Which Avengers: Infinity War Character Deserves the Most Blame for the Big Snap?

Scowl with us for a moment at these five characters whose mistakes were cosmically consequential.

by | May 8, 2018 | Comments

As viewers of Avengers: Infinity War can attest, there were several key moments where the tide of battle could have gone differently. J.R.R. Tolkien used to refer to such moments as a “eucatastrophes” – a sudden rush of good fortune. Of course, that good fortune all depends on the needs of the story and the actions of the characters.

Spoilers follow from here.

The characters in Infinity War certainly had chances to prevent Thanos (Josh Brolin) from completing his legendary snap of the gauntleted fingers, but as the fourth Avengers film next year will see the survivors attempting to put things right, his victory in Infinity War was assured. Nonetheless, there are a handful of characters who could have been instrumental in preventing Thanos from completing his goal. Here are five Marvel Cinematic Universe characters who share the blame for his success and the snap heard around the cosmos.

1. Peter Quill, Star-Lord

(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

Let’s just start with this one as it sticks in the craw of a lot of MCU fans. Peter Quill (Chris Pratt) lost his cool when confronted with the possibility that Gamora (Zoe Saldana) was dead. In the battle on Titan, Peter was meant to be part of the group forcing the Infinity Gauntlet off Thanos’ hand while Mantis (Pom Klementieff) pacified the Mad Titan. But along the way, Thanos began to talk about his personal sacrifice – offering Gamora up so he could gain the Soul Stone – and it hampered Peter’s ability to process any other new information.

Many wondered why Peter assumed Thanos was telling the truth and why he could be so easily swayed. In fact, the moment almost breaks the character in order for Thanos to achieve his victory over Iron Man’s (Robert Downey Jr.) team. It is a fair criticism of the film; which really didn’t have the room to note the passage of time between Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 and Infinity War beyond Thanos derisively referring to Peter as “the boyfriend” and the one kiss we see. In order for the moment to work, one has to assume Peter and Gamora have been a couple for a while. Then again, his jealousy of Thor (Chris Hemsworth) suggests they are nowhere near a commitment; which once again makes Peter’s easy distraction at the key moment suspect.

Whether it was just a failing of Peter as manchild or the character getting the short straw due to plotting needs, it leaves Peter with a lot of the blame. Without the Time Stone, Thanos could not have undone  Vision and Scarlet Witch’s (Paul Bettany and Elizabeth Olsen) sacrifice.

2. Thor

(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

The God of Thunder was the best chance of defeating Thanos on sheer strength alone. He also had his new axe, Stormbreaker, to aid him in getting to Earth in time and harnessing his abilities to stick the landing. And yet, Thor ultimately failed as he aims for Thanos’s chest instead of hacking his gloved hand off or going for the headshot, a tactical error the Mad Titan addresses just as he snaps his fingers.

Yeah, he definitely shares some of the blame here alongside Peter Quill.

Co-director Joe Russo recently suggested Thor had a reason for choosing the chest-hit: he wanted to gloat over Thanos and let him know he got his revenge. A motivation which makes sense when you hear it – even if it is a huge tactical error – but does not come across effectively in the film itself; making Thor’s attempted deathblow an even greater mistake. But at least Thor is still around to learn, once again, that his hubris is his greatest enemy. Maybe it will be a lesson he finally takes to heart this time.

3. Doctor Stephen Strange

(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

And if we’re assigning blame on tactical prowess, then Stephen Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch) deserves to sit at that table as well. Despite the awesome power of the Time Stone to create time loops and prevent catastrophe, he ultimately abdicates the Stone to Thanos. Now, anyone familiar with event comic book crossovers or this sort of operatic pulp storytelling knows that Strange is seeing the long game. As he tells Tony, this is the only scenario in which they ultimately win. But it still left plenty of audiences stunned as he, the Guardians, and Peter Parker (Tom Holland) blew away into the Titan sky.

Also, going back to Peter Quill’s screw-up, we have to assume Strange went along with a plan he knew would fail just for the sake of making his ultimate surrender look convincing. Which, in the long game, will probably prove successful, but makes the Titan fight so much sound and fury – and that’s a shame as the Titan fight is the best fight in the movie.

There is the possibility everyone was playacting during the fight to sell Strange’s capitulation to Thanos, but Tony’s surprise as they all vanished seemed truly genuine.

So Doctor Strange’s portion of the blame may not be as large as Peter Quill’s or Thor’s hefty servings, but there is still some blame to share as he kept the full nature of the future to himself.

4. Scarlet Witch

(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

Like Peter Quill’s screw-up, Wanda Maximoff earns her measure of blame for a very similar reason: the depth and strength of her love for someone else. In this case, it is Vision, the android powered by the Mind Stone on a journey toward humanity. As Marvel Comics readers know, Vision and Scarlet Witch have a long, storied, and occasionally troubling romance. The MCU version of that relationship appears to be only beginning in Captain America: Civil War, but is in full bloom as Infinity War first finds the characters on a romantic getaway in Scotland. That leap in their relationship status left plenty of movie-only Marvel fans confused if they were unaware of the character’s comic past, making Wanda’s reticence to destroy the Mind Stone all the more baffling.

Considering Vision immediately offered himself up for the greater good and explained how she could make the Mind Stone disappear, Wanda’s reluctance to atomize the Stone seemed bull-headed without an extra movie to convey the reality of their relationship. In fact, her hesitation at the end of the film was definitely a topic of discussion heard as audiences left theaters over the last two weeks. If she had just destroyed the stone when they first arrived in Wakanda, Thanos would’ve been defeated.

Unless, of course, he was able to use the Time Stone, go back hours instead of seconds, and retrieve the final piece of his gauntlet.

With that in mind, Wanda’s share of the blame may not be as large as Peter Quill’s or Thor’s, but a case can be made for it —  especially from viewers unaware of just how much she and Vision loved one another.

5. Scott Lang, Ant-Man

(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

While Scott Lang (Paul Rudd) has a reasonable excuse for sitting out Infinity War – accepting the terms of the Sokovia Accords and house-arrest to be closer to his daughter – it has not stopped people from noting he could have offered a valuable resource to Captain America’s (Chris Evans) Earthbound team.

The scenario you might hear while leaving the theater is this: Scott could shrink down to a size imperceptible to Thanos and sneak his way into the Infinity Gauntlet. Then, at a key moment, grow and help push the glove off the Mad Titan’s hand.

Granted, this strategy would require everyone on Cap’s team fully understanding the nature of the Gauntlet prior to leaving for Wakanda. They also would have needed to convince Scott to break his house-arrest and endanger his connection with Cassie (Abby Ryder Forston). With that in mind, it is understandable why Cap dismisses calling Scott into the field at that moment.

Then again, Scott would’ve likely been all in had someone bothered to ask him, but he still would’ve failed once Thanos sensed his presence. So his measure of the blame is confined to a single saltine cracker’s worth as the theory of how he might have helped crumbles into dust.

Bonus: Phillip J. Coulson, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D.

(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

Sure, Phil Coulson (Clark Gregg) has a lot on his plate at the moment: he just got back from a horrendous future where the Kree control the remains of an exploded Earth, his original wound from Loki’s (Tom Hiddleston) scepter in Marvel’s Avengers is threatening to consume his body again, and his old ally Glenn Talbot (Adrian Pasdar) absorbed all the Gravitonium Hydra collected (long story) and threatens to split open the planet himself to get more of the substance buried deep in the Earth.

But thanks to the alien confederacy orbiting Earth, Coulson is also aware of Thanos now and could offer assistance or a word of warning to his old allies, the Avengers. Well, provided that they even knew he was still alive and defending the Earth in his own way from Hydra remnants, evil books from the Dark Dimension, and the impending Kree occupation.

Now, to be fair, he is facing an immediate threat from Talbot, whose already damaged brain is becoming further unhinged by the minds stuck in the Gravitonium, and it seems the Black Order’s New York attack began only as Coulson was learning about Thanos. But if he is to share any of the blame, it stems back from his decision to never tell the Avengers he came back from the dead. Their combined resources might have made a big difference against both of their current foes.

Then again, expecting a lot of crossover between Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. and the Marvel movies is a tall ask these days.

Of course, the blame game might be an academic pursuit once we see the results of Strange’s choice in next year’s fourth Avengers film. But in the meantime, it offers a thought experiment as tantalizing as choosing a side during Captain America: Civil War or deciding whether Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan) or Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) is the better life-mate for Cap. And if assigning blame to characters in Infinity War is anything like those debates, it will go on long after the fifth Avengers film.

Tag Cloud

Country cults DirecTV TCM Infographic IFC Films Lifetime APB Polls and Games TLC streaming ITV Food Network Dark Horse Comics 2017 American Society of Cinematographers Winners adventure Paramount Network talk show Mindy Kaling serial killer Year in Review doctor who composers TruTV National Geographic Superheroe Comic Book Showtime Starz Mystery Podcast Fantasy war SDCC historical drama NYCC Marathons BBC Schedule IFC WGN First Look OWN Spike Super Bowl Character Guide Animation RT History YouTube Red Sundance Now ABC Musical Warner Bros. Action Spring TV dc Tomatazos CMT TBS transformers Rocky Valentine's Day The CW Creative Arts Emmys biography DC Universe cooking TNT Sneak Peek Amazon Hulu what to watch TV BET Rock police drama robots dramedy Premiere Dates mutant discovery Nat Geo crime thriller festivals Rom-Com Ellie Kemper binge Universal VH1 Music X-Men Countdown Set visit cats GoT Logo Disney Shondaland Pirates LGBTQ Paramount TV Land social media psycho crossover Writers Guild of America CBS All Access 007 Tumblr crime drama Columbia Pictures Superheroes Disney Channel science fiction Watching Series BBC America Trivia FXX Nominations See It Skip It 2016 thriller Election Horror E3 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Trailer cops Musicals Awards Comedy Central harry potter aliens USA USA Network Martial Arts 45 sports Reality Competition diversity zombie spy thriller Star Trek San Diego Comic-Con VICE Song of Ice and Fire Comedy Netflix YouTube Premium Crackle Epix PBS Certified Fresh CW Seed vampires Ovation 21st Century Fox Drama boxoffice period drama Britbox President based on movie Pixar travel Sci-Fi MSNBC Toys Apple Fox News 24 frames YA Pop TIFF politics finale Teen Walt Disney Pictures sitcom GLAAD docudrama zombies Adult Swim Biopics SXSW CNN DC streaming service Reality HBO Cosplay dceu Fall TV Freeform El Rey Summer MTV crime Bravo Esquire Thanksgiving A&E 2015 ratings GIFs technology FX cinemax Lucasfilm Winter TV NBC 20th Century Fox Kids & Family Emmys supernatural Holidays Red Carpet medical drama Ghostbusters Nickelodeon Lionsgate E! Extras ABC Family golden globes Acorn TV The Arrangement Mary Tyler Moore FOX Cartoon Network hist Marvel blaxploitation Opinion Western History TCA Photos Interview Oscars singing competition unscripted Star Wars Calendar DC Comics PaleyFest Christmas TCA 2017 justice league Sundance Syfy Box Office comiccon Sony Pictures political drama CBS romance Grammys Best and Worst AMC Masterpiece SundanceTV Video Games ESPN