Critics Consensus

The Meg Isn't Ridiculous Enough

Plus, Dog Days is a passable rom-com, Slender Man is thin on scares, and BlacKkKlansman, A Prayer Before Dawn, and season 4 of Better Call Saul are all Certified Fresh

by | August 9, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got  Jason Statham versus a giant shark (The Meg, co-starring Li Bingbing), puppy pals versus loneliness in Los Angeles (Dog Days, starring Nina Dobrev and Vanessa Hudgens), some Massachusetts teens versus a spindly menace (Slender Man, starring Joey King and Julia Goldani Telles), and Spike Lee versus The Man (BlacKkKlansman, starring John David Washington and Adam Driver). What are the critics saying?


The Meg (2018) 45%

Giant sharks and Jason Statham can both be pretty darn entertaining up on the big screen. Put ’em both together and you ought to have yourself a rollicking good time, right? We now have what would seem to be the definitive answer with The Meg, and unfortunately, critics say it never really hits that B-movie sweet spot the way you might expect. An adaptation of the 1997 Steve Alten bestseller, it stars Statham as Jonas Taylor, a rescue diver whose previous experience with sharks happens to come in extra handy when he winds up in an underwater research station under attack by a 75-foot Megalodon. It’s the type of preposterous setup begging for ladles full of action thriller cheese, but reviews describe the end results as rarely more than just okay. As a home viewing experience, it isn’t hard to see this attracting a cult following over the years. For the price of a ticket to the theater, however, it sinks.


Dog Days (2018) 60%

If our culture’s ever-expanding collection of internet memes is anything to go by, people love Love Actually almost as much as they love dogs, so why not just go ahead and put them together? Critics say that’s pretty much what director Ken Marino has done with Dog Days, in which an ensemble cast (including Eva Longoria, Nina Dobrev, Adam Pally, and Finn Wolfhard) play Los Angelenos whose intertwining lives and loves are fluffed up by a menagerie of canine companions. As one might expect of a rom-com titled Dog Days and released in the dog days of August, reviews describe a movie made of decidedly undemanding stuff; if you’re expecting much more than an air-conditioned interlude with a handful of heartwarming moments, you may come away disappointed. On the other hand, from its poster on down, one could hardly accuse this movie of pretending to be anything it isn’t — which is to say that if you’re in the market for Dog Days, you know exactly what you’re getting. In the context of the genre, it might be a bit of a mutt, but you’ve probably seen mangier.


Slender Man (2018) 7%

Studio tussles, release delays, pleas for common decency — all manner of obstacles conspired to keep Slender Man from reaching theaters, but his creeping advance cannot be denied. Perhaps the only thing capable of finally thwarting this internet-inspired, true crime-adjacent horror outing is the utter lack of interest it seems to be generating among the critical set: if the number of early reviews are anything to go by, there isn’t much in the way of anticipation for the movie, which attempts to turn a freaky-looking meme into the basis for a chilling tale about teenagers in supernatural peril. If you’re into horror movies, critics say you’ve almost certainly seen worse — but there really isn’t much about any of this that’s honestly scary, or even terribly memorable. Add in the staunch (and understandable) opposition of family members involved in the real-life 2014 assault inspired by the character, and you’re left with a fairly long and compelling list of reasons to beware this Slender Man.


BlacKkKlansman (2018) 95%

Spike Lee has dabbled in a number of genres over the years, but he’s typically best remembered as a filmmaker with a strong social conscience — one that returns to center stage with his new release, this weekend’s BlacKkKlansman. Inspired by the real-life story of Ron Stallworth, an African-American police detective who infiltrated his local Ku Klux Klan in 1979, Lee’s latest joint blends purely entertaining drama and pointed social commentary as only his films can — and critics say it’s one of the writer-director’s best, seething with a potent fury that’s brought powerfully to life by a solid ensemble led by John David Washington as Stallworth and rounded out by Laura Harrier, Adam Driver, and Topher Grace. It may not be the type of thing you’ll want to seek out if you’re in the mood for mindless entertainment, but BlacKkKlansman has a lot to say about America’s past, present, and future, and it proves one of modern cinema’s most singular visionaries hasn’t lost a step.


What’s New on TV

Better Call Saul: Season 4 (2018) 99%

Well-crafted and compelling as ever, Better Call Saul‘s fourth season deftly balances the show it was and the one it will inevitably become.


Insatiable: Season 1 (2018) 12%

Broad stereotypes, clumsy social commentary, and a failed attempt at “wokeness” make Insatiable hard to swallow.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • A Prayer Before Dawn (2018) , starring Joe Cole as a young British boxer trapped in the hell of the Thai prison system, is Certified Fresh at 93%.
  • Madeline's Madeline (2018) , an unusual exploration of a young woman’s theater work intertwined with her relationship with her mother, is at 92%.
  • Skate Kitchen (2018) , in which a teenage girl makes fateful friendships with an all-female skateboarding crew, is at 92%.
  • Euthanizer (Armomurhaaja) (2018) , about the increasingly fraught conflict brewing between a dog euthanizer and the former owner of a pet he refused to put down, is at 92%.
  • BuyBust (2018) , about a special ops mission gone violently awry in Manila, is at 78%.
  • Summer of '84 (2018) , a period horror outing about neighborhood kids tracking a serial killer, is at 67%.
  • The Swan (Svanurinn) (2018) , in which a young Icelandic girl is sent to the country for a summer, is at 67%.
  • Elizabeth Harvest (2018) , a modern retelling of Bluebeard in which a young woman’s marriage may not be quite what it seems, is at 50%.

Tag Cloud

docudrama science fiction vampires singing competition thriller crime thriller Year in Review Mary poppins spy thriller Apple based on movie E3 travel Winners Disney Spike Horror Fantasy Super Bowl TCM Infographic OWN talk show Netflix Photos YouTube Red Chilling Adventures of Sabrina zombies Animation 45 Freeform Schedule CMT BBC America MTV Amazon New York Comic Con SundanceTV TIFF Rocky TV Land robots Fox News Rock Marathons San Diego Comic-Con CNN Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 24 frames Starz golden globes Comics on TV sitcom Countdown Masterpiece crime TNT Writers Guild of America Nat Geo Disney Channel Grammys VICE Cartoon Network Comedy Central transformers IFC dc biography SDCC composers cinemax HBO award winner serial killer festivals DC Universe Quiz technology Pop YouTube Premium binge DC Comics First Look SXSW jamie lee curtis Trophy Talk American Society of Cinematographers President Awards 2015 cats ITV Western Character Guide aliens BBC FX GoT Musicals Music Comic Book Action Shudder cooking Pirates Martial Arts RT History Teen Toys political drama Dark Horse Comics Esquire Summer Certified Fresh PBS WGN APB discovery 20th Century Fox Bravo A&E Country X-Men Emmys supernatural FOX Video Games crossover comiccon The CW TV See It Skip It Adult Swim politics Cosplay boxoffice Musical Lionsgate Premiere Dates MSNBC hist FXX NBC Epix 2018 Sundance Now Britbox zombie Comedy VH1 GIFs Lucasfilm Sneak Peek ESPN Sundance romance spider-man police drama psycho Pixar TCA 2017 Columbia Pictures IFC Films CBS Extras finale Black Mirror E! TCA medical drama 2017 Tumblr war Star Trek El Rey ABC Family period drama USA Calendar Logo Lifetime Showtime Paramount Walt Disney Pictures History Set visit Best and Worst adventure Shondaland TruTV Trivia comic Universal doctor who Valentine's Day Syfy Opinion crime drama TLC 21st Century Fox The Arrangement Thanksgiving Nominations 007 CW Seed Mary Tyler Moore Mindy Kaling anime NYCC Food Network USA Network Warner Bros. GLAAD Creative Arts Emmys Nickelodeon National Geographic Spring TV Box Office Awards Tour TBS ABC facebook Hulu BET Trailer Ovation dramedy Acorn TV Oscars social media Christmas Superheroes Mystery PaleyFest miniseries LGBTQ Superheroe Kids & Family Tomatazos Reality what to watch Rom-Com Sony Pictures Interview harry potter YA Red Carpet Drama Star Wars streaming Polls and Games Reality Competition Fall TV Sci-Fi cops Watching Series Song of Ice and Fire dceu 2019 CBS All Access Ellie Kemper Ghostbusters Marvel ratings green book Holidays unscripted diversity television sports cults DirecTV Election Paramount Network AMC DC streaming service historical drama Mary Poppins Returns justice league blaxploitation Crackle 2016 Biopics mutant Winter TV Podcast