RT Fans Crown The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King as the Best of the Best Picture Winners

Peter Jackson's fantasy epic outpaced Francis Ford Coppola's mafia tale by a wide, convincing margin.

by | February 7, 2020 | Comments

(Click to enlarge.)

The Oscar Best Picture Showdown is officially over, and the RT community has crowned The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King as the best of the Best Pictures! In addition to Best Picture, Peter Jackson’s epic finale to the Lord of the Rings series was nominated for 10 more Oscars at the 2004 Academy Awards, including Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best Original Score, and it won every single one of them. That not only matched the most wins for a single film at the Oscars (Ben-Hur and Titanic previously achieved the same distinction), but set the record for the most wins by a film that took home the trophy in every category in which it was nominated. Here, Return of the King defeated all of its opponents, from classic films like All Quiet on the Western Front and The French Connection to more recent hits like Spotlight and No Country for Old Men, by a wide margin before facing off against The Godfather, and even then, Return took the crown with a decisive 59% of the vote.

Over the course of this bracket’s six rounds, almost a million votes were tallied across all of the individual match-ups, so big thanks to everyone in the RT community who participated! Click below to see the results of all the prior rounds, and stay tuned for our next big bracket showdown!

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results

Final Round Results

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results

Thumbnail image by ©New Line courtesy Everett Collection

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next

Tag Cloud

anime BBC Holidays CBS All Access cancelled television composers Apple TV+ Cosplay Starz Photos Film Festival Pop Apple TV Plus Hallmark USA Network SDCC romance Walt Disney Pictures New York Comic Con NBC APB quibi social media science fiction true crime Opinion Comedy Central Infographic Calendar DirecTV TV renewals Classic Film versus canceled TV shows Cartoon Network cooking finale TNT The CW Kids & Family Britbox police drama FX directors E! Endgame Star Trek SXSW Rom-Com Freeform OWN Mary poppins Election Crackle canceled Reality Competition Sci-Fi First Reviews Lionsgate 2020 breaking bad Esquire animated Black Mirror TCA Winter 2020 The Walking Dead Marathons Warner Bros. sag awards 21st Century Fox television unscripted ITV adventure werewolf YouTube Premium Christmas Netflix Turner Sundance TV Box Office renewed TV shows dogs Extras Rocketman screenings Lifetime jamie lee curtis casting X-Men YA Disney ABC Mystery Shondaland zombie movies TCM Country toy story Spring TV Fantasy cars documentary Comics on TV independent Shudder comiccon WGN Drama Year in Review San Diego Comic-Con facebook 2017 LGBTQ AMC Star Wars Disney Plus space romantic comedy Marvel Ovation binge FXX Ellie Kemper Sneak Peek Disney streaming service hist Anna Paquin discovery Amazon Prime Disney Channel Sundance Cannes christmas movies Dark Horse Comics cats A&E TLC justice league Watching Series Family cops crime cancelled 2015 Hallmark Christmas movies Animation Ghostbusters Song of Ice and Fire crime drama MTV Biopics Columbia Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina PaleyFest PBS zombies Interview Peacock Oscars 007 Western reboot batman foreign Academy Awards Pride Month Trailer Certified Fresh halloween cartoon Lucasfilm revenge TV GLAAD BET Mary Poppins Returns Stephen King HBO Women's History Month Trophy Talk ghosts MSNBC latino game show period drama serial killer TV Land politics boxoffice Superheroes Action comic CW Seed hispanic Chernobyl NYCC spider-man Awards Tour Music game of thrones Binge Guide Tubi strong female leads miniseries RT History YouTube Red Comic Book History theme song Winners Super Bowl Fall TV political drama Creative Arts Emmys Grammys Musicals stand-up comedy HBO Max The Arrangement SundanceTV LGBT kids rotten movies we love 2018 supernatural south america CMT harry potter dramedy Vudu Comedy cancelled TV series natural history Thanksgiving Mary Tyler Moore mutant screen actors guild Food Network Winter TV Set visit Epix Superheroe DC Universe witnail movie dragons free movies Amazon Studios blockbuster Rock crime thriller robots mockumentary President Arrowverse adaptation Character Guide thriller 2019 Disney+ Disney Plus Emmys name the review Amazon Prime Video transformers Bravo 20th Century Fox Brie Larson Best and Worst Quiz Showtime psycho Polls and Games Valentine's Day war Pixar Holiday Marvel Studios Tomatazos Paramount spinoff Masterpiece Trivia Sony Pictures Discovery Channel doctor who Reality Television Academy National Geographic 2016 CNN joker elevated horror richard e. Grant 71st Emmy Awards USA First Look Writers Guild of America what to watch docudrama 24 frames indie spy thriller Pet Sematary TBS series sitcom DGA crossover golden globes Awards TIFF psychological thriller RT21 Paramount Network Nat Geo Countdown Emmy Nominations cinemax video TCA 2017 vampires Heroines Film talk show book Fox News TruTV Turner Classic Movies Mudbound comics VH1 Toys anthology Summer 45 based on movie Adult Swim dc Horror Lifetime Christmas movies Hulu Mindy Kaling Tumblr award winner Premiere Dates GoT singing competition Pirates A24 Marvel Television Martial Arts IFC Films WarnerMedia Tarantino Amazon TCA nature Video Games Crunchyroll dceu The Witch DC Comics Nickelodeon sequel Spectrum Originals E3 cults green book MCU BBC America children's TV ABC Family DC streaming service FOX CBS The Purge Spike Baby Yoda Nominations American Society of Cinematographers Red Carpet Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Logo spain Acorn TV Captain marvel historical drama cancelled TV shows Universal blaxploitation ratings El Rey zero dark thirty ESPN Elton John Podcast slashers spanish language Rocky biography travel diversity Sundance Now aliens Teen OneApp GIFs Avengers Apple Musical Syfy See It Skip It IFC Netflix Christmas movies festivals teaser tv talk medical drama technology YouTube disaster Schedule sports VICE streaming