Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Breaking Dawn Part 1 Doesn't Shine

Plus, Happy Feet Two looks nice but lacks a solid script.

by | November 17, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a vampire wedding (The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 1, starring Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson), and dancing penguins (Happy Feet Two, with voice work by Elijah Wood and Robin Williams). What do the critics have to say?

The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 1


As the Twilight Saga comes into the home stretch, it looks to go out with a whimper rather than a bang, say critics, who find Breaking Dawn Part 1 to be full of limp pacing and unintentional laughs. In Breaking Dawn Part 1, Bella (Kristen Stewart) and Edward (Robert Pattinson) have gotten hitched, and soon Bella is preggers with a lil’ bloodsucker, a development that fills old flame Jacob (Taylor Lautner) with apprehension. The pundits say Breaking Dawn Part 1 is even more melodramatic than previous installments, with cringe-worthy dialogue and a weird puritanical streak that robs the movie of any sense of swoony fun.

Happy Feet Two


Those jovial aquatic birds are back with Happy Feet Two, though critics say the sequel lacks the easy charm of Happy Feet; instead, it’s nicely animated but also thinly plotted and way too busy. This time out, Mumbles (Elijah Wood) and his two-left-footed son must rescue a group of emperor penguins trapped in an ice floe. The pundits say Happy Feet Two looks terrific, but it’s hampered by a lackluster script and an overabundance of supporting characters. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Robin Williams’ best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

LGBTQ Comedy Central Extras TNT space BBC America facebook true crime Nat Geo Chilling Adventures of Sabrina police drama dceu Holidays PaleyFest CBS San Diego Comic-Con Freeform Starz Character Guide crime TV Comics on TV composers 2018 Lifetime historical drama Shudder Food Network Spike harry potter finale sitcom Star Trek hist Cosplay Fall TV period drama FX jamie lee curtis dramedy National Geographic social media Hulu Showtime Pride Month supernatural Columbia Pictures Podcast First Look The CW OWN El Rey Logo Valentine's Day CBS All Access 007 20th Century Fox Mudbound Emmys Pop cats IFC Films biography Shondaland mutant Mary poppins Musicals theme song Amazon Prime political drama dragons Christmas Superheroes Year in Review golden globes Winners TLC USA Brie Larson Music Amazon doctor who Trailer Martial Arts unscripted Pirates Disney Channel Election psycho APB VICE PBS Warner Bros. 2015 Premiere Dates Reality Competition Interview serial killer NYCC Sneak Peek crossover DC Universe Rom-Com crime drama Polls and Games Star Wars Reality based on movie toy story dc green book teaser VH1 streaming ABC New York Comic Con ABC Family richard e. Grant sports WGN ITV President Rocky animated BET transformers Crackle Acorn TV disaster Quiz festivals Sony Pictures See It Skip It discovery DC streaming service comiccon 21st Century Fox adventure ratings Syfy NBC Fantasy Lionsgate TV Land Black Mirror Walt Disney Pictures Song of Ice and Fire technology TIFF Kids & Family Nominations Adult Swim Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Esquire Video Games Fox News Paramount Network psychological thriller RT History 2017 Country FXX Thanksgiving strong female leads talk show Tarantino crime thriller USA Network DGA cooking Disney WarnerMedia ESPN A&E Dark Horse Comics boxoffice justice league zombie aliens Summer Netflix comic spy thriller Sundance Comedy Stephen King Western cops LGBT Certified Fresh Chernobyl Cannes Tomatazos miniseries X-Men DC Comics Winter TV Biopics The Witch adaptation Ghostbusters Mystery Tumblr Red Carpet elevated horror The Arrangement natural history science fiction Mary Poppins Returns Paramount binge Cartoon Network spinoff MCU E! GoT American Society of Cinematographers Writers Guild of America politics YA docudrama Teen game show Pixar Heroines Opinion Nickelodeon casting HBO Film Festival cinemax Calendar Mary Tyler Moore war 2016 anthology TruTV Schedule vampires Horror BBC Set visit RT21 Pet Sematary SundanceTV nature MSNBC HBO Max medical drama television robots blaxploitation SDCC Lucasfilm SXSW singing competition diversity E3 TCA what to watch CMT witnail Musical Countdown TCM award winner mockumentary CNN Grammys Vudu Sci-Fi 45 Photos CW Seed Britbox YouTube Premium TBS Rock zero dark thirty anime spider-man Trophy Talk Best and Worst GIFs Creative Arts Emmys Superheroe Awards Tour Spectrum Originals Animation Epix AMC zombies Emmy Nominations YouTube Red Spring TV Box Office IFC Universal TCA 2017 Infographic Elton John MTV History DirecTV romance Action Awards Toys FOX Rocketman Ellie Kemper sequel Ovation Comic Book travel Marvel GLAAD Captain marvel 24 frames Mindy Kaling Trivia 2019 Drama Anna Paquin thriller Super Bowl Bravo Apple Watching Series Marathons Sundance Now Oscars Women's History Month cults Masterpiece