Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones Is a Derivative Fantasy

Plus, You're Next, The World's End, and Blue Jasmine are all Certified Fresh.

by | August 22, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a teenage demon-slayer (The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones, starring Lily Collins and Lena Headey), a band of masked killers (You’re Next, starring Sharni Vinson and Nicholas Tucci), some resilient pub crawlers (The World’s End, starring Simon Pegg and Nick Frost), and a desperate housewife (Blue Jasmine, starring Cate Blanchett and Alec Baldwin). What do the critics have to say?

The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones


When gauging the potential audience for The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones, a classic Hollywood tagline comes to mind: “You read the book. Now see the movie!” In this case, critics say only those familiar with the source novel will be able make much of an emotional investment in this overstuffed, overlong mashup of familiar fantasy elements. Lily Collins stars as a New York City teenager who discovers that she’s from a long line of half-human, half-angel demon-killers; soon, she’s on a mission to rescue her mother and stop a powerful object from falling into the wrong hands. The pundits say The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones may appeal to its target audience, but everyone else is likely to find it derivative, confusing, and short on excitement. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Lena Headey’s best-reviewed movies.)

You’re Next


Question: Will horror buffs ever tire of home invasion thrillers? Answer: Not if they’re made with the energy and unnerving intelligence that runs through You’re Next, which critics say delivers enough bloody fun to rise above its hoary premise. A family get-together at a remote country estate is interrupted when masked, crossbow-wielding psychos start to pick off the house’s inhabitants one by one — that is, until one of them fights back. The pundits say the Certified Fresh You’re Next is an energetic mix of black humor and gore that transcends its predictable setup with invention and panache. (Flip through our gallery of memorable movie masks here.)

The World’s End


Director Edgar Wright and stars Simon Pegg and Nick Frost have parodied zombie flicks (Shaun of the Dead) and cop-buddy action movies (Hot Fuzz) with a warmth that’s hard to resist. The critics say their latest, The World’s End, is another winner, one that sends up apocalyptic sci-fi films with wit and empathy. A group of old schoolmates reunite to embark on an epic pub crawl, but during the course of their journey, our heroes notice that something has gone seriously amiss around them. The pundits say the Certified Fresh World’s End is an inspired bit of lunacy — wild, unpredictable, and often disarmingly compassionate. (Watch our video interviews with Wright, Pegg, and Frost.)

Blue Jasmine


Woody Allen‘s Blue Jasmine goes into wide release this week, and critics say this heartrending tragicomedy boasts an outstanding performance from Cate Blanchett in the title role. Blanchett stars as a well-to-do socialite whose world is upended when her husband’s white-collar criminal activities are unveiled. Now destitute, she moves into her sister’s cramped apartment, offering unwanted advice while hoping to return to her life of luxury. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Blue Jasmine offers up a strong example of Allen’s trademark blend of humor and pathos, and the film is elevated by a fantastic supporting cast.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

canceled dc X-Men lord of the rings American Society of Cinematographers dceu anime ABC Election rotten AMC video movies A24 E! spider-man Nickelodeon streaming Tomatazos 79th Golden Globes Awards psycho Star Trek USA Network 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Esquire worst Pacific Islander Winners Pop TV comic LGBT twilight Fargo Freeform 21st Century Fox Comic-Con@Home 2021 Netflix Binge Guide based on movie USA Walt Disney Pictures Television Critics Association christmas movies spy thriller Paramount independent child's play 007 Epix Chernobyl cooking zero dark thirty indie IMDb TV new star wars movies know your critic festivals cats die hard Cosplay BBC First Look Arrowverse TCM RT21 game show australia docudrama Sony Pictures NBA serial killer black DGA Comics on TV cars Mary Poppins Returns chucky teaser golden globes Travel Channel miniseries Video Games spanish telelvision target Box Office 73rd Emmy Awards mission: impossible Disney Channel Syfy indiana jones fresh dreamworks Disney streaming service Pirates scary wonder woman kids strong female leads supernatural marvel comics binge PaleyFest Logo President disaster Universal SundanceTV Television Academy Emmys BAFTA dragons medical drama scene in color MSNBC historical drama Family best Columbia Pictures documentary biography robots rt labs CBS All Access Disney Crackle screen actors guild Sundance king kong james bond TV One sopranos First Reviews Toys adaptation Spike revenge Ghostbusters The Academy Image Comics Showtime Stephen King Warner Bros. E3 Song of Ice and Fire 2015 news 2021 Kids & Family cancelled TV series cancelled TV shows Fall TV Watching Series Cannes Amazon 71st Emmy Awards Nat Geo doctor who deadpool Avengers Fantasy TNT OneApp Grammys crime thriller Hallmark Christmas movies boxoffice NBC BET Awards Writers Guild of America TCA Winter 2020 Women's History Month talk show vs. blaxploitation Universal Pictures Thanksgiving ITV Mystery CMT GoT Premiere Dates concert cinemax Mudbound singing competition kong classics posters comiccon Superheroes San Diego Comic-Con Sci-Fi Marathons rotten movies we love Superheroe spanish language Apple TV+ Best and Worst Winter TV award winner olympics action-comedy animated DC streaming service latino docuseries superman sequels Hollywood Foreign Press Association vampires scorecard LGBTQ Paramount Network Extras Countdown New York Comic Con book adaptation aapi Comedy Central Food Network Reality Competition zombies boxing trophy game of thrones Amazon Studios golden globe awards HBO Go young adult television festival south america new zealand Character Guide Shondaland documentaries Britbox Lifetime Christmas movies dogs Schedule blockbusters royal family Marvel Television sports FOX Black Mirror cancelled Classic Film zombie hollywood mutant Mary Tyler Moore finale franchise El Rey french Film sitcom streaming movies Tubi Tokyo Olympics Funimation foreign Animation parents quibi asian-american comic book movies Horror psychological thriller ghosts Western The CW aliens Apple TV Plus godzilla archives Pop women Anna Paquin movie hidden camera FX on Hulu Set visit Action 4/20 ABC Signature Ellie Kemper IFC Films NYCC Marvel Studios PBS spain black comedy Quiz Elton John renewed TV shows TV Prime Video versus ratings The Arrangement SDCC TBS Martial Arts canceled TV shows stand-up comedy basketball Red Carpet Hallmark slasher stop motion Exclusive Video Peacock Spring TV Comic Book gangster 2020 genre 2019 laika Super Bowl 99% APB TCA Pride Month police drama Teen war Star Wars Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Musicals Lucasfilm Neflix joker werewolf VOD nfl crossover Shudder marvel cinematic universe live event breaking bad hist Sundance TV rt archives video on demand ID adenture Nominations elevated horror toy story 24 frames WGN witnail razzies Comedy halloween tv travel ESPN rom-coms unscripted SXSW free movies TCA Awards Film Festival Pixar Starz composers Interview pirates of the caribbean TruTV hispanic heritage month romance DirecTV cops Fox Searchlight WarnerMedia Valentine's Day monster movies justice league Reality BET dexter critic resources Vudu 1990s YA a nightmare on elm street cults leaderboard Calendar superhero Alien Bravo Infographic ViacomCBS Rom-Com feel good universal monsters Musical directors Creative Arts Emmys Broadway Academy Awards Certified Fresh cartoon Endgame TCA 2017 what to watch Brie Larson richard e. Grant PlayStation suspense 45 space Biopics harry potter TV Land Lifetime series Opinion Tarantino tv talk 2017 Drama spinoff National Geographic Rocketman Paramount Plus TV renewals Tumblr History kaiju facebook sag awards Emmy Nominations trailers Sundance Now Summer japan mob Apple Baby Yoda romantic comedy Netflix Christmas movies 90s italian HBO Podcast 72 Emmy Awards Country Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spider-verse fast and furious YouTube Red worst movies technology Marvel comic books all-time legend thriller social media Spectrum Originals IFC Disney Plus MCU football screenings political drama Wes Anderson theme song TV movies heist movie emmy awards comics casting Disney+ Disney Plus CNN Polls and Games CW Seed VICE BBC America 93rd Oscars Tags: Comedy satire jamie lee curtis nbcuniversal dramedy 2018 comedies Year in Review GIFs VH1 criterion art house Christmas high school Crunchyroll Awards Legendary transformers films Trivia halloween The Witch true crime comic book movie slashers TIFF mcc remakes Acorn TV japanese new york reviews DC Comics reboot MTV Discovery Channel DC Universe ABC Family anthology YouTube Premium jurassic park See It Skip It science fiction politics Photos live action king arthur The Walking Dead biopic crime drama cancelled television Black History Month Ovation mockumentary Sneak Peek Trailer Amazon Prime Video natural history Mary poppins critics Hear Us Out stoner OWN dark Instagram Live Holidays book discovery BBC One sequel Trophy Talk The Walt Disney Company venice Fox News Turner Rocky green book Music Cartoon Network rt labs critics edition The Purge international Hulu Amazon Prime FXX Mindy Kaling Adult Swim children's TV blockbuster Awards Tour Captain marvel obituary name the review hispanic 2016 YouTube HFPA prank Oscars Lionsgate TLC debate nature Heroines Rock Pet Sematary HBO Max diversity crime scary movies FX GLAAD period drama Turner Classic Movies adventure toronto Holiday AMC Plus RT History popular saw 20th Century Fox Dark Horse Comics A&E batman CBS Masterpiece