Critics Consensus

Alien: Covenant Is Certified Fresh

Plus, Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Long Haul isn't worth the trip, and Everything, Everything is a tepid weepie.

by | May 18, 2017 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have a group of people no one can hear scream (Alien: Covenant, starring Michael Fassbender and Katherine Waterston), the continuing saga of a less-than-assertive young man (Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Long Haul, starring Jason Drucker and Owen Asztalos), and a pair of young star-crossed lovers (Everything, Everything, starring Amandla Stenberg and Nick Robinson). What do the critics have to say?

Alien: Covenant (2017) 65%

The first two chapters in the Alien saga were so close to flawless that the failures of their subsequent sequels were almost preordained — and yet the allure of the franchise’s sturdy premise continues to prove a powerful draw for audiences as well as the director who helped start it all. With this weekend’s Alien: Covenant, Ridley Scott continues building on the Alien origin story he started in 2012’s Prometheus, introducing audiences to another ill-fated space crew whose dreams of a utopian mission are destined to go horribly (and gorily) wrong. Like its predecessor, reviews describe Covenant as a solidly entertaining sci-fi horror outing whose nagging failures are magnified by its evident desire to tackle weighty themes it never satisfactorily addresses — and, of course, its connection to a couple of modern classics. Yet those flaws aren’t enough to keep the majority of critics from recommending the movie, which compensates for a somewhat uneven narrative with strong acting (particularly from Michael Fassbender in a dual role) and plenty of pulse-pounding xenomorph action. And remember, Alien fans: if you like this, Scott’s got at least a couple more installments up his sleeve.

Diary Of A Wimpy Kid: The Long Haul (2017) 18%

Aging out of a role is a fact of life for any franchise actor, but time can be particularly cruel to child stars. To wit: the Diary of a Wimpy Kid series, whose original junior stars are now too old to fit their parts, and have been replaced as part of a top-to-bottom casting overhaul for the fourth installment, Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Long Haul. Unfortunately, that roster of fresh faces (which includes Alicia Silverstone and Tom Everett Scott as our wimpy kid’s parents) hasn’t improved the franchise’s critical fortunes. While never exactly an acclaim magnet, earlier Wimpy Kid movies managed middling reviews; not so The Long Haul, whose road-trip plot opens up the canvas without adding much of actual interest. If your tastes run toward pratfalls and family-friendly scatological humor, make a beeline for the theater posthaste — but for everyone else, this chapter offers a particularly poor substitute for the best-selling books on which it’s based.

Everything, Everything (2017) 45%

A boy, a girl, a seemingly insurmountable obstacle: this is the stuff YA love stories are made of, and Everything, Everything is no exception. Adapted from Nicola Yoon’s novel, this teen-targeted romance seeks to make viewers swoon over the story of a housebound teenager (Amandla Stenberg) whose rare illness prevents her from leaving the safety of her sterile environment — but can’t keep her from falling for the boy next door (Nick Robinson), who’s determined to be with her despite her condition. If three-hankie romances are your thing, in other words, you’ve seen more than a few variations on this type of thing before, and it won’t surprise you to learn that critics aren’t exactly falling over themselves with praise. On the other hand, in the context of the genre, the limited number of reviews have been somewhat surprisingly kind, describing a viewing experience that — while certainly predictable and a little manipulative — more or less achieves its limited goals. If you’re in the mood to cry in the dark with some strangers this weekend, Everything, Everything should just about fit the bill.

What’s New on TV


Downward Dog: Season 1 (2017) 85%

The adorable and insightful — though sometimes grating — titular pet elevates Downward Dog from its potentially “ruff” premise into a sweet, intellectual comedy.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Elián (2017) , a documentary look at the headline-grabbing tale of young refugee Elián González, is at 100 percent.
  • The Survivalist (2017) , a post-apocalyptic drama about the fraught connection between three people fighting for their lives, is at 97 percent.
  • Paint It Black (2017) , starring Alia Shawkat as a woman grappling with her grief over the death of her boyfriend — and facing a looming confrontation with his mother — is at 93 percent.
  • Icaros: A Vision (2017) , about the unusual bond that develops between a woman and an Amazonian shaman through ayahuasca, is at 86 percent.
  • Wakefield (2017) , starring Bryan Cranston as a man who abandons his family under exceedingly odd circumstances, is at 83 percent.
  • Abacus: Small Enough to Jail (2017) , a documentary about the only bank indicted in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, is at 81 percent.
  • Soul on a String (2017) , about a Tibetan cowboy’s quest to return a sacred stone to a holy mountain, is at 80 percent.
  • Afterimage (Powidoki) (2017) , about an artist’s increasingly miserable experiences under socialist rule, is at 77 percent.
  • The Commune (Kollektivet) (2017) , about the complex repercussions of a couple’s decision to open their home to a group of strangers, is at 72 percent.

Tag Cloud

CBS Western justice league talk show television TNT BBC America Epix theme song TV renewals christmas movies PaleyFest streaming foreign book TIFF witnail Tomatazos TBS green book Discovery Channel 007 canceled cinemax asian-american indie Superheroes Countdown Nominations FX Emmys Certified Fresh best Comedy Central APB Valentine's Day Endgame Cartoon Network Emmy Nominations Mary Poppins Returns Marathons festivals E3 elevated horror BBC One ghosts VOD Cosplay quibi TCM Marvel Television breaking bad SDCC richard e. Grant 2015 sag awards critics ITV Interview FXX mission: impossible Christmas Anna Paquin sequel 2019 Comedy Thanksgiving sports Paramount Network Pride Month Lifetime BAFTA A&E Mudbound El Rey Schedule latino political drama discovery TCA crime drama DC Universe ESPN Star Trek 71st Emmy Awards Film name the review thriller Arrowverse Action National Geographic Rocky Food Network Box Office BET Drama serial killer unscripted OWN Song of Ice and Fire Baby Yoda reboot supernatural Biopics The Purge Disney Plus Martial Arts LGBTQ batman Walt Disney Pictures Trivia stand-up comedy First Reviews screen actors guild technology Polls and Games Mystery Kids & Family Winter TV sitcom die hard cooking adaptation anthology Bravo YouTube Red Extras screenings dramedy Esquire 45 south america films canceled TV shows CW Seed Opinion Best and Worst spider-man CMT TruTV twilight comics cancelled Pirates what to watch YA The CW series Cannes revenge RT21 Rock Women's History Month animated Awards Pop Freeform Podcast Summer casting Shudder Reality Competition See It Skip It Sundance social media directors TV Amazon Prime Video video Pixar ABC Family Comics on TV 20th Century Fox Marvel VH1 SundanceTV DGA dragons Creative Arts Emmys The Witch universal monsters a nightmare on elm street Fox News independent 2018 Marvel Studios Comic Book GoT San Diego Comic-Con Spectrum Originals toy story Disney streaming service composers Binge Guide Academy Awards Stephen King Travel Channel 2017 Family Pet Sematary boxoffice Election Rom-Com Awards Tour IFC ratings renewed TV shows cats slashers news kids Spike MCU USA Network Oscars Black Mirror Super Bowl Animation First Look Apple Heroines CBS All Access Amazon romantic comedy biography diversity robots spinoff historical drama Funimation zombie romance cancelled television Columbia Pictures Disney Channel movie mutant Lionsgate President Musical NYCC YouTube Premium Sundance Now Tarantino dceu RT History DirecTV WGN Infographic Captain marvel Apple TV Plus crime thriller zero dark thirty Britbox Pop TV medical drama harry potter Logo natural history Netflix spy thriller Crackle joker zombies Universal 2020 BET Awards GLAAD LGBT Winners docudrama crime USA Writers Guild of America Star Wars Disney Amazon Prime Crunchyroll cops NBC PlayStation blockbuster HBO Go Netflix Christmas movies Horror parents GIFs comedies OneApp Sneak Peek chucky dc facebook HBO Max psycho free movies Starz Lucasfilm hispanic children's TV Quiz FX on Hulu based on movie cults 21st Century Fox 24 frames Holidays SXSW Nat Geo ABC strong female leads WarnerMedia scary movies Mary poppins Hulu American Society of Cinematographers award winner History Mary Tyler Moore spain Classic Film The Arrangement Black History Month Mindy Kaling FOX Lifetime Christmas movies reviews Avengers Paramount Premiere Dates Calendar aliens stoner Music Rocketman vampires spanish language YouTube werewolf police drama X-Men true crime Dark Horse Comics Nickelodeon game of thrones Television Academy documentary TV Land travel Grammys TLC DC streaming service IFC Films Fantasy Elton John hist Photos war miniseries VICE Warner Bros. Apple TV+ science fiction Toys Sony Pictures transformers MSNBC Ghostbusters teaser Hallmark Christmas movies franchise doctor who BBC Country blaxploitation Tubi Watching Series Brie Larson Film Festival Hear Us Out cancelled TV series 2016 A24 game show binge politics Superheroe psychological thriller AMC TCA Winter 2020 Year in Review documentaries Peacock Character Guide Vudu crossover TCA 2017 Masterpiece Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Fall TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Turner Sundance TV Turner Classic Movies rotten movies we love Holiday Showtime Trailer tv talk Musicals Ovation finale Amazon Studios Set visit criterion period drama singing competition Trophy Talk Red Carpet Sci-Fi cars comiccon Reality New York Comic Con child's play dogs Hallmark anime Shondaland indiana jones Adult Swim concert MTV video on demand cartoon nature disaster all-time cancelled TV shows Spring TV adventure Video Games E! 4/20 jamie lee curtis space PBS halloween comic Chernobyl dark Tumblr versus mockumentary Acorn TV Disney+ Disney Plus Ellie Kemper movies Teen The Walking Dead satire golden globes HBO CNN Syfy DC Comics