Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Jackass" Kicks; "King" Is Dethroned; "Fearless" Is Action-Packed; "Flyboys" Is Grounded

by | September 21, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got antisocial behavior ("Jackass: Number Two," with Johnny Knoxville and the gang), hell-raising politicos ("All The King’s Men," starring Sean Penn), fearless warriors ("Fearless," starring Jet Li), and flying aces ("Flyboys," starring James Franco). What do the critics have to say?

For some, the perilous, grotesque antics of the "Jackass" posse offer inarguable proof of America’s cultural decline, if not a bellwether of the Apocalypse. For others (Critical Consensus included)… well, what can I say? Wasabi snooters? Off-road tattoo? Gets me every time. Now, Johnny Knoxville, Bam Margera, Steve-O and the rest are back with "Jackass: Number Two," a film that promises to be as puerile as its title. But guess what? It’s getting pretty good reviews! The critics say this latest collection of stoopid stunts and bad behavior maintains a certain warped integrity in addition to its sophomoric laughs. At 64 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Jackass" may be worth a ride, provided you can stomach this stuff. And it’s better-reviewed than its predecessor (49 percent).

I want those #&^%@* snakes out of this #&^%@* ball crawl!

"All The King’s Men" has everything that makes for a compelling movie. It’s got a great cast (Sean Penn, Jude Law, Kate Winslet, and Anthony Hopkins, among others). It’s based on a great novel (by Robert Penn Warren). It’s got great cinematography. Unfortunately, critics say, the superlatives end there. Loosely based on the life of populist Louisiana Governor Huey "The Kingfish" Long, "All The King’s Men" tells the story of a small town rabble-rouser’s ascent in politics and descent into shady morality. Critics say the film is too bombastic to work, with too many vague characters and an over-the-top performance from Penn. The film received a muted reception in Toronto; it currently stands at 15 percent on the Tomatometer. And it’s well below the 1949 Oscar-winning original film (94 percent).

Sean Penn makes Howard Dean seem pretty chill.

Jet Li has come to personify a specific film subgenre: the historical martial arts epic. "Hero" and the "Once Upon a Time in China" movies were marked by sweeping visuals and Li’s remarkable athleticism. But the star says he’s no longer making that type of picture; if that’s the case, critics say "Fearless" makes for one heck of a swan song. The film tells the tale of a great martial arts master who looks inward after succumbing to his own ego and the murder of his family. The scribes say "Fearless" is quite a show, with remarkable action sequences and an interesting philosophical undercurrent. "Fearless" is currently at 70 percent on the Tomatometer. And it’s Li’s third consecutive fresh American release, following "Unleashed" (68 percent) and "Hero" (94 percent).

"Fearless": I had no idea people wore baseball hats in China in the early 1900s!

"Flyboys" tells an old-fashioned tale of courage and heroism with the latest in CG technology; unfortunately, critics say, the technology ends up overshadowing everything else. The film tells the story of a group of Americans who volunteered to fly in WWI alongside the French. According to the critics, "Paths of Glory" this ain’t; they note that the CG effects are excellent, and the dogfights are exciting, but the story and the characters are far less involving. At 37 percent on the Tomatometer, "Flyboys" doesn’t soar.

"And another thing… None of you better be making any wisecracks about ‘The Pink Panther!’"

Also in theaters this week in limited release: "American Hardcore," a documentary about the life and death of the louder-faster punk rock style, is at 100 percent; "The Blossoming of Maximo Oliveros," a coming of age tale set in Manila, is at 100 percent; "Jesus Camp," a documentary about evangelical Christian campers, is at 93 percent; "Old Joy," a meditative tale of eroding friendship starring indie darling Will Oldham, is at 88 percent; "Solo Con Tu Pareja," the debut of "Y Tu Mama Tambien" helmer Alfonso Cuaron, is at 80 percent; "The Science of Sleep," Michel Gondry‘s latest head trip starring Gael Garcia Bernal and Charlotte Gainsbourg, is at 69 percent; the "Project Greenlight"- approved horror flick "Feast" is at 57 percent; and "Renaissance," a visually remarkable French noir, is at 50 percent.

"I wish I could be as carefree and wild/ But I got cat class and I got cat style."

Recent Johnny Knoxville Movies:
41% — The Ringer (2005)
0% — Daltry Calhoun (2005)
15% — The Dukes of Hazzard (2005)
54% — Lords of Dogtown (2005)
52% — A Dirty Shame (2004)

Recent Jet Li Movies:
68% — Unleashed (2005)
94% — Hero (2004)
26% — Cradle 2 the Grave (2003)
14% — The One (2001)
49% — Kiss of the Dragon (2001)

Recent Dean Deviln-Produced Movies:
90% — Who Killed the Electric Car? (2006)
54% — Cellular (2004)
47% — Eight Legged Freaks (2002)
61% — The Patriot (2000)
25% — Godzilla (1998)

Tag Cloud

Broadway A&E classics theme song 45 72 Emmy Awards Tokyo Olympics Prime Video know your critic binge DirecTV sitcom Sundance TV mcc olympics young adult scorecard Amazon Prime Video Sundance GIFs Box Office Binge Guide Film Festival Hear Us Out Tubi technology Instagram Live stand-up comedy festival criterion OWN green book saw IFC movies golden globes Neflix Pop tv talk travel 007 stop motion disaster 4/20 Superheroes cancelled WGN hispanic 90s GoT Infographic HFPA debate Pet Sematary TV movies APB crime thriller diversity SXSW best Black History Month Election TCA Awards critics CBS All Access New York Comic Con popular First Look Action Black Mirror screen actors guild spy thriller Trophy Talk game show Lifetime Christmas movies medical drama Columbia Pictures superhero Photos comics Crunchyroll Countdown Bravo Extras crossover Epix MSNBC AMC American Society of Cinematographers Cannes razzies MTV art house historical drama james bond comic books romantic comedy children's TV kong suspense Discovery Channel Interview new york mission: impossible Food Network Year in Review Cosplay period drama prank composers TV One basketball Legendary Television Critics Association spider-verse blaxploitation Masterpiece nbcuniversal Schedule justice league cancelled TV shows Kids & Family free movies The Witch genre Chilling Adventures of Sabrina kaiju Teen DGA Tumblr child's play canceled BBC America 2015 wonder woman TV renewals boxoffice news ESPN kids Biopics streaming movies Starz Alien biopic Character Guide El Rey hollywood ABC Signature Pacific Islander Toys die hard Rocky Comic Book directors Netflix Christmas movies Trailer boxing 2017 Marvel Studios name the review heist movie Walt Disney Pictures The Walking Dead gangster Reality Competition National Geographic live action Reality Funimation Chernobyl Western E! Hulu Martial Arts Stephen King Comics on TV Set visit Song of Ice and Fire Classic Film video on demand singing competition Syfy slashers worst action-comedy LGBTQ DC streaming service Image Comics President australia Sci-Fi war godzilla sopranos BET Awards comedies king arthur Heroines PBS rotten ITV Captain marvel facebook Rocketman Awards Tour Sony Pictures Comic-Con@Home 2021 A24 TV Land AMC Plus Netflix canceled TV shows dramedy Ovation dceu adventure Musicals documentary Vudu VICE 71st Emmy Awards Britbox Fargo Emmy Nominations sequel Hallmark Christmas movies dragons Wes Anderson fast and furious jamie lee curtis Apple TV+ Spectrum Originals Star Trek finale 2021 sports Spike Rom-Com spain serial killer Arrowverse japanese remakes Disney nfl halloween First Reviews Travel Channel 2020 rotten movies we love sequels Mary poppins Creative Arts Emmys mockumentary scary movies Peacock trailers Rock indie football Family The Arrangement Certified Fresh Anna Paquin slasher RT History cults archives cinemax strong female leads San Diego Comic-Con festivals toronto social media spanish language FX witnail legend concert ABC Grammys hispanic heritage month Amazon Studios Baby Yoda PaleyFest Music docudrama casting Nat Geo Television Academy politics YA Shondaland true crime target versus universal monsters 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards new zealand hist Universal Pictures Emmys ABC Family spanish spinoff police drama Calendar rt labs Women's History Month Trivia GLAAD YouTube Premium Adult Swim laika 2018 Turner VH1 based on movie 93rd Oscars Film streaming Apple TV Plus a nightmare on elm street Endgame Lifetime BBC One Universal Disney streaming service parents Paramount Network french teaser Lionsgate video Drama YouTube Red IMDb TV Winners BET NBA TIFF Comedy 99% natural history hidden camera Summer satire vs. Premiere Dates robots cancelled TV series FOX scene in color space Star Wars comic book movies blockbuster The Walt Disney Company MCU CW Seed PlayStation NYCC Awards comic Mary Tyler Moore science fiction WarnerMedia Super Bowl zombie Dark Horse Comics rt archives zero dark thirty psycho doctor who biography reboot quibi Disney Plus marvel comics Shudder Superheroe NBC ratings comiccon Watching Series scary Showtime vampires cancelled television king kong Avengers Sundance Now live event werewolf comic book movie Disney+ Disney Plus all-time The CW international DC Universe Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt new star wars movies cops trophy TCA 2017 rom-coms adenture Video Games SDCC asian-american zombies Warner Bros. Quiz political drama black cooking HBO Go fresh ghosts animated 79th Golden Globes Awards cars batman pirates of the caribbean royal family ViacomCBS TNT RT21 Pride Month TruTV chucky Musical what to watch series Lucasfilm unscripted Esquire latino high school aapi golden globe awards anthology indiana jones screenings cats 24 frames leaderboard black comedy Turner Classic Movies monster movies Valentine's Day breaking bad Hollywood Foreign Press Association Fox News Polls and Games discovery docuseries USA Network LGBT Thanksgiving Paramount Spring TV Mystery mutant obituary Podcast south america Holiday ID Amazon Prime adaptation worst movies mob Nominations marvel cinematic universe Horror dark dexter crime drama sag awards Winter TV BAFTA Mary Poppins Returns TCA Apple 73rd Emmy Awards critic resources SundanceTV women Elton John HBO Max cartoon talk show jurassic park Nickelodeon Ghostbusters dreamworks Tags: Comedy posters lord of the rings 2019 DC Comics Tomatazos joker rt labs critics edition thriller telelvision CMT TCM History 20th Century Fox miniseries HBO YouTube BBC Brie Larson elevated horror TCA Winter 2020 dc The Academy CNN CBS dogs OneApp Academy Awards revenge Animation Freeform television Acorn TV venice Country Opinion Cartoon Network 2016 independent franchise twilight Logo Red Carpet 21st Century Fox Crackle blockbusters Paramount Plus documentaries Ellie Kemper Best and Worst FXX award winner feel good Pop TV FX on Hulu Disney Channel Marvel Television renewed TV shows emmy awards supernatural movie halloween tv italian X-Men 1990s Fantasy Mindy Kaling book USA TV toy story TBS harry potter Fall TV Pixar Christmas romance anime E3 stoner game of thrones Mudbound superman richard e. Grant Sneak Peek reviews Oscars Exclusive Video IFC Films Hallmark See It Skip It Tarantino crime Amazon transformers Marvel The Purge Comedy Central christmas movies Holidays spider-man VOD book adaptation aliens Fox Searchlight deadpool foreign Marathons Writers Guild of America Pirates nature psychological thriller japan films TLC