Binge Guide

Weekly Binge: The Comeback

by | October 23, 2014 | Comments

To prime yourself for season two of The Comeback, premiering on Nov. 9 at 10 pm on HBO, here’s what you need to know before spending a weekend with Aunt Sassy.

The Comeback

The Comeback

What’s the premise? A fading TV star (Lisa Kudrow) attempts to reboot her career with her own reality show.

What’s it like? One of the ultimate cringe comedies of the last decade, The Comeback shows what happens when a narcissist confronts irrelevance. Valerie Cherish, once a TV star on the fictitious 1990s sitcom “I’m It,” nabs a minor role as “Aunt Sassy” on the fake series Room and Bored — so long as she also lets cameras film her for a reality show called The Comeback at the same time. For Cherish, the humiliation of trying to fit in with a much younger, more popular cast is hard to watch at times, but also makes for some delicious satire. There’s nothing else really like The Comeback, which practically prophesied what was to come on reality TV when it first aired in 2005. It’s also a fine example of meta-television with one of the first-ever TV shows within a TV show within a TV show!

Where can I see it? The complete first season is available on DVD, HBO Go, HBO On Demand, Amazon Prime, Amazon Instant Video, Google Play, iTunes, and Vudu. HBO2 will also air a marathon of the entire season on Nov. 8 from 10:30 am to 6 pm.

How long will it take? Season one of The Comeback is only 13 half-hour episodes, so you have plenty of time to catch up before season two. You may, however, need to take a few breaks to de-cringe from your binge.

What do the critics think? The Comeback was not overwhelmingly popular with critics in 2005, and at 46 percent on the Tomatometer, season one was rotten. Don’t let that deter you, however. Sal Cinquemani of Slant Magazine
wrote, “The Comeback quickly reveals itself to be not just a satire of the fickle, bottom-line-oriented sitcom world, but a depressing examination of sexism and ageism in Hollywood as a whole.” And Brian Lowry of Variety
lauded Lisa Kudrow (a 1990s sitcom star herself) in his fresh 2005 review, saying that “Kudrow is gifted and believable enough to sell Valerie as more than just her alter ego.” Years later, The Comeback has earned cult status and in 2012, the Guardian published an article in which Michael Hogan called the series “too far ahead of its time,” and Entertainment Weekly, in spite of having given it a rotten review in 2005, named The Comeback one of the 10 best TV shows of the decade in 2009.

Why should I watch this? Lisa Kudrow, who co-created the series, delivers a comedic tour de force with a performance so subtle that you forget she and Valerie Cherish are different people (Kudrow was nominated for an Emmy in 2006 for the role). Yes, there’s something sad about The Comeback, but the way Valerie Cherish acts self-conscious to the point of actually making herself look worse never fails to be funny. Also, Robert Michael Morris as Mickey the hairdresser, Malin Akerman as the new clueless “It” girl, and Damian Young as Valerie’s disinterested husband are hilarious. And don’t let the fact that The Comeback is 10 years old fool you; Valerie’s look was dated then too.

What’s my next step? Tina Fey’s 30 Rock is the next logical step, as are Ricky Gervais’s Extras and The Office. You should also check out HBO’s Hello Ladies, Family Tree, Veep, and Curb Your Enthusiasm. For movies, look no further than the filmography of Christopher Guest, especially This Is Spinal Tap, Waiting for Guffman, and For Your Consideration. Also, for fans of Kudrow since her Friends days, check out the Showtime series, Web Therapy, coming back for season four tonight at 11 pm.


Isn’t it time The Comeback made a comeback? Tell us why!


Tag Cloud

anime disaster Spectrum Originals cars Sony Pictures hollywood Tubi rom-coms BET deadpool Warner Bros. DC streaming service series festival Musicals ABC dreamworks japanese movies nbcuniversal TCA Awards Acorn TV children's TV 2017 Binge Guide Trophy Talk Martial Arts TCM Britbox Alien Podcast SDCC Amazon Prime Video Grammys IFC Films Spring TV Shondaland IFC HBO FOX Awards biopic hist Fox News mission: impossible zombies Set visit nature cinemax BAFTA Apple DC Comics mutant Video Games dragons aliens binge The CW joker crime Avengers 21st Century Fox YouTube Premium cartoon crime drama Classic Film james bond Television Critics Association FXX independent FX on Hulu Peacock indie Box Office finale 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The Witch Opinion comic books TIFF aapi Best and Worst witnail Turner strong female leads elevated horror political drama BBC America discovery period drama richard e. Grant Western renewed TV shows serial killer jamie lee curtis zombie Animation BBC One hidden camera unscripted Black History Month MSNBC lord of the rings sequels Fall TV christmas movies Academy Awards royal family Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Crackle DGA venice genre Summer docuseries The Walking Dead Nat Geo football talk show Travel Channel Freeform First Look ID streaming WarnerMedia TV Land vs. Comics on TV GoT Chernobyl Funimation The Purge olympics Paramount Plus TruTV Broadway worst movies First Reviews 2016 all-time trophy superman news Paramount CMT Sundance TV DC Universe Valentine's Day best Vudu cancelled television south america godzilla police drama Horror LGBTQ fast and furious Fantasy ITV The Arrangement wonder woman Legendary TV dark Bravo asian-american dceu sitcom Baby Yoda fresh 71st Emmy Awards Lionsgate RT History Sneak Peek toy story composers sports 2019 cancelled TV shows TV movies diversity Syfy italian X-Men Ellie Kemper Universal Pictures target festivals boxoffice Showtime spy thriller Esquire movie Mudbound 20th Century Fox Captain marvel comic book movies trailers Reality Competition USA Network sequel Emmy Nominations king kong stoner comiccon Pop TV marvel cinematic universe based on movie Toys dc war high school Fox Searchlight natural history parents adenture adaptation rt archives leaderboard Film Festival mcc SXSW films blockbuster Ghostbusters Calendar 1990s Anna Paquin thriller Rocky Teen Nominations twilight Epix spanish language Drama 2015 black Disney streaming service Tokyo Olympics Marvel Studios screen actors guild comic women HBO Max doctor who indiana jones space Hear Us Out video criterion science fiction slashers Masterpiece rotten Creative Arts Emmys TCA 2017 cops Trailer politics Rock Lifetime stand-up comedy CNN Food Network President Superheroe legend Crunchyroll kaiju Emmys Instagram Live travel OneApp television rotten movies we love RT21 historical drama Cartoon Network Character Guide Arrowverse ratings Prime Video scary movies docudrama BET Awards Comic Book AMC animated WGN marvel comics documentary critic resources what to watch Disney+ Disney Plus Hallmark Christmas movies Wes Anderson casting new zealand revenge Quiz documentaries Disney Plus live event cults CBS quibi razzies chucky 79th Golden Globes Awards latino reboot Year in Review HFPA APB archives tv talk Rocketman reviews Heroines social media telelvision Tumblr 007 GIFs Mary poppins live action YouTube Red Cosplay true crime San Diego Comic-Con Apple TV+ heist movie Election satire Writers Guild of America A24 PBS facebook feel good Walt Disney Pictures Kids & Family worst NBC Watching Series Comedy Central werewolf name the review franchise crime thriller Musical Stephen King Photos Pop ghosts Lucasfilm Hallmark japan Brie Larson Tags: Comedy 2018 Schedule emmy awards Discovery Channel Winners Action Holidays rt labs french Super Bowl History Exclusive Video superhero pirates of the caribbean foreign 4/20 Song of Ice and Fire Family Neflix Certified Fresh game show cancelled kids scene in color Star Wars gangster ABC Signature Disney Channel die hard E3 AMC Plus Interview FX batman E! new star wars movies PaleyFest TNT 72 Emmy Awards Marvel Television universal monsters CW Seed comedies remakes comics Amazon Studios ESPN psychological thriller cats Nickelodeon golden globe awards Sci-Fi versus Paramount Network directors Awards Tour kong 45 jurassic park Amazon Infographic Hollywood Foreign Press Association YouTube PlayStation slasher Apple TV Plus American Society of Cinematographers crossover Dark Horse Comics Turner Classic Movies popular Adult Swim Netflix Christmas movies technology Pirates australia halloween TBS streaming movies blaxploitation supernatural MCU biography Winter TV El Rey 2020 See It Skip It YA New York Comic Con Mary Poppins Returns Women's History Month dexter suspense 73rd Emmy Awards VOD IMDb TV Tarantino singing competition green book Sundance Now hispanic heritage month cooking Disney award winner Ovation mob cancelled TV series Marathons canceled concert Countdown Film Mindy Kaling monster movies art house breaking bad 24 frames robots 99% Trivia video on demand dramedy OWN adventure harry potter know your critic Columbia Pictures game of thrones king arthur TCA Winter 2020 hispanic DirecTV book adaptation Polls and Games a nightmare on elm street Universal VH1 TCA spider-man black comedy book NBA Netflix Pacific Islander scary Pet Sematary psycho comic book movie A&E romance 2021 Endgame transformers MTV National Geographic debate Black Mirror Reality dogs theme song vampires halloween tv spanish Chilling Adventures of Sabrina BBC free movies justice league blockbusters spider-verse Lifetime Christmas movies anthology TV One The Walt Disney Company Holiday canceled TV shows Starz spain Mary Tyler Moore young adult miniseries boxing nfl Mystery Pride Month Christmas Marvel Thanksgiving The Academy NYCC TV renewals romantic comedy TLC child's play Amazon Prime Sundance Comedy classics Image Comics USA Fargo obituary Pixar Hulu saw Cannes scorecard mockumentary new york Biopics CBS All Access Tomatazos spinoff Star Trek teaser LGBT Elton John SundanceTV zero dark thirty ViacomCBS 90s rt labs critics edition Premiere Dates Extras sopranos Country Spike international VICE sag awards critics Logo laika Superheroes Red Carpet HBO Go golden globes prank action-comedy medical drama Rom-Com basketball stop motion Television Academy Shudder screenings GLAAD posters Music 93rd Oscars Oscars Comic-Con@Home 2021 ABC Family toronto