Critics Consensus

Bohemian Rhapsody Will Rock You, Eventually

Plus, The Nutcracker and the Four Realms is a beautiful mess and Homecoming season 1 and House of Cards season 6 are Certified Fresh.

by | November 1, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a legendary singer (Bohemian Rhapsody, starring Rami Malek and Lucy Boynton), a classic fantasy retold (The Nutcracker and the Four Realms, starring Mackenzie Foy and Keira Knightley), and a tale of two sisters (Nobody’s Fool, starring Tiffany Haddish and Tika Sumpter). What are the critics saying?


Bohemian Rhapsody (2018) 60%

For a certain segment of the moviegoing audience, the words “Bohemian Rhapsody” immediately invoke images of Wayne, Garth, and crew headbanging in an AMC Pacer. That memorable scene spawned a new generation of fans who would discover the music of Queen — and its charismatic frontman Freddie Mercury — for the first time, and this week, Bryan Singer‘s Bohemian Rhapsody seeks to do the same. Ostensibly centered on Mercury (played by Rami Malek), the film covers 15 years of the singer’s life, including the formation of the band and its spectacular rise, and culminates in the band’s legendary 1985 Live Aid performance at Wembley Stadium. Critics say that although the film plays like an abridged biography and handles Mercury’s sexuality and drug issues with kid gloves, Malek is electric in the role, and the climactic performance is appropriately dazzling. Those expecting an in-depth character study may be disappointed, but Queen fans are likely to sing right along in their seats, particularly during the spectacular Live Aid sequence.


The Nutcracker and the Four Realms (2018) 32%

German writer E.T.A. Hoffmann’s The Nutcracker and the Mouse King has been entertaining children in various forms for literally centuries since it was first published in 1816, most notably as a ballet scored by Tchaikovsky. In film, the story has been adapted either fully or in part several times, and we get the latest iteration in this week’s The Nutcracker and the Four Realms, directed by Lasse Hallström. Mackenzie Foy stars as the young girl who travels to a parallel world full of fantastical creatures where she must face off with a tyrannical Helen Mirren. Unfortunately, critics say Four Realms falters as a holiday tale and offers little in the way of compelling storytelling or sensational setpieces, even if it’s quite pretty to look at. It may make for a visual distraction for the kids, but it may also leave you scratching your head.


Nobody's Fool (2018) 25%

Tyler Perry hasn’t exactly been a critical darling over the last decade or so, but that hasn’t slowed him down one bit. This week, we get his latest offering, a comedy called Nobody’s Fool (not a remake of the 1994 Paul Newman movie) starring Tiffany Haddish and Tika Sumpter as two sisters whose lives have taken dramatically opposite directions. Wild child Tanya (Haddish) has just been released from a prison stint and reunites with her straight-laced sister Danica (Sumpter); as it turns out, Danica may be in over her head with her mysterious new boyfriend, and Tanya’s just the one to help. We’d love to tell you what critics thought of Nobody’s Fool, but it wasn’t screened for critics (or anyone, really). You know what that means: Guess that Tomatometer!


What’s New on TV

Homecoming: Season 1 (2018) 97%

An impressive small-screen debut for Julia Roberts, Homecoming balances its haunting mystery with a frenetic sensibility that grips and doesn’t let go.


House of Cards: Season 6 (2018) 65%

House of Cards folds slightly under the weight of its labyrinthian ending — thankfully Robin Wright‘s commanding performance is strong enough to keep it standing strong.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Number 37 (2018) , a Rear Window-inspired thriller about a wheelchair-bound criminal who witnesses a murder in an adjacent apartment building, is at 100%.
  • Infinite Football (2018) , a documentary about a former Romanian soccer player’s efforts to reduce injuries in the sport, is at 100%.
  • The Grief of Others (2015) , a drama about a family grieving the loss of a newborn son whose lives are changed by an unexpected visitor, is at 100%.
  • Maria by Callas: In Her Own Words (2017) , a documentary chronicling the life of the legendary opera singer, is at 96%.
  • Searching for Ingmar Bergman (2018) , a documentary celebrating the life of the influential Swedish director, is at 92%.
  • Unlovable (2018) , a drama about a sex addict who connects with a musician on her road to recovery, is at 92%.
  • Bodied (2017) , about a grad student whose sudden rise in the battle rap scene causes controversy, is Certified Fresh at 91%.
  • A Private War (2018) , starring Rosamund Pike and Jamie Dornan in a drama about journalist Marie Colvin, who died while covering the Syrian civil war in 2012, is at 90%.
  • They'll Love Me When I'm Dead (2018)Morgan Neville‘s Netflix original documentary about Orson Welles‘ efforts to complete his film The Other Side of the Wind (also out this week) before his death, is at 89%.
  • In Search of Greatness (2018) , a documentary exploring the nature of athletic success via interviews with elite athletes in various sports, is at 88%.
  • Possum (2018) , a horror film about a disgraced puppeteer who confronts dark secrets from his past, is at 86%.
  • Boy Erased (2018) , starring Joel Edgerton, Nicole KidmanLucas Hedges, and Russell Crowe in Edgerton’s drama about a bay teen who is sent to conversion therapy by his religious parents, is at 83%.
  • Distant Constellation (2017) , a documentary about the lively residents of a Turkish retirement home, is at 82%.
  • Prospect (2018) , a sci-fi thriller about a father and daughter who encounter unexpected trouble while mining for gems on an alien moon, is at 80%.
  • The Other Side of the Wind (2018) , Orson Welles’ Hollywood satire about an aging director attempting a comeback — which was completed after Welles’ death — is at 78%.
  • Rampant (2018) , a period horror film about a zombie outbreak in ancient Korea, is at 71%.

Tag Cloud

lord of the rings razzies CBS All Access APB strong female leads First Look black Musicals kaiju basketball Image Comics GoT suspense Pet Sematary SXSW 2022 halloween Neflix Crackle Nat Geo legend die hard medical drama new zealand Song of Ice and Fire ABC NBC Paramount San Diego Comic-Con theme song Winter TV animated versus interviews Endgame Best Actor 71st Emmy Awards TCA 2017 casting marvel comics what to watch Fargo Year in Review OWN HFPA biography archives political drama video award winner Fantasy obituary boxing AMC TV Land prank E3 Film DirecTV singing competition CMT Rocky FX ViacomCBS LGBTQ christmas movies TCA Winter 2020 National Geographic indie new star wars movies crime drama Comedy Central 1990s A24 hist Anna Paquin Avengers TNT Spectrum Originals cancelled rt labs critics edition Calendar target rt archives Hulu Disney Plus zombie Premiere Dates 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Tomatazos spinoff Dark Horse Comics Funimation facebook Disney DC streaming service Fox Searchlight Comics on TV spider-man DC Comics chucky renewed TV shows high school war CW Seed pirates of the caribbean Christmas Pacific Islander historical drama RT History hispanic heritage month The Walt Disney Company USA space kids Winners scary sopranos comic books Wes Anderson GIFs mob BET Awards documentary New York Comic Con Paramount Plus reviews dark streaming movies mcc reboot rotten movies we love PlayStation Reality psycho BBC America WGN TLC dexter 2016 Disney+ Disney Plus asian-american heist movie Schedule BBC sequels BAFTA binge Amazon Action marvel cinematic universe screenings robots toronto Broadway finale slashers TCA Awards TV Kids & Family MCU Polls and Games Certified Fresh Sundance TV science fiction japan Apple cancelled TV series Film Festival Interview mockumentary trophy RT21 Ghostbusters LGBT critics sitcom VICE scary movies Adult Swim scene in color satire Apple TV Plus blaxploitation 94th Oscars indiana jones natural history 93rd Oscars Oscar emmy awards Focus Features NYCC south america Epix sag awards golden globes worst movies miniseries Stephen King supernatural golden globe awards Disney streaming service anime unscripted based on movie Comic Book comics 21st Century Fox australia Emmys Mystery canceled TV shows justice league Hollywood Foreign Press Association broadcast latino cops El Rey Awards MSNBC A&E Marvel Studios 007 X-Men serial killer YouTube Premium fast and furious spain Pop TV Superheroe Tumblr witnail Shudder 2020 tv talk comiccon The Arrangement debate Marathons hollywood IFC Films Spring TV saw Tarantino Fox News cinemax dceu Character Guide docudrama Fall TV HBO olympics travel BET comic OneApp name the review critic resources HBO Max Esquire Lifetime Christmas movies Peacock nfl gangster Trivia Baby Yoda popular Hear Us Out aapi Food Network slasher football technology Oscars Warner Bros. NBA documentaries crime thriller Netflix Christmas movies 99% Walt Disney Pictures Travel Channel 45 Star Wars talk show batman foreign diversity President CBS nature Rocketman TV One Trophy Talk Television Critics Association Syfy Tokyo Olympics TV renewals FXX trailers comic book movie screen actors guild new york classics 2018 blockbuster Podcast Comic-Con@Home 2021 live event jurassic park action-comedy best Pride Month Best and Worst Star Trek dramedy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Television Academy DC Universe stand-up comedy E! Spike stop motion comic book movies Acorn TV game of thrones cartoon Sci-Fi superhero obi wan police drama Britbox Binge Guide Turner Classic Movies Mindy Kaling Universal Pictures DGA french teaser psychological thriller remakes richard e. Grant spanish Marvel cancelled TV shows Video Games Masterpiece Teen kong South by Southwest Film Festival TV movies Columbia Pictures Amazon Prime Nickelodeon Mary poppins Best Actress mutant cancelled television Brie Larson movie Black History Month SundanceTV Logo Reality Competition rotten Infographic Cannes 4/20 hidden camera Cosplay canceled Pixar Watching Series free movies biopic Shondaland MTV concert Paramount Network summer preview comedies Disney Channel CNN independent 73rd Emmy Awards Extras MGM universal monsters Freeform 79th Golden Globes Awards rt labs vampires Photos AMC Plus Rom-Com zero dark thirty dogs sports 2015 Amazon Prime Video Heroines book adaptation vs. Hallmark child's play WarnerMedia Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Vudu films adenture adaptation revenge zombies Countdown History Showtime IFC Chernobyl worst game show VH1 composers news Bravo 20th Century Fox VOD 2021 royal family Drama italian stoner ABC Signature The Witch king kong green book Trailer The Academy Starz black comedy TCM spanish language joker Ovation See It Skip It Legendary Election PBS FOX king arthur hispanic Comedy Apple TV+ movies franchise television Box Office spy thriller Opinion cars art house superman Summer Tubi adventure Animation twilight ESPN quibi festival 2019 Set visit Red Carpet venice video on demand YouTube international Arrowverse book harry potter The Walking Dead Classic Film 72 Emmy Awards posters Ellie Kemper Universal Toys Rock women Best Picture deadpool Grammys USA Network Biopics GLAAD dragons Emmy Nominations scorecard wonder woman IMDb TV Alien Nominations Mary Poppins Returns HBO Go cats Academy Awards Best Director Sundance Now blockbusters ratings laika social media all-time rom-coms Super Bowl Lifetime doctor who a nightmare on elm street werewolf aliens ID criterion Pirates Marvel Television Tags: Comedy ABC Family discovery toy story Prime Video Valentine's Day 90s young adult TCA TruTV anthology mission: impossible spider-verse disaster boxoffice Thanksgiving festivals transformers Awards Tour telelvision TIFF cooking YA Hallmark Christmas movies Captain marvel Instagram Live directors live action Elton John james bond Pop Quiz Horror Sundance TBS Lucasfilm children's TV 2017 ghosts Exclusive Video Creative Arts Emmys parents godzilla First Reviews cults know your critic Mary Tyler Moore Family 24 frames crossover elevated horror Holiday Crunchyroll halloween tv Martial Arts Mudbound Writers Guild of America Western Discovery Channel Sony Pictures Amazon Studios ITV genre American Society of Cinematographers Paramount Pictures fresh SDCC period drama dc Musical feel good streaming leaderboard Black Mirror summer TV Cartoon Network series thriller romance monster movies Superheroes Holidays sequel SXSW PaleyFest BBC One Netflix true crime Sneak Peek romantic comedy jamie lee curtis YouTube Red docuseries politics nbcuniversal Women's History Month The Purge breaking bad streamig Turner japanese dreamworks Music Lionsgate FX on Hulu summer TV preview The CW Country crime