Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Sherlock Holmes Is Worth Investigating

Plus, Alvin and Nine hit flat notes, It's Complicated is too simple, and Up in the Air is Certified Fresh.

by | December 23, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a legendary detective (Sherlock Holmes, starring Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law); matriculating rodents (Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel, starring David Cross and Jason Lee); a middle aged love triangle (It’s Complicated, starring Meryl Streep and Alec Baldwin); turbulent business travel (Up in the Air, starring George Clooney and Vera Farmiga); and a directionless director (Nine, starring Daniel Day-Lewis and Penelope Cruz). What do the critics have to say?


Sherlock Holmes

Known for his hyperkinetic lad pictures, Guy Ritchie may not seem like an obvious choice to direct a Sherlock Holmes adaptation, given that 221B Baker St.’s most famous resident is a paragon of sophistication and stateliness. But a little Robert Downey Jr. goes a long way, critics say, and the star’s elementary appeal helps to draw us into this 21st century, action-packed update of the legendary detective. As Holmes, Downey is abetted by Jude Law, who plays his right hand man Watson; together, they must foil a plot to destroy Britain, while Holmes must deal with his favorite nemesis, the brilliant Irene Adler (Rachel McAdams). The pundits say Sherlock Holmes maintains both the pulpy spirit of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s original short stories and the wittiness of its lead characters, and if the movie’s sometimes too high-octane for its own good, it still provides a cracking good time. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Law’s best-reviewed films.)


Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel

Alright everyone, sing along with me: “Christmas, Christmas time is near /Time for toys and time for cheer…” “The Chipmunk Song” is a holiday staple, but critics say the pint-sized trio’s latest seasonal offering — Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel — is far less likely to bring yuletide merriment. This time around, Alvin, Simon, and Theodore are headed to high school, where they meet riot grrrls the Chipettes — now employed by the ‘Munks old enemy, Ian Hawke (David Cross). Can these two rodent bands find common ground — and save their school’s music program? The pundits say this Squeakquel is sure to please little kids, but adults may be less amused by the film’s lowbrow hi-jinks and general inanity.


It’s Complicated

With names like Meryl Streep, Alec Baldwin and Steve Martin on the marquee, you’d expect a film with a title like It’s Complicated to provide some smarter-than-average laughs. And critics say that while the cast does its best to elevate this movie, the results are more farcical — and predictable — than one would hope. Streep stars as Jane, whose ex-husband Jake (Baldwin) has remarried; at their son’s graduation, the two resume their love affair – which complicates things for Jane’s children and her new suitor Adam (Martin). The pundits say everything here is handled with plenty of professionalism, but It’s Complicated ultimately succumbs to sitcom conventions when it could have been something more.


Up in the Air

Jason Reitman‘s Certified Fresh Up in the Air has already thrilled critics and snared a number of award nominations, and this week it expands into wide release. George Clooney stars as Ryan Bingham, who has accumulated big frequent flyer mileage from his company, which tasks him with firing people in person. But when the corporation cuts back on travel, will Bingham still cross paths with a fellow traveler (Vera Farmiga)? The pundits say Up in the Air is styling, timely, and features magnificent performances.



It’s based on a hit Broadway musical (which is itself adapted from the Fellini classic 8 1/2). It’s loaded with Oscar winners. So what’s the matter with Nine? Well, critics say it lacks showstopping numbers, a strong narrative, and a sense of restraint. Daniel Day-Lewis stars as a film director who is in an artistic rut, so he turns to the women in his life, a group that includes Penelope Cruz, Nicole Kidman, and Marion Cotillard, among others. The pundits say the cast acquits itself well enough on the vocal front, and the film has a couple dazzling moments, but ultimately, Nine is superficially flashy, hyperactively edited, and musically undistinguished.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Crunchyroll Masterpiece renewed TV shows miniseries ESPN comic Action USA Network archives versus See It Skip It nfl science fiction television TCA 2017 Disney Plus CNN TCA Winter 2020 MSNBC Arrowverse Lifetime Emmys Video Games VICE Pixar werewolf rotten movies we love Nat Geo Best and Worst Spectrum Originals supernatural SundanceTV batman TNT Super Bowl Creative Arts Emmys Cannes dc hist Rock aliens AMC chucky Marvel Studios Trophy Talk game of thrones true crime Dark Horse Comics Podcast talk show historical drama Reality video TV Freeform CBS All Access TV renewals Holidays Awards El Rey RT21 laika Box Office zero dark thirty robots casting Classic Film Martial Arts anime cults Winter TV Rom-Com Apple TV+ discovery 2015 zombies universal monsters Tumblr Epix Mary poppins Fall TV what to watch children's TV Fantasy Polls and Games canceled TV shows spanish Drama asian-american cooking Spike dragons BET richard e. Grant TV Land Comic Book TBS Rocketman CW Seed Emmy Nominations First Look psycho SDCC hispanic transformers Nickelodeon composers parents Oscars news Nominations all-time FOX The Academy Disney Channel Netflix satire child's play Ellie Kemper IFC Films APB Country Marvel Television technology Fox Searchlight The Arrangement DC Comics comics japanese halloween diversity based on movie Logo spanish language Peacock History space Sneak Peek 2018 Television Academy Walt Disney Pictures 20th Century Fox concert Sci-Fi Marvel series Turner Classic Movies police drama ITV quibi Esquire classics travel name the review criterion Toys 2017 revenge Black History Month Christmas Chernobyl GLAAD 2019 E3 dark italian First Reviews anthology spinoff Holiday breaking bad 2020 Election Lucasfilm sitcom Lionsgate jamie lee curtis 72 Emmy Awards HBO Go superhero YouTube Premium green book festival stoner Infographic Columbia Pictures Pet Sematary Interview festivals Cartoon Network mutant NBC Baby Yoda Star Wars obituary french rotten Sundance TV serial killer Rocky strong female leads YA reviews TIFF cartoon crime Watching Series politics Syfy halloween tv slashers romantic comedy Star Trek game show south america ABC dceu Mary Poppins Returns Mudbound Academy Awards Summer finale GoT cops Grammys Cosplay Character Guide SXSW Disney Extras Binge Guide Stephen King Apple Trivia TLC dogs DirecTV Adult Swim Vudu Crackle Musicals 24 frames cancelled Countdown singing competition crime thriller Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Shudder dramedy MCU adaptation Discovery Channel 2016 kids canceled binge mockumentary PaleyFest Film Pop reboot TCM indiana jones disaster Sundance Now streaming sports Anna Paquin social media TCA Sony Pictures toy story Reality Competition American Society of Cinematographers scorecard RT History HBO Max Amazon Prime Video Acorn TV Song of Ice and Fire directors critics Television Critics Association The Walking Dead boxoffice President remakes documentaries YouTube Musical FX Netflix Christmas movies Tarantino MTV cars indie Elton John Set visit GIFs Shondaland A24 stand-up comedy best Film Festival Showtime latino The Purge golden globes 007 joker Tubi justice league blaxploitation Turner USA Premiere Dates book Paramount romance christmas movies BBC One ABC Family Sundance elevated horror Red Carpet tv talk ghosts WGN BBC Marathons PlayStation Schedule The CW die hard franchise worst independent PBS OneApp crime drama Family Captain marvel psychological thriller cancelled TV shows Hear Us Out WarnerMedia Hulu zombie CBS harry potter Hallmark Christmas movies nature screenings Amazon Prime award winner video on demand Black Mirror mission: impossible Endgame OWN VOD spain Avengers X-Men Valentine's Day ratings Teen Mystery docudrama TCA Awards Apple TV Plus DC streaming service Travel Channel Pride Month cancelled television Amazon Studios New York Comic Con LGBT movies Funimation Certified Fresh Comedy BAFTA Fox News spider-man Pop TV 71st Emmy Awards Universal unscripted films blockbuster E! comedies thriller doctor who free movies Quiz Opinion BBC America cats sag awards Comedy Central biography Superheroe spy thriller natural history Britbox Calendar Disney+ Disney Plus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Brie Larson Spring TV BET Awards Horror DC Universe Amazon 21st Century Fox movie Mindy Kaling vampires screen actors guild Warner Bros. Lifetime Christmas movies political drama Pirates Ovation theme song Women's History Month Writers Guild of America 45 Kids & Family cinemax cancelled TV series VH1 nbcuniversal teaser hollywood witnail Food Network Winners FX on Hulu Heroines Music Bravo stop motion worst movies animated football medical drama YouTube Red HBO Superheroes The Witch FXX a nightmare on elm street toronto documentary twilight Comics on TV fast and furious period drama IFC TruTV Tomatazos LGBTQ Mary Tyler Moore Biopics DGA National Geographic Western crossover Hallmark emmy awards Paramount Network adventure war Disney streaming service sequels Starz CMT NYCC facebook Trailer Awards Tour sequel Animation Photos venice Ghostbusters Year in Review A&E scary movies Thanksgiving 4/20 comiccon San Diego Comic-Con foreign