Chucky vs. Annabelle: Who Wins the Ultimate Murder Doll Showdown?

We crunch the numbers to see who emerges victorious when these toys of terror face off.

by | June 20, 2019 | Comments

Earlier this month we compared two cinematic titans in our Godzilla vs. King Kong showdown; this week we’re looking at two smaller-scale destroyers, Chucky and Annabelle. Both are returning to screens this month: First up, Chucky arrives rebooted – and with the voice of Mark Hamill – in the new Child’s Play; then the Conjuring Universe’s mischief-making little cutie returns in Annabelle Comes HomeBut which doll is the most terrifying? Our host Mark Ellis pits them against each other in a special episode of Vs., comparing the two dolls and their film histories by Tomatometer, box office, kills, and in one special bonus round. Check out who gets top shelf position above.

Child’s Play is in theaters June 21 | Annabelle Comes Home is in theaters June 26

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Amazon San Diego Comic-Con 20th Century Fox movies romance Binge Guide History slashers high school PBS ABC Signature Nominations ABC Family Premiere Dates Cosplay Photos crime drama TCA Awards The Witch The Academy chucky cinemax adventure Pop TV Character Guide Stephen King free movies name the review RT21 BET Classic Film stand-up comedy ViacomCBS marvel cinematic universe versus mockumentary sequel OWN based on movie pirates of the caribbean 71st Emmy Awards 90s Columbia Pictures mission: impossible Crackle Pride Month crime thriller Oscars Schedule Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Marvel Television A24 Holiday razzies NBA spider-man christmas movies jurassic park 2020 45 Creative Arts Emmys Hallmark ghosts American Society of Cinematographers HBO ABC Pet Sematary Anna Paquin black Superheroe suspense 2016 Wes Anderson Music fresh dceu cars Nickelodeon Box Office cooking 21st Century Fox cops President police drama Amazon Studios Mystery Sneak Peek nbcuniversal casting National Geographic Mudbound diversity book First Look Year in Review doctor who Walt Disney Pictures Nat Geo Fantasy The Walt Disney Company Film Festival joker Watching Series 2017 OneApp adenture king kong Horror Mary Poppins Returns golden globes Awards Tour video on demand dark X-Men true crime Set visit Women's History Month rt archives sitcom Election unscripted crossover Biopics Emmys Shondaland Disney Holidays Alien Warner Bros. IFC Films E3 transformers Drama comic books Lionsgate rom-coms comic book movies universal monsters Winter TV Star Trek Disney Plus critic resources WGN robots hispanic series BBC America strong female leads Adult Swim Video Games art house women Academy Awards thriller hidden camera action-comedy rotten Mary poppins TCM vs. live action posters Food Network Paramount Plus 2019 Teen Action Amazon Prime Video animated toy story all-time Opinion supernatural mob Acorn TV Polls and Games psychological thriller Toys king arthur 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Awards Trivia Rock MCU asian-american GIFs cancelled screen actors guild Ovation remakes archives Lucasfilm comic book movie zombies anthology Comedy Central classics Logo Heroines twilight superman historical drama green book political drama popular a nightmare on elm street indiana jones Black History Month mcc binge DirecTV TIFF fast and furious Travel Channel spinoff 99% BBC One 72 Emmy Awards south america natural history travel films Trophy Talk genre LGBT Interview scorecard feel good disaster blockbusters BAFTA adaptation rotten movies we love Summer Disney Channel GLAAD harry potter golden globe awards Comedy hist halloween tv Tokyo Olympics TBS black comedy The Arrangement Pirates Animation Legendary Trailer technology movie Valentine's Day 24 frames GoT festivals DGA HBO Max Reality Competition talk show blockbuster Elton John indie scary Universal Pictures ITV DC Comics Peacock directors CNN scary movies Netflix Christmas movies MSNBC australia jamie lee curtis Pop Television Academy Baby Yoda Cannes Certified Fresh elevated horror stoner kong children's TV Best and Worst Christmas YouTube Red VH1 Marathons NYCC Starz godzilla halloween live event heist movie new star wars movies young adult breaking bad WarnerMedia Musical Sundance TV Spike Rocketman PaleyFest kaiju hispanic heritage month BBC TLC Comic-Con@Home 2021 PlayStation kids cancelled television 73rd Emmy Awards Marvel sopranos emmy awards video First Reviews canceled miniseries venice SXSW international IMDb TV rt labs FXX Pacific Islander Family Amazon Prime boxoffice cults Podcast Endgame Hear Us Out period drama spanish language monster movies Super Bowl parents HBO Go deadpool serial killer wonder woman IFC nfl debate 007 Comic Book richard e. Grant news Exclusive Video dreamworks japanese franchise finale TV One Black Mirror Lifetime Christmas movies Film spider-verse Rocky USA TCA 2017 Chernobyl Brie Larson what to watch social media VICE satire 4/20 cancelled TV series dexter Reality Television Critics Association Hulu Ellie Kemper werewolf AMC Extras revenge japan Funimation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt blaxploitation AMC Plus Song of Ice and Fire dragons justice league Britbox Crunchyroll NBC toronto Bravo spy thriller See It Skip It book adaptation Calendar Country TCA Winter 2020 Spring TV anime Quiz SDCC Freeform Grammys TV game of thrones boxing Captain marvel screenings comic Fox News laika Mary Tyler Moore best marvel comics comics Infographic CBS All Access canceled TV shows Cartoon Network Sundance Now Syfy Fall TV renewed TV shows 2015 Winners Star Wars Instagram Live scene in color The Purge YouTube Premium Disney+ Disney Plus politics Spectrum Originals saw facebook nature The Walking Dead superhero Pixar war MTV VOD Rom-Com ESPN worst Fox Searchlight Arrowverse james bond reboot Comics on TV Apple gangster mutant concert streaming movies die hard Esquire batman El Rey stop motion cats zero dark thirty comedies Image Comics YA lord of the rings quibi Turner Classic Movies Tomatazos prank Marvel Studios slasher Martial Arts psycho Red Carpet new york DC streaming service Universal TV renewals Disney streaming service TNT Ghostbusters telelvision new zealand legend critics USA Network composers vampires television theme song zombie A&E New York Comic Con dogs Dark Horse Comics FOX The CW Musicals SundanceTV Apple TV+ dc Emmy Nominations Lifetime italian obituary Turner E! LGBTQ streaming crime space child's play sag awards Apple TV Plus 1990s Sci-Fi Tarantino Showtime Sundance cancelled TV shows ID hollywood documentaries rt labs critics edition independent olympics basketball game show FX royal family Neflix dramedy Western TV movies Countdown singing competition discovery 2021 RT History latino APB cartoon 2018 Masterpiece docudrama CMT Mindy Kaling TruTV sequels foreign sports CW Seed TV Land french aapi reviews medical drama worst movies spanish Avengers YouTube CBS spain documentary trailers Discovery Channel ratings criterion biopic science fiction comiccon Sony Pictures aliens Thanksgiving Hallmark Christmas movies BET Awards 93rd Oscars Paramount FX on Hulu Superheroes Tubi target Netflix Epix Paramount Network teaser award winner TCA Vudu witnail DC Universe docuseries Shudder football biography tv talk Kids & Family Writers Guild of America romantic comedy festival know your critic Tumblr Broadway