Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Divergent Disappoints

Plus, Muppets Most Wanted is Certified Fresh.

by | March 21, 2014 | Comments


This week at the movies, we’ve got individuality under attack (Divergent, starring Shailene Woodley and Kate Winslet) and Kermit under lock and key (Muppets Most Wanted, starring Ricky Gervais and Tina Fey). What do the critics have to say?



Based on a series of popular young adult novels, Divergent is a sci-fi allegory about the dangers of conformity. Ironically, critics say the biggest problem with the film is that it borrows too heavily from the likes of The Hunger Games and Harry Potter, leaving its terrific cast stranded in a sea of exposition. In a dystopian future, teenagers are forced to chose one of five factions with which they’ll associate for life. However, Beatrice Prior (Shailene Woodley) doesn’t fit neatly into any one group, and her independent streak makes her a target when two rival tribes prepare for war. The pundits say Woodley gives a star-making performance, and her supporting cast is top-notch, but Divergent is too grim and jumbled to fully resonate. (Check out our gallery of co-star Kate Winslet in some of her most memorable roles.)

Muppets Most Wanted


“Everybody knows that the sequel’s never quite as good,” sing Kermit and Fozzie in the opening scene of Muppets Most Wanted. The operative word here is “quite,” for the critics say that while this caper comedy lacks the breezy charm of The Muppets, it’s got enough laughs and catchy tunes to entertain in its own right. Hot off their successful reunion show, the Muppets decide to take their act on the road, but things quickly go amiss when they sign up with a fast-talking booking agent (Ricky Gervais) who’s in league with a wanted criminal mastermind — and who looks exactly like Kermit the Frog. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Muppets Most Wanted maintains the anarchic spirit of the Muppets, and if the story isn’t as strong this time out, the rapid-fire gags are reliably witty and inventive. (Check out our video interviews with the cast, as well as our rundown of the best films from the Jim Henson Company.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Vicente Torres and Nat Brautigam for coming the closest to guessing The Single Moms Club‘s 17 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

italian BET Awards Rock cancelled TV series Food Network Tarantino spy thriller basketball TV renewals Premiere Dates zero dark thirty obituary unscripted The Purge Image Comics AMC comics The Academy Grammys Marvel science fiction Mindy Kaling ITV spanish language Sony Pictures adaptation die hard kids Esquire Black History Month animated book Rocky Writers Guild of America Holidays ratings high school criterion cats IFC Films YouTube Red Black Mirror supernatural mission: impossible medical drama Christmas The Walking Dead crime thriller posters Fantasy heist movie parents Heroines Polls and Games TV movies japan french Showtime halloween tv Mary poppins revenge psychological thriller chucky Paramount Network 2017 spanish jurassic park comic books Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt transformers Certified Fresh indie Arrowverse 71st Emmy Awards TruTV NBC Thanksgiving Animation Cannes historical drama Horror marvel comics hollywood Turner Classic Movies franchise YA A&E fresh children's TV superman Disney+ Disney Plus OneApp X-Men miniseries History worst movies 4/20 Reality Competition Amazon Studios FX on Hulu aapi travel 1990s reboot rom-coms Superheroe SDCC Holiday cancelled television PaleyFest VH1 2018 Columbia Pictures A24 IFC pirates of the caribbean dexter Photos Super Bowl Lionsgate Comedy Central latino crime justice league TV docuseries Music 2015 Western ID toronto Cosplay TLC Exclusive Video critics a nightmare on elm street Character Guide 93rd Oscars romance BBC One mcc tv talk HBO Go wonder woman Walt Disney Pictures ABC Signature 20th Century Fox Ghostbusters Quiz Acorn TV Dark Horse Comics Interview dc Year in Review DC streaming service Tomatazos GIFs Disney streaming service comic book movie The CW Disney Best and Worst Pacific Islander Mary Poppins Returns comiccon comic Disney Plus south america Television Critics Association TCA GLAAD adventure Universal Comic Book NBA Awards Tour Legendary Lifetime Countdown DC Universe Cartoon Network Shudder dramedy halloween HBO ABC Family scary movies Tokyo Olympics Comic-Con@Home 2021 versus stop motion Sci-Fi rt labs Apple TV Plus Elton John adenture YouTube blockbusters Comedy Hear Us Out NYCC razzies spinoff discovery MTV Amazon Prime Schedule Amazon Prime Video boxoffice natural history TNT TCA 2017 batman rotten movies we love name the review directors PlayStation USA Network MSNBC zombies Fox News james bond Paramount Family Country television TCA Awards young adult Apple cars zombie Chernobyl Spectrum Originals psycho sequels FXX Pop TV Crunchyroll toy story FOX debate Tubi Anna Paquin golden globe awards Fox Searchlight Calendar crime drama Brie Larson RT21 serial killer Winners Vudu Funimation Epix new york Extras japanese anthology Alien Captain marvel disaster quibi Martial Arts godzilla black DirecTV Sundance prank Starz kaiju hispanic heritage month police drama dceu American Society of Cinematographers joker Television Academy robots 72 Emmy Awards rotten suspense slashers award winner HBO Max Drama ESPN cops true crime Hulu mutant 45 satire 21st Century Fox romantic comedy facebook Hallmark Christmas movies Netflix Christmas movies Tumblr Emmy Nominations series worst Crackle Lucasfilm WGN theme song cancelled Rocketman Britbox San Diego Comic-Con USA BET werewolf ghosts superhero Ellie Kemper Winter TV TCA Winter 2020 GoT free movies Marathons Pirates scene in color docudrama El Rey critic resources VOD all-time period drama Spike 007 live action richard e. Grant royal family SXSW stand-up comedy 2021 crossover cancelled TV shows biography Toys Nickelodeon lord of the rings dark E! target elevated horror biopic Sundance TV 2020 dragons reviews 2016 Song of Ice and Fire Emmys comedies 2019 sitcom video on demand Turner news trailers screen actors guild Nominations political drama Marvel Television Kids & Family hidden camera nature golden globes Comics on TV politics CBS All Access Baby Yoda Women's History Month social media DC Comics anime aliens Pride Month composers New York Comic Con Mystery emmy awards See It Skip It classics football Masterpiece Summer rt archives Amazon CBS BBC America films vampires streaming feel good Binge Guide The Witch Adult Swim book adaptation game of thrones Fall TV spider-man women space stoner Oscars Travel Channel ABC gangster Syfy Sneak Peek 73rd Emmy Awards cults strong female leads blaxploitation harry potter scorecard Endgame Disney Channel DGA documentaries Apple TV+ Rom-Com MCU LGBT Discovery Channel OWN 90s PBS VICE Pixar President CNN saw renewed TV shows Infographic festival canceled TV shows nfl talk show deadpool Wes Anderson Stephen King king arthur Broadway binge new star wars movies sag awards spain Warner Bros. international The Walt Disney Company CMT The Arrangement popular Film independent Sundance Now Action Election Superheroes Pet Sematary Classic Film action-comedy Musical Netflix Shondaland green book TBS christmas movies witnail universal monsters telelvision Watching Series boxing sports child's play diversity Logo thriller RT History Trivia Mudbound Lifetime Christmas movies venice documentary screenings best archives nbcuniversal australia Marvel Studios Set visit what to watch Video Games based on movie 99% Pop asian-american king kong Hallmark Podcast canceled TV Land TCM rt labs critics edition singing competition foreign Awards Red Carpet cartoon technology marvel cinematic universe Reality comic book movies Star Wars streaming movies First Reviews game show cooking BBC Peacock BAFTA Mary Tyler Moore legend TV One CW Seed Valentine's Day concert fast and furious doctor who Trophy Talk video Avengers Freeform Musicals SundanceTV National Geographic new zealand Box Office Ovation blockbuster Star Trek 24 frames monster movies Teen Academy Awards war movies E3 sequel Paramount Plus twilight FX laika casting festivals Nat Geo WarnerMedia indiana jones ViacomCBS TIFF APB Biopics cinemax finale Film Festival LGBTQ First Look breaking bad hist jamie lee curtis remakes dogs kong movie YouTube Premium 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards teaser slasher Trailer Opinion Bravo hispanic Chilling Adventures of Sabrina mockumentary Creative Arts Emmys know your critic olympics Spring TV