The Knick Season Finale: What Did Critics Think?

by | October 18, 2014 | Comments

Before Friday night’s broadcast of The Knick‘s season finale, Cinemax teased that production of season two will commence in early 2015. Bittersweet news for fans of one of the summer’s best-reviewed new shows. So, yes, there will be more episodes of The Knick, but you’ll have to wait at least eight months for them.

For now, let’s talk about The Knick season one finale: “Crutchfield.” Here’s what the critics had to say. Caution: spoilers ahead.

Fresh
Jennifer Silverman, Rolling Stone: It certainly stays true to what Soderbergh and writers Amiel and Begler have tried to do in this premiere run. That is: create a world of flawed people with f—ed up but noble ideas about scientific technology and man’s place in it, spiced up with the gory minutia of turn-of-the-century medicine just for kicks.

Fresh
Alan Sepinwall, HitFix: Story-wise, this first season had its bumps and sluggish periods, but things rounded into satisfying form by the end, particularly in the ways that different stories intersected… My hope is that the season two storylines will feel more compelling on their own, rather than just being a Soderbergh delivery system. But if that’s all the show ever turns out to be, I’m okay with that, too.

Rotten

Keith Uhlich, New York Magazine/Vulture: Consider that the emotional high point of “Crutchfield” comes early when Cornelia Robertson — having paid for a dead-of-night procedure to terminate her and Dr. Algernon Edwards’s unborn child — stumbles into Tom Cleary and Sister Harriet’s underground abortion operation… Nothing else in “Crutchfield” quite lives up to this scene.

Fresh
Mike Hale, New York Times: As always, there were some impressively cinematic moments. The best was one of the episode’s least important scenes, Everett’s assault on Algernon. It was a single 80-second shot… Virtuosic and completely unobtrusive.

Fresh
Matt Fowler, IGN.com: The Knick‘s season finale, which held actual serious consequences for just about every character on the show, was a beautifully unnerving ride. No happy endings here.

Fresh
Emily Nussbaum, The New Yorker: I fell in love with the season’s final shot.

Fresh
Kevin Yeoman, Screen Rant: The finale is the kind of episode a loosely plotted series like this almost needs to have. Instead of searching for an end point on which to conclude the season, writers Jack Amiel and Michael Begler deserve credit for forcing the characters to take the next misery-filled steps of their stories, before calling it a day (or a season).

Rotten
Steve MacFarlane, Slant Magazine: Right up to the finish line, Soderbergh fudges the show’s tone to the point of emotional misdirection, with “Crutchfield” signing off on a note that’s both grimly hilarious and which sucks most of the pathos out of Thackery’s downfall.)

Fresh
Chris E. Hayner, Zap2It.com: The season one finale of The Knick tied things up nicely, while leaving room to explore in Season two. The biggest moment came when Thackery agreed to check into rehab to get control of his cocaine problem. Of course, in this era that sort of thing is treated with heroin care of the Bayer aspirin company. So that’ll be fun.

Fresh
Robert Ham, Paste Magazine: This season finale follows the template of most any other show: pile on the drama and leave plenty of loose ends dangling to have viewers slavering for the second season to start. And, by golly, do Soderbergh, Amiel, and Begler have me hoping they can get to filming the next batch of episodes quick-like. Still, I can’t deny that this last installment of Season One started to feel like much too much.

Fresh
Brandon Nowalk, AV Club:
Even before this final act “Crutchfield” was the most exquisite episode of The Knick, but after it, “Crutchfield” is evangelism material. Every new shot is diamond.

Fresh
Ben Travers, IndieWire: No one will be waiting with bated breath to find out how Thackery recovers from his drug addiction or if Edwards sustained any permanent damage from that brutal fistfight. We will, though, eagerly wait to see what Soderbergh has in his never-ending bag of camera tricks.

What did YOU think about The Knick season finale. Sound off in the comments section below.

Season one of The Knick is Certified Fresh. Read reviews here.

 

  • Bart Beasly

    What a great TV show!

Tag Cloud

2015 21st Century Fox ABC Family Trophy Talk MCU Country Sundance Now adventure Schedule Rocky GIFs festivals Bravo Photos Chernobyl Reality Holidays theme song Stephen King Mudbound space sequel Pet Sematary true crime New York Comic Con CBS police drama Certified Fresh Star Wars Premiere Dates Syfy APB Reality Competition A&E PBS FX 20th Century Fox BBC DC Comics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Election Comedy Lionsgate Emmys sitcom President Netflix social media what to watch Trailer LGBTQ The Arrangement Animation toy story Musical unscripted NYCC RT History docudrama Elton John Year in Review Tarantino Ovation Sneak Peek based on movie Hulu Mary poppins Grammys AMC politics VH1 Epix Drama American Society of Cinematographers Film Festival Black Mirror Ghostbusters 24 frames Lucasfilm Winners IFC psycho dc Watching Series Mary Poppins Returns TBS DGA vampires Winter TV historical drama Heroines BET golden globes Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Interview Women's History Month DC streaming service discovery PaleyFest Acorn TV YouTube Premium Tomatazos Biopics TLC Trivia Box Office Fox News Writers Guild of America period drama 2016 Captain marvel Infographic political drama Toys Spike facebook cults Warner Bros. WGN Superheroes Super Bowl Creative Arts Emmys aliens anime Summer Masterpiece HBO Columbia Pictures Comic Book Nat Geo teaser San Diego Comic-Con Ellie Kemper Valentine's Day mutant The Witch 45 TNT FOX Rock travel VICE Marvel 007 CW Seed FXX comiccon Fall TV Freeform Countdown award winner Video Games Pride Month thriller LGBT TIFF adaptation medical drama spinoff Quiz zero dark thirty game show dragons 2018 Rocketman richard e. Grant zombie Christmas Pixar serial killer El Rey Amazon Prime Sci-Fi sports Spring TV ITV Brie Larson Best and Worst hist Vudu Podcast Red Carpet dceu Logo jamie lee curtis USA casting Pirates Disney GoT Oscars Kids & Family IFC Films doctor who CBS All Access crossover television Western green book mockumentary TruTV blaxploitation Character Guide crime drama SDCC SundanceTV strong female leads Fantasy cooking composers Set visit Nominations miniseries Comedy Central elevated horror Star Trek Amazon dramedy USA Network Cartoon Network TCM The CW Mystery Music Crackle TCA 2017 Esquire finale Extras Teen 2019 Martial Arts ratings diversity Song of Ice and Fire Sundance See It Skip It Adult Swim MSNBC Paramount Network Showtime SXSW Musicals disaster Polls and Games psychological thriller nature Universal NBC robots Mary Tyler Moore animated spy thriller E3 Thanksgiving Sony Pictures E! cats BBC America Awards streaming ABC Opinion war YouTube Red boxoffice Shudder Action 2017 Britbox Comics on TV OWN CMT Paramount spider-man Rom-Com talk show Tumblr cinemax Nickelodeon RT21 crime natural history anthology transformers supernatural romance X-Men Anna Paquin comic Disney Channel Apple Calendar justice league Food Network zombies Cosplay YA Horror crime thriller DC Universe Cannes GLAAD MTV Spectrum Originals TCA Walt Disney Pictures Lifetime Marathons National Geographic singing competition technology History biography TV Pop First Look TV Land Emmy Nominations Awards Tour ESPN CNN cops science fiction DirecTV Starz binge witnail Mindy Kaling harry potter Dark Horse Comics Superheroe Shondaland