo Tumblr PBS Kids & Family SDCC Nominations Syfy Tomatazos Reality Competition adventure Video Games Amazon Action Sneak Peek Trivia dramedy docudrama Hulu ITV Star Trek Country CNN cooking TruTV AMC IFC Red Carpet Masterpiece Disney Channel Winter TV war Teen Food Network PaleyFest Exclusive Video biography BBC America vampires 2015 Spring TV Marathons President SundanceTV Universal DC Comics Winners Photos sitcom Nat Geo Interview Year in Review TCA VICE Pop USA Rom-Com Comedy Grammys GoT travel Emmys MTV sports ESPN boxoffice Logo singing competition aliens Pirates Cosplay RT History Comedy Central Biopics period drama Valentine's Day E! Martial Arts GLAAD TNT CBS Calendar based on movie crime thriller Opinion TBS CBS All Access History NYCC Cartoon Network TV ABC Family Mary Tyler Moore VH1 social media Summer GIFs FXX Certified Fresh Awards 007 X-Men cinemax Horror Star Wars cops Best and Worst Polls and Games Reality Infographic Schedule Fantasy diversity politics thriller Holidays First Look harry potter El Rey technology Comic Book Podcast Premiere Dates Toys Nickelodeon 2016 2017 Superheroes Showtime NBC Fox News Starz Esquire Lifetime