Video Interviews

Who is the Best Batman?

Find out which Dark Knight soars highest when it comes to box office, Tomatometer, iconic moments, and cultural impact.

by | March 26, 2020 | Comments

Robert Pattinson is our new Batman, but who is the best Caped Crusader among his predecessors? That’s what our contributing editor Mark Ellis is asking in the latest episode of Vs., the show where we use Tomatometer and box office data, among other considerations, to settle some of popular culture’s biggest debates. In our battle of the Batmen, we restricted our field to those who have appeared on the big screen: Is the greatest Dark Knight the moody Christian Bale? The quirky Michael Keaton? Perhaps the original, Adam West, who starred in Batman’s first big-screen adventure? Or the man whose voice work made Batman: The Animated Series a landmark, Kevin Conroy, and who also voiced the Bat in Mask of the Phantasm and The Killing Joke. Those four actors go up against other past Bats of the big screen: Ben Affleck, Val Kilmer, George Clooney, and Will Arnett, who put a hilarious spin on the character in The Lego Movie, its sequel, and his own solo spinoff. Who comes out on top? Check out the video above – and then check out our Vs. episode on the Joker.

Disagree with our winner? Let us have it in the comments. And be sure to check out our ranking of Batman movies by Tomatometer

Tag Cloud

Horror Stephen King Photos high school 2019 science fiction Drama 2015 ABC Family BET disaster Shondaland international critics Pacific Islander Captain marvel adaptation period drama game show NBC docudrama 1990s Summer IFC Pirates spain ratings Mary poppins concert The Academy Kids & Family Tokyo Olympics Emmys Exclusive Video Marvel Television Epix boxing movies DirecTV Trophy Talk directors Disney Plus Ghostbusters crime thriller Travel Channel Trivia screen actors guild vampires Classic Film crime drama black movie Amazon Prime Mindy Kaling cancelled dark Mary Tyler Moore french name the review Premiere Dates olympics DC streaming service TV One rotten movies we love Tubi CBS deadpool rom-coms TIFF Nat Geo LGBTQ ghosts films TBS Western based on movie VICE NBA cancelled TV shows Box Office GLAAD MSNBC universal monsters Nominations Superheroes MCU RT21 Polls and Games indiana jones aapi streaming unscripted Netflix Christmas movies criterion cooking miniseries series Video Games New York Comic Con Apple TV Plus Masterpiece serial killer Adult Swim dogs razzies Marvel Studios ID The Arrangement Disney christmas movies Quiz remakes The Walking Dead MTV USA Oscars Women's History Month spider-man cinemax telelvision Freeform Peacock Avengers comedies anthology Cannes Extras robots docuseries FX on Hulu suspense superhero Comics on TV FX Trailer binge ESPN video Lifetime Christmas movies RT History historical drama PaleyFest witnail Syfy Lifetime crime mockumentary Amazon composers italian Winners YouTube Premium anime AMC discovery The Witch facebook canceled finale ABC Signature cartoon Interview SDCC romantic comedy American Society of Cinematographers DGA psychological thriller documentary Anna Paquin Comic-Con@Home 2021 prank women Showtime Best and Worst Reality 24 frames independent Crackle kids adenture Reality Competition king kong sequels technology satire DC Universe golden globes news See It Skip It LGBT comiccon DC Comics Arrowverse TCA Winter 2020 Winter TV Britbox rt archives Television Critics Association Star Wars VOD monster movies superman Acorn TV Nickelodeon Countdown Country TLC sitcom harry potter spy thriller 21st Century Fox Family hist festival El Rey Pop TV Turner reviews what to watch A&E TV Sundance TV Valentine's Day Super Bowl CNN thriller Holidays PBS Chernobyl Spring TV CBS All Access spinoff scene in color video on demand dceu Disney Channel stand-up comedy The Purge VH1 die hard jamie lee curtis HBO Go game of thrones FOX SundanceTV worst natural history Endgame Wes Anderson new york justice league Mystery TruTV Fox News Biopics 4/20 TCA Awards Toys Tarantino Alien BBC Awards Tour foreign Certified Fresh Netflix Black History Month laika National Geographic The CW cats E! spanish ViacomCBS emmy awards Heroines comic books Creative Arts Emmys cancelled television police drama aliens blockbusters Year in Review best Apple TV+ Tomatazos 90s Thanksgiving Pet Sematary Awards transformers lord of the rings Discovery Channel renewed TV shows child's play book adaptation Cartoon Network Emmy Nominations WarnerMedia jurassic park Song of Ice and Fire GIFs popular sequel Mary Poppins Returns TV movies television doctor who pirates of the caribbean TCM stop motion CMT USA Network Set visit social media cults award winner Animation YouTube obituary Music dramedy Pride Month archives ITV 2016 Black Mirror Crunchyroll Amazon Prime Video Pixar Image Comics Sneak Peek 2020 007 crossover Logo spanish language cancelled TV series Spike chucky hidden camera revenge Teen Chilling Adventures of Sabrina The Walt Disney Company 2021 scary movies Election TV Land new star wars movies Baby Yoda toy story venice canceled TV shows Paramount Plus Paramount Hulu 99% war OneApp twilight Musical saw Ovation Rom-Com 20th Century Fox kong batman blockbuster Spectrum Originals diversity Schedule Rock HBO politics Film Festival golden globe awards HBO Max green book comics biography Holiday asian-american Writers Guild of America toronto E3 latino Character Guide talk show animated new zealand zombie Dark Horse Comics 2017 blaxploitation mission: impossible japanese Broadway target Walt Disney Pictures Disney streaming service screenings worst movies scorecard Binge Guide Calendar Marathons Martial Arts supernatural south america BET Awards Opinion Red Carpet Hear Us Out Film Television Academy fresh Vudu Warner Bros. hispanic teaser Podcast Bravo psycho space true crime Amazon Studios Columbia Pictures BBC One joker fast and furious TV renewals a nightmare on elm street Comedy Central documentaries Legendary Action streaming movies Hallmark Christmas movies political drama TCA 2017 Superheroe singing competition strong female leads zero dark thirty Academy Awards australia cars 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Disney+ Disney Plus Comedy Tumblr versus Starz APB 71st Emmy Awards Grammys japan Infographic Mudbound TCA Rocketman adventure A24 TNT Sony Pictures Christmas festivals live action children's TV halloween Cosplay slashers marvel cinematic universe Elton John Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt NYCC Paramount Network 2018 FXX Food Network 45 President Rocky First Reviews know your critic halloween tv trailers travel First Look cops Apple tv talk Lionsgate sports Fox Searchlight classics godzilla Turner Classic Movies nfl GoT Marvel Esquire Lucasfilm franchise zombies parents Sundance Now medical drama stoner 93rd Oscars richard e. Grant Hallmark Pop all-time book ABC sag awards BAFTA Fantasy San Diego Comic-Con WGN elevated horror casting hollywood free movies james bond Brie Larson Musicals kaiju heist movie IFC Films quibi reboot indie Watching Series werewolf breaking bad Star Trek nbcuniversal History PlayStation football Ellie Kemper X-Men YouTube Red Funimation YA comic theme song CW Seed Fall TV romance boxoffice Universal OWN rotten dragons Comic Book 72 Emmy Awards SXSW dc Shudder Sundance Sci-Fi basketball mutant BBC America nature