Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Positive Role Models, So-So Soul Men

Plus, Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa tops the original.

by | November 6, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Big Brothers (Role Models, starring Paul Rudd and Seann William Scott), wild animals (Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa, with voice work by Ben Stiller and Chris Rock), and R&B vets (Soul Men, starring Bernie Mac and Samuel L. Jackson). What do the critics have to say?

Films that are at once raucously stupid and genuinely funny are a rarity. However, critics say Role Models fits the bill with aplomb. The film stars Paul Rudd and Seann William Scott as a pair of energy drink pitchmen with a proclivity for bad behavior and law-breaking; assigned to community service, they act as Big Brothers to a pair of troublemakers — and learn something in the process. It may sound like pure formula, but the pundits say this is a worthy entry in the Judd Apatow-inspired subgenre of gross-out comedy with heart, featuring well-paced, spectacularly dumb (in a good way) gags and engaging performances. At 75 percent on the Tomatometer, Role Models may be worth following.

“I’d like to dedicate this next number to McLovin.”

Speaking of rarities, how many sequels top the original? Madagascar
made a ton of money but disappointed critics unimpressed with its string of pop culture references and flatulence jokes. The scribes say Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa is better in almost every regard, with sharper animation, funnier jokes, and a better story. Alex the Lion (Ben Stiller), Gloria the Hippo (Jada Pinkett Smith), Marty the Zebra (Chris Rock) and Melman the Giraffe (David Schwimmer) are relocated from captivity in New York to a savannah in Africa. Once there, they rediscover their roots, but pine for the friendly confines of the zoo. It may not be the edgiest animation out there, but pundits say Madagascar is bright and cheerful, with a good deal of energy and some smart laughs. At 68 percent on the Tomatometer, Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa may be worth a trip.

“They call me the Hiphopapotamus, my lyrics are bottomless…..”

The script of Soul Men may be coarse and shopworn, but critics say it’s an ok sendoff for the great comic Bernie Mac, who passed away earlier this year. The film stars Mac and Samuel L. Jackson as a pair of R&B backup singers who reluctantly agree to perform at a tribute concert for a soul legend despite mutual acrimony; their cross-country journey to the show is filled with wacky hostility. The critics say Soul Men isn’t particularly original, borrowing from a number of road-buddy flicks, and the jokes are pretty blue. Still, they also note it’s a worthy final performance for Bernie Mac, an actor who stole many scenes in supporting roles and is in fine form as a lead here (and the late soul great Isaac Hayes also turns in a sharp supporting performance). At 54 percent on the Tomatometer, Soul Men hits some decent notes.

One of these men is in no hurry to take it to the bridge, to the consternation of the other.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Captain Abu Raed, a tale of a janitor in Jordan who inspires a goup of children who believe he’s a pilot, is at 100 percent.

  • A revival of Francois Truffaut‘s classic The Wild Child, based on the true story of a boy who survived alone in the wild, is at 100 percent.

  • Pray the Devil Back to Hell, a documentary about a group of Liberian women’s political activism in the midst of civil war, is at 100 percent.

  • JCVD, starring Jean-Claude Van Damme as a version of himself fighting to escape a hostage situation in a bank, is at 85 percent (check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down the Muscles from Brussels’ best-reviewed films).

  • The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, a Holocaust drama about the son of a Nazi officer who forms a friendship with a boy in a concentration camp, is at 71 percent.

  • The World Unseen, a drama about two South African women who form a tight bond during the Apartheid era, is at 29 percent.

  • Repo! The Genetic Opera, a futuristic musical about a biotech company that harvests human organs, is at 25 percent.

Finally, props to indiefilmfan2, Mary R., and rockclimbr6 for coming the closest to guessing The Haunting Of Molly Hartley‘s three percent Tomatometer.

Best-Reviewed Bernie Mac Movies:

Tag Cloud

twilight Tumblr Epix diversity VOD Turner Thanksgiving Binge Guide Syfy ESPN boxing social media 45 children's TV Netflix Christmas movies Tomatazos Mudbound Christmas NBA New York Comic Con binge Grammys Heroines GoT jurassic park fresh black strong female leads best Paramount HBO worst movies Wes Anderson Song of Ice and Fire E! Crunchyroll book know your critic BET Awards rotten movies we love Calendar Superheroe aliens Biopics Avengers Mary Tyler Moore comic book movies Netflix IFC criterion Holiday superhero dexter die hard SundanceTV Disney Plus justice league 2019 Schedule Apple TV Plus Valentine's Day doctor who spain Television Critics Association BBC Comedy versus debate MTV chucky Creative Arts Emmys Animation Pacific Islander indiana jones First Reviews PaleyFest Ellie Kemper Tarantino sequels supernatural YouTube Premium reviews news harry potter Fox News superman Election theme song Year in Review basketball Certified Fresh telelvision christmas movies ITV CBS Countdown Anna Paquin Mary poppins Musical game show monster movies A&E Travel Channel Apple ratings gangster psycho international sports richard e. Grant Pop Pirates 93rd Oscars high school Marvel child's play hispanic TCM canceled TV shows Box Office australia San Diego Comic-Con technology ghosts Video Games mission: impossible mutant kaiju golden globes Kids & Family batman transformers FX 99% football movies The Academy Cartoon Network dark saw Comics on TV Red Carpet Freeform action-comedy dragons south america free movies Holidays Dark Horse Comics crime finale Trophy Talk cults disaster feel good facebook blaxploitation Character Guide book adaptation 2015 Superheroes blockbuster thriller Hallmark Christmas movies venice Western cancelled Trailer italian HBO Max rom-coms Rom-Com king kong jamie lee curtis Brie Larson live action crime drama parents japanese franchise godzilla cats Emmy Nominations cancelled TV series Food Network Nat Geo A24 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Vudu Infographic green book 2021 LGBTQ President GLAAD game of thrones asian-american streaming sequel nature anthology Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DGA comics laika Emmys TV renewals TV movies remakes Disney streaming service Fantasy Reality canceled TIFF TCA The Purge BBC America CW Seed Chernobyl concert comic books Marvel Television medical drama documentary Columbia Pictures spider-man 2016 historical drama Ghostbusters Amazon hidden camera WGN Britbox DC Comics Premiere Dates mockumentary rt labs critics edition OWN psychological thriller unscripted spinoff Endgame Marathons Turner Classic Movies Mary Poppins Returns Spike a nightmare on elm street Funimation Paramount Plus OneApp 2020 Discovery Channel emmy awards Rocketman cars X-Men directors stoner marvel comics period drama 2018 Legendary target reboot animated composers Sundance Universal suspense movie women Warner Bros. anime adenture sitcom TV royal family streaming movies WarnerMedia Fall TV APB El Rey dramedy Polls and Games docuseries dc toronto new zealand Tubi elevated horror Acorn TV natural history Amazon Studios Spring TV based on movie Baby Yoda PBS Fox Searchlight lord of the rings independent latino 24 frames See It Skip It Writers Guild of America cancelled television Awards Walt Disney Pictures Spectrum Originals slasher dceu BET FXX Academy Awards Photos Sneak Peek docudrama Amazon Prime james bond Sundance TV joker 20th Century Fox FOX Alien Comic Book Set visit TBS prank scene in color mcc worst Logo Film Festival true crime TCA 2017 fast and furious Mindy Kaling films trailers police drama award winner SXSW SDCC festival Nickelodeon obituary 73rd Emmy Awards boxoffice Musicals deadpool legend Pixar talk show Hear Us Out 007 90s Cosplay cops E3 science fiction Disney Channel aapi sag awards 21st Century Fox CNN NYCC hist Television Academy cancelled TV shows television Summer serial killer what to watch Black History Month foreign miniseries BBC One Hallmark Disney 4/20 comic book movie Oscars MCU halloween The CW rotten dogs DC streaming service ABC Family teaser vampires werewolf new star wars movies Lucasfilm USA CMT crime thriller Sundance Now biopic DirecTV Pet Sematary cartoon USA Network Lifetime Christmas movies french space 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Exclusive Video young adult popular olympics Apple TV+ ABC Winter TV Bravo Captain marvel Marvel Studios Peacock CBS All Access Comic-Con@Home 2021 History Rock golden globe awards rt archives Family war Country TCA Awards Nominations IFC Films 2017 MSNBC razzies critic resources Disney+ Disney Plus Horror TV Land nbcuniversal Awards Tour Winners stand-up comedy Opinion HBO Go biography AMC VICE Reality Competition Lifetime video on demand Mystery Pop TV cooking Broadway tv talk spy thriller ID Women's History Month Comedy Central Image Comics blockbusters Podcast Sony Pictures archives GIFs Quiz comedies scorecard classics PlayStation Lionsgate documentaries VH1 scary movies Watching Series The Witch RT21 zero dark thirty heist movie kong YouTube Red wonder woman Music zombie Amazon Prime Video breaking bad Adult Swim Shudder Star Wars Sci-Fi toy story Tokyo Olympics revenge all-time Best and Worst posters marvel cinematic universe Pride Month screenings NBC First Look Action TCA Winter 2020 Hulu japan crossover Stephen King Drama political drama ViacomCBS travel Extras Ovation 72 Emmy Awards BAFTA Super Bowl universal monsters Interview spanish language hollywood satire spanish name the review TruTV renewed TV shows series adaptation YouTube Crackle YA Trivia Cannes TLC The Walt Disney Company rt labs The Walking Dead festivals Elton John nfl robots comic cinemax Masterpiece National Geographic pirates of the caribbean halloween tv stop motion kids Arrowverse singing competition screen actors guild adventure Paramount Network LGBT witnail RT History DC Universe indie video American Society of Cinematographers TV One Star Trek The Arrangement 1990s zombies slashers comiccon new york Classic Film FX on Hulu Black Mirror ABC Signature Toys Shondaland discovery 71st Emmy Awards critics Rocky hispanic heritage month Teen Starz quibi romance Esquire Martial Arts king arthur Film romantic comedy politics casting TNT Showtime