Binge Guide

Weekly Binge: The Comeback

by | October 23, 2014 | Comments

To prime yourself for season two of The Comeback, premiering on Nov. 9 at 10 pm on HBO, here’s what you need to know before spending a weekend with Aunt Sassy.

The Comeback

The Comeback

What’s the premise? A fading TV star (Lisa Kudrow) attempts to reboot her career with her own reality show.

What’s it like? One of the ultimate cringe comedies of the last decade, The Comeback shows what happens when a narcissist confronts irrelevance. Valerie Cherish, once a TV star on the fictitious 1990s sitcom “I’m It,” nabs a minor role as “Aunt Sassy” on the fake series Room and Bored — so long as she also lets cameras film her for a reality show called The Comeback at the same time. For Cherish, the humiliation of trying to fit in with a much younger, more popular cast is hard to watch at times, but also makes for some delicious satire. There’s nothing else really like The Comeback, which practically prophesied what was to come on reality TV when it first aired in 2005. It’s also a fine example of meta-television with one of the first-ever TV shows within a TV show within a TV show!

Where can I see it? The complete first season is available on DVD, HBO Go, HBO On Demand, Amazon Prime, Amazon Instant Video, Google Play, iTunes, and Vudu. HBO2 will also air a marathon of the entire season on Nov. 8 from 10:30 am to 6 pm.

How long will it take? Season one of The Comeback is only 13 half-hour episodes, so you have plenty of time to catch up before season two. You may, however, need to take a few breaks to de-cringe from your binge.

What do the critics think? The Comeback was not overwhelmingly popular with critics in 2005, and at 46 percent on the Tomatometer, season one was rotten. Don’t let that deter you, however. Sal Cinquemani of Slant Magazine
wrote, “The Comeback quickly reveals itself to be not just a satire of the fickle, bottom-line-oriented sitcom world, but a depressing examination of sexism and ageism in Hollywood as a whole.” And Brian Lowry of Variety
lauded Lisa Kudrow (a 1990s sitcom star herself) in his fresh 2005 review, saying that “Kudrow is gifted and believable enough to sell Valerie as more than just her alter ego.” Years later, The Comeback has earned cult status and in 2012, the Guardian published an article in which Michael Hogan called the series “too far ahead of its time,” and Entertainment Weekly, in spite of having given it a rotten review in 2005, named The Comeback one of the 10 best TV shows of the decade in 2009.

Why should I watch this? Lisa Kudrow, who co-created the series, delivers a comedic tour de force with a performance so subtle that you forget she and Valerie Cherish are different people (Kudrow was nominated for an Emmy in 2006 for the role). Yes, there’s something sad about The Comeback, but the way Valerie Cherish acts self-conscious to the point of actually making herself look worse never fails to be funny. Also, Robert Michael Morris as Mickey the hairdresser, Malin Akerman as the new clueless “It” girl, and Damian Young as Valerie’s disinterested husband are hilarious. And don’t let the fact that The Comeback is 10 years old fool you; Valerie’s look was dated then too.

What’s my next step? Tina Fey’s 30 Rock is the next logical step, as are Ricky Gervais’s Extras and The Office. You should also check out HBO’s Hello Ladies, Family Tree, Veep, and Curb Your Enthusiasm. For movies, look no further than the filmography of Christopher Guest, especially This Is Spinal Tap, Waiting for Guffman, and For Your Consideration. Also, for fans of Kudrow since her Friends days, check out the Showtime series, Web Therapy, coming back for season four tonight at 11 pm.


Isn’t it time The Comeback made a comeback? Tell us why!


Tag Cloud

Opinion Hallmark Christmas movies technology 2019 VH1 romance Super Bowl facebook TV renewals Lucasfilm Emmys Brie Larson Starz San Diego Comic-Con TCA boxoffice game show Mary Poppins Returns slashers Fox News cinemax Endgame aliens Black Mirror Mary poppins Spike Holiday diversity Apple TV+ Winners CW Seed Comedy Central Netflix Christmas movies Emmy Nominations YA sequel IFC Films Nominations Epix elevated horror children's TV sag awards Tubi historical drama RT21 Academy Awards NYCC Heroines social media spanish language comiccon ITV strong female leads hist Fall TV Winter TV talk show Grammys based on movie Comics on TV Animation ESPN Musical streaming The Witch FOX reboot television Disney streaming service cars mockumentary game of thrones Sci-Fi BET spinoff award winner Musicals Apple crossover Writers Guild of America Oscars SundanceTV science fiction jamie lee curtis 24 frames President cops E3 screenings Horror spider-man halloween Disney Plus Star Trek politics rotten movies we love New York Comic Con Red Carpet disaster cancelled TV series The Walking Dead Amazon 45 natural history Superheroe Disney book Trophy Talk The Arrangement Comedy hispanic unscripted Binge Guide 21st Century Fox VICE indie First Look dragons TV Crunchyroll Mary Tyler Moore Certified Fresh 71st Emmy Awards Toys GIFs MSNBC Reality Competition Western blaxploitation Christmas Universal OWN finale transformers Lifetime space DGA TIFF APB Family TCA Winter 2020 Discovery Channel Anna Paquin Sneak Peek Superheroes serial killer Video Games discovery Shondaland Ovation HBO Max movies cooking blockbuster Trailer Mudbound latino Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TBS stand-up comedy Pet Sematary werewolf Cannes political drama ghosts Mindy Kaling teaser theme song Hallmark 2016 doctor who WarnerMedia zero dark thirty Rocketman crime thriller Creative Arts Emmys Amazon Prime video Tomatazos MCU cancelled Set visit docudrama Pixar tv talk Year in Review period drama Vudu Sundance Now versus American Society of Cinematographers what to watch Film Festival crime drama harry potter Watching Series Premiere Dates Extras Rocky nature Rock National Geographic Logo YouTube Red thriller Tarantino anthology The Purge Hulu robots Country Calendar LGBTQ Masterpiece Action BBC America DC streaming service Film NBC SDCC CMT Turner Mystery Infographic Chernobyl Marvel Studios GoT Showtime SXSW TCM composers comics Ellie Kemper GLAAD joker Marathons 2017 cancelled TV shows canceled TV shows golden globes travel kids sports Stephen King Character Guide Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Thanksgiving christmas movies Dark Horse Comics DC Comics anime TLC Freeform binge Arrowverse Pirates BBC Disney Channel Captain marvel Cartoon Network toy story sitcom 2015 green book Disney+ Disney Plus Walt Disney Pictures name the review police drama DirecTV FX Sony Pictures Song of Ice and Fire A24 medical drama supernatural vampires Sundance TV CBS cults Rom-Com Peacock Amazon Prime Video renewed TV shows screen actors guild batman Podcast zombies Spring TV Best and Worst mutant RT History Teen adaptation E! richard e. Grant USA LGBT TV Land Spectrum Originals spain Avengers Syfy Britbox MTV Schedule Countdown casting Box Office Polls and Games Elton John crime Esquire Lifetime Christmas movies Pride Month quibi Martial Arts Awards Tour south america TCA 2017 true crime The CW YouTube Premium FXX OneApp Biopics CNN dc Shudder Apple TV Plus foreign A&E justice league free movies YouTube breaking bad zombie PBS Paramount Network witnail Drama Crackle Quiz Columbia Pictures 007 animated Acorn TV cancelled television See It Skip It romantic comedy Reality Marvel Television Lionsgate directors Bravo Adult Swim HBO Food Network Kids & Family Valentine's Day Cosplay psychological thriller Women's History Month Paramount Trivia Nickelodeon Nat Geo series CBS All Access WGN psycho comic Star Wars PaleyFest Music singing competition cats Fantasy spy thriller Pop AMC war cartoon Warner Bros. ratings USA Network Photos Television Academy 2020 First Reviews biography ABC Family Summer festivals TruTV Awards adventure dceu TNT Netflix History revenge Turner Classic Movies Ghostbusters canceled Holidays Baby Yoda 2018 Comic Book ABC Classic Film Election independent dramedy miniseries Interview 20th Century Fox IFC DC Universe El Rey Sundance Tumblr Marvel X-Men