Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Killing Them Softly Is Certified Fresh

Plus, The Collection improves a bit on its predecessor.

by | November 29, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an efficient enforcer (Killing Them Softly, starring Brad Pitt and Richard Jenkins) and a methodical madman (The Collection starring Emma Fitzpatrick and Josh Stewart). What do the critics have to say?

Killing Them Softly


The economic collapse of 2008 didn’t just deep six Wall Street — it put the squeeze on the underground economy as well. That’s the theme of Killing Them Softly, a twisty crime thriller that critics say is sharply written and visually striking, though it occasionally pushes its big ideas too hard. After a couple of incompetent crooks steal from a mafia-sanctioned poker game, the family sends Jackie Cogan (Brad Pitt) to rub them out. However, the mafia’s corporation-like structure makes Jackie’s task more complicated at nearly every turn. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Killing Them Softly doesn’t always match its outsized ambitions, but it’s still a thoughtful, visceral foray into gangland built around Pitt’s magnetic performance. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Pitt’s best-reviewed movies.)

The Collection


The Collection is a sequel to the 2009 frightfest The Collector, and critics say it’s an improvement — it’s a sleek, twisted, and well acted, though it intermittently gets bogged down in predictability and gratuitous bloodiness. Thinking she’s going to a party, Elena (Emma Fitzpatrick) is taken to a mysterious location, only to wind up in the clutches of the murderous Collector. In order to retrieve her, a rescue squad turns to Arkin (Josh Stewart), the only one to ever escape the Collector’s clutches. The pundits say The Collection will please gorehounds with its grisly inventiveness, but others are likely to blanch at its over-the-top violence.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

prank king arthur Lifetime Christmas movies PaleyFest chucky 21st Century Fox Star Wars Black History Month adventure MSNBC A24 Funimation classics Brie Larson Super Bowl black Sundance TV Winners Crunchyroll saw Pacific Islander Instagram Live The Academy adenture space Best Actress Rom-Com Best Director cancelled television children's TV Columbia Pictures Legendary Box Office cancelled Thanksgiving rom-coms GoT singing competition Amazon Studios monster movies harry potter period drama know your critic james bond Music festivals HFPA witnail 90s Nat Geo Geeked Week RT History criterion Trailer comics Alien broadcast NYCC Summer FXX Song of Ice and Fire die hard aapi spider-man TV One 79th Golden Globes Awards werewolf ratings Set visit best action-comedy true crime police drama Video Games dark italian Cosplay dramedy USA Network Pixar CW Seed X-Men Election christmas movies olympics breaking bad suspense Netflix Britbox GLAAD El Rey Extras Mystery DirecTV crime thriller Avengers Arrowverse screenings romantic comedy trophy YouTube Premium blaxploitation independent VICE YouTube Crackle Comedy Central dexter latino Christmas Oscars TV movies leaderboard summer TV preview Lifetime The Walking Dead TCM PBS series ESPN zombie deadpool indiana jones Sci-Fi kaiju 2018 FX on Hulu nfl based on movie Pop Paramount live event Television Critics Association cartoon films Amazon television Universal interviews scary movies football sequels The Walt Disney Company cancelled TV shows cinemax Rock SXSW 2022 disaster President comedies Prime Video Marvel Television Holiday Superheroes CBS Disney Channel Cartoon Network Disney Plus asian-american Native cults sequel Mary poppins Apple TV Plus VH1 007 Photos 2017 SDCC Neflix Television Academy psychological thriller TLC Epix summer preview mob romance Film South by Southwest Film Festival Bravo elevated horror First Reviews Freeform Year in Review HBO Go 4/20 black comedy king kong superhero Awards Tour The Witch TV crime Focus Features casting reboot ID Comedy marvel cinematic universe robots book obituary dceu travel TNT Cannes Superheroe Drama comiccon Tags: Comedy Travel Channel pirates of the caribbean royal family Reality Competition mission: impossible marvel comics twilight boxing ViacomCBS E! Chernobyl Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comic Quiz social media Tokyo Olympics hispanic heritage month YA target TCA Awards rotten movies we love Fox News theme song Rocky Writers Guild of America Paramount Pictures LGBTQ young adult Interview Premiere Dates spy thriller Mary Poppins Returns critics FX Black Mirror name the review dreamworks Musicals Shondaland docudrama hollywood Hallmark canceled a nightmare on elm street Family cooking teaser Sundance Indigenous AMC Universal Pictures Sony Pictures scorecard Paramount Plus Action OWN 73rd Emmy Awards south america composers Red Carpet Kids & Family Tumblr Nickelodeon award winner scene in color series BET streaming spinoff cats live action AMC Plus cancelled TV series stop motion Mindy Kaling venice renewed TV shows Musical Toys cars Paramount Network MCU Opinion 99% movie Comic-Con@Home 2021 E3 stoner DC Comics Marathons science fiction thriller vs. video Academy Awards ABC Family 45 jurassic park hispanic ITV Comics on TV DGA Emmys franchise sopranos DC Universe Syfy San Diego Comic-Con docuseries Elton John legend facebook diversity golden globes japanese telelvision discovery international Schedule stand-up comedy Oscar Teen heist movie Reality NBA Fox Searchlight sag awards NBC Animation rotten richard e. Grant parents HBO Max Vudu game of thrones video on demand superman documentary Marvel CNN natural history BBC blockbusters Sundance Now scene in color IFC Films Film Festival GIFs Comic Book remakes Western Amazon Prime Video Best Picture lord of the rings New York Comic Con blockbuster godzilla sports Discovery Channel Grammys anime dc CMT game show justice league Acorn TV war See It Skip It Star Wars Celebration Food Network ABC 94th Oscars supernatural kids BET Awards Turner finale spanish language trailers vampires toy story what to watch The CW slashers satire 93rd Oscars LGBT Dark Horse Comics sitcom The Arrangement Certified Fresh unscripted Best Actor dragons technology summer TV obi wan Rocketman child's play rt labs Star Trek aliens Pride Month worst Character Guide The Purge Binge Guide news scary Spike TIFF Country BBC One movies politics hist Turner Classic Movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina laika canceled TV shows Tarantino indie SundanceTV new york halloween tv nbcuniversal wonder woman comic book movie OneApp free movies Nominations Marvel Studios versus Ovation adaptation archives Ellie Kemper streaming movies new zealand Peacock biopic BAFTA screen actors guild scene in color film series MGM ABC Signature Heroines transformers talk show Tubi Ghostbusters toronto reviews MTV ghosts Baby Yoda Stephen King Showtime Broadway WarnerMedia biography Holidays emmy awards concert Martial Arts anthology strong female leads VOD serial killer critic resources crossover revenge Emmy Nominations streamig spanish Podcast Lucasfilm green book medical drama Apple spider-verse high school women documentaries Calendar Netflix Christmas movies Mary Tyler Moore Disney+ Disney Plus mutant zombies Winter TV Infographic historical drama book adaptation target scene in color Esquire feel good TV Land new star wars movies Sneak Peek Valentine's Day APB Starz kong joker Hulu Classic Film FOX PlayStation Best and Worst IFC nature 24 frames boxoffice political drama HBO TBS festival crime drama Tomatazos comic book movies universal monsters french YouTube Red Fall TV Exclusive Video History miniseries Creative Arts Emmys Wes Anderson slasher Lionsgate TruTV Horror Disney mcc Apple TV+ rt labs critics edition gangster Trophy Talk jamie lee curtis Pop TV foreign WGN IMDb TV fresh 72 Emmy Awards 2015 Image Comics National Geographic Fantasy rt archives TV renewals razzies directors Warner Bros. Spectrum Originals First Look 20th Century Fox halloween CBS All Access TCA quibi Spring TV Hallmark Christmas movies Endgame basketball art house 71st Emmy Awards Amazon Prime posters spain American Society of Cinematographers Disney streaming service Pirates Awards Adult Swim golden globe awards Trivia TCA 2017 doctor who Biopics 2020 Sony RT21 A&E 2016 Hollywood Foreign Press Association 2019 cops fast and furious Mudbound Fargo SXSW USA australia Polls and Games 2021 Countdown batman Women's History Month TCA Winter 2020 all-time binge Pet Sematary Walt Disney Pictures Watching Series mockumentary hidden camera tv talk japan BBC America Shudder Hear Us Out animated genre DC streaming service zero dark thirty psycho comic books Anna Paquin debate Masterpiece 1990s popular Logo worst movies dogs 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Captain marvel