Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Sherlock Holmes Plays a Good Game

Plus, Mission: Impossible Ghost Protocol and Young Adult are Certified Fresh, while Chipwrecked is all wet.

by | December 15, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a brilliant detective (Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows, starring Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law), secret agents (Mission: Impossible Ghost Protocol, starring Tom Cruise and Simon Pegg), singing rodents (Alvin and the Chipmunks: Chipwrecked, starring Jason Lee and David Cross), and a prodigal daughter (Young Adult, starring Charlize Theron and Patton Oswalt). What do the critics have to say?

Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows


Purists griped about the first Sherlock Holmes, but audiences didn’t seem to mind the famously logical detective in full on action mode. Critics say you’ll get more of the same with A Game of Shadows, a muscular, bombastic adventure that benefits greatly from a strong cast. Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law are back as Holmes and Watson, and this time they face their most formidable opponent: the nefarious Professor Moriarty (Jared Harris), who spins a conspiracy to profit from political chaos. The pundits say A Game of Shadows is bigger but not necessarily better than the first movie, but it looks terrific, and Downey and Law make for a splendid odd couple at the center. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down producer Joel Silver’s best-reviewed films, as well as our gallery of Sherlock Holmes movies through the years.)

Mission: Impossible Ghost Protocol


It appears that Pixar wizard Brad Bird has done the impossible, or at least the unlikely: critics say Mission: Impossible Ghost Protocol is not only the best entry in the franchise, it’s one of the finest blockbusters of the year, filled with exhilarating action sequences and memorable characters. The Impossible Missions Force has been falsely accused of bombing the Kremlin, so it’s up to Ethan Hunt (Tom Cruise) and his crew to go rogue and clear the organization of any wrongdoing — preferably while scaling skyscrapers in Dubai. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Mission: Impossible Ghost Protocol is light on plot, but the stunning set pieces and brisk pacing more than compensate.

Alvin and the Chipmunks: Chipwrecked


Another year, another Alvin and the Chipmunks movie — and critics say Chipwrecked is as middling as its two predecessors, though the wee ones probably won’t mind. This time out, Alvin, Simon, and Theodore join David Seville (Jason Lee) and the Chipettes on a luxury cruise, where they make enough mischief to get themselves shipwrecked on a desert island that’s not as empty as it first appears. The pundits say Chipwrecked is a reasonably safe bet for undiscriminating children, but parents are unlikely to find much amusement in this juvenilia.

Young Adult


Four years after the whip-smart, quirky Juno, director Jason Reitman and screenwriter Diablo Cody are back with the pitch-black Young Adult, and critics say it’s a sharp and occasionally painfully astute comedy. Charlize Theron stars as a former high school queen bee who, now pushing 40, returns to her hometown to get back together with an old flame (Patrick Wilson). Unfortunately for her, he’s happily married, though our heroine does end up bonding with another former classmate (Patton Oswalt) — one she treated badly despite his massive crush on her. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Young Adult is an intelligent and often very funny character study, one that’s so honest that it may make you cringe from time to time.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Schedule GIFs adventure Sci-Fi Pirates LGBTQ Food Network harry potter Fantasy Universal Interview Syfy Premiere Dates Musicals Exclusive Video Polls and Games TNT Rock Teen First Look Disney Comedy Mary Tyler Moore TCA E! AMC social media Calendar Starz Best and Worst CNN FOX Crackle Animation Super Bowl GLAAD Superheroes Martial Arts 2015 Showtime VICE Hulu TV SundanceTV Set visit Comedy Central Podcast Ghostbusters Tomatazos Netflix Lionsgate Opinion CMT American Society of Cinematographers ABC Sneak Peek Box Office Certified Fresh SDCC 2016 Masterpiece Freeform sitcom WGN HBO Emmys Music TIFF sports Watching Series Drama Toys diversity Amazon Star Trek TCA 2017 DirecTV NBC Video Games MTV dramedy crime thriller Horror GoT Infographic The CW Winter TV Character Guide Extras politics DC Comics technology thriller Valentine's Day based on movie BET Reality cinemax MSNBC Kids & Family BBC America aliens Pop BBC Writers Guild of America Trailer Biopics 24 frames Rocky Nat Geo El Rey travel Rom-Com VH1 Oscars Lifetime Countdown A&E Fall TV Election RT History Tumblr OWN Nickelodeon PaleyFest Logo Marvel TV Land FX crime drama comiccon Winners President science fiction Cartoon Network Trivia TCM Action Disney Channel Red Carpet USA Grammys Spring TV FXX TBS singing competition Marathons Star Wars Cosplay Summer boxoffice X-Men ITV CBS TruTV biography History PBS police drama cops Country 007 Adult Swim Esquire Comic Book war CBS All Access Year in Review cooking Sundance Fox News ESPN discovery Bravo docudrama Holidays Awards serial killer period drama Mystery APB 2017 Nominations Photos ABC Family NYCC Thanksgiving Reality Competition IFC vampires