News

The Higher the Body Count, The Worse the Horror Movie

A deep data dive shows that the more the bodies pile up, the further the Tomatometer drops for movies in horror franchises.

by | October 22, 2018 | Comments

Michael Myers earned big numbers at the box office last weekend, crushing the franchise’s previous opening-weekend record with a $77.5 million take. Keen observers, though, noted that the box office total wasn’t the only big number that David Gordon Green’s new movie was racking up. In 2018’s Halloween, Myers more than doubles the body count he accumulated in John Carpenter’s 1978 original film. We won’t spoil anything by saying how many people die at Myers’ hands, or who they are, but just know this: the blood bath he leaves behind makes the events of late-’70s Haddonfield seem quaint by comparison.

It’s an age-old sequel trend: bigger, harder, bloodier. But does it always work? The higher body count in the latest Halloween left us wondering: Does the number of kills in a horror movie affect that horror movie’s Tomatometer score, and its box office results? With the new Halloween, the answer seems to be: No. But is Green’s movie the rule – or the exception to it?

Halloween

(Photo by Ryan Green/© Universal)

To find out, we gathered a data set of 188 horror movies that are part of a horror franchise (“franchises” had to have at least two theatrical wide releases). We then counted the deaths caused by the central antagonist or protagonist in each film. We didn’t count accidental deaths, or deaths caused by animals or other non-antagonists, and we didn’t count the killer’s own death; we focused solely on kills caused by central villains like Hannibal Lecter, Freddy Krueger, Norman Bates, Jason Voorhees, and, in the case of Final Destination, Death itself.

What did we find? Horror movies featuring between 0 and 5 kills have a much higher Tomatometer rating – an almost-Fresh 56.7% – than their more kill-heavy counterparts. The same movies made more money at the box office, with an average inflated domestic total of $115 million. The worst-performing movies, both on the Tomatometer and at the box office, were those that featured more than 10 deaths. Halloween 2018 is one exception.

We also discovered that Randy Meeks was mostly right when he said, in Scream 2, that “sequels suck!”. (Ironically, that movie has a higher Tomatometer score than the original Scream). Why? The majority of the high-scoring, low-killing movies were first and second franchise installments, which, according to our data, have higher Tomatometer scores and domestic box office averages than later franchise installments. Take a look at how the Tomatometer and box office numbers fall off with each horror franchise installment.

First film in franchise:  $145 million average box office |
67% Tomatometer average
Second: $70 million | 42% Tomatometer average
Third: $68 million | 39% Tomatometer average
Fourth: $67 million | 40% Tomatometer average
Fifth: $49 million | 32% Tomatometer average
Sixth–tenth: $45 million | 27.625% Tomatometer average
Remakes (and their sequels/prequels): $52 million |
37% Tomatometer average

Now, let’s dig deeper.



Horror Movies with 11–Plus Kills

Tomatometer Average: 38.1%
Inflated Domestic Box Office Average: $56,941,241
Number of Movies: 65
Movies include: CarrieAliensArmy of Darkness (see full set)

We can’t pinpoint exactly why kill-heavy horror films make less money and have lower Tomatometer scores than their less violent peers. But, when looking through the 65 movies in this category, one clear trend emerges: 86% of them (some 56 titles) are sequels or remakes, which are traditionally prone to higher body counts, and poorer critical reception. It might explain why 78% of the movies in this group (51 titles) are Rotten, and only seven crossed the $100 million milestone domestically, adjusted for inflation (Carrie, Aliens, Friday the 13th, Friday the 13th Part III, Alien 3, Freddy vs. Jason, AVP, Prometheus).

These Rotten statistics make us appreciate the few kill-heavy originals that managed to earn Fresh status on the Tomatometer: Carrie, Piranha, An American Werewolf in London, and Sinister, and sequels/remakes such as Army of Darkness, Piranha 3-D, Final Destination 5, Dawn of the Dead, Prometheus, Aliens, Alien: Covenant, Land of the Dead, and …28 Weeks Later. While less death generally leads to Fresher results, there are some beautifully bloody exceptions to the rule.



Horror Movies with 6–10 Kills

Tomatometer Average: 41.7%
Inflated Domestic Box Office Average: $78,796,453
Number of Movies: 50
Movies include: Black ChristmasScream 2Predator (see full set)

The 41.7% Tomatometer average for movies in this group is a slight improvement from the previous category, with Fright Night, Scream 2, Black Christmas, A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors, and Day of the Dead giving the category a Tomatometer boost. The percentage of Rotten films decreased from 80% for the previous group to 74% for the movies in this set, which features 37 Rotten titles.

Fifteen of the movies in this category cleared the $100 million milestone, with Friday the 13th, Alien, Predator, Anaconda, Jaws 2, Scream 2, Saw 2, and The Omen II bringing in lots of money. Why do the films in this category have a higher domestic box office than the 11-plus category? It helps that 54% of the movies are first or second installments, which, according to our data set, typically make more money than other franchise entries.



Horror Movies With 0–5 Kills

Tomatometer Average: 56.7%
Inflated Domestic Box Office Average: $115,418,833
Number of Movies: 73
Movies include: PsychoThe OmenThe Conjuring (see full set)

With a killer’s row of classics like The Exorcist, The Evil Dead, Jaws, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Fright Night, Poltergeist, Night of the Living Dead, The Blair Witch Project, The Conjuring, Halloween, A Nightmare on Elm Street, and Psycho, it’s unsurprising that this group has the highest Tomatometer average, as well as the highest inflated domestic box office average. The aforementioned franchise-starting originals have an average Tomatometer score of 91.75%. There are a total of 36 Fresh films in the group, with 25 of those Fresh titles being first installments.

So why is the overall score for this group just shy of Freshness? Blame the sequels that managed to eke their way into the set. Classics like Jaws did their best to buoy the averages, but its sequels, like Jaws 3D and Jaws: The Revenge (which we love), did their best to sink the ship. It’s not just sequels that hurt the overall averages, though: Five originals – Ouija, I Know What You Did Last Summer, Saw, The Strangers, and Prom Night – failed to achieve a Fresh Tomatometer score despite their low kill counts. It’s worth noting that all are audience faves.


Halloween is in theaters everywhere.


Full Data Sets

Horror movies featuring 11-plus kills

Carrie (1976), Piranha (1978), My Bloody Valentine (1981), The Omen III: The Final Conflict (1981), An American Werewolf in London (1981) Friday the 13th: Part III (1982), Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter (1984), Aliens (1986), Friday the 13th: Jason Lives (1986), Friday the 13th: The New Blood (1988), Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988), Hellraiser 2 (1988), Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan (1989), Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989), Predator 2 (1990), Alien 3 (1992), Hellraiser III, Hell on Earth (1992), Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday (1993), Army of Darkness (1993), Halloween – The Curse of Michael Myers (1995), Alien: Resurrection (1997), An American Werewolf in Paris (1997), Bride of Chucky (1998), Species 2 (1998), I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (1998), Carrie 2 (1999), Final Destination (2000), Jason X (2002), Halloween: Resurrection (2002), Freddy vs. Jason (2003), Final Destination 2 (2003), AVP – Alien Vs. Predator (2004), Seed of Chucky (2004), Exorcist: The Beginning (2004), Dawn of the Dead (2004), Land of the Dead (2005), Black Christmas (2006), Final Destination 3 (2006), The Grudge 2 (2006), 28 Weeks Later (2007), Alien Vs. Predator: Requiem (2007), Halloween (2007), Prom Night (2008), The Collector (2009), Friday the 13th (2009), The Final Destination (2009), Halloween 2 (2009), My Blood Valentine 3D (2009), Saw VI (2009), Piranha 3D (2010), Saw 3D (2010), Final Destination 5 (2011), Scream 4 (2011), The Thing (2011), Prometheus (2012), The Collection (2012), Sinister (2012), Carrie (2013), The Purge (2013), The Purge: Anarchy (2014), Sinister 2 (2015), The Purge: Election Year (2016), Alien: Covenant (2017), Rings (2017), Jigsaw (2017)


Horror movies featuring 6–10 kills

Black Christmas (1974),  Jaws 2 (1978), The Omen II (1978), Alien (1979), The Amityville Horror (1979), Friday the 13th (1980), Friday the 13th: Part Two (1980), Halloween 2 (1981), Halloween III – Season of the Witch (1982) Amityville 2: The Possession (1982), Amityville 3-D (1983), A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy’s Revenge (1985), Day of the Dead (1985), Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors (1987), Hello Mary Lou: Prom Night 2 (1987), Predator (1987), A Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master (1988), Child’s Play 2 (1990), The Exorcist III (1990), Child’s Play 3 (1991), Candyman: Farewell to the Flesh (1994), Species (1995), Hellraiser – Bloodline (1996), Anaconda (1997), Scream 2 (1997), Halloween H20: 20 Years Later (1998), Book of Shadows – Blair Witch 2 (2000), Scream 3 (2000), Jeepers Creepers (2001), Jeepers Creepers 2 (2003), The Amityville Horror (2004), Anacondas: The Hunt for the Blood Orchid (2004), The Grudge (2004), Saw 2 (2005), The Hills Have Eyes (2006), The Omen (2006), Saw 3 (2006), The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning (2006), Hannibal Rising (2007), The Hills Have Eyes 2 (2007), Hostel 2 (2007), Saw 4 (2007), Saw 5 (2008), Predators (2010), Fright Night (2011), The Thing (1982), The Woman in Black (2012), Evil Dead (2013), Paranormal Activity: The Marked Ones (2014), Unfriended (2015)


Horror movies featuring 0–5 kills 

Psycho (1960), Night of the Living Dead (1968), The Exorcist (1973), The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974), Jaws (1975), The Omen (1976), Exorcist II: The Heretic (1977), The Hills Have Eyes (1977), Halloween (1978), Dawn of the Dead (1979), Prom Night (1980), The Evil Dead (1981), Poltergeist (1982), Jaws 3D (1983), Psycho II (1983), Gremlins (1984), Nightmare on Elm Street (1984), Friday the 13th, Part V: A New Beginning (1985), Fright Night (1985), Poltergeist (1985), Manhunter (1986), Poltergeist II (1986), The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 (1986), Psycho III (1986), Evil Dead 2 (1987), Hellraiser (1987), Jaws: The Revenge (1987), Child’s Play (1988), Poltergeist III (1988), Fright Night 2 (1989), A Nightmare on Elm Street 5: The Dream Child (1989), Gremlins 2 (1990), Night of the Living Dead (1990), Leatherface: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre III (1990), The Silence of the Lambs (1991), Freddy’s Dead: The Final Nightmare (1991), Candyman (1992),  Wes Craven’s New Nightmare (1994), Scream (1996), I know What You Did Last Summer (1997), Psycho (1998), The Blair Witch Project (1999), Hannibal (2001), Red Dragon (2002), The Ring (2002), 28 Days Later (2003), The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003), Saw (2004), The Ring 2 (2005), Hostel (2006), The Strangers (2008), Paranormal Activity (2009), A Nightmare on Elm Street (2010), Paranormal Activity 2 (2010), Insidious (2011), Paranormal Activity 3 (2011), Paranormal Activity 4 (2012), The Conjuring (2013), Insidious: Chapter 2 (2013), Texas Chainsaw 3D (2013), Annabelle (2014), Ouija (2014), Insidious: Chapter 3 (2015), Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension (2015), The Woman in Black: The Angel of Death (2015), The Blair Witch (2016), The Conjuring 2 (2016), Ouija 2 (2016), Annabelle: Creation (2017), Insidious: The Last Key (2018), The Strangers: Prey at Night (2018)

Tag Cloud

First Look GLAAD biography movie book Watching Series name the review cancelled Stephen King PaleyFest Starz Country AMC films TIFF breaking bad FX south america Britbox Walt Disney Pictures The Witch scorecard blockbuster TruTV romance Box Office Freeform universal monsters dark discovery APB kids Fall TV Drama worst movies Pop Peacock Funimation comedies TCA Winter 2020 Epix Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Emmys Netflix History halloween tv docudrama Musicals diversity TV Land MSNBC comic VH1 revenge MCU Writers Guild of America medical drama Winners Character Guide cats dc Winter TV Sundance ratings DC Comics dramedy elevated horror talk show dogs Hear Us Out Disney+ Disney Plus Spring TV unscripted remakes E3 spain franchise Interview 71st Emmy Awards deadpool Action Pride Month Tubi casting Syfy DirecTV japanese SDCC Travel Channel Fantasy Women's History Month sag awards HBO Max Biopics E! Rom-Com comiccon canceled politics ABC Family comic books Brie Larson Anna Paquin doctor who Mary poppins foreign Thanksgiving worst witnail OWN werewolf Set visit mission: impossible Awards Tour facebook Teen Music cartoon TCM Television Academy BET Awards mockumentary 2015 Logo TNT vampires The Arrangement YA canceled TV shows Endgame RT History animated Tomatazos australia Photos Musical batman Turner concert 2016 based on movie Classic Film Tarantino die hard jamie lee curtis GoT fast and furious Paramount supernatural venice Spectrum Originals serial killer Chernobyl rotten movies we love zero dark thirty Marvel Television anthology tv talk cooking Sundance TV IFC twilight Calendar Crunchyroll Amazon Prime strong female leads james bond cinemax Disney Plus Awards YouTube Red BBC America BBC One Sundance Now PBS 007 DC streaming service boxoffice teaser Sony Pictures Academy Awards richard e. Grant aliens nature Pirates 45 FX on Hulu ID reboot sequel free movies Year in Review Lifetime Christmas movies CBS The Walking Dead Pet Sematary The Academy Star Wars obituary NYCC Rocketman binge Holiday Disney streaming service cars CBS All Access DGA Quiz thriller Lionsgate Universal Creative Arts Emmys nbcuniversal scary movies cancelled TV series rotten Hulu quibi award winner New York Comic Con television anime sports Pop TV dceu Oscars Paramount Network spider-man Trailer Toys Arrowverse Mudbound crossover Sneak Peek TCA 2017 Vudu National Geographic french Fox Searchlight Holidays 99% TCA Awards VOD Television Critics Association festival movies documentaries stoner dragons TV TCA emmy awards adventure festivals Summer Extras Shondaland The CW space harry potter stop motion Food Network comics what to watch Lucasfilm Cannes child's play Hallmark Christmas movies Binge Guide BBC psycho singing competition Emmy Nominations FXX Captain marvel Superheroe screen actors guild ESPN rt archives IFC Films Heroines Cosplay cults cops halloween A&E Black History Month Ghostbusters hollywood series science fiction A24 Avengers 72 Emmy Awards Polls and Games Western LGBTQ composers 2020 Opinion documentary critics indiana jones Video Games Infographic transformers renewed TV shows Christmas versus game of thrones Martial Arts Song of Ice and Fire game show Amazon Sci-Fi crime drama Shudder natural history Election archives SundanceTV spanish TLC 2018 Elton John First Reviews Comedy hist ITV news Bravo Crackle best Film TV renewals HBO Go zombie Warner Bros. Acorn TV SXSW Ovation Premiere Dates Mystery Certified Fresh Turner Classic Movies Trivia Best and Worst Dark Horse Comics theme song American Society of Cinematographers Schedule criterion technology President 20th Century Fox Disney Channel Netflix Christmas movies Tumblr Marathons Hallmark Grammys golden globes Apple period drama Baby Yoda a nightmare on elm street screenings Reality Kids & Family children's TV finale cancelled TV shows Trophy Talk BET toy story LGBT Amazon Prime Video Reality Competition Esquire Showtime video Family sequels spanish language YouTube X-Men romantic comedy Superheroes travel ghosts 4/20 Nickelodeon Comedy Central hispanic crime thriller GIFs CNN El Rey 2019 WarnerMedia spy thriller political drama Ellie Kemper adaptation indie joker parents NBC Super Bowl Pixar Comics on TV laika Lifetime Amazon Studios USA Network TBS independent directors Nominations OneApp 21st Century Fox YouTube Premium HBO Film Festival all-time 24 frames Mary Tyler Moore satire Alien USA psychological thriller CW Seed Star Trek video on demand stand-up comedy Nat Geo justice league classics VICE reviews chucky miniseries cancelled television disaster PlayStation CMT 2017 Valentine's Day ABC spinoff Podcast Cartoon Network italian toronto slashers Comic Book football Mindy Kaling MTV Animation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt christmas movies Disney fresh Masterpiece historical drama police drama WGN crime San Diego Comic-Con mutant Adult Swim Discovery Channel Red Carpet social media latino Fox News true crime DC Universe The Purge Marvel Studios sitcom RT21 green book Rocky Spike Columbia Pictures Apple TV+ streaming boxing FOX Black Mirror Horror black Countdown nfl BAFTA zombies Apple TV Plus superhero Marvel asian-american robots See It Skip It Rock war Mary Poppins Returns blaxploitation