Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Borat" Best Reviewed Film Of Year: High-Five!; "Flushed Away" Worth A Spin; "Santa Clause 3" Gets Coal

by | November 2, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies brings us the profound discoveries of a great Kazak journalist ("Borat," starring Sacha Baron Cohen), a battle between Santa and Jack Frost ("The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause," starring Tim Allen), and a tale of rats in the sewer ("Flushed Away," featuring the voice work of Kate Winslet and Hugh Jackman). What do the critics have to say?

Jagshemash! Here in U.S and A., what do critic say about "Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan?" They like! In fact, the scribes are almost universally pleased with the film, and some are going as far as calling it one of the funniest comedies ever. Part satire, part shockumentary, "Borat" follows the gleefully sexist, homophobic, and anti-Semitic title character (Cohen) on a cross-country trek to learn more about our strange nation; along the way he dredges up the seamy underbelly of American prejudice and ignorance. At 95 percent on the Tomatometer, "Borat" is not only Certified Fresh, it’s the best reviewed wide release of the year, topping such acclaimed movies as "Dave Chappelle’s Block Party," "The Departed," and "United 93." That’s a good thing, since Borat himself has said if the movie doesn’t do well, he will be execute.

Borat loves the U.S. and A.

It doesn’t sound like the most auspicious subject for a film: mice and rats are flushed down a toilet, where they find a bustling municipality in the sewer. However, in the hands of Aardman Productions, the endlessly imaginative company responsible for "Chicken Run" and "Wallace and Gromit," anything is possible. And so it is with "Flushed Away," which tells the upstairs-downstairs tale of a coddled mouse who finds action and adventure after a trip through the plumbing. Critics say that while "Flushed Away" may not achieve the dizzying heights of "Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit" (which scored 95 percent on the Tomatometer), it’s an eccentric, inventive family film with plenty of laughs. At 76 percent on the Tomatometer, "Flushed Away" is critically sanitized for your viewing pleasure.

Dive in! It’s fresh!

"The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause," was barely screened for critics, much like star Tim Allen‘s last flick, "Zoom." The big difference is that "Clause" at least has a couple good reviews, whereas "Zoom" had none. The story of Santa’s duel with Jack Frost for control over Christmas, "Clause" hasn’t exactly enchanted the critics who have seen it; they say the movie is labored and mostly mirthless. It’s currently at 29 percent on the Tomatometer.

Yes, Virginia, there is a "Santa Clause 3."

Also opening this week in limited release: "Commune," a documentary about the Black Bear Ranch in California, is at 100 percent; "Romantico," a heartbreaking documentary about a musician working illegally in the U.S., is at 100 percent; Pedro Almodovar‘s "Volver," starring Penelope Cruz in a complex tale of womanhood, is Certified Fresh at 90 percent; "Wondrous Oblivion," the story of a boy and his neighbor who bond over the game of cricket, is at 60 percent; "Death & Texas," a death penalty satire, is at 60 percent; the twisty thriller "Unknown," starring Greg Kinnear, is at 29 percent; "Shottas," a based-on-true-events Jamaican crime flick, is at 20 percent; and "Zerophilia," a gender-bending rom-com, is at 18 percent.

Pedro Almodovar and Penelope Cruz take a spectral walk down memory lane with "Volver." Check out our retrospective of the Spanish director’s work here.

Finally, we’d like to bestow props upon the whimsically monikered killthemall4444, who correctly predicted that the equally whimsical "Saw III" would wind up with a Tomatometer of 28 percent. Congrats, ktm4444.

Best Reviewed Wide Releases of 2006:
95% — Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan
93% — Dave Chappelle’s Block Party
93% — The Departed
90% — United 93
88% — Inside Man
84%– Akeelah and the Bee
83% — Slither
83% — The Descent
80% — A Prairie Home Companion
79% — Catch a Fire

Recent Tim Allen Movies:
0% — Zoom (2006)
28% — The Shaggy Dog (2006)
4% — Christmas with the Kranks (2004)
55% — The Santa Clause 2 (2002)
22% — Who Is Cletis Tout? (2002)

Recent Sacha Baron Cohen Movies:
72% — Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby (2006)
55% — Madagascar (2005)
55% — Ali G Indahouse: The Movie (2002)

Tag Cloud

films Ellie Kemper game show versus Premiere Dates Grammys south america 4/20 Mary poppins docudrama FOX black unscripted Baby Yoda Disney Channel foreign GoT news romance science fiction parents strong female leads Interview DGA Comics on TV Thanksgiving Ovation 21st Century Fox jamie lee curtis Sundance Now Black History Month psycho game of thrones Columbia Pictures Vudu NYCC Creative Arts Emmys Holiday chucky Tomatazos political drama Fox News Family Endgame Podcast latino 2016 cartoon doctor who mockumentary TLC laika Box Office canceled TV shows Fantasy Mindy Kaling cancelled Fall TV Nickelodeon Election Universal YouTube diversity CNN Disney streaming service crime drama Pride Month Superheroes 71st Emmy Awards remakes 20th Century Fox franchise streaming X-Men Amazon Prime Tumblr worst movies See It Skip It Opinion all-time comedies Nat Geo dceu Action batman period drama football Marvel police drama National Geographic cops children's TV Brie Larson criterion slashers Music aliens ABC Family Trailer video zero dark thirty E3 Marvel Television sequels Masterpiece comic books Watching Series YouTube Premium Video Games Turner Classic Movies screenings cancelled television BET robots Adult Swim OWN hollywood Mudbound TCA Winter 2020 Martial Arts SXSW Freeform Hallmark Christmas movies Comic Book RT History fast and furious joker archives boxoffice MCU Sony Pictures First Reviews ghosts Pet Sematary Cosplay Apple TV+ Pop comic Walt Disney Pictures cars WarnerMedia Black Mirror HBO Go nfl breaking bad YouTube Red superhero blaxploitation BET Awards canceled crossover Awards Tour thriller ESPN sitcom zombies FX scary movies Turner Comedy revenge venice Cannes free movies cults mutant A24 harry potter Emmys Syfy nature TCA The Walking Dead japanese blockbuster TCM Awards Binge Guide based on movie satire sports golden globes Academy Awards Stephen King dramedy E! Biopics indiana jones biography MTV FX on Hulu Sneak Peek spinoff Trophy Talk historical drama Winter TV theme song Trivia Lifetime Tarantino Tubi renewed TV shows Character Guide serial killer Mary Poppins Returns ABC 45 Funimation Photos adaptation BBC One CMT Spike Hallmark San Diego Comic-Con natural history ITV Apple TV Plus Disney best CW Seed SundanceTV SDCC DirecTV anime Women's History Month PaleyFest Western DC Universe transformers 007 sequel Classic Film Valentine's Day spanish language discovery Red Carpet DC Comics CBS Britbox Captain marvel die hard AMC vampires OneApp Emmy Nominations politics social media Amazon Prime Video VH1 halloween Acorn TV Mystery Netflix cats USA Network Disney+ Disney Plus Sci-Fi TNT directors Schedule Calendar Nominations NBC Rocketman television Countdown FXX rotten richard e. Grant Lionsgate composers christmas movies teaser Heroines facebook HBO stand-up comedy Year in Review Warner Bros. TV Land what to watch Shondaland Comedy Central Summer quibi USA spider-man concert BAFTA asian-american 2020 Mary Tyler Moore Hulu Television Critics Association Starz Marvel Studios Film Sundance First Look Spring TV Amazon talk show video on demand 2018 singing competition Polls and Games supernatural The Arrangement reboot American Society of Cinematographers Discovery Channel tv talk festivals Animation italian medical drama Rocky ID romantic comedy CBS All Access green book independent Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Paramount Network cinemax hist Super Bowl twilight scorecard a nightmare on elm street Dark Horse Comics witnail Epix mission: impossible Reality 2017 Drama deadpool President Chernobyl Holidays dragons LGBT documentary BBC dogs movie Paramount TV travel Sundance TV Set visit Toys crime The Academy VICE Song of Ice and Fire Certified Fresh toronto Logo true crime Lucasfilm IFC Films The CW APB Teen A&E documentaries ratings justice league Shudder Apple 2019 worst TBS stoner rotten movies we love halloween tv toy story nbcuniversal stop motion VOD Writers Guild of America History Country New York Comic Con Rom-Com award winner crime thriller Spectrum Originals movies comics war Pirates cooking comiccon RT21 psychological thriller LGBTQ Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TruTV Esquire series Anna Paquin name the review Netflix Christmas movies Peacock PBS Musicals Reality Competition Cartoon Network binge TIFF australia Ghostbusters Kids & Family IFC Best and Worst miniseries werewolf Food Network Arrowverse cancelled TV series Elton John sag awards child's play The Purge Avengers animated elevated horror emmy awards classics Pixar Lifetime Christmas movies obituary TCA 2017 spy thriller Horror GIFs Marathons disaster adventure Film Festival finale The Witch cancelled TV shows GLAAD El Rey Musical Hear Us Out zombie Crunchyroll dark Travel Channel Crackle Superheroe critics MSNBC Bravo anthology Star Wars Amazon Studios french YA 2015 Quiz TV renewals Christmas Winners festival Television Academy Disney Plus Infographic screen actors guild technology DC streaming service hispanic PlayStation 24 frames reviews Showtime indie kids Star Trek spanish rt archives WGN dc Rock Fox Searchlight TCA Awards 72 Emmy Awards Extras casting book Oscars space BBC America universal monsters spain Pop TV HBO Max