Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: A-Team, Karate Kid Reboots Both Not Too Bad

Plus, Winter's Bone is chilling and powerful, and a doc on Joan Rivers is smart and revealing.

by | June 11, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a pair of 1980s reboots, one featuring a band of ragtag mercenaries (The A-Team, starring Liam Neeson and Bradley Cooper), and another about an aspiring martial artist (The Karate Kid, starring Jaden Smith and Jackie Chan). What do the critics have to say?


The A-Team

Don’t you love it when a plan (or, in this case, a remake) comes together? And since we’re asking questions, is there anything wrong with a big dumb action flick every once in a while? The critics would likely answer yes to the former question, but on the later they’re largely split — at least in the case of The A-Team. For those of you who didn’t grow up in the 1980s, this is the tale of a crack commando unit that was sent to prison for a crime they didn’t commit. They promptly escaped from a maximum security stockade; today, still wanted by the government, they survive as soldiers of fortune, hoping to defeat the bad guys and clear their names. The pundits say if you like mindless action with a wink and a nod, you could do a lot worse than this reboot, which executes its set pieces with plenty of panache. If, however, you’re a fan of character development and plot, you’ve come to the wrong place.


The Karate Kid

A treasured highlight of 1980s mainstream cinema, The Karate Kid may not be a classic, but it’s got plenty of heart and charm. So, how does the remake fare? Not too badly, say critics, even if this appealing, energetic movie adheres to the plot of the original like it’s a sacred text. Jaden Smith stars as Dre, a youngster who moves to China with his mother; after running afoul of the local bully, Dre comes under the tutelage of the wise, subdued Mr. Han (Jackie Chan), who teaches him a thing or two about both martial arts and life. The pundits say this Karate Kid is slickly mounted, and benefits greatly from strong performances (particularly Chan, who lends heft and melancholy to the Mr. Miyagi role). However, some find the note-for-note retelling of the first Kid simply reinforces how dated the material is. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Jackie Chan’s best reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Winter’s Bone, drama about a 17-year-old’s desperate search for her father in an attempt to save her family’s home, is at 100 percent.

  • Joan Rivers: A Piece of Work, an intimate documentary portrait of the comedian and talk show host, is at 89 percent.
  • Reel Injun, a doc about the history of Native Americans in cinema, is at 83 percent.

  • Coco Chanel & Igor Stravinsky, a period drama about the liaison between the legendary fashion designer and the great composer, is at 56 percent.

Tag Cloud

Polls and Games historical drama cooking Grammys Marathons USA Nominations Holidays psycho Emmys Musicals thriller TCM Super Bowl DC Comics American Society of Cinematographers Masterpiece Dark Horse Comics IFC Rocky A&E Character Guide GIFs science fiction travel dramedy Premiere Dates adventure 007 Disney Teen DC Universe Certified Fresh Crackle Country Adult Swim Valentine's Day OWN Spring TV TNT VICE Fox News TCA cops Nickelodeon Countdown crime thriller Winners Interview Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt LGBTQ transformers cinemax Watching Series VH1 biography NYCC Star Wars Box Office Cartoon Network Photos BET ITV PBS YA war singing competition Animation ESPN President cats 2016 Calendar Thanksgiving Kids & Family TIFF NBC Superheroes docudrama Martial Arts Drama BBC CNN Comedy Central CMT Musical Starz FX Pirates police drama TCA 2017 crime drama Ellie Kemper 45 AMC Summer Sundance Universal 24 frames boxoffice harry potter supernatural Cosplay comiccon Awards Reality based on movie Sneak Peek 2015 Hulu sports Syfy The CW DirecTV TBS GLAAD Winter TV Reality Competition composers Warner Bros. Oscars Rock Disney Channel Music Amazon Action SDCC Netflix Best and Worst APB Election Fall TV Showtime Marvel Video Games Nat Geo TV Land Extras Tumblr TV crime FXX Logo Comedy Food Network political drama Schedule Mindy Kaling Set visit discovery History Mystery RT History Podcast SundanceTV technology Lionsgate zombie Lifetime Esquire aliens Pop Biopics CBS All Access FOX MSNBC WGN TLC MTV CBS Bravo Mary Tyler Moore Freeform sitcom Trivia Horror Infographic ABC Family X-Men E! Ghostbusters HBO Red Carpet E3 vampires Trailer The Arrangement Tomatazos TruTV PaleyFest BBC America El Rey Rom-Com serial killer ABC politics Opinion Sci-Fi Writers Guild of America Year in Review Star Trek Paramount Comic Book Toys social media diversity First Look GoT Fantasy 2017 period drama