Critics Consensus

Beauty and the Beast Is Beautiful But A Bit Too Familiar, and Iron Fist Is a Marvel Misstep

Plus, The Belko Experiment is gleefully brutal but uneven, and T2: Trainspotting and Trial & Error are Certified Fresh.

by | March 16, 2017 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have Disney’s latest live-action fairy tale (Beauty and the Beast, starring Emma Watson and Dan Stevens) and a really bad day at the office (The Belko Experiment, starring John Gallagher Jr. and Adria Arjona). What are the critics saying?


Beauty and the Beast (2017) 71%


If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again. And if you do succeed? You can add a few new ingredients to the mix and try again anyway — as Disney’s ongoing streak of live-action remakes makes clear, the odds are pretty decent that you might hit another home run. With this weekend’s Beauty and the Beast, the studio is out to breathe fresh box-office life into the tale (as old as time) of a cursed prince whose castle becomes a young girl’s prison — and whose, ahem, beastly appearance hides a heart she can’t help falling for. With Bill Condon in the director’s chair, a cast that includes Emma Watson and Dan Stevens as the titular lovebirds, and some of the same songs that helped captivate audiences during the animated classic, all the ingredients seem to be there for another irresistible romance — and if this pass at the story doesn’t quite reach its predecessor’s lofty heights, critics say it gets close enough to make it worth a watch. Fans of Disney’s original Beauty may feel it suffers by beggaring comparisons to its predecessor, but if you haven’t seen that version — or can temper your expectations accordingly — this remake should make for a suitably sweet night out at the movies.


The Belko Experiment (2017) 54%


If you like your action (or your horror) high-concept, The Belko Experiment dangles what might seem like an irresistible premise: an office full of Americans working in Bogotá suddenly finds their building under lockdown — and under the command of mysterious figures demanding that they either kill their coworkers or be killed themselves. It’s a nifty setup, and one whose on- and offscreen pedigree suggests great things; with a script by James Gunn and a cast that includes John C. McGinley and Michael Rooker, the genre thrills should flow as freely as the B-movie gore. Unfortunately, that isn’t quite the case — critics say that while this isn’t exactly a failed Experiment, it’s neither as gonzo as it could be nor as smart as it thinks, which undermines its attempts at satire and makes it harder to enjoy as a straight-up action thriller. A mixed bag not without its moments, Belko could still be worth checking out… but unless you’re really into this stuff, it might be best to wait for the rental.


What’s New on TV

Trial & Error: Season 1 (2017) 86%

Trial & Error hilariously parodies the true-crime genre with consistent laughs, irreverently funny “stupid humor,” and animated characters who populate the show’s dependably entertaining narratives.


Marvel's Iron Fist: Season 1 (2017) 20%

Despite some promising moments, Iron Fist is weighed down by an absence of momentum and originality.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Tickling Giants (2017) , a documentary about Egyptian political satirist Baseem Youssef‘s journey from heart surgeon to public figure, is at 100 percent.
  • Betting on Zero (2017) , a documentary probe of the multi-level marketing corporation Herbalife, is at 100 percent.
  • After the Storm (Umi yori mo mada fukaku) (2017) , about a creatively adrift author at a crossroads with his estranged family, is at 97 percent.
  • The Devil's Candy (2017) , about a dream home that becomes a paranormal nightmare for an artist and his family, is at 92 percent.
  • Mean Dreams (2017) , starring Bill Paxton as a corrupt cop whose double dealings get tangled in his teenage daughter’s love life, is at 83 percent.
  • Frantz (2017) , about the unlikely bond that develops between a veteran and a young woman grieving over the death of her fiancé, is at 78 percent.
  • T2 Trainspotting (2017) , director Danny Boyle‘s belated sequel to the 1996 classic, is Certified Fresh at 74 percent.
  • Song to Song (2017) , a Terrence Malick drama about life and love among musicians in Austin, is at 56 percent.
  • They Call Me Jeeg (Lo chiamavano Jeeg Robot) (2017) , about a criminal on a quest for vengeance after obtaining superpowers in an accident, is at 50 percent.
  • Atomica (Deep Burial) (2017) , about a safety inspector who encounters strange goings-on at an isolated nuclear power plant, is at 14 percent.

Tag Cloud

Ovation TCA 4/20 Sony Pictures scary movies A24 SundanceTV TNT batman based on movie VOD TIFF Pixar Hallmark Paramount Network kids crime thriller Masterpiece canceled twilight dramedy Photos classics Pop TV 21st Century Fox satire crossover Travel Channel south america crime drama 99% Amazon Studios Grammys toronto festival Western television New York Comic Con Sneak Peek Emmy Nominations TCM movie cops Rocky Superheroes Nat Geo Rom-Com deadpool werewolf TLC Britbox Anna Paquin PlayStation LGBTQ Musical Pop facebook TV Quiz versus Television Academy YouTube Red vampires Brie Larson IFC Films supernatural FXX Syfy VICE Freeform MTV DirecTV Action First Reviews space spanish sports game of thrones YouTube DC Universe stop motion Hallmark Christmas movies Kids & Family universal monsters The Walking Dead Certified Fresh quibi unscripted documentaries First Look documentary CNN NYCC ITV Classic Film justice league nature TCA Winter 2020 cooking Music adventure Chernobyl halloween tv name the review psycho Marvel Studios worst cartoon Election sequel Spectrum Originals cinemax black movies Tubi Spike boxing historical drama Lucasfilm Valentine's Day Nickelodeon italian Nominations TBS TV renewals strong female leads CBS All Access Shondaland IFC adaptation aliens Emmys fresh President 2017 sitcom children's TV ABC Family Superheroe GIFs Food Network christmas movies PaleyFest Marvel Television Sci-Fi Hulu MSNBC Mary Tyler Moore sag awards green book See It Skip It Trophy Talk Tomatazos romantic comedy harry potter police drama Podcast canceled TV shows comedies Columbia Pictures Opinion discovery Country Comics on TV remakes Character Guide Rock Mindy Kaling hist Apple TV+ social media FX hispanic APB free movies DC Comics binge Baby Yoda OWN ratings spinoff Christmas BAFTA franchise indiana jones concert blaxploitation Super Bowl CW Seed japanese natural history renewed TV shows Box Office Trailer tv talk reviews Awards Tour Family Pet Sematary thriller Fall TV WarnerMedia WGN films Ellie Kemper ghosts serial killer cancelled television TCA Awards Black Mirror Year in Review Sundance Amazon Prime Video medical drama Black History Month mockumentary Rocketman Trivia richard e. Grant Tarantino all-time obituary Lionsgate cancelled TV series Turner Classic Movies Star Trek 2020 National Geographic Sundance TV mutant 72 Emmy Awards The Witch Captain marvel politics Reality Walt Disney Pictures boxoffice Paramount slashers anthology YA reboot BBC One Interview Mudbound war disaster Television Critics Association composers parents Tumblr joker Red Carpet RT21 video on demand The CW psychological thriller E3 Cannes X-Men jamie lee curtis ABC Avengers golden globes Video Games foreign comiccon video rotten 71st Emmy Awards dc Peacock Academy Awards Martial Arts Schedule AMC diversity Holiday Shudder news indie Thanksgiving Mary poppins HBO Max A&E Mary Poppins Returns Star Wars crime Lifetime Christmas movies archives sequels Marathons nfl venice football game show Bravo stoner cars cats latino stand-up comedy Winners festivals Disney+ Disney Plus Hear Us Out Adult Swim docudrama Polls and Games Universal Biopics LGBT travel Apple TV Plus hollywood TruTV SDCC Holidays cancelled nbcuniversal History Endgame Marvel Funimation mission: impossible Stephen King Song of Ice and Fire comic Disney Plus screenings FX on Hulu streaming period drama Apple BBC America Best and Worst theme song Chilling Adventures of Sabrina die hard critics Arrowverse Binge Guide child's play Lifetime ESPN Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt spain Creative Arts Emmys CBS dark Dark Horse Comics cancelled TV shows 2018 Calendar VH1 HBO El Rey Netflix BET Awards Showtime transformers RT History screen actors guild GLAAD rt archives YouTube Premium Film Festival E! FOX superhero Cartoon Network Alien HBO Go talk show Premiere Dates USA Women's History Month Infographic best Elton John james bond halloween miniseries 20th Century Fox ID Spring TV french USA Network what to watch SXSW dceu revenge finale Toys DGA 2015 elevated horror 2016 Amazon 45 biography singing competition Turner robots zero dark thirty TV Land GoT blockbuster series Extras Netflix Christmas movies TCA 2017 Watching Series Comedy Central Film The Academy Esquire award winner Comedy American Society of Cinematographers worst movies rotten movies we love breaking bad independent Disney technology teaser Ghostbusters Disney Channel spanish language Sundance Now Disney streaming service anime Cosplay Oscars Pirates 24 frames asian-american toy story fast and furious animated comics spider-man romance book The Arrangement Writers Guild of America Drama directors Summer witnail Mystery doctor who Winter TV 007 casting Epix australia Countdown MCU Animation Awards OneApp Comic Book BBC PBS true crime spy thriller Logo Acorn TV San Diego Comic-Con chucky zombie Crunchyroll Teen Musicals zombies political drama laika Set visit comic books science fiction Crackle criterion Heroines Warner Bros. cults Fantasy 2019 Reality Competition a nightmare on elm street Starz Vudu Amazon Prime Fox News Horror Discovery Channel Pride Month dragons The Purge BET Fox Searchlight CMT dogs emmy awards scorecard DC streaming service NBC