News

6 Big Questions About Warner Bros.' HBO Max 2021 Release Strategy (And the Future of Theatrical Releasing)

Will other studios follow suit? How do filmmakers feel? And could WB reverse course? We're asking it all!

by | December 6, 2020 | Comments

Gal Gadot in Wonder Woman 1984

(Photo by Clay Enos/©2020 Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.)

During the summer of the pandemic, Warner Bros. was holding true to the optimism that a partial movie season could be salvaged. They had two of the season’s most-anticipated films under their belt – Tenet and Wonder Woman 1984 – and even leaned into the branding that the former’s release could be the thing that saved movie theaters from months of shutdown. Though America saw some hope in major cities flattening the curve, it was short-lived and caution continued to influence policy and re-openings. As a result, Disney moved scheduled summer release Mulan to streaming and WB was forced to inch back its releases of Tenet and Wonder Woman 1984.

Ultimately, Tenet was released theatrically in August and did as well as one possibly could – especially internationally – when faced with limited venues, scared moviegoers, and a final product that some felt didn’t live up to everyone’s lofty expectations. After a few more shifts, WB finally decided to release Wonder Woman 1984 on Christmas Day – but then decided to do so both in theaters (where safe) and on its affiliated streaming platform, HBO Max. The announcement of the dual release strategy was a volcanic moment for a debate that has raged since March about whether studios would, could, or should sacrifice potential hundreds of millions of dollars in theatrical revenue for their guaranteed blockbusters by going straight to streaming.

Then, two weeks later, WB went one further: It announced it would release its entire 2021 slate simultaneously on HBO Max and in theaters – a slate that includes blockbusters like The Suicide SquadDune, and In the Heights. Many began to wonder: Was this going to be the way of the future? Were the days of theatrical releasing over? There are still many questions to consider before calling the time for the patient on the table, we think, and here are some of the most pertinent – and what you should know about them.


Will Other Studios Follow In Warner Bros’ Footsteps?

Timothee Chalamet and Rebecca Ferguson in Dune

(Photo by Chiabella James/Warner Bros. Entertainment)

Others studios have been exploring different release models since this mess officially kicked into gear nine months ago. Universal got the ball rolling with a temp fix, helping to ease a little parental stress by sticking with its Trolls World Tour release date, only to move it to streaming services for a price. After initial pushback from AMC Theatres about the movie, they eventually worked out a longer-term deal where the length of commitment of Universal’s films in their locations would be determined on immediate box office success. So, lower-grossing films would be moved to streaming after three weeks, at which time a lower split-profit model with the theaters would kick in; higher-grossing movies would stay.

Disney, too, experimented in changing the game with Mulan, but the title’s $30 price tag (comparable to a small family trip to a matinee) on top of the subscription price did not translate into the kind of headline-grabbing total that business and box office analysts would salivate over.

So now what? Is Paramount+ going to expand the revamped CBS All Access from television into their feature library? Can Lionsgate Play’s recent soft launch from India make its way over to the States? Would Sony be able to bring “Let’s Crackle and Chill” into the lexicon? Disney’s acquisition of Fox already reduced the number of these questions by one, but so far they have been skittish to move their blue chip titles over to immediate home viewing. Sending Artemis Fowl and The One and Only Ivan to Disney+ felt more like acceptable sacrifices rather than trailblazing.

However, the numbers on Pixar’s Soul (now directly competing with Wonder Woman 1984 on HBO Max over Christmas) could begin to shift Disney’s thinking. Universal’s Peacock service may be the one to watch in the near future. Trolls kicked off the conversation and any commitment from another franchise-heavy studio to simultaneous theatrical/streaming releases would send speculation into overdrive – and there may be officially no way back to the old model. On the other hand…


Is a Less-Crowded Marketplace A Great Incentive for Others To Stay in the Theatrical Game?

Black Widow

(Photo by © Marvel Studios, © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

Warner Bros. is continuing to utilize theaters for its 2021 slate. But when a single ticket in certain areas will cost more than a monthly subscription to an entire library of content, the incentive to head out – in a still-new (presumably) post-vaccine landscape – may be reduced to the kind of purists who still buy albums. Socially-distanced or streaming-distanced, those who still like getting out and about could still have major event options in their local theater, which may not want to give up more than a single screen for the movies playing at home. A few shifts to the schedule and studios could take advantage of the voids left by The Suicide Squad in the August kickoff slot and Dune in October, the period that WB has recently taken up a bunch of space in with Joker, Gravity, and A Star is Born. The HBO Max partnership may have sent three potential $100 million grossers (Godzilla vs. Kong, The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It, In the Heights) from May-to-July next year, but Universal and Disney still have scheduled Black Widow, Fast & Furious 9, Minions: The Rise of Gru, and Jungle Cruise in that frame, which could see double or triple those numbers. Again, this is all dependent on the success of the vaccines and the comfort-level of our society. WB bet on this and lost last summer and clearly did not want to again.


Will There Be Pushback From Filmmakers?

Tenet

(Photo by © Warner Bros. / Courtesy Everett Collection)

Someone who has definitely benefited from the seemingly unlimited pocketbook of the leader in streaming is Martin Scorsese. A three-and-a-half epic such as The Irishman, costing anywhere from $150 million to $250 million, likely would not have gone forward anywhere else but Netflix, and now Apple is backing his latest, Killers of the Flower Moon. Paramount is still slated to distribute the film theatrically, but that is another $180-$200 million price tag just as of today. Artists like Scorsese are not nearly as interested in bottom lines as the studios are, especially if he gets to keep working regardless. Will supporters of the theatrical experience as an integral component of cinema be so ready to give it up, though?

One cannot imagine Christopher Nolan is on board with Warner Bros.’ 2021 distribution model. (The studio has distributed seven of his 11 movies.) Many feel the filmmaker’s insistence on releasing his work on the biggest screen possible was one of the many reasons the studio felt it had no choice but to put Tenet in theaters (regular and IMAX) first. If WB does stand alone on this for the time being, is that going to hurt their standing with those filmmakers with the power to insist their movies play on something larger than a 55-inch screen? It is highly doubtful that James Cameron has spent 86 years working on the Avatar sequels only to watch Disney potentially shift gears on their event pictures.


Can Theaters Offer New Incentives to Get Us In the Door?

In the Heights

(Photo by Macall Polay / © Warner Bros. / Courtesy Everett Collection)

3-D engaged moviegoers in the 1950s, got a brief, largely lame revival in the ’80s. and then generated extra box office in the late ’90s and beyond; super-wide Cinemascope was utilized to dazzle home viewers away from their newly-bought television screens into a much grander experience. Today, theaters may have exhausted their technological innovations – and no one is making a special trip to have their seats vibrate with the noise. So they may be down to the best possible innovation of all in a post-pandemic world: savings. Depending on the theater chain, a trip to the movies for a family these days can feel like one to a professional ball game. MoviePass was a fun, if financially irrational, experiment that benefited weekly attendees. Would local theaters be able to manifest something comparable that would encourage movie fans to offer a bigger, traditional night out that will not have them weighing the savings versus a monthly subscription cost? More importantly, can they do it without being subjected to the ire of studios who feels themselves losing out on the scraps they may still be providing to the theaters if discounts, punch cards, and 2-for-1 specials become necessary.


Could Sneak Previews Make a Big Comeback?

(Photo by © Warner Bros.)

You may be revealing your age if you do not remember the practice of sneak previews. It actually was not that long ago and many faces would light up at the prospect of seeing a commercial or newspaper ad revealing that the movie they could not wait to see would not make me wait any longer with a one-time showing on Saturday night. Imagine you are just a week away from seeing Dune or Matrix 4, and WB announces that you can see them in theaters – for one night only – before the official launch. Would there be a flock comparable to recent Amazon “sneak preview” events like Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle and Aquaman, which netted around $2 million each, or Fandango’s high-selling Early Access screening series? Films good enough to generate ecstatic word-of-mouth could certainly encourage more fans to rally around the big screens for their first viewing – and potentially discover the incentives theaters may develop to bring them back.


Finally, Could Warner Bros. Reverse Course?

The Suicide Squad

(Photo by © Warner Bros.)

The streaming of Universal’s Trolls World Tour was a big success early in our pandemic times; six weeks later, Scoob! failed to replicate it. Tenet tried to correct the blockbuster drought in theaters, but did not live up to Warner Bros.’ hopes, and eventually Wonder Woman 1984 comes home without the restraint of a separate $30 Mulan surcharge. The world is not out of the woods yet and while vaccines provide optimism, there are still so many unanswered questions. Who knows what the future will hold between now and the still-scheduled summer movie season slated to kickoff in May with Marvel’s Black Widow? If Disney holds course and we see a $100 million box office report on May 9, will WB consider delaying premieres of The Suicide Squad and Dune on HBO Max? It seems unlikely that the entire strategy would be abandoned in 2021 after all the headlines it has generated. That may also depend on how quickly other studios jump at the chance to make some of their own. Everything is an experimentation at this point, with various parties considering and even rooting for success or failure. Jumping right to a half-empty conclusion is premature… though there is no reason not to prepare for all possibilities.


Erik Childress can be heard each week evaluating box office on WGN Radio with Nick Digilio as well as on Business First AM with Angela Miles and his Movie Madness Podcast.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Thumbnail image: Chiabella James for © Warner Bros. 

Tag Cloud

Lifetime E3 Oscars Vudu football venice rt archives Showtime rt labs hollywood Writers Guild of America police drama feel good james bond satire indie rt labs critics edition child's play reboot binge Comic-Con@Home 2021 Infographic E! Mystery trophy GLAAD what to watch Disney Plus mission: impossible Oscar rom-coms twilight basketball Lucasfilm Hollywood Foreign Press Association blockbusters Set visit BBC One Superheroe Kids & Family 45 stand-up comedy Interview Podcast OneApp Watching Series IMDb TV chucky medical drama Trailer Pet Sematary San Diego Comic-Con renewed TV shows dc Ghostbusters criterion breaking bad 2019 SXSW 2022 hist CBS All Access Sneak Peek justice league Hulu 90s emmy awards italian 2016 Rock olympics New York Comic Con richard e. Grant golden globe awards Classic Film nfl Tomatazos target casting Masterpiece Shudder adaptation ESPN Food Network Disney streaming service best cops Walt Disney Pictures Creative Arts Emmys cartoon Super Bowl NYCC Mary Tyler Moore Black History Month marvel cinematic universe elevated horror Endgame ABC Signature Best Actor comic books suspense witnail children's TV television Amazon Studios summer TV preview Family pirates of the caribbean Awards Tour President Spring TV supernatural DC Comics ratings kong Premiere Dates Paramount Disney HBO spain Tags: Comedy biography GIFs See It Skip It Grammys dreamworks MCU cancelled TV series dogs teaser black comedy FX crossover romance Sci-Fi Polls and Games PaleyFest transformers TV One space TCA 2017 Travel Channel scary VICE TCM 4/20 Best Director Song of Ice and Fire versus toronto animated The Walking Dead Paramount Pictures SDCC strong female leads Cosplay 2017 sports Captain marvel japan docudrama The Walt Disney Company The Arrangement tv talk serial killer Focus Features Amazon Prime Elton John slasher comics diversity YouTube Premium blockbuster films Drama name the review scene in color Rocky Best Actress cooking reviews anthology TV renewals Pop TV Turner BET Awards Sundance Now Opinion Black Mirror 21st Century Fox Ovation Image Comics quibi universal monsters Chilling Adventures of Sabrina know your critic Extras joker ID ViacomCBS Video Games Biopics Tubi SundanceTV CBS CMT Western sequel Marathons stoner lord of the rings boxing Countdown game of thrones TLC parents Neflix theme song First Look The Academy nature NBC mcc stop motion documentaries adenture Spectrum Originals streamig zombies Certified Fresh romantic comedy Discovery Channel leaderboard Baby Yoda Exclusive Video 2018 sequels HFPA critic resources thriller Tokyo Olympics 72 Emmy Awards A&E NBA remakes finale jurassic park game show Chernobyl festival war Netflix Christmas movies Fox Searchlight Lifetime Christmas movies Amazon Prime Video comiccon Paramount Plus TV Land Schedule politics dceu OWN art house indiana jones hispanic The Witch social media MSNBC Holiday Tumblr Anna Paquin trailers documentary razzies 93rd Oscars international Pop YA historical drama laika classics Best and Worst screen actors guild Universal 94th Oscars Fantasy series Christmas Ellie Kemper canceled TV shows revenge Marvel Television GoT superhero Music fast and furious comic book movies Paramount Network spanish Emmy Nominations french summer TV Brie Larson superman science fiction golden globes spinoff cinemax crime thriller IFC dragons Stephen King aapi comedies award winner Rocketman critics screenings zombie mutant 2020 Mary poppins crime godzilla Tarantino werewolf 1990s spy thriller Peacock debate Disney+ Disney Plus Mindy Kaling halloween tv Comic Book asian-american Calendar TCA Awards live event a nightmare on elm street HBO Max 71st Emmy Awards Hear Us Out obituary free movies South by Southwest Film Festival CW Seed Mudbound dramedy spider-man worst movies Epix robots Winners scorecard scary movies History LGBT mob Toys Warner Bros. Sundance TV adventure dexter king arthur TruTV TV Shondaland LGBTQ comic book movie Esquire Amazon Acorn TV Martial Arts Awards Pride Month technology 73rd Emmy Awards movie ABC Family MGM discovery aliens video USA Network psycho psychological thriller rotten movies we love Emmys BBC all-time black disaster VH1 RT History CNN Crunchyroll Reality ABC talk show legend Bravo Marvel worst japanese Animation christmas movies broadcast cars Sundance HBO Go DGA canceled Thanksgiving RT21 facebook ghosts summer preview Alien Mary Poppins Returns Photos Superheroes Apple prank vampires Quiz cults monster movies Box Office foreign Nat Geo cats FOX DirecTV Country latino Horror Freeform 2021 Star Trek zero dark thirty Musicals marvel comics women book Netflix 20th Century Fox First Reviews gangster AMC jamie lee curtis National Geographic streaming Syfy Broadway die hard Britbox Hallmark Christmas movies rotten festivals Heroines toy story X-Men heist movie VOD new star wars movies cancelled IFC Films singing competition harry potter sitcom 79th Golden Globes Awards action-comedy ITV Year in Review directors young adult Cannes popular green book BBC America TCA Winter 2020 99% Star Wars USA natural history Winter TV Columbia Pictures Crackle royal family AMC Plus Sony Pictures TV movies boxoffice Lionsgate miniseries Comedy Central genre DC streaming service halloween king kong streaming movies Action dark Spike saw Television Critics Association biopic TBS period drama DC Universe kaiju deadpool blaxploitation Trivia franchise Holidays vs. docuseries Summer 2015 A24 APB FX on Hulu Reality Competition Character Guide TIFF Musical Wes Anderson Pirates composers australia Marvel Studios nbcuniversal PlayStation YouTube Red political drama slashers Election anime 24 frames Arrowverse BET new zealand Universal Pictures high school spider-verse WarnerMedia PBS Fox News Binge Guide 007 cancelled television comic Cartoon Network Comics on TV YouTube true crime Best Picture south america The CW movies TNT American Society of Cinematographers Instagram Live SXSW Turner Classic Movies Trophy Talk video on demand TCA cancelled TV shows Avengers independent sag awards The Purge Nickelodeon crime drama Pacific Islander Rom-Com Apple TV+ obi wan hidden camera travel Comedy Television Academy telelvision Film Film Festival unscripted hispanic heritage month doctor who Funimation FXX Nominations MTV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Disney Channel Academy Awards based on movie Fall TV fresh sopranos archives batman new york news Legendary Starz WGN Hallmark BAFTA live action concert Valentine's Day Women's History Month Adult Swim kids Prime Video spanish language posters 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Pixar mockumentary Red Carpet wonder woman Apple TV Plus Dark Horse Comics Logo El Rey Teen Fargo book adaptation