Fall TV Scorecard 2015

Critics Consensus: Life in Pieces' strong cast delivers funny, offbeat stories even if they're not always relatable.

Starring: Dianne Wiest, James Brolin, Zoe Lister Jones, Colin Hanks

Critics Consensus: The Muppets brings new energy to a beloved franchise -- and although longtime fans may be taken aback by the show's adult mockumentary approach, the classic characters retain their essential spirit.

Starring: Steve Whitmire, Eric Jacobson, Dave Goelz, Bill Barretta

Critics Consensus: Blindspot is elevated by an intriguing mystery and enough strong action to propel most viewers into a necessary suspension of disbelief.

Starring: Sullivan Stapleton, Jaimie Alexander, Marianne Jean-Baptiste, Rob Brown

Critics Consensus: John Stamos is as handsome and charming as ever, but Grandfathered's jokes are tired and schmaltzy.

Starring: John Stamos, Paget Brewster, Josh Peck, Christina Milian

Critics Consensus: Led by a stellar performance from Martin Clunes, Arthur & George honors its source material with a memorable adaptation.

Starring: Martin Clunes, Arsher Ali, Art Malik, Emma Fielding

Critics Consensus: Trevor Noah's confidence and likability augur well for The Daily Show, even if his edgier jokes are hit-or-miss.

Critics Consensus: Red Oaks offers an affectionate nod to 1980s sex comedies that -- largely thanks to a talented ensemble cast -- finds fresh humor in its familiar premise.

Starring: Craig Roberts, Paul Reiser, Jennifer Grey, Richard Kind

Critics Consensus: Obvious copycatting aside, Quantico provides ludicrously entertaining thrills from a well-balanced cast.

Starring: Priyanka Chopra Jonas, Josh Hopkins, Jake McLaughlin, Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor

Critics Consensus: Indian Summers gathers intrigue slowly but effectively, building into an addictive political thriller with exotic overtones.

Starring: Julie Walters, Patrick Malahide, Jemima West, Nikesh Patel

Critics Consensus: W/ Bob and David offers a long-overdue reunion between Mr. Show principals Odenkirk and Cross - and a suitably hilarious reminder of the reasons for their subsequent individual successes.

Starring: Bob Odenkirk, David Cross, Paul F. Tompkins, Jill Talley