Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Breaking Dawn Part 1 Doesn't Shine

Plus, Happy Feet Two looks nice but lacks a solid script.

by | November 17, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a vampire wedding (The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 1, starring Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson), and dancing penguins (Happy Feet Two, with voice work by Elijah Wood and Robin Williams). What do the critics have to say?

The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 1


As the Twilight Saga comes into the home stretch, it looks to go out with a whimper rather than a bang, say critics, who find Breaking Dawn Part 1 to be full of limp pacing and unintentional laughs. In Breaking Dawn Part 1, Bella (Kristen Stewart) and Edward (Robert Pattinson) have gotten hitched, and soon Bella is preggers with a lil’ bloodsucker, a development that fills old flame Jacob (Taylor Lautner) with apprehension. The pundits say Breaking Dawn Part 1 is even more melodramatic than previous installments, with cringe-worthy dialogue and a weird puritanical streak that robs the movie of any sense of swoony fun.

Happy Feet Two


Those jovial aquatic birds are back with Happy Feet Two, though critics say the sequel lacks the easy charm of Happy Feet; instead, it’s nicely animated but also thinly plotted and way too busy. This time out, Mumbles (Elijah Wood) and his two-left-footed son must rescue a group of emperor penguins trapped in an ice floe. The pundits say Happy Feet Two looks terrific, but it’s hampered by a lackluster script and an overabundance of supporting characters. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Robin Williams’ best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

WGN Marvel PaleyFest Nat Geo Certified Fresh SundanceTV Sundance Summer VICE technology Oscars Rocky Star Trek OWN Countdown composers Ellie Kemper ITV Musicals Comedy crime dramedy TBS MSNBC Cartoon Network ABC Family Box Office E! Super Bowl FXX thriller aliens First Look BBC America Musical Bravo police drama VH1 USA adventure President YA Paramount Mary Tyler Moore Grammys Food Network Horror Warner Bros. Marathons LGBTQ Amazon Reality Valentine's Day Thanksgiving Calendar CMT Extras Freeform BBC Character Guide SDCC BET DC Comics Sneak Peek harry potter Fantasy The Arrangement FOX travel serial killer TCA cats Adult Swim boxoffice Awards Comedy Central Disney Channel Syfy Dark Horse Comics Mindy Kaling Country FX Holidays social media cops period drama NYCC Universal A&E Video Games Pirates Lionsgate Red Carpet Toys science fiction Netflix RT History Fall TV Schedule 45 Star Wars Reality Competition Trivia X-Men TV Land IFC docudrama NBC transformers DC Universe TNT Rom-Com Set visit 2015 American Society of Cinematographers Teen Winners TIFF crime thriller diversity supernatural APB Infographic 24 frames Podcast Masterpiece Spring TV sitcom vampires politics Election Sci-Fi Tomatazos biography zombie CBS All Access Music discovery E3 007 Hulu Fox News AMC Starz ESPN Mystery psycho El Rey sports Winter TV Esquire Showtime DirecTV Premiere Dates Biopics war Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt based on movie Nickelodeon 2017 TCA 2017 Opinion Crackle Cosplay Emmys Watching Series HBO Interview talk show Action GLAAD ABC GIFs Comic Book History Trailer Year in Review singing competition Logo TLC crime drama comiccon Tumblr MTV Ghostbusters 2016 historical drama Drama Photos Best and Worst Polls and Games CBS Disney cinemax Rock Nominations Writers Guild of America Pop TV Lifetime GoT political drama TruTV PBS TCM Martial Arts Kids & Family Superheroes The CW CNN cooking Animation