RT Fans Crown The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King as the Best of the Best Picture Winners

Peter Jackson's fantasy epic outpaced Francis Ford Coppola's mafia tale by a wide, convincing margin.

by | February 7, 2020 | Comments

(Click to enlarge.)

The Oscar Best Picture Showdown is officially over, and the RT community has crowned The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King as the best of the Best Pictures! In addition to Best Picture, Peter Jackson’s epic finale to the Lord of the Rings series was nominated for 10 more Oscars at the 2004 Academy Awards, including Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best Original Score, and it won every single one of them. That not only matched the most wins for a single film at the Oscars (Ben-Hur and Titanic previously achieved the same distinction), but set the record for the most wins by a film that took home the trophy in every category in which it was nominated. Here, Return of the King defeated all of its opponents, from classic films like All Quiet on the Western Front and The French Connection to more recent hits like Spotlight and No Country for Old Men, by a wide margin before facing off against The Godfather, and even then, Return took the crown with a decisive 59% of the vote.

Over the course of this bracket’s six rounds, almost a million votes were tallied across all of the individual match-ups, so big thanks to everyone in the RT community who participated! Click below to see the results of all the prior rounds, and stay tuned for our next big bracket showdown!

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results

Final Round Results

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results

Thumbnail image by ©New Line courtesy Everett Collection

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next

Tag Cloud

Awards Tour stoner DGA dogs USA ghosts diversity what to watch TV 2018 Reality Binge Guide blaxploitation TruTV Family Acorn TV A24 Marvel Studios TIFF universal monsters foreign unscripted Ellie Kemper Hulu Oscars franchise miniseries Marvel MCU spy thriller animated Apple TV+ 007 Film Rocketman renewed TV shows Star Wars 45 Cannes DC Comics Disney Toys Crunchyroll 2016 technology TV renewals 21st Century Fox Crackle Quiz BET cancelled TV series Pop doctor who Podcast Arrowverse independent comedies DC Universe Sony Pictures Disney+ Disney Plus cancelled television APB Comedy Central canceled TV shows video Brie Larson YouTube Premium political drama breaking bad strong female leads award winner quibi Anna Paquin Character Guide robots Apple indie dramedy Amazon Studios rotten movies we love politics IFC YouTube FX on Hulu binge adaptation sitcom Election series Esquire Winners cults Disney Plus green book Nominations scary movies Disney Channel richard e. Grant CMT Tarantino sports Netflix Lifetime Tomatazos christmas movies mutant HBO Animation PBS Spring TV psychological thriller New York Comic Con serial killer elevated horror LGBTQ FOX cooking Biopics sequel justice league 24 frames GLAAD Spike Masterpiece Certified Fresh Red Carpet television Tumblr Calendar Countdown travel E3 cancelled TV shows Paramount Network VICE Marathons halloween ratings dc Baby Yoda OWN period drama President Teen Superheroe Bravo Reality Competition The Purge The Witch Paramount biography theme song disaster Pixar TV Land Black Mirror spain concert Emmy Nominations kids TCM Classic Film aliens transformers Peacock Nickelodeon Hallmark Christmas movies Sundance TV zero dark thirty mission: impossible a nightmare on elm street comiccon Starz Cartoon Network docudrama OneApp Dark Horse Comics asian-american BBC NYCC Freeform adventure thriller BBC America cars CBS All Access Watching Series Columbia Pictures LGBT PaleyFest book Hallmark singing competition ESPN versus FXX romance E! Syfy nature war Logo The Walking Dead blockbuster First Look Captain marvel police drama Infographic 2020 Premiere Dates screenings Amazon CNN tv talk Pop TV See It Skip It Writers Guild of America cats Comic Book batman screen actors guild streaming CBS spinoff Awards 4/20 psycho name the review 2015 Travel Channel based on movie comic teaser X-Men zombies Music Academy Awards Marvel Television Hear Us Out Thanksgiving Endgame TCA Emmys Turner Classic Movies DC streaming service VH1 El Rey Apple TV Plus free movies RT21 Opinion 2019 Drama vampires Country DirecTV Creative Arts Emmys Comedy comics supernatural best Fall TV cancelled IFC Films Fox News RT History Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt movies critics Cosplay Winter TV TNT A&E Tubi sag awards social media Box Office SundanceTV Ghostbusters reviews WarnerMedia Avengers Trivia Star Trek cops festivals YA composers FX true crime 20th Century Fox natural history Amazon Prime revenge WGN space Holiday Sundance Now anime HBO Max Musicals American Society of Cinematographers boxoffice Sneak Peek Shudder Superheroes chucky cartoon TCA Winter 2020 Pride Month Horror crime thriller child's play die hard Pet Sematary MSNBC USA Network History discovery werewolf Martial Arts Britbox Turner MTV Black History Month finale Interview Sundance historical drama Walt Disney Pictures Rom-Com Valentine's Day Spectrum Originals Super Bowl Extras romantic comedy Netflix Christmas movies directors Sci-Fi The Arrangement talk show Warner Bros. Mary Poppins Returns Schedule Holidays crime hispanic south america Mudbound Stephen King SXSW Comics on TV ABC Family GoT Showtime NBC mockumentary dark children's TV all-time Musical reboot Mary Tyler Moore casting Set visit TLC Mystery Chernobyl Best and Worst Grammys Funimation spider-man crime drama movie Ovation Vudu Western Chilling Adventures of Sabrina joker documentary criterion harry potter Fantasy Lucasfilm Epix ITV 2017 TBS Rock Video Games parents ABC Christmas golden globes Mary poppins slashers San Diego Comic-Con Food Network anthology TCA 2017 Kids & Family YouTube Red Shondaland Universal canceled crossover zombie Amazon Prime Video cinemax Trailer Nat Geo Year in Review Disney streaming service toy story National Geographic Trophy Talk Lionsgate Rocky Adult Swim spanish language Song of Ice and Fire Photos Summer game show stand-up comedy witnail facebook Lifetime Christmas movies Pirates Polls and Games dragons The CW Elton John CW Seed dceu 71st Emmy Awards Television Academy science fiction jamie lee curtis Heroines Mindy Kaling medical drama hist SDCC Discovery Channel Women's History Month GIFs latino Action First Reviews Film Festival game of thrones AMC