UK Critics Consensus: Twilight Shines In The UK Reviews

Plus, Fear And Loving For Gonzo, Whilst The Tale Of Despereaux Is Met With Indifference

by | December 19, 2008 | Comments

It’s Christmas week in the UK cinemas, but instead of any festive films on offer, we have the eagerly anticipated (by young girls everywhere…) romantic vampire movie Twilight. Gonzo: The Life And Work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson, a documentary about the godfather of Gonzo journalism, and the writer of Fear And Loathing in Las Vegas is also lighting up the big screens, with mouse-based animation The Tale Of Despereaux making up the numbers for this week’s releases. But what did the UK critics have to say?

Twilight is the film adaptation of the hugely successful and popular teen-fantasy novel by Stephanie Meyer. The books, Twilight being the first in a series of four, have sold by the boat-load in the US, approaching an almost Potter level of success, but mainly amongst hormonal teenage girls of a certain age. Meyer’s tales of teenage yearning and angst, combined with the gothic supernatural seem to have struck a rich vein of youth literature, and the film adaptation has been generating a massive amount of interest amongst the book’s legions of fans.

The film was released last month in the US, and didn’t fare too well with the critics. It stood at a Rotten 45% on the Tomatometer, with the critics feeling that it didn’t live up to the source material, and many bemoaning the chemistry (or lack of) between Bella and Edward, played by Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson. But, perhaps due to the more muted level of popularity of the source material here in blighty, the UK critics have really fallen for Twilight. From the 20 reviews collated today, only one review came in unfavourably, and even The Sun’s critic The Sneak admitted that the film was “A superior high school romance, which looks set to live on after the sun has set on Hogwarts.” So with UK reviews only Twilight would stand at a much more respectable (and Fresh) 95% on the Tomatometer. Critics swooned over the breathless romance and dark but well-meaning tone, meaning that Twilight may just be the hit of the winter season with Will Lawrence from Empire saying “A sometimes girlie swirl of obsession that will delight fans, this faithful adaptation is after teenage blood, and will most likely hit a box office artery.”

Gonzo: The Life and Work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson does exactly what it says on the tin. Alex Gibney‘s documentary currently stands at a Certified Fresh 86% on the Tomatometer. UK critics echoed the US critical response, applauding the insightful, accessible and definitive biography into Thompson’s weird and wonderful life, whilst a few complained that Gibney failed to delve deeply enough into his darker and more idiosyncratic foibles. Summing up the film, and it’s hagiographic nature, James Christopher of The Times said…

Gonzo is much more than a tribute to a maverick and genuine pioneer. It’s a lament for the gaping hole that Thompson left behind. The only obvious weakness is Gibney’s reluctance to engage fully with Thompson’s toxic personal life.”

It must be a literary themed this week, as our third big release is The Tale Of Despereaux, an adaptation of the Kate DiCamillo fantasy novel, concerning the eponymous brave rodent Despereaux. Boasting an all-star cast including Sigourney Weaver, Matthew Broderick and Potter alumni Emma Watson, The Tale Of Despereaux is a modern animated fairytale with princesses, castles and talking mice, naturally. At 47% on the Tomatometer though, it seems that Despereaux doesn’t have the required level of magic to garner a Fresh rating. The critics felt that kids would probably enjoy it (but, at the risk of sounding patronising, what animated feature don’t they?), they praised the crisp animation, but felt the story was laboured, the characters weak, and film displayed a concerning lack of warmth. Paling in comparison to the similar yet superior Ratatouille and Shrek, The Tale of Despereaux is more stale than fairytale.

Quote Of The Week

“Horror fans will find little to sink their teeth into, but it’ll get tweenage hearts fluttering like orgasmic bats.”

Twilight. Larushka Ivan-Zadeh, Metro.

Tag Cloud

Infographic LGBTQ Ghostbusters Comedy Logo cooking political drama Tomatazos Trophy Talk festivals Mary Poppins Returns dramedy Emmys Disney Hulu Mudbound The CW Black Mirror Writers Guild of America Trailer Adult Swim Sundance Now Valentine's Day sequel supernatural green book Paramount Marathons Kids & Family psycho teaser Summer anime nature Epix Fantasy Music singing competition Extras FXX theme song Christmas Star Trek 007 Captain marvel discovery spy thriller BBC The Arrangement X-Men spider-man Animation hist Mystery justice league sitcom TCM Anna Paquin Apple DirecTV based on movie ITV Opinion IFC Films space BET Walt Disney Pictures science fiction CNN richard e. Grant AMC MSNBC Countdown thriller Spectrum Originals CMT travel American Society of Cinematographers President DGA crime drama Shudder Ovation Podcast sports ESPN war New York Comic Con Awards 2019 TIFF VICE boxoffice Quiz 24 frames Certified Fresh comic jamie lee curtis OWN historical drama SundanceTV National Geographic elevated horror Sneak Peek Thanksgiving E! mockumentary Comedy Central Comics on TV cinemax vampires Marvel First Look Trivia Disney Channel Britbox Columbia Pictures police drama strong female leads GLAAD Tarantino Universal Star Wars DC Universe A&E Sony Pictures Stephen King doctor who TLC Mindy Kaling Nominations Cartoon Network Showtime Mary Tyler Moore Video Games Shondaland Fall TV Pixar Heroines Dark Horse Comics Election television WGN YA 2017 Acorn TV DC Comics RT21 Lucasfilm robots CBS technology Toys facebook dc DC streaming service Premiere Dates Sci-Fi Nickelodeon GIFs Vudu witnail Biopics Superheroe CBS All Access crime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mary poppins TCA dceu HBO Horror RT History Cosplay Reality Reality Competition Cannes Watching Series serial killer Pop Comic Book anthology 2018 blaxploitation harry potter Musicals Women's History Month See It Skip It Spike Amazon CW Seed Netflix 45 TBS GoT Awards Tour Elton John Winter TV docudrama MCU Warner Bros. talk show San Diego Comic-Con Musical aliens BBC America 21st Century Fox Box Office social media ABC Sundance composers TV Land finale golden globes Pet Sematary 20th Century Fox Calendar disaster transformers cats Amazon Prime ratings NBC Red Carpet Food Network Fox News medical drama Nat Geo Tumblr Creative Arts Emmys Syfy SXSW APB romance Starz crossover TCA 2017 Masterpiece dragons Interview USA mutant Year in Review adaptation Lionsgate miniseries FOX FX Western zombie YouTube Premium TNT Action MTV Holidays ABC Family Rocketman Winners USA Network Teen binge zombies award winner comiccon psychological thriller natural history YouTube Red Bravo VH1 2016 Freeform politics TV period drama TruTV Brie Larson unscripted Photos Character Guide Rock Superheroes Set visit Esquire Grammys Rocky IFC History Film Festival biography Best and Worst crime thriller Drama 2015 El Rey Song of Ice and Fire Pirates Schedule what to watch casting Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt true crime diversity zero dark thirty Rom-Com The Witch Ellie Kemper Spring TV streaming Country Martial Arts E3 SDCC Crackle Super Bowl Paramount Network Polls and Games PaleyFest Oscars PBS cops NYCC adventure Lifetime cults