Showdowns

RT Fans Crown Halloween the Ultimate Horror Movie

The John Carpenter classic surged from behind on the last day of voting to eke out a victory over The Shining by a mere 20 votes!

by | October 29, 2021 | Comments

(Click to enlarge.)

After six intense rounds of voting on some of the most beloved, most iconic horror films ever, we can finally announce that the winner of the Ultimate Horror Movie Showdown is John Carpenter’s original Halloween! And, appropriately enough, the win came by the narrowest of margins, making it the closest battle of the entire tournament. Stanley Kubrick’s adaptation of Stephen King’s The Shining held a tenuous lead of just under 100 votes as the last day of voting began, but as afternoon came, the tide began to turn. When all was said and done, almost 14,000 votes were cast, and Halloween received a last-minute surge that helped it eke out the victory over The Shining by a mere 20 votes (6917 to 6897, to be exact)!

As always, thanks to everyone who participated and followed along, leaving comments and discussing the results. If nothing else, we hope we’ve reminded you of a few forgotten favorites or a few gems you’ve been meaning to check out that you can place on your Halloween watch list for the weekend. With that said, stay tuned for our next showdown, and have a safe and Happy Halloween!

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results


Final Round Result

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next

Tag Cloud

Sci-Fi legend Binge Guide singing competition based on movie japan halloween prank Comedy TCA VOD adventure Spectrum Originals Western science fiction wonder woman Christmas Masterpiece anime zombie Tubi satire Comedy Central die hard comic books Year in Review sports crime GLAAD mutant asian-american Stephen King Captain marvel Esquire stop motion know your critic richard e. Grant Disney+ Disney Plus Fargo Marvel Elton John HFPA reboot toy story Netflix Chernobyl nfl Spike LGBTQ Warner Bros. Academy Awards Amazon Studios joker YouTube Red chucky deadpool TCA Awards Universal Pictures witnail young adult 24 frames Summer ESPN LGBT dc Hulu comedies ITV lord of the rings Universal nature festival American Society of Cinematographers psychological thriller supernatural a nightmare on elm street latino dark Character Guide video Turner romance mockumentary Lifetime Christmas movies HBO Go slasher child's play The Witch OWN Oscar justice league spanish 2019 green book rt labs critics edition President Musical thriller target CNN heist movie PBS screen actors guild pirates of the caribbean marvel comics historical drama SDCC Writers Guild of America Pet Sematary war 2020 CMT serial killer talk show Indigenous National Geographic psycho summer TV A&E Pop TV cancelled TV shows Disney Plus Star Wars Celebration crime thriller Trivia parents Instagram Live TV renewals Funimation king kong Best Director Rom-Com spider-man Sundance blockbuster Infographic The Arrangement dceu Black History Month Star Wars criterion new zealand Musicals Black Mirror scary Thanksgiving Ghostbusters 99% Wes Anderson Mindy Kaling Box Office live event Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt biopic Film Festival ABC Photos IMDb TV Mary Tyler Moore DirecTV Tarantino Acorn TV name the review hidden camera Schedule Comic-Con@Home 2021 nbcuniversal TV dogs Walt Disney Pictures Bravo movies blaxploitation TIFF james bond kaiju History italian trophy golden globes The Academy DC Comics TLC 45 halloween tv breaking bad The CW Hallmark docuseries gangster Classic Film true crime Pixar romantic comedy hispanic heritage month AMC Plus Apple mission: impossible Family posters Set visit comic book movies hollywood basketball social media comic zombies Creative Arts Emmys broadcast Anna Paquin Vudu mob police drama TruTV new star wars movies best international cooking Disney worst MCU RT21 zero dark thirty Image Comics Teen rt labs Cannes Columbia Pictures emmy awards batman YouTube Premium vs. summer TV preview Toys Film Epix scene in color series Paramount Plus slashers laika A24 target scene in color versus spain live action Brie Larson dreamworks french cults quibi ID TCA Winter 2020 Best Actress screenings scene in color film series Sundance TV australia women Awards Tour BET Tumblr robots comiccon 90s popular USA Network mcc streamig boxing Disney Channel marvel cinematic universe toronto Ellie Kemper WGN Oscars FX on Hulu Country 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards interviews streaming movies Heroines 1990s DGA video on demand Rocky Neflix rom-coms South by Southwest Film Festival king arthur foreign all-time Marvel Television San Diego Comic-Con Mudbound game of thrones franchise Paramount Network Countdown Mary Poppins Returns Super Bowl 71st Emmy Awards GoT Pop APB new york Cartoon Network Martial Arts RT History The Walking Dead Shudder Marvel Studios rotten movies we love Mary poppins facebook period drama space FXX casting MGM Legendary Adult Swim renewed TV shows Netflix Christmas movies concert 4/20 Crunchyroll Ovation New York Comic Con Calendar travel ABC Signature Food Network Television Academy twilight BBC America BBC book adaptation IFC Films hispanic royal family comic book movie 2016 NBA Pacific Islander Travel Channel VICE miniseries cancelled TV series Best Actor Television Critics Association Rocketman werewolf El Rey 73rd Emmy Awards Prime Video Native Exclusive Video FX adaptation politics Election sopranos sequel stand-up comedy critics Kids & Family medical drama composers tv talk Focus Features cars aliens Britbox Drama discovery Certified Fresh doctor who Tokyo Olympics fast and furious films Biopics anthology DC streaming service comics book First Reviews 2015 godzilla venice Starz theme song rotten WarnerMedia documentaries football VH1 christmas movies binge boxoffice MTV black comedy directors CBS All Access SXSW NYCC blockbusters worst movies Freeform jurassic park Animation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina razzies PlayStation Sneak Peek revenge Mystery Disney streaming service elevated horror YA Nominations Lucasfilm Emmy Nominations See It Skip It aapi spanish language DC Universe harry potter BAFTA MSNBC 2017 TCM Showtime Watching Series Podcast kids Fox News TV movies Endgame suspense telelvision Action technology spider-verse movie high school Amazon Prime finale Best Picture hist 79th Golden Globes Awards crime drama TV Land independent children's TV art house Women's History Month Interview Apple TV+ Winners golden globe awards saw dexter disaster 2021 cancelled television Pirates BET Awards political drama news cinemax Tags: Comedy obituary dramedy canceled TV shows NBC 94th Oscars Red Carpet Turner Classic Movies television Fox Searchlight ABC Family The Walt Disney Company spinoff sag awards SundanceTV cats Emmys X-Men Arrowverse PaleyFest Dark Horse Comics Horror sitcom Rock documentary Paramount diversity critic resources kong 007 Nickelodeon Awards Best and Worst AMC Spring TV Syfy Amazon Prime Video YouTube Sony Pictures Superheroe Peacock debate ratings animated Premiere Dates HBO superman Avengers universal monsters docudrama Tomatazos series Trophy Talk Baby Yoda Pride Month First Look Valentine's Day E! stoner Lionsgate teaser action-comedy genre olympics superhero 72 Emmy Awards Shondaland cops OneApp BBC One Hollywood Foreign Press Association Grammys classics summer preview Crackle biography monster movies Marathons Paramount Pictures Cosplay spy thriller festivals CBS Quiz Reality Competition vampires cartoon cancelled E3 TCA 2017 CW Seed 21st Century Fox Reality FOX The Purge Discovery Channel black Hallmark Christmas movies TBS free movies strong female leads fresh adenture rt archives indie Apple TV Plus SXSW 2022 Hear Us Out trailers Video Games ghosts Holidays Superheroes Holiday obi wan Winter TV dragons scary movies crossover remakes award winner Lifetime GIFs TNT Song of Ice and Fire IFC Sony leaderboard USA Extras 20th Century Fox archives feel good Trailer Opinion scorecard jamie lee curtis Music Fantasy Fall TV Alien scene in color japanese 2018 Geeked Week transformers natural history what to watch Logo Polls and Games Star Trek canceled HBO Max 93rd Oscars Broadway unscripted streaming Comic Book Amazon indiana jones TV One reviews sequels Comics on TV game show south america Nat Geo ViacomCBS Sundance Now