Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: A So-So "Year", "Fiction" Works; "Babel" Shoots and Scores; "Harsh Times" Lives Up To Its Title; Guess "Return"'s Tomatometer!

by | November 9, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we ve got a rom-com in Provence ("A Good Year," starring Russell Crowe), a guy whose life is a novel ("Stranger than Fiction," starring Will Ferrell), interconnected tales of despair ("Babel," starring Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett), a tough homecoming ("Harsh Times," starring Christian Bale), and supernatural visions ("The Return," starring Sarah Michelle Gellar). What do the critics say?

"Stranger than Fiction" is a movie about a guy named Harold Crick (Will Ferrell) who discovers that his life is being narrated and controlled by a bitter, brilliant novelist (Emma Thompson) who intends to do him in. As a result, Crick tries to turn the tables and reclaim his own life story. Sounds totally meta, huh? Well, critics generally say this is one head trip that won’t trip you up, thanks to warm performances and an agreeably kooky (and not over-heady) script. At 68 percent on the Tomatometer, it’s a fact that "Fiction" is Fresh.

"Guess how much I liked ‘Mystery, Alaska.’"

There’s a new movie out called "A Good Year" that’s being described as "Under the Tuscan Sun" with a guy in the main role. Even weirder, it’s from the ultra-macho team of Ridley Scott and Russell Crowe — y’know, the dudes who brought you "Gladiator." Perhaps it isn’t much of a surprise that the critics are finding this pairing of filmmakers and material doesn’t totally work. Crowe stars as an arrogant, hyper-competitive London banker who inherits a house in Provence; laughs, love and life-lessons ensue. The scribes give Crowe and Scott props for trying to stretch, but unfortunately, they also say the film is working way too hard to be whimsical. At 29 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Year" isn’t looking so…. well, you get the idea.

"Babel" is a story of a shot heard ’round the world. A boy in Morocco unintentionally shoots an American tourist, and the ramifications of his mistake are felt in the U.S., Mexico, and Japan. Critics are praising Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu‘s latest as an elaborate, stylistically deft emotional juggling act, with fine performances from Brad Pitt, Cate Blanchett, and particularly Rinko Kikuchi as a deaf teenager trying to make her way in the world. If there is a complaint from the scribes, it’s that "Babel" may be overly ambitious, but most concede that it’s ambition of a high order. At 73 percent on the Tomatometer, "Babel" is Certified Fresh.

"I suggest you stop killing people; it’s doing a number on your cholesterol."

"Harsh Times" is not a movie with a misleading title. However, critics are split on whether this dark, intense story of an Iraq war vet returning home is ultimately rewarding. "Harsh Times" stars Christian Bale as a man consumed by his memories of war; as he tries to integrate back into society, he finds it impossible to suppress his violent impulses. Some critics have praised "Harsh Times" for its performances and intensity, but others say it’s too relentlessly grim and brutal to really be worthwhile. "Harsh Times" currently stands at 52 percent on the Tomatometer.

"The Return" marks Sarah Michelle Gellar‘s, uh, return to the horror genre. Guess what? It wasn’t screened for critics. Guess that Tomatometer, children.

"To tell you the truth, I’ve been listening to a lot of Prince lately."

Also opening this week in limited release: the Mongolian import "The Cave of the Yellow Dog," featuring breathtaking scenery as well as cute kids and adorable doggies, is at 100 percent on the Tomatometer; "Iraq in Fragments," a structurally adventurous documentary about the state of Iraq, is at 82 percent; "Cautiva," an Argentine film coming-of-age tale about an uprooted teenager, is at 80 percent; "Come Early Morning," a tale of Southern small-town life starring Ashley Judd, is at 65 percent; "F***," an examination of the English language’s naughtiest word, is at 50 percent; "Fur: An Imaginary Portrait of Diane Arbus," starring Nicole Kidman as the gifted but troubled photographer, is at 33 percent; and the historical fiction "Copying Beethoven," about the great composer’s relationship with a copyist, is at 27 percent.

Recent Russell Crowe Movies:
81% — Cinderella Man (2005)
85% — Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World (2003)
78% — A Beautiful Mind (2001)
40% — Proof of Life (2000)
78% — Gladiator (2000)

Recent Will Ferrell Movies:
72% — Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby (2006)
41% — Winter Passing (2006)
70% — Curious George (2006)
52% — The Producers (2005)
24% — Bewitched (2005)

Tag Cloud

A&E X-Men MSNBC prank space TCM TV movies halloween tv TBS Sundance TV Adult Swim Action theme song Alien NBA slasher cancelled television The Walking Dead Masterpiece Paramount Epix Endgame summer TV preview Amazon Prime Video Spike golden globes 79th Golden Globes Awards boxoffice BBC One NBC child's play scene in color series blockbuster Fargo elevated horror what to watch award winner Sneak Peek reviews Red Carpet Cosplay AMC Plus game show Polls and Games universal monsters movies archives free movies screenings joker halloween FXX Character Guide 1990s streamig Geeked Week a nightmare on elm street pirates of the caribbean spider-verse Summer dreamworks critics 4/20 zero dark thirty hispanic heritage month 21st Century Fox YA Musical comic Extras video on demand The Witch boxing international romance hidden camera razzies social media PlayStation ABC IFC ABC Signature Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Calendar comic book movie Schedule Marathons Quiz cinemax Writers Guild of America Superheroe based on movie Ghostbusters ITV robots 71st Emmy Awards green book Anna Paquin Star Wars Celebration jamie lee curtis Acorn TV 90s Sundance finale ViacomCBS hist Best Actress canceled TV shows Trophy Talk E3 kong ID Holiday Black Mirror BBC Heroines VH1 true crime Peacock The Purge Apple TV+ Sony Pictures President psycho Set visit Pop TV italian independent IFC Films crime drama Reality Competition 20th Century Fox Neflix Star Trek TruTV all-time comic books cooking Lifetime 2015 OWN Toys medical drama Tokyo Olympics name the review 2018 docudrama Arrowverse Lucasfilm dragons See It Skip It Starz Comedy Creative Arts Emmys Avengers cancelled indie miniseries 73rd Emmy Awards dc biopic children's TV Lionsgate SundanceTV IMDb TV trophy police drama christmas movies news TLC mob VICE Universal 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards black comedy HBO Max football Hulu 72 Emmy Awards Tags: Comedy Country spain royal family APB Film Festival 2017 marvel cinematic universe Sundance Now FX First Look Pacific Islander Film Drama spanish book adaptation breaking bad period drama king arthur E! toronto ESPN Academy Awards golden globe awards TV Land Comic-Con@Home 2021 Song of Ice and Fire australia Amazon Studios crossover Sony canceled adaptation nfl video Marvel Studios Mary Tyler Moore trailers Hear Us Out Christmas die hard dark Vudu Interview Pixar SXSW Women's History Month scary movies know your critic parents Travel Channel BAFTA mutant mcc Television Academy Video Games concert worst movies emmy awards criterion Mudbound DGA batman cartoon new york monster movies GoT FX on Hulu spider-man Rock kids Walt Disney Pictures National Geographic biography laika Instagram Live RT21 Discovery Channel saw teaser 45 binge werewolf Countdown Disney WGN Focus Features toy story tv talk RT History festivals BBC America FOX aliens sports summer preview Spring TV Turner fast and furious First Reviews Awards crime thriller Emmy Nominations basketball DirecTV Spectrum Originals talk show godzilla Elton John 2016 TCA 2017 worst stop motion Trailer Fox Searchlight target scene in color Cartoon Network composers wonder woman CNN series Comics on TV Cannes posters Western Native best Comic Book cults debate dceu comic book movies 2020 science fiction Logo Paramount Plus CW Seed BET Awards japan Nickelodeon Best Director Winter TV obi wan AMC psychological thriller richard e. Grant Shondaland American Society of Cinematographers TCA Opinion Hallmark lord of the rings Photos blockbusters Sci-Fi Exclusive Video Broadway GLAAD Apple TV Plus Valentine's Day Election comics LGBT scary popular Biopics Syfy versus renewed TV shows spinoff serial killer target films live action Ellie Kemper sitcom twilight Disney Plus slashers Tomatazos hispanic Tubi young adult fresh TV renewals HFPA NYCC disaster GIFs PaleyFest jurassic park USA feel good scorecard olympics comiccon Tumblr Legendary genre Kids & Family Dark Horse Comics witnail 94th Oscars Horror Mystery Universal Pictures blaxploitation gangster Ovation cancelled TV shows classics Reality Best Actor docuseries nbcuniversal Hallmark Christmas movies Rocky DC Universe WarnerMedia ratings Box Office Rom-Com king kong Disney Channel rt archives nature justice league Prime Video Black History Month quibi Apple suspense Fall TV festival Indigenous obituary revenge Watching Series CBS All Access Animation sequels critic resources aapi superhero CMT streaming movies Disney+ Disney Plus Superheroes singing competition war SXSW 2022 indiana jones Grammys doctor who CBS Music Showtime high school Musicals Mindy Kaling Marvel supernatural action-comedy kaiju vampires Crunchyroll marvel comics Premiere Dates TNT interviews television scene in color film series Super Bowl Tarantino 2019 discovery ghosts mission: impossible YouTube Premium Martial Arts Food Network franchise cops rt labs critics edition HBO MCU directors Esquire Family Oscar comedies Turner Classic Movies stoner The Walt Disney Company Shudder Warner Bros. Marvel Television technology spy thriller Chilling Adventures of Sabrina BET historical drama superman DC Comics YouTube DC streaming service political drama Thanksgiving New York Comic Con Classic Film zombies cats french SDCC harry potter leaderboard Fantasy Netflix anime james bond latino MGM Best and Worst heist movie Disney streaming service venice Image Comics rotten movies we love south america anthology 007 Crackle mockumentary Lifetime Christmas movies game of thrones transformers The Arrangement Nominations hollywood sopranos telelvision 99% summer TV adventure documentaries vs. VOD spanish language travel scene in color documentary Binge Guide unscripted Nat Geo Podcast Funimation screen actors guild TV Fox News broadcast Year in Review reboot japanese live event Star Wars OneApp Certified Fresh satire Captain marvel sequel Paramount Pictures Paramount Network romantic comedy animated Pop A24 Mary Poppins Returns new zealand zombie dramedy facebook TCA Awards San Diego Comic-Con 93rd Oscars Awards Tour Britbox Stephen King diversity Hollywood Foreign Press Association Teen Amazon Prime USA Network Pet Sematary Columbia Pictures natural history stand-up comedy Television Critics Association strong female leads streaming Amazon South by Southwest Film Festival rt labs thriller dexter Freeform rom-coms History foreign HBO Go The CW YouTube Red rotten black 2021 LGBTQ Baby Yoda book PBS TV One women remakes Winners legend Trivia Best Picture Brie Larson sag awards chucky El Rey Pride Month politics Chernobyl TCA Winter 2020 Infographic Oscars asian-american TIFF deadpool casting adenture cancelled TV series Rocketman Wes Anderson MTV new star wars movies The Academy dogs crime Emmys Pirates cars Netflix Christmas movies ABC Family Bravo Comedy Central movie Holidays art house Mary poppins 24 frames