News

Wendy First Reviews: Visually Dazzling but Unfocused and Overly Familiar

Critics say Beasts of the Southern Wild director Benh Zeitlin's ode to Peter Pan is whimsical, beautifully shot, and full of fresh ideas, but fails to pull everything together in satisfying fashion.

by | January 27, 2020 | Comments

Beasts of the Southern Wild debuted at Sundance in 2012, cementing Benh Zeitlin as a uniquely imaginative filmmaker. The movie blew audiences away and wound up with four Oscar nominations, including one for Best Picture. Fans couldn’t wait to see what this new auteur would deliver next. Well, Zeitlin took eight years to finish his sophomore feature, the Peter Pan-inspired Wendy, and it just premiered at Sundance to mixed reviews. If you love Beasts, though, there’s a good chance that you’ll want to see this movie, too.

Here’s what critics are saying about Wendy:


Is Zeitlin’s follow-up worth the wait?

That magnificent eye is still there… Zeitlin is an auteur just as we thought he was and he’s going to continue to challenge his audience.
– Gregory Ellwood, The Playlist

With Wendy, Zeitlin aims for the stars, often forgetting what direction to fly in… Most disappointing.
– Ian Thomas Malone, Ian Thomas Malone

What felt so revolutionary in 2012 is no less visionary today but packs a disappointing sense of familiarity this time around.
– Peter Debruge, Variety

There’s a reason that films that take this many years to get to screens often come up short… Wendy is a cautionary tale about what causes sophomore slumps.
– Brian Tallerico, RogerEbert.com


Will fans of Beasts of the Southern Wild enjoy it?

Zeitlin’s wondrous Pan riff feels like such a natural continuation of the Beasts experience that it practically unfolds in the same immersive universe.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

Wendy bears some of the same elements — rambunctious kids, magical realism, unknown actors, climate awareness — [but] it feels like an even stronger picture thanks to its filmmaker’s growing ambition.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

Maybe some people will think Zeitlin is revisiting the style and themes of Beasts a little too closely, but that movie was thrilling and so is this one.
Steve Pond, The Wrap

It seems hard to imagine anyone who didn’t respond to Beasts somehow thinking this one works, and even fans of that film may be startled at the repetition.
Brian Tallerico, RogerEbert.com


Fox Searchlight Pictures

(Photo by Fox Searchlight Pictures)

What about fans of Peter Pan?

Wendy both honors its inspiration and creates something original.
Steve Pond, The Wrap

As with David Lowery’s transportive live-action remake Pete’s Dragon, Zeitlin has taken an overwrought children’s story and given it a fresh identity without toppling the original’s core ideas.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

Zeitlin’s adaptation overflows with imagination as it manages to deconstruct the myth while never losing its timeless energy… The result is constantly enchanting and beguiling.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

It’s thrilling to discover how Wendy reinvents the particulars of a fairy story audiences know so well, and which Disney has so strongly codified for nearly everyone alive today — although the omission of Tinker Bell and the other fairies will likely be a let-down.
Peter Debruge, Variety

There are times when you can feel the film straining to deal with aspects of the original story in a so-called organic way.
Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter


Will children enjoy it?

The movie’s a bit too intense, and more than a little too arty, to suit young audiences.
Peter Debruge, Variety

Kids will be bored by this movie.
Brian Tallerico, RogerEbert.com

The lack of any real narrative structure — and the few odd surges of menace, one of which blooms into a moment of shocking physical violence — make it hard to imagine that a younger audience will follow.
Leah Greenblatt, Entertainment Weekly

Mileage will vary when it comes to Zeitlin’s “Terrence Malick for kids” aesthetic, which turns on awe-inspiring cues at every turn, and sometimes threatens to turn into a parody of that very thing.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire


How does it look?

Wendy is an absolutely beautiful film. Largely filmed in the Caribbean, the cinematography provides visual overload time and time again.
Ian Thomas Malone, Ian Thomas Malone

The new movie uses the expansive landscapes of the Caribbean to imbue the proceedings with a spiritual tranquility that lingers in every shot.
Eric Kohn, IndieWire

Every frame of the film is excitingly alive and freshly conceived, making it something very much worth seeing on the big screen.
Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter

As raw and arresting as Wendy’s visuals are, they’re in service of familiar notions about the fragility of innocence and the impermanence of childhood.
Tim Grierson, Screen International


Fox Searchlight Pictures

(Photo by Fox Searchlight Pictures)

Does the story match the visuals?

If Zeitlin is infatuated with the act of storytelling, he’s also very good at it.
Steve Pond, The Wrap

The social commentary feels not only pointed and timely, but still relevant to the conflict of innocent childhood versus jaded adulthood.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

After a fairly dazzling setup, Wendy stumbles in its later reels, introducing ideas that are often obvious or unfocused… Wendy is so passionately crafted that its narrative shortcomings, though bothersome, can’t entirely detract
Tim Grierson, Screen International

Wendy is fun for a while, but as it drags on, it becomes harder to follow — and worse, boring.
Peter Debruge, Variety

The script is a one-trick pony, uninterested in anything resembling normal human interaction. That wouldn’t necessarily be a problem if the plot knew how to do anything other than meander along at a glacier-slow pace.
Ian Thomas Malone, Ian Thomas Malone

The actual plot of Wendy is so uninteresting that I wished Zeitlin would have been more surreal and symbolic.
Brian Tallerico, RogerEbert.com

Every kid inevitably grows and turns toward something new; storytellers should too.
Leah Greenblatt, Entertainment Weekly


Is Wendy’s lead the next Quvenzhané Wallis?

Zeitlin’s best asset here is actually [Devin] France, his young lead, who has striking screen confidence and a maturity that makes her seem like a natural leader.
Brian Tallerico, RogerEbert.com

[Devin France] resonates with a richness that carries you through the story and often when Zeitlin needs it the most. Out of all the young (and old) actors she makes you believe in this scenario.
Gregory Ellwood, The Playlist


Does Wendy invite repeat viewings?

Wendy in every way feels like a handmade, one-of-a-kind, exceptionally fresh and…organic piece of work that quite quickly imparts a desire to see it again.
Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter


Wendy premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on Sunday, January 26, and opens in limited release on February 28.

#1

Wendy (2020)
42%

#1
Adjusted Score: 48143%
Critics Consensus: Wendy dares to do something different with its classic source material; unfortunately, the movie's breathtaking visuals are at odds with a flawed take on the story.
Synopsis: Lost on a mysterious island, a girl fights to save her family, her freedom and the joyous spirit of youth.... [More]
Directed By: Benh Zeitlin

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

rotten movies we love GoT Tubi scary hollywood marvel cinematic universe 2015 game of thrones basketball french archives stand-up comedy Dark Horse Comics Ghostbusters 24 frames war Rom-Com Action doctor who Cosplay trailers concert superman toy story ITV canceled TV shows stop motion Best and Worst The CW discovery ratings Neflix reviews laika binge E3 free movies Elton John YouTube Red TCA Winter 2020 romantic comedy cults Walt Disney Pictures toronto video Oscars Logo Musicals mob AMC Plus The Academy independent 2017 pirates of the caribbean adaptation parents Schedule Infographic cancelled TV shows satire Universal joker Comic Book Apple anime politics Comic-Con@Home 2021 ViacomCBS streaming Superheroes reboot Hear Us Out Reality fast and furious lord of the rings 72 Emmy Awards technology talk show revenge First Reviews 99% Certified Fresh The Walt Disney Company Biopics marvel comics Image Comics sequel Broadway Cannes Polls and Games vampires Horror Interview legend Martial Arts Travel Channel Epix cancelled Binge Guide Pop TCM Drama Premiere Dates chucky political drama Pet Sematary zero dark thirty Rock Cartoon Network ABC A24 Hulu prank Fall TV NYCC kaiju adventure PaleyFest harry potter wonder woman Quiz dragons Stephen King Vudu BBC America Netflix Christmas movies Pirates finale rt archives aapi Amazon Studios art house spanish language Alien genre italian Academy Awards Nominations DGA Paramount Plus comedies werewolf Writers Guild of America crime thriller christmas movies scorecard Warner Bros. feel good ABC Signature hispanic composers Character Guide aliens Tomatazos james bond hidden camera Hallmark Emmys jurassic park PBS video on demand Superheroe Crackle rt labs IFC Instagram Live movies Funimation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina biopic Creative Arts Emmys boxing Trivia remakes See It Skip It 2021 Pacific Islander RT21 Election 45 LGBT game show comics razzies vs. Song of Ice and Fire rom-coms japan canceled nfl Comedy Central series MCU TruTV spanish GIFs Crunchyroll godzilla cooking Showtime social media ID OWN hispanic heritage month cancelled TV series Turner Classic Movies Avengers Spring TV festival CNN PlayStation target cinemax Podcast The Walking Dead cancelled television young adult child's play Apple TV Plus Film Festival hist sopranos Syfy criterion 73rd Emmy Awards mutant green book teaser Winter TV FOX what to watch justice league adenture directors YouTube Premium Tarantino Calendar HBO Max Animation streaming movies cars Amazon Prime Marvel Studios Tokyo Olympics psycho BET Disney Channel kong emmy awards live action 2019 screenings stoner theme song TCA Columbia Pictures south america anthology black Video Games kids Shondaland 2018 USA Marathons obituary olympics TV One die hard TV Land San Diego Comic-Con period drama batman 2016 new york Tumblr breaking bad sitcom children's TV mission: impossible ghosts Paramount Network psychological thriller Sundance black comedy Amazon Prime Video indie telelvision Ellie Kemper spinoff Amazon historical drama BBC One Toys football Freeform unscripted Sci-Fi a nightmare on elm street Sneak Peek mockumentary Country BAFTA name the review Heroines critics Starz foreign boxoffice biography Classic Film 93rd Oscars Captain marvel slasher suspense HBO sag awards Food Network robots RT History Comics on TV E! YouTube casting king kong book adaptation SXSW Emmy Nominations Pride Month 21st Century Fox CBS All Access Brie Larson Esquire blockbuster 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards MTV Acorn TV YA History Sundance Now Grammys First Look king arthur ESPN dexter X-Men Reality Competition documentaries OneApp TNT Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt fresh Exclusive Video Lifetime royal family docuseries 90s Disney Plus based on movie science fiction Marvel Television venice Super Bowl serial killer Arrowverse Sundance TV mcc 4/20 supernatural Mystery crossover Baby Yoda new zealand NBA new star wars movies blockbusters high school Watching Series live event singing competition SDCC SundanceTV zombies richard e. Grant medical drama Valentine's Day miniseries Pixar quibi deadpool comic books Black History Month television WGN nature Sony Pictures news Mary Poppins Returns TCA Awards sports The Purge Mary Tyler Moore slashers 007 Universal Pictures golden globes festivals elevated horror BET Awards golden globe awards Christmas Box Office Bravo TLC halloween tv Rocketman Spike twilight FX Mindy Kaling WarnerMedia Television Academy MSNBC Peacock posters superhero Family Fox News TCA 2017 Legendary cops comic book movies Opinion Pop TV Rocky Paramount transformers New York Comic Con CBS Shudder films critic resources animated thriller Spectrum Originals sequels Women's History Month Mary poppins Red Carpet Fantasy DC Universe best Fox Searchlight know your critic international TIFF versus El Rey President diversity crime dogs The Witch worst movies Lucasfilm FX on Hulu Kids & Family popular australia IMDb TV Extras japanese Turner facebook comic book movie Awards VOD spider-man book nbcuniversal APB Trophy Talk classics award winner halloween universal monsters Nat Geo Teen 2020 USA Network Wes Anderson Discovery Channel Netflix gangster HBO Go Black Mirror Britbox Photos Year in Review Holiday Music zombie Musical Masterpiece BBC Nickelodeon dceu Disney streaming service crime drama scary movies movie screen actors guild witnail docudrama Disney American Society of Cinematographers 1990s Set visit Disney+ Disney Plus Lionsgate romance rt labs critics edition Endgame National Geographic jamie lee curtis Lifetime Christmas movies Awards Tour AMC franchise true crime DC streaming service The Arrangement indiana jones strong female leads VH1 Adult Swim Summer renewed TV shows FXX scene in color A&E tv talk Western spain LGBTQ Television Critics Association latino Holidays cats cartoon dramedy disaster IFC Films documentary comiccon VICE Thanksgiving saw TV movies Chernobyl rotten Hallmark Christmas movies asian-american travel space 20th Century Fox DC Comics blaxploitation 71st Emmy Awards Film TV renewals debate dark GLAAD worst Apple TV+ Anna Paquin Star Trek spider-verse Trailer CW Seed spy thriller women Mudbound DirecTV action-comedy Countdown comic Comedy Marvel monster movies Winners dreamworks Ovation CMT natural history NBC TV dc police drama TBS all-time ABC Family heist movie Star Wars