Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Atonement is Certified Fresh, One Missed Call Not Screened

Three days into the new year and we have our first not-screened movie!

by | January 3, 2008 | Comments

week at the movies, we’ve got cell phone shivers (One Missed Call,
starring Shannyn Sossamon and
Edward Burns) and a sweeping war drama/romance (Atonement,
starring Keira Knightley and
James McAvoy). What do the critics have to say?

period romance/war drama
has been generating some serious Oscar
buzz, and critics say it’s a worthy awards-season entry. Based upon
Ian McEwan‘s
widely praised novel, Atonement tells the story of Brionly (Saoirse
Ronan), a 13-year-old who (intentionally or not) sabotages a budding romance
between her posh sister Cecilia (Keira Knightley) and the more blue-collar Robbie (James McAvoy); with World War II on the horizon, all three of their lives will
change forever. Critics say director
Joe Wright‘s adaptation does an outstanding
job of translating the source material’s multilayered complexity to the screen
while maintaining a riveting sense of irony and romantic longing throughout;
strong performances from Knightley, McAvoy, and newcomer Ronan don’t
hurt, either. At 85 percent on the Tomatometer, Atonement is not only
Certified Fresh, it’s the statistical equal of the previous Wright-Knightley collabo,
Pride and Prejudice
. (Read our interviews with Wright
here and McAvoy
here; also, check out
RT’s Editors’ Picks for 2007, since Atonement
made several of our lists.)

Worst. Candygram. Ever.

appears the folks behind
One Missed Call
forgot to add film critics to
their "friends and family" plan, since the movie wasn’t screened before release.
In this remake of a J-horror flick of the same name, people find audio of the
final moments of their lives on voicemail — before they’ve even expired. Kids,
stop calling those 900 numbers and guess that Tomatometer.

“To shreds, you say?”

opening this week in limited release:

  • The Killing of John Lennon
    , the
    story of Mark David Chapman’s descent into madness, is at 48 percent on the Tomatometer.

  • The Korean slash-fest
    A Bloody Aria
    is at 33 percent.

    Chapman considers a blind purchase.

And congratulations to m_ioannidis for guessing Alien vs. Predator: Requiem‘s 16 percent Tomatometer last week! Makes you just want to go out and facehug somebody.

James McAvoy Movies:
89% — Starter for Ten (2007)
58% — Becoming Jane (2007)
88% — The Last King of Scotland (2006)
76% —
The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe

50% — Rory O’Shea Was Here (2005)

Tag Cloud

reviews Ghostbusters best Tumblr Thanksgiving cartoon Britbox blockbuster adaptation quibi Trophy Talk disaster Kids & Family Shudder remakes LGBTQ The Academy twilight Paramount Network Peacock french OneApp USA worst comiccon teaser Sci-Fi TCA Awards Tubi name the review mutant BBC 2015 Song of Ice and Fire Apple TV+ talk show Oscars Film 21st Century Fox Academy Awards CBS dceu Rom-Com cancelled television Mudbound First Look President stop motion IFC HBO Max Adult Swim Sundance TV Amazon Prime richard e. Grant Video Games cops elevated horror Turner Classic Movies OWN Funimation directors Christmas book Baby Yoda Grammys X-Men USA Network Sneak Peek rt archives rotten versus TruTV thriller dramedy Amazon Studios die hard Logo canceled TV shows italian witnail Showtime Western movies TV 2016 Action Trivia MSNBC nature spy thriller 2019 crime ghosts Countdown YouTube Red news werewolf Comedy DC Comics Musical critics Netflix Turner Spring TV Fantasy Film Festival nfl FOX Esquire The Arrangement Pirates screenings Hallmark 24 frames sports Hear Us Out Television Academy Disney Plus The Witch E3 harry potter politics GIFs casting Schedule TNT series mockumentary ITV Amazon Family batman Summer WGN Podcast Rocketman Valentine's Day venice Winter TV NYCC Trailer true crime Box Office HBO Mary Poppins Returns SundanceTV a nightmare on elm street spain dragons MCU reboot theme song dogs discovery Music indiana jones Mary Tyler Moore APB Calendar Chilling Adventures of Sabrina PlayStation Certified Fresh strong female leads Holiday DGA Epix FX on Hulu historical drama boxoffice crime drama Fox News Nominations BET HBO Go SXSW mission: impossible Shondaland VH1 A24 rotten movies we love archives robots Holidays Sundance Now ABC game of thrones psychological thriller Lifetime Christmas movies Apple TV Plus Cartoon Network medical drama toronto films crime thriller Pet Sematary Chernobyl Set visit Comic Book renewed TV shows LGBT Watching Series TIFF TCM Dark Horse Comics Classic Film tv talk FXX transformers social media Musicals VOD Apple The Purge Super Bowl Brie Larson blaxploitation singing competition worst movies facebook japanese zero dark thirty documentaries TV renewals Polls and Games Reality Columbia Pictures 4/20 adventure Extras Drama canceled Hulu cancelled TV shows Anna Paquin james bond cars free movies ID Discovery Channel Creative Arts Emmys breaking bad anime YA criterion game show Amazon Prime Video universal monsters asian-american New York Comic Con Marvel Studios festivals Universal slashers sequels Sony Pictures 2020 movie Rocky Character Guide YouTube Premium Horror foreign Black History Month TCA 2017 halloween tv jamie lee curtis supernatural green book doctor who video Lucasfilm Masterpiece comedies sequel Women's History Month Pop TV 2018 ratings halloween scorecard Biopics Fall TV cults Tarantino space Tomatazos travel cancelled TV series CBS All Access PBS superhero cinemax Emmy Nominations nbcuniversal Walt Disney Pictures Star Wars Crunchyroll indie psycho romantic comedy children's TV Cannes Arrowverse See It Skip It dc San Diego Comic-Con Stephen King TCA Fox Searchlight E! chucky south america christmas movies parents Quiz Paramount BAFTA 20th Century Fox El Rey biography Superheroe TCA Winter 2020 streaming joker television SDCC period drama what to watch Ellie Kemper The CW cooking Best and Worst RT21 Emmys Reality Competition FX Awards 2017 Marvel CNN Winners cats comic books Comedy Central DC streaming service Freeform hispanic Travel Channel Teen aliens laika vampires Warner Bros. sitcom Toys Endgame cancelled TBS ABC Family 72 Emmy Awards kids BET Awards police drama Mystery Awards Tour 007 diversity revenge Syfy golden globes anthology BBC One BBC America football classics independent sag awards CMT Animation Mindy Kaling American Society of Cinematographers Disney+ Disney Plus Country Hallmark Christmas movies Opinion MTV Food Network deadpool spanish Disney Pride Month AMC Marathons Bravo Disney Channel Vudu science fiction unscripted Ovation A&E Spectrum Originals comic Sundance First Reviews Superheroes Photos award winner latino Crackle Netflix Christmas movies finale TV Land composers stand-up comedy 45 zombies miniseries Election Nickelodeon festival 71st Emmy Awards GLAAD RT History obituary Black Mirror Spike Binge Guide hollywood spanish language war technology PaleyFest DC Universe DirecTV NBC video on demand ESPN Television Critics Association docudrama political drama fast and furious History Rock serial killer Disney streaming service zombie IFC Films hist Elton John binge TLC Writers Guild of America VICE Avengers documentary Marvel Television Lifetime black justice league natural history based on movie Acorn TV The Walking Dead australia Mary poppins animated Lionsgate Heroines Starz spinoff Interview Red Carpet satire Nat Geo dark Cosplay concert screen actors guild franchise National Geographic GoT YouTube comics Pop stoner Infographic Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pixar scary movies Star Trek Martial Arts WarnerMedia crossover emmy awards Premiere Dates toy story Comics on TV child's play Captain marvel Year in Review all-time CW Seed romance spider-man