SUNDANCE: Capsule Reviews of "Sunshine," "Science," "Proposition," And More

by | February 3, 2006 | Comments

Here are capsule reviews of some of the films we screened at the 2006 Sundance Film Festival.

"Thank You for Smoking" is a comedy for our troubled, intensely partisan times – a film about the ways in which framing an issue becomes more important than solving a problem. Nick Naylor (Aaron Eckhart) is the type of smarmy guy you want to punch – if only he weren’t so smarmily likeable. As a tobacco lobbyist, Naylor knows he’s in the wrong, but he’s just so good at spin — and hey, everyone’s got a mortgage to pay. And is William H. Macy‘s liberal senator — who berates an aide for not getting a more pitiable cancer patient on a talk show to square off against the lobbyist — really any better? "Thank You for Smoking" merrily skews the left and the right, making the point that sometimes solutions are less important to politicians than looking good.

Part gritty Western, part Jodorowsky-esque mystic journey, and part Cain and Abel parable, "The Proposition" is a terrific movie, a film loaded with blood, tears, and profound moral ambiguity. A Western tableau has rarely been as dirty as "The Proposition"’s 1880s Australian Outback; even in the relative affluence of the police captain and his wife’s home, there are flies everywhere. Guy Pearce stars as a criminal who’s been set free; the catch is that he must bring his (even more ruthless) brother to justice, or his (sweeter) younger brother will be hanged. But no plot description could do justice to the mood and feel of this film, one of the wildest and bloodiest odysseys in recent cinema.

Let’s get one thing out of the way right now: "Art School Confidential" is not as good as Terry Zwigoff and Daniel Clowes‘ previous collaboration, "Ghost World," nor does it reach the dizzying heights of Zwigoff’s two documentaries about artists, "Louie Bluie" and "Crumb." Still, the film has its share of pleasures, particularly as a wry satire of how arbitrarily the art world selects its favorites for reasons that can have little to do with the art itself. Unlike "Ghost World"’s unsure heroines, whose aimlessness and cynicism go hand in hand with a search for their inner values, "Art School"’s insecure protagonist (Max Minghella) has ambition to burn, and descends into an amorality that pays dividends the lower he goes.

The reason urban legends hold such morbid fascination is that they’re largely in the mind; it’s the telling that makes them amusing. The main problem with "The Darwin Awards" (based upon the website that cites the stupidest deaths, thus maintaining a stronger evolutionary gene pool) is that the visual reputation of gruesome death makes this black comedy a bit hard to stomach. The filmmakers understand this on some level, as their protagonist Michael Burrows (Joseph Fiennes) plays a cop turned insurance claims investigator who faints at the sight of blood. But a subplot about a film student following Burrows around doesn’t work, and Burrows’ risk aversion comes across not as quirky but as labored slapstick.

The hottest film at Sundance, "Little Miss Sunshine," is barely a comedy for its first half, focusing more on the sad (but darkly amusing) quirks of an extremely dysfunctional family. But the film builds to a stunningly funny climax, one that is a moment of familial growth without an ounce of schmaltz. "Little Miss Sunshine" features deft performances from an ensemble cast that includes Greg Kinnear, Steve Carell, Alan Arkin, and Toni Collette; each cast member pulls off the neat trick of exuding familial concern and contempt for others with aplomb.

Michel Gondry‘s rep is largely due to his phantasmagoric visuals, but one would be hard pressed to find a more hopeless romantic at work in contemporary cinema. Like "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind," his latest, "The Science of Sleep," navigates the divide between the real world and dream states. Gael Garcia Bernal and Charlotte Gainsbourg play neighbors who share whimsy, insecurity, and potentially love; the result is a film that is equally fanciful and haunting.

Check out Sundance features by Rotten Tomatoes:
Sundance Full Coverage
Sundance Blog
Sundance Discussion

Tag Cloud

Chernobyl Western 20th Century Fox golden globes game of thrones Adult Swim Sundance medical drama children's TV miniseries Acorn TV supernatural Comics on TV Thanksgiving latino Tomatazos teaser Netflix war Disney streaming service Syfy Star Trek Mystery Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt biography festivals sequel New York Comic Con WarnerMedia stand-up comedy CNN crossover Trailer adventure spain cats toy story sitcom Super Bowl FXX Grammys Mary Poppins Returns Disney Channel See It Skip It Star Wars ghosts TV Land Action casting RT History HBO 2016 composers cops The Witch FOX Family YouTube Red Marathons Vudu quibi south america Binge Guide Marvel SundanceTV Box Office elevated horror DirecTV Lifetime Winners jamie lee curtis Elton John Cartoon Network revenge Comedy finale Spike Amazon Prime Video Valentine's Day Walt Disney Pictures Trivia Spring TV Dark Horse Comics First Reviews book Ovation ITV YA social media richard e. Grant TCA 2017 Tumblr award winner aliens video Film Festival Emmys History 2019 El Rey Opinion Superheroes Character Guide Infographic Esquire Freeform Women's History Month Drama thriller NBC Extras Black Mirror Captain marvel First Look VICE Creative Arts Emmys BBC America spinoff GLAAD foreign based on movie Quiz BBC unscripted Paramount Pride Month Warner Bros. YouTube Premium Calendar witnail Fall TV The CW SDCC psycho CW Seed facebook LGBTQ ratings doctor who Nominations Teen Nickelodeon science fiction streaming MSNBC television VH1 Election AMC TV Rocky diversity Biopics Paramount Network FX crime drama WGN USA Network Interview nature Starz 71st Emmy Awards TCM Amazon Trophy Talk hispanic National Geographic dragons Superheroe political drama crime thriller Pixar Toys Masterpiece zombies binge justice league Schedule IFC dceu 24 frames DC streaming service Emmy Nominations theme song dramedy Lucasfilm GIFs natural history mockumentary PBS E! Certified Fresh Film Brie Larson Animation Cannes Sundance Now strong female leads RT21 technology Nat Geo comic Horror CBS Pop 2017 SXSW Kids & Family Oscars kids MCU singing competition spy thriller cars NYCC Food Network spanish language tv talk Fox News animated green book comiccon E3 Song of Ice and Fire LGBT San Diego Comic-Con Comedy Central 2018 psychological thriller Mary poppins Fantasy mutant The Arrangement true crime Columbia Pictures adaptation DC Comics Disney Premiere Dates Mindy Kaling period drama TNT game show Bravo Music robots Watching Series Tarantino 45 historical drama Rock talk show Pet Sematary Comic Book TIFF X-Men DC Universe IFC Films ABC Family Photos Christmas Mary Tyler Moore Ghostbusters Awards police drama 21st Century Fox TBS Epix crime cinemax zombie BET Britbox disaster what to watch Polls and Games USA docudrama Countdown Stephen King Winter TV Mudbound Reality Competition American Society of Cinematographers Logo Pirates Apple TCA Crackle Martial Arts Best and Worst romance OWN Set visit space Red Carpet Ellie Kemper Sci-Fi GoT Showtime dc politics Holidays Shondaland vampires HBO Max Writers Guild of America TruTV Television Academy CMT Reality Video Games Country blaxploitation discovery travel DGA MTV 007 PaleyFest cults cooking APB Rom-Com movies Sony Pictures Lionsgate Rocketman Peacock series Anna Paquin ESPN ABC boxoffice hist President Amazon Prime A&E Musical Summer anthology Cosplay Spectrum Originals Podcast Shudder Arrowverse harry potter Universal 2015 sports anime spider-man transformers Musicals Sneak Peek serial killer zero dark thirty Year in Review Heroines Hulu Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Awards Tour TLC CBS All Access