Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Amazing Spider-Man Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Savages is uneven, pulpy fun, and Katy Perry: Part of Me is Certified Fresh.

by | July 5, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a legendary web-slinger (The Amazing Spider-Man, starring Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone), a deadly cartel (Savages, starring Taylor Kitsch and Salma Hayek), and a teenage dream (the 3D concert documentary Katy Perry: Part of Me). What do the critics have to say?

The Amazing Spider-Man


The Spider-Man franchise might have set a record for the quickest reboot, though critics say The Amazing Spider-Man is still entertaining, gritty, action-packed stuff — even if we’ve seen it all before. It’s the story of how Peter Parker (Andrew Garfield) gets bitten by a radioactive spider, becomes a superhero, develops a relationship with Gwen Stacy (Emma Stone), and battles a supervillain named the Lizard. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Amazing Spider-Man covers some pretty well-trodden ground, but Garfield and Stone are excellent and the action sequences pack a wallop. (Check out 24 Frames for a pictorial rundown of Marvel characters on the big screen.)



Oliver Stone may have mellowed in recent years, but critics say Savages is a return to the disreputable Stone films of old — one that’s messy, but often queasily compelling. A couple of friends (Taylor Kitsch and Aaron Johnson) run a profitable marijuana-dealing business, but a fearsome Mexican drug cartel led by the ruthless Elana (Salma Hayek) insists on a partnership – with severe consequences if they refuse. The pundits say Savages is tonally uneven and a bit overlong, but it’s also exuberantly pulpy and features fine supporting turns from Benicio Del Toro and John Travolta. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Stone’s best-reviewed movies.)

Katy Perry: Part of Me


At first glance, Katy Perry: Part of Me looks like a tricked-out infomercial, but critics say it’s a rousing and brightly-colored concert documentary that gives some insight into the star’s offstage life. The film follows Perry on her “California Dreams” world tour, capturing her eye-popping stage show as well as archival footage of her younger days and glimpses of backstage drama. The pundits say that even if the Certified Fresh Katy Perry: Part of Me doesn’t delve too deeply, it’s still a revealing portrait of a likeable pop star dealing with the rigors of life on the road.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

cooking GoT TCA discovery Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt NYCC Oscars Marvel GIFs Pirates Interview Holidays Ellie Kemper cinemax Pop Polls and Games Animation Fall TV Nickelodeon Calendar psycho justice league social media E3 crime Crackle Opinion medical drama Sci-Fi Esquire BET cats Comedy FXX historical drama dc DC Universe ABC TBS USA IFC science fiction political drama SundanceTV Star Trek Universal Fox News 21st Century Fox singing competition war Netflix Set visit Emmys Hulu crime drama technology Winners talk show Warner Bros. Thanksgiving Tumblr DC Comics Dark Horse Comics Ghostbusters Marathons based on movie Masterpiece Grammys Countdown Lionsgate Action AMC Trailer Summer Infographic Reality PaleyFest SDCC Toys Logo adventure Sundance composers Musical serial killer Reality Competition 24 frames TCA 2017 dceu 45 Comedy Central Nominations Lifetime TLC Disney Cosplay harry potter crime thriller TCM vampires Horror CBS Rom-Com Best and Worst Food Network romance Character Guide dramedy supernatural TNT TruTV zombie Star Wars VICE Martial Arts Writers Guild of America El Rey Year in Review A&E X-Men TV Land Superheroes Extras Awards Fantasy Mary Tyler Moore what to watch Mindy Kaling Trivia Red Carpet transformers RT History Sneak Peek Election comiccon Rock FX Adult Swim History FOX WGN Spring TV docudrama Watching Series 2017 Freeform period drama Teen LGBTQ thriller President E! GLAAD APB Kids & Family 007 Rocky Drama Mystery 2015 Cartoon Network Bravo Photos cops Video Games politics Musicals OWN Certified Fresh MSNBC ESPN Starz BBC boxoffice police drama Tomatazos Country The Arrangement travel HBO Biopics TV binge DirecTV Syfy TIFF Premiere Dates biography Western The CW sitcom First Look CMT 2016 MTV VH1 CNN Disney Channel Amazon American Society of Cinematographers Box Office Comic Book Music ABC Family aliens Paramount Showtime ITV Super Bowl CBS All Access Podcast NBC Schedule YA BBC America Valentine's Day diversity sports Winter TV PBS Nat Geo