News

10 Questions Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Must Answer

From the fate of Carrie Fisher's Leia to the truth behind Supreme Leader Snoke, Rey's origins, and – ugh – midichlorians, here's what we want to know.

by | December 12, 2019 | Comments

With Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker touted as the conclusion of the Skywalker Saga, it has more to do than typical trilogy-wrapping films like The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, The Matrix Revolutions, or, indeed, Return of the Jedi. It is designed to be the culmination of a nine-part saga told across 40+ years and has a lot to accomplish in less than 180 minutes. Even LOTR author J.R.R. Tolkien would sweat at this writing prompt.

Nonetheless, there are questions the film definitely needs to answer, even if only in a glib way, before the curtain falls on the Skywalkers and their role in galactic affairs. The following are the 10 questions we think the The Rise of Skywalker must answer.


Who Are Rey’s Parents?

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

We’ll be honest, we really like the idea that Rey (Daisy Ridley) comes from nowhere. The Star Wars galaxy gets a little too small sometimes and you need an outlier to shake things up. That was the solution seemingly given to us by Kylo Ren (Adam Driver) and Rey in Star Wars: The Last Jedi, and it is perfectly satisfactory. Unless, of course, you consider the way Rise of Skywalker director J.J. Abrams set up the issue of her parents in Star Wars: The Force Awakens. It requires some sort of resolution, even if it’s just an independent confirmation that her parents were, in fact, dirt farmers who sold her to Unkar Plutt (Simon Pegg) for beer money.


Did Palpatine Will Anakin Into Existence?

TM and ©copyright Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by TM and ©copyright Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved courtesy Everett Collection)

In one of Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith’s best scenes, Sheev Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) suggests to the audience that he learned a way to force the midichlorians to create life. By implication, he is Anakin Skywalker’s (Hayden Christensen) father. Well, from a certain point of view, anyway. Was he really that skilled in Sith powers? Or was it all a happy accident he used to his advantage? Considering Anakin was central to his scheme, greater clarity about his birth may be in the offing. Granted, answering this question means confronting the existence of midichlorians, something a lot of Star Wars fans would rather avoid.


Who are Finn’s Kin?

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Perhaps more interesting than Rey’s parents is the lost heritage of former First Order stormtrooper FN-2187 (John Boyega), A.K.A. Finn. Press-ganged into service as a child, there is a lot of unacknowledged terror in Finn’s past, but there’s also a lost world he might call home and a family he has never known. Considering The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi saw him running from things, maybe The Rise of Skywalker will offer him the chance to run toward something – the kin the First Order stole from him. And like our preferred answer for Rey’s ancestry, we’d like Finn to derive from a world and bloodline heretofore unseen.


Was This Palpatine’s Plan All Along?

As Emperor, Palpatine reached his zenith with the completion of the first Death Star, even if that apex of power was short lived. But even into his arrival in the Endor system during Return of the Jedi, he believed everything was proceeding as he had foreseen. We’re disinclined to believe his powers of prognostication were that absolute. For one thing: would he really allow himself to appear defeated for 30 years and allow a New Republic to establish itself? One imagines he will have the chance to explain his long absence in The Rise of Skywalker, and the true shape of his plan is something he might finally reveal.


Will Leia Survive?

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Because of Carrie Fisher’s untimely death in 2016, this question is more of a minefield than it would otherwise be. Had she lived, Episode IX was to be her movie, much the same way The Force Awakens was Han’s (Harrison Ford) film and The Last Jedi was about Luke (Mark Hamill). And in that paradigm, we would expect her to sacrifice herself for the good of the next generation like her brother and her child’s father. But now, it’s all different. There are pros and cons to both killing Leia off and letting her survive into the last iris-out. Hopefully, it will be satisfying either way.


Can The Republic Ever Be Restored?

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

This is one of the bigger-level questions Star Wars movies may not be equipped to answer. The sequels showed us a Republic so corrupt that Palpatine could use a meaningless trade dispute to slip into power. The sequel trilogy has revealed a New Republic so tolerant of wannabe Imperials that it led to the Republic’s destruction. Both were wiped away by more aggressive forces. Can the Resistance prove to be better at restoring government than the Rebel Alliance? This may be a question for tie-in novels after the film’s release, but it has to give us some inkling Poe (Oscar Isaac), Rose (Kelly Marie Tran), and the others can do better.


What The Poodoo Was The Real Prophecy?

TM and ©copyright Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by TM and ©copyright Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved courtesy Everett Collection)

In our recent rewatch of the prequels, we were struck by how ill-defined the prophecy really is. When it is confronted directly, we’re only told a chosen one will emerge to bring balance to the Force — but the actual wording of this prophecy is nowhere to be found in the films. Now, there is something poetic about the Jedi failing to see it as a warning, but it is never framed as such in Episodes I-III. Was it a textual hand grenade left in the Jedi library by an older Sith Lord, or was it something Palpatine himself planted? He was fond of using the truth as a weapon and skilled at obscuring his presence from the Jedi.


Who Was Snoke?

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

The two halves of his corpse may still be rotting aboard his broken and abandoned Star Destroyer, but Snoke’s (Andy Serkis) identity finally matters now that Palpatine is back in the picture. Was he the last surviving Inquisitor? A cover identity for the disembodied Palpatine? Or just a hapless Force-sensitive seduced by the Dark Side? Like some of the other questions we need answered, this one just needs a brief word from Darth Sidious about his role in the formation of the First Order, but even in that brevity, he needs to slot into place.


Are The Jedi Worth Saving?

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

This is another philosophical question the movie may not have the bandwidth to address, but considering the scenes of Rey training in the Jedi arts featured in trailers and commercials, we have to ask if the Jedi are worth saving. True, The Last Jedi ultimately makes a case for their restoration, but it was the rigidity of their philosophy that led the galaxy to Sith rule. Players of the Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic games will recognize this question, as it lurks at the heart of its narrative, but it also seems to matter here, as Rey holds the future of Force-wielding in the Galaxy. Like the others in the Resistance, can she do better?

Outside of the film, there are big financial reasons for the Jedi to be restored past the Skywalker Saga — at least a few people have not made their own saber at Star Wars: Galaxy’s Edge — but the soul of the order is as important to the overall saga as Anakin’s soul. And for that reason, Rey must make a definitive choice.


When Will We See Episode X?

TM and ©copyright Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by TM and ©copyright Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved courtesy Everett Collection)

Long, long ago, Star Wars creator George Lucas let slip an initial plan for the series to be 12 parts. At the time, it was envisioned as more of a James Bond-style serial with fewer overarching plots. When the ongoing plot became important, he revised this number to nine (and then to six during the prequel era). We fully expect this original plan to be Lucasfilm’s excuse when Episodes X-XII inevitably happen.  But how long will we have to wait? It’s a question The Rise of Skywalker can actually answer if it gives the audiences an authentic and complete ending.

And the chances of that happening are about as good as Palpatine meeting his true, final fate.


Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker opens on December 20.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

New York Comic Con See It Skip It spanish language Nat Geo what to watch Polls and Games X-Men Summer Academy Awards latino The Purge The Witch Freeform series ABC Family spy thriller Apple TV Plus political drama science fiction Amazon Prime Fall TV IFC Films cancelled television cults Marathons witnail based on movie miniseries zombie halloween Lifetime Christmas movies game show Universal Sundance TV space 20th Century Fox MTV Musicals psychological thriller VH1 Disney streaming service canceled TV shows television Country Reality 45 HBO stand-up comedy ESPN cartoon SXSW GLAAD Endgame natural history Music Awards Superheroe Peacock Star Trek dceu strong female leads Writers Guild of America Arrowverse TIFF spider-man Crunchyroll Turner Tubi Martial Arts Holiday Spectrum Originals Disney Channel Epix FOX RT21 cinemax Trivia Masterpiece screen actors guild President Photos game of thrones comiccon Warner Bros. Apple Sundance Now police drama Year in Review Mary Poppins Returns El Rey zero dark thirty Cartoon Network dc Schedule 21st Century Fox harry potter IFC Sci-Fi aliens Comedy Central Turner Classic Movies werewolf Amazon Prime Video Spring TV screenings hispanic singing competition Opinion Nickelodeon Tomatazos Paramount Network zombies Set visit adventure DC Comics spain Drama A&E PBS versus TV renewals Sundance BBC Teen TV Land war batman NYCC Video Games SDCC Nominations theme song social media Trailer sports Mystery Marvel Television OWN golden globes Trophy Talk comics crime thriller Creative Arts Emmys dragons streaming Fox News Thanksgiving book docudrama cancelled A24 boxoffice MCU Mindy Kaling Kids & Family nature Pride Month indie directors Adult Swim Lucasfilm travel spinoff Chernobyl disaster anthology Food Network DC Universe GIFs unscripted TBS YA adaptation Captain marvel First Look HBO Max movies foreign politics blockbuster Film finale Disney+ Disney Plus PaleyFest 71st Emmy Awards TLC doctor who BBC America Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Christmas comic GoT Amazon binge biography historical drama Dark Horse Comics FXX MSNBC mockumentary The CW Action Rocketman Extras AMC 2017 Hallmark The Arrangement Hulu Netflix Certified Fresh WarnerMedia diversity Star Wars FX TCM E3 2020 Horror RT History ghosts dramedy Spike Apple TV+ TCA 2017 Election richard e. Grant Vudu APB 2019 CBS Song of Ice and Fire sequel The Walking Dead SundanceTV Best and Worst Winners Emmys Shondaland talk show Paramount Brie Larson CBS All Access hist YouTube Pirates Infographic tv talk YouTube Red Mary Tyler Moore Countdown History TCA Winter 2020 crime Mary poppins technology DirecTV Interview Black Mirror Acorn TV discovery Premiere Dates slashers Ovation Columbia Pictures Winter TV Television Academy reboot E! toy story Tarantino Anna Paquin Showtime LGBT 2016 Disney Plus cops elevated horror Marvel Emmy Nominations Sneak Peek Family YouTube Premium WGN Oscars Hallmark Christmas movies south america teaser Pet Sematary USA Logo festivals Binge Guide DC streaming service Western Pop Super Bowl Baby Yoda quibi cars Britbox Lifetime National Geographic Women's History Month Biopics BET Podcast Pixar Avengers Holidays NBC Grammys award winner jamie lee curtis Lionsgate Film Festival joker 2015 CNN animated sag awards USA Network christmas movies canceled Sony Pictures serial killer Discovery Channel cancelled TV shows Awards Tour period drama children's TV Starz San Diego Comic-Con free movies true crime crime drama Comics on TV Comedy supernatural Ellie Kemper medical drama Disney TV Netflix Christmas movies Rocky Watching Series Ghostbusters Rom-Com Walt Disney Pictures Stephen King justice league cancelled TV series Character Guide video rotten movies we love psycho Cannes romantic comedy Musical Animation anime 007 2018 OneApp kids transformers name the review Valentine's Day Mudbound casting American Society of Cinematographers sitcom Chilling Adventures of Sabrina breaking bad Calendar Esquire mutant Tumblr Bravo TruTV crossover Red Carpet DGA cats Crackle TNT 24 frames LGBTQ renewed TV shows TCA CMT Reality Competition Cosplay Comic Book First Reviews vampires Syfy green book Shudder cooking robots Heroines ABC Box Office facebook Fantasy Classic Film romance Rock Toys independent blaxploitation revenge ratings Superheroes Quiz thriller Elton John ITV CW Seed composers Marvel Studios VICE