Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Jennifer's Body Is Hot, But The Movie Isn't

Plus, The Informant! is offbeat and funny, Cloudy is tasty and wacky, and Love Happens doesn't.

by | September 17, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a possessed student body (Jennifer’s Body, starring Megan Fox and Amanda Seyfried); an oddball snitch (The Informant!, starring Matt Damon and Scott Bakula); food from the heavens (Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs, with voice work by Bill Hader and Anna Faris); and unlikely love (Love Happens, starring Jennifer Aniston and Aaron Eckhart). What do the critics have to say?


Jennifer’s Body

Megan Fox is the “it” actress of the moment, and Diablo Cody (Juno) is one of Hollywood’s hottest writers. Unfortunately, critics say their combined efforts can’t elevate Jennifer’s Body above typical teen horror fare. Fox stars as a high school student who’s possessed by a demon, one that implores her to feast on her fellow students. The pundits say Jennifer’s Body doesn’t quite work as a horror flick or as a satire; despite flashes of wit, it’s not all that funny, nor is it ever particularly scary.


The Informant!

Steven Soderbergh is one of mainstream cinema’s most enigmatic, unpredictable directors. It’s a good thing, too, because his latest, The Informant!, is about an enigmatic, unpredictable guy, and the result, critics say, is odd but offbeat and entertaining. Based upon a true story, The Informant! stars Matt Damon as Mark Whitacre, an executive for a massive agri-business. He discovers a price fixing scheme within the company, and becomes an FBI informant; however, he’s got some problematic secrets of his own. The pundits say Damon is outstanding – nerdy, manic, and in way over his head – and though the film occasionally strains for wackiness, it’s ultimately both light-hearted and thoughtful.


Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs

It’s tough to adapt a beloved (and relatively brief) children’s book into a feature length film while maintaining the spirit of the original. Luckily, critics say Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs avoids most of the potential pitfalls, and the result is a laugh-filled, mouth-watering family treat. Flint Lockwood (voiced by Bill Hader) is a small-town inventor who constructs a machine that turns precipitation into sustenance, much to the confusion of his fellow citizens – particularly the spunky meteorologist Sam Sparks (Anna Faris). The pundits say Cloudy‘s CGI is remarkably detailed and whimsical, and the film features plenty of absurdist touches and riotous slapstick – as well as sharp vocal performances from Bruce Campbell (!) and Mr. T (!!).


Love Happens

In a romantic comedy, chemistry is an elusive thing — you know it when you see it. Unfortunately for Love Happens, critics say the chemistry between its leads is almost non-existent. Aaron Eckhart stars as a self-help author with a secret, and Jennifer Aniston plays a lonely florist who stumbles into his life; will these two crazy, messed-up kids make it? The pundits say Love Happens is bland, sad, and bereft of laughs – a downbeat, clichéd mediocrity that can’t be salvaged despite the presence of two appealing stars. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run don some of cinema’s most iconic couples.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

USA Network jamie lee curtis game show Paramount Plus dramedy young adult superman aliens cinemax teaser Apple police drama wonder woman Sundance TV Horror ABC Family Interview 2020 BBC One cancelled television streaming movies news stand-up comedy worst movies scene in color film series Musicals social media book Holiday Sneak Peek Turner Classic Movies travel Western royal family biopic art house Indigenous movie franchise king arthur docuseries transformers Tokyo Olympics Classic Film rt labs universal monsters Sci-Fi Tomatazos TCM 24 frames Binge Guide MGM spinoff The Purge TV One jurassic park political drama AMC Plus TV movies streamig james bond Sundance Video Games psychological thriller blockbusters biography pirates of the caribbean Character Guide TCA adenture debate 2015 93rd Oscars renewed TV shows Star Trek A24 streaming Trivia cancelled politics Certified Fresh Showtime RT History Elton John Animation FXX Toys blaxploitation rt labs critics edition japan Star Wars TBS video on demand Awards singing competition Disney Plus The Academy Best Picture Rock Watching Series justice league Lionsgate Lucasfilm supernatural Mary poppins Mary Poppins Returns Pop Acorn TV The Arrangement Superheroe Rocketman Heroines Trophy Talk name the review Valentine's Day rotten ESPN Music Countdown golden globe awards Election concert spain war slasher NYCC critic resources Fox Searchlight Set visit sports First Look deadpool TV renewals chucky Disney Channel comic books Comedy Central composers National Geographic Travel Channel thriller Song of Ice and Fire Action Tubi binge leaderboard AMC Brie Larson YouTube Red IMDb TV telelvision Tumblr scary 79th Golden Globes Awards Lifetime kids ratings black venice 72 Emmy Awards children's TV HFPA cats Prime Video Hear Us Out historical drama IFC Films Hallmark Christmas movies obi wan lord of the rings Warner Bros. Holidays Premiere Dates scene in color series San Diego Comic-Con Film Martial Arts Universal VICE medical drama reboot halloween Reality Competition natural history movies The Walt Disney Company casting Film Festival Marvel Television Drama BET Awards SundanceTV Black Mirror Summer anime cars toronto Comedy saw Spike Image Comics interviews video Hollywood Foreign Press Association ABC Signature PBS Nickelodeon TNT MSNBC criterion TLC archives cancelled TV series popular kaiju vampires CBS All Access Turner Schedule nature Best and Worst Mystery action-comedy spanish language Crackle cops Wes Anderson sitcom BBC America versus Geeked Week child's play South by Southwest Film Festival Comic Book Pet Sematary Trailer spider-man fast and furious Fall TV TV obituary documentary Winners Best Actor VH1 Columbia Pictures zero dark thirty 99% comic book movie what to watch Emmys high school dceu The Witch Shondaland Year in Review American Society of Cinematographers Crunchyroll E! films Amazon Studios posters 71st Emmy Awards BET disaster Star Wars Celebration Stephen King Paramount Pictures game of thrones DC Comics El Rey indiana jones comics Writers Guild of America Paramount facebook Masterpiece festival YouTube Premium Comic-Con@Home 2021 talk show new star wars movies independent Apple TV Plus Photos japanese summer TV Ellie Kemper DGA hist critics satire Fantasy Television Critics Association GoT king kong Podcast DC streaming service History psycho zombie Netflix Freeform 007 cooking aapi Academy Awards Calendar breaking bad Marvel Studios mission: impossible Infographic Fargo BBC WarnerMedia live event sag awards 21st Century Fox USA scorecard hollywood canceled TV shows boxoffice twilight Funimation free movies Legendary Teen technology Polls and Games Adult Swim Oscar live action 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ViacomCBS Cartoon Network OWN Television Academy Shudder Comics on TV sequels hispanic heritage month godzilla Spring TV Epix halloween tv Hallmark crossover Women's History Month President DC Universe Emmy Nominations dragons marvel comics reviews quibi book adaptation summer TV preview IFC Best Director Food Network laika 2018 serial killer Winter TV New York Comic Con MCU remakes black comedy mob MTV Christmas crime drama Instagram Live broadcast Family comic book movies FX on Hulu Esquire series space DirecTV basketball Black History Month Sundance Now Spectrum Originals foreign football PaleyFest 2021 docudrama CMT Logo Sony Marathons Lifetime Christmas movies Pixar mcc scene in color CBS HBO Go Britbox 94th Oscars TCA 2017 sequel cults Rocky dark target scene in color Cannes based on movie nfl NBA The Walking Dead spy thriller all-time stop motion 1990s TIFF Discovery Channel 2016 CW Seed slashers 2019 Exclusive Video trophy dreamworks Grammys witnail asian-american Anna Paquin harry potter SXSW 2022 Fox News rotten movies we love golden globes directors Arrowverse miniseries VOD cancelled TV shows BAFTA spider-verse Sony Pictures Mary Tyler Moore Opinion women hidden camera APB 45 razzies strong female leads die hard Walt Disney Pictures science fiction feel good Amazon Prime rom-coms crime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt HBO adaptation diversity heist movie batman legend festivals christmas movies TCA Awards Apple TV+ classics SDCC PlayStation unscripted Kids & Family cartoon Disney 73rd Emmy Awards See It Skip It YouTube ID best ghosts spanish Peacock marvel cinematic universe ITV Captain marvel prank TV Land suspense Quiz elevated horror australia target hispanic scary movies Red Carpet Thanksgiving Extras anthology award winner Reality SXSW true crime richard e. Grant CNN Mudbound genre Amazon Prime Video television Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pop TV Vudu Rom-Com LGBTQ romantic comedy Dark Horse Comics FX Disney streaming service Alien comiccon Universal Pictures Focus Features WGN 2017 Neflix Syfy Avengers mockumentary OneApp sopranos Cosplay TruTV vs. animated Amazon First Reviews monster movies Ovation boxing X-Men indie 4/20 period drama Paramount Network Tarantino green book Nominations toy story rt archives TCA Winter 2020 Biopics new zealand Super Bowl screenings 20th Century Fox mutant GIFs Mindy Kaling south america robots discovery Pride Month E3 worst Chernobyl Native screen actors guild Hulu emmy awards know your critic canceled Pacific Islander werewolf YA Bravo revenge a nightmare on elm street Country Nat Geo summer preview international fresh FOX joker Starz comic crime thriller Ghostbusters LGBT blockbuster latino Best Actress kong NBC tv talk comedies zombies Superheroes 90s finale Tags: Comedy Pirates ABC GLAAD Musical Awards Tour superhero romance dexter HBO Max trailers Marvel theme song Netflix Christmas movies documentaries new york Disney+ Disney Plus olympics The CW Baby Yoda Creative Arts Emmys italian dc doctor who Box Office adventure parents A&E french gangster dogs Broadway Endgame stoner RT21 Oscars nbcuniversal