Weekly Ketchup

Weekly Ketchup: Benicio Del Toro as the Villain in Star Trek 2?

Plus, some planned blockbusters get rewrites, and movies based on Where's Waldo? and a Facebook game.

by | November 11, 2011 | Comments

This week’s Ketchup covers a relatively slow one, following last week’s which was full of big movie franchise news. At least one big franchise (Star Trek) does get covered here, but technically, even that happened last week, just after the Ketchup was published last Friday. Other stuff that made the cut this week includes movies based on Absolutely Fabulous, Where’s Waldo? and the Facebook game Monster Galaxy, and new roles for Steve Carell, Michael Fassbender, Clive Owen and Elijah Wood.

This Week’s Top Story


With the large ensemble cast already signed to return for the sequel to the 2009 reboot of Star Trek, the biggest question mark has always been who would be joining them as the new villain. The answer was revealed this week to be Puerto Rican/Spanish actor Benicio Del Toro, who won an Oscar for Traffic, and also costarred in Sin City, Snatch and The Usual Suspects. The deal came after meetings between Del Toro and producer/director J.J. Abrams, although Abrams reportedly allowed one detail to remain a mystery even to Del Toro himself: what character would Benicio Del Toro be playing? The obvious guess (which may or may not be correct) among fans would be Khan Noonien Singh, a super soldier from the past who was portrayed by Mexican actor Ricardo Montalban in both the original 1960s TV series (“Space Seed”) and in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. The sequel has been written by returning writers Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman, as well as LOST executive producer Damon Lindelof, who also collaborated with Orci and Kurtzman on Cowboys & Aliens, and cowrote Ridley Scott’s upcoming science fiction epic Prometheus. Filming of the Star Trek sequel is scheduled by Bad Robot and Paramount Pictures to start in January, 2012.

Fresh Developments This Week


Although 20th Century Fox set plans for a sequel to Rise of the Planet of the Apes into motion just last week, the project is far from ready to go, allowing director Rupert Wyatt time to take on another film. Wyatt has been a hot property in Hollywood since the film’s release, and this week, he appears to have found his next project. Wyatt is in negotiations with Warner Bros to direct Londongrad, a spy movie based upon the real events of the final weeks of the life of ex-KGB agent Alexander Litvinenko. Litvinenko made international news in November, 2006 when he became mortally ill in London from poisoning by radioactive polonium-210, and subsequently made death bed accusations that Russian President Vladimir Putin had ordered his execution. Michael Fassbender, who costarred in this summer’s other 20th Century Fox reboot/prequel (X-Men: First Class) is also in negotiations to star in Londongrad as Alexander Litvinenko. Screenwriter David Scarpa, who wrote the 2008 remake The Day the Earth Stood Still and cowrote The Last Castle, adapted the Londongrad script from the Alan Cowell book The Terminal Spy.


British comedienne/actress Jennifer Saunders has announced plans to write a movie based upon the popular and long running BBC TV series Absolutely Fabulous (which she also created). Jennifer Saunders and Joanna Lumley starred in the various (and still continuing) incarnations of Absolutely Fabulous as two older women whose various traits include a fascination with staying in touch with youth culture (despite their ages) and the consumption of mass quantities of drugs and alcohol. The BBC has recently commissioned three new Absolutely Fabulous TV specials, the first of which will be air during the Christmas, 2011 season. Jennifer Saunders is currently busy working on the Spice Girls stage musical Viva Forever in London, but expects to start writing the Absolutely Fabulous movie in 2012. The premise of Ab Fab: The Movie appears to borrow its set up from The Hangover, as it will start with “Patsy and Edina waking up hungover in the empty drifting yacht of an oligarch in the middle of the ocean.” Ab Fab: The Movie will actually be the second movie based upon the series, as there was already a French film in 2001 called Absolument Fabuleux based upon the series. The “Fresh or Rotten” status of an Absolutely Fabulous movie probably depends upon whether one is a fan of the show, so it’s a borderline Fresh Development this week.

Rotten Ideas of the Week


This entry is a catch-all laundry list item covering four different movies that all had two things in common: they’re big budget science fiction movies, and they all got rewrites this week. That last part is not necessarily “Rotten” in every case (and in fact, it might be a good thing), but there’s enough that’s “Rotten” about at least three of the four to still get this group story listed here. Possibly the Freshest of the four is Warner Bros’ and Legendary Pictures’ planned reboot of Godzilla, to be directed by Gareth Edwards (Monsters). The script was formerly being worked on by David Goyer, but now it will be rewritten by Max Borenstein (2003’s Swordswallowers and Thin Men), who has lately become something of a WB studio darling (although none of his projects have yet been produced). Over at Universal Pictures, the studio has hired one of the cowriters (Evan Spiliotopoulos) of next year’s Snow White and the Huntsman to rewrite their adaptation of the Atari arcade game Asteroids. Although Asteroids was ostensibly just about a little triangle shooting dots at big rocks (turning them into smaller rocks), the movie’s story is now described as being “the story of two estranged brothers that must team up to save Earth from an alien race.” In the case of One Thousand A.E., it’s a case of a writer (Stephen Gaghan of Syriana and Traffic) with a pretty good resume signing on to rewrite the new film from a director with a spottier track record (M. Night Shyamalan). Will Smith and Jaden Smith will star in One Thousand A.E. as a father and son who crash land on Earth a thousand years after mankind has abandoned the planet. Finally, there is Singularity, the next big budget science fiction extravaganza from director Roland Emmerich, the director of that other Godzilla reboot. The $175 million Sony project was expected to start filming in March, but it has now been put on hold while Singularity gets a rewrite by Ray Kurzweil, a “futurist and AI specialist.” Kurzweil’s hiring suggests that the problems with Singularity involve the science behind the premise, which involves “a young man whose body is made up of a swarm of nanobots, giving him all sorts of human powers at the same time it brings unwanted attention from an evil corporation.”


Just a week after Walden Media and Jennifer Lopez announced movie plans for Where in the World is Carmen Sandiego?, a very similarly themed movie project has also been announced. MGM has acquired the feature film rights to the Where’s Waldo? franchise from Classic Media, based upon the series of books created by Martin Handford, first published in 1987. The Where’s Waldo? books (and also videogames, etc) involve large crowd shots that challenge the reader to find the thin lead character wearing a red-and-white-striped sweater. MGM is just the latest studio to start development on a Where’s Waldo? live action movie, following previous attempts at both Nickelodeon/Paramount (in the early 2000s) and Illumination/Universal (in 2009). Where’s Waldo? is one of the week’s Rotten Ideas based mostly on the non-narrative nature of the puzzle books.


Clive Owen has signed on to star in an independent thriller entitled Recall, about an NSA agent trying to piece together what exactly happened during a botched hostage rescue operation. Recall will be the first film in over a decade for director Harold Becker, since 2001’s Domestic Disturbance. Harold Becker’s filmography, which also includes Sea of Love and Mercury Rising, includes a total of 9 movies with RT Tomatometer scores, only 3 of which are “Fresh” (and 2 of those are early in his career: Taps and The Onion Field). Becker’s screenwriting partner on Recall is someone else who has mostly been (nearly) inactive in the last decade, Paul Schrader, who is still best known for his collaborations with Martin Scorsese, such as Raging Bull, Taxi Driver, The Last Temptation of Christ and Bringing Out the Dead. Harold Becker and Paul Schrader also worked together on the 1996 film City Hall. The independent production company Moonstone Entertainment aims to start filming of Recall in March, 2012 at locations in Washington DC and Bulgaria.


MGM is in negotiations to acquire the feature film rights to Killer Pizza, a novel by Greg Taylor about “a 14 year old boy who lands a summer job at a pizza joint that is actually a front for a monster hunting enterprise.” Director/producer Chris Columbus is one of the film’s producers, but he is not expected to direct, as that job is more likely to go to Adam Green, who adapted the script from the novel. Adam Green is an independent horror filmmaker best known for Hatchet (50% RT Tomatometer, Rotten), Hatchet II (36% RT Tomatometer, Rotten) and Frozen (60% RT Tomatometer, Fresh). Chris Columbus reportedly brought Killer Pizza to MGM because he knew that the studio was interested in “Gremlins and Goonies-type fare.” Killer Pizza is one of the week’s Rotten Ideas partly because of Adam Green’s RT Tomatometer track record, but also because there are a lot more “Rotten” movies that tried to be like Gremlins and The Goonies than those that were actually as good.


Lord of the Rings star Elijah Wood has signed on to play the lead role as the serial killer Zito in the remake of the 1980 slasher flick Maniac. Reasons for this being a Rotten Idea lie in the Wikipedia description of Zito, as “a middle-aged, overweight, Italian-American loner,” and the fact that Elijah Wood… doesn’t really seem like he’d be great at “being” any of those things. This remake of Maniac was cowritten by horror director Alexandre Aja (Mirrors, Piranha 3-D), who also directed the 2006 remake of Wes Craven’s The Hills Have Eyes. The remake of Maniac will be directed by Franck Khalfoun, who previously directed P2, which received a “Rotten” Tomatometer score of 34%, which is another reason why this is one of the week’s Rotten Ideas.


Universal Pictures has acquired the feature film rights to the novel Lunatics by Dave Barry and Alan Zweibel, who will also adapt their book’s script. The plan is for Steve Carell to star in the comedy about two “soccer dads” in New Jersey whose “minor feud escalates to create worldwide consequences.” Dave Barry’s novel Big Trouble was also previously adapted as a 2002 movie (RT Tomatometer “Rotten” score = 48%) starring Tim Allen and Rene Russo. Alan Zweibel’s career as a screenwriter includes cowriting Dragnet, The Story of Us and the adaptation of his novel North, of which film critic Roger Ebert once wrote, “I hated this movie. Hated hated hated hated hated this movie. Hated it. Hated every simpering stupid vacant audience-insulting moment of it. Hated the sensibility that thought anyone would like it. Hated the implied insult to the audience by its belief that anyone would be entertained by it.” That Lunatics gave me an opportunity to use that famous North quote is part of why it is one of the week’s Rotten Ideas.


With rumors and reports about possible movie projects based on games like Angry Birds and Farmville, the basic premise of this story is not entirely new news, but it’s certainly part of a growing trend. Gaia Interactive, the company behind the Facebook game Monster Galaxy, has signed a deal with Radar Pictures to adapt the game into an animated feature film. Radar Pictures was the production company behind movies like The Invention of Lying, All About Steve, Swing Vote and the 2005 remake of The Amityville Horror, but mostly the press release stresses that producer Ted Field also produced the Vin Diesel science fiction film Pitch Black. Monster Galaxy has been one of the top 10 most played Facebook games for over six months, based upon a game style that many compare to Pokemon… except it’s on Facebook. Monster Galaxy is one of the week’s Rotten Ideas because if you’re going to make a Facebook game movie, Farmville seems the more obvious choice? (Not that the idea of a Farmville movie is particularly “Fresh” either…)

For more Weekly Ketchup columns by Greg Dean Schmitz, check out the WK archive, and you can contact GDS via Facebook or a RT forum message.

Tag Cloud

Nominations Esquire directors rotten werewolf Disney Plus Mudbound best witnail crime thriller Red Carpet E3 dramedy Trailer Comic Book OneApp technology Crackle Amazon laika PaleyFest YouTube GLAAD spanish Apple elevated horror Universal Hallmark superhero cops Film Awards DC Comics fast and furious Sundance TV asian-american sequel Columbia Pictures children's TV Chernobyl Emmys TV Song of Ice and Fire Marvel Television true crime YouTube Premium TV Land zombies Holiday Superheroes IFC Films independent Martial Arts BET Extras Trophy Talk Marvel Studios criterion CMT mutant Fox Searchlight AMC 2017 Disney streaming service Cartoon Network chucky canceled TV shows series The Witch animated scorecard Awards Tour medical drama romance Lucasfilm Elton John twilight Amazon Prime Ghostbusters game of thrones Mindy Kaling Marvel all-time Walt Disney Pictures rotten movies we love festival spain Lionsgate Mystery Sneak Peek space MTV Schedule Paramount Network psycho Music nature nbcuniversal First Look Binge Guide festivals USA Network emmy awards TLC CNN RT21 batman Creative Arts Emmys Brie Larson Anna Paquin finale TruTV die hard singing competition cancelled television war Winners mission: impossible Lifetime Christmas movies transformers social media 45 Turner casting SDCC YouTube Red crime drama Opinion TV renewals indiana jones The Arrangement italian MCU remakes Nat Geo thriller Summer obituary ESPN Family Sci-Fi news miniseries BAFTA halloween tv vampires anthology National Geographic cancelled TV shows supernatural Podcast 2019 BBC One Epix Discovery Channel worst Musicals Pride Month Thanksgiving CBS All Access adaptation Western award winner Crunchyroll Amazon Prime Video docudrama TCM Photos PlayStation justice league what to watch Black History Month ABC Family Mary Poppins Returns Television Critics Association 71st Emmy Awards Paramount DirecTV Tumblr The Purge Avengers Syfy jamie lee curtis Marathons documentaries films TBS Set visit canceled book Warner Bros. tv talk free movies LGBTQ Shondaland richard e. Grant child's play Pop TV Mary Tyler Moore Holidays worst movies Action 72 Emmy Awards documentary crossover comics Logo FX video screen actors guild renewed TV shows spider-man WGN Fantasy 20th Century Fox zombie biography Pet Sematary sports a nightmare on elm street south america Starz joker MSNBC natural history Spike See It Skip It Certified Fresh Biopics SXSW breaking bad harry potter 2020 talk show American Society of Cinematographers toy story historical drama cancelled TV series Country binge Hallmark Christmas movies theme song Rocketman archives Quiz OWN Disney Channel hist teaser Vudu Super Bowl cars Rock Election Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Disney Cannes Stephen King quibi NBC comiccon Year in Review DGA dc doctor who parents nfl Freeform Disney+ Disney Plus christmas movies Cosplay disaster Kids & Family comic Hear Us Out Fall TV Rocky 2016 stop motion cancelled Spring TV GoT FXX sag awards Bravo Toys dceu boxoffice green book ratings based on movie Star Wars Funimation reviews X-Men DC streaming service The Walking Dead ghosts Classic Film TIFF CW Seed spy thriller Television Academy Masterpiece versus 007 anime Ellie Kemper foreign political drama Drama Christmas cults HBO Go kids critics Apple TV Plus Valentine's Day Reality cartoon Horror Teen Black Mirror Watching Series ABC VH1 football romantic comedy comedies classics Grammys hispanic HBO Max LGBT ITV Tubi franchise Sundance Now El Rey Superheroe Apple TV+ SundanceTV television spinoff diversity History FX on Hulu golden globes Peacock GIFs E! Infographic robots Rom-Com Ovation First Reviews spanish language revenge Emmy Nominations Box Office Women's History Month Video Games TCA 2017 zero dark thirty facebook cooking Fox News halloween Endgame The Academy science fiction discovery DC Universe stand-up comedy mockumentary composers name the review serial killer Comedy BET Awards Reality Competition french Trivia dragons universal monsters hollywood sequels blockbuster scary movies crime Premiere Dates NYCC Sundance indie Academy Awards Character Guide Dark Horse Comics video on demand Star Trek APB 4/20 period drama FOX cinemax Baby Yoda slashers Captain marvel Winter TV Nickelodeon PBS Britbox Travel Channel Lifetime VOD movies TCA CBS Spectrum Originals cats dogs Adult Swim blaxploitation sitcom unscripted Netflix Christmas movies A24 Musical Acorn TV satire Oscars Best and Worst Heroines YA Arrowverse movie game show USA stoner BBC HBO Turner Classic Movies Tomatazos Calendar The CW streaming Tarantino concert BBC America Pixar 2015 travel 21st Century Fox Interview VICE San Diego Comic-Con Animation aliens A&E Food Network Polls and Games President police drama politics Pop Pirates Shudder latino Showtime reboot psychological thriller Sony Pictures Amazon Studios venice dark 24 frames screenings TCA Winter 2020 WarnerMedia New York Comic Con Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Countdown toronto Comics on TV Hulu TNT Comedy Central RT History 2018 adventure Netflix Writers Guild of America TCA Awards IFC strong female leads Mary poppins Film Festival