Critics Consensus

Solo Is the Lowest Rated Live-Action Star Wars Movie Since the Prequels

But it's still fast-paced and fun. Plus, season 5 of Arrested Development returns to form and Amazon's Picnic at Hanging Rock is a decent retelling of a classic mystery.

by | May 24, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have the origin story of the galaxy’s most charming smuggler (Solo: A Star Wars Story, starring Alden Ehrenreich and Emilia Clarke). What are the critics saying?

Solo: A Star Wars Story (2018) 70%

Long before our current reboot-happy era of franchise-driven do-overs, Hollywood made a habit of recasting well-known roles. Love any popular character long enough, and the movie industry will eventually serve them up to you again with a different face — just ask any James Bond, Doctor Who, Superman, or Batman fan. Going the recast route is always a gamble, but some characters are far more inextricably intertwined with their actors than others, and after one person has played a part for a few decades, it can be awfully tough to imagine someone else taking over. Take Han Solo, for instance: the quick-shooting, quip-dispensing Corellian has been a popular fixture of the Star Wars franchise since its 1977 arrival, and every time we’ve seen him on the big screen, he’s been played by Harrison Ford. Until now, that is: when Lucasfilm decided to depict Han’s early years in a standalone anthology installment, the 75-year-old Ford was obviously not an option, so they handed the role to Alden Ehrenreich.

It was just the first in a series of risky moves surrounding the project, which got through a substantial chunk of its production with original directors Phil Lord and Christopher Miller before the duo were surprisingly fired and replaced with Oscar winner (and longtime friend of Lucasfilm) Ron Howard. As time wore on, the odds that this movie stood any prayer of making a positive impact with critics — let alone one of the most passionate fanbases in film — seemed to go from “long” to “infinitesimal.” But as those fans are aware, Han himself wasn’t much for putting stock in the odds, which makes it somewhat fitting that Solo: A Star Wars Story has earned itself some fairly respectable reviews.

In the context of the Star Wars franchise, Solo can’t help but look like an underachiever, but given that we’re talking about a series that contains some of the most widely seen and best-loved movies of the last few decades, that’s no surprise. In fact, critics say this Star Wars Story contains fairly few surprises — but rather than pulling back the curtain on a bunch of hotly anticipated mysteries from Solo’s early years, it serves up a solidly entertaining space adventure sprinkled with a few bits of fan service for the faithful and enlivened by a well-chosen supporting cast (particularly Donald Glover as everyone’s favorite pansexual schemer, Lando Calrissian). It probably isn’t destined to be mentioned in the same breath as Empire Strikes Back, but on the whole, Solo looks like a decent first outing for this scruffy-looking nerf herder — and given the way studios operate these days, don’t be surprised if it ends up spawning a sequel or two of its own.

What’s New on TV

Arrested Development: Season 5 (2018) 55%

Arrested Development finds itself back in familiar form, recapturing much of the cast’s chemistry and comedic brilliance — though it still doesn’t quite live up to its own past.

Picnic at Hanging Rock: Miniseries (2018) 80%

Natalie Dormer charms in Picnic at Hanging Rock, a stylish retelling of an Australian classic — though convoluted sub-plots at times distract from its otherwise tantalizing delights.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

Year in Review DC streaming service NYCC natural history miniseries Paramount Network RT21 Rocky The Witch dceu San Diego Comic-Con Kids & Family blaxploitation Apple ITV witnail Comedy Biopics TruTV 2018 Cartoon Network Warner Bros. NBC Spike Red Carpet TNT X-Men 24 frames American Society of Cinematographers Logo Countdown teaser vampires Rom-Com Trophy Talk politics BET dc LGBTQ romance E3 Sundance Now Nickelodeon Rocketman Sony Pictures Oscars Interview supernatural TCA 2017 anime Epix Christmas MTV Music Disney robots sitcom 45 space Quiz Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt award winner jamie lee curtis casting Photos ABC Family Tarantino mockumentary Tumblr TBS 2015 binge Creative Arts Emmys YouTube Red period drama E! Awards travel Song of Ice and Fire dramedy Lucasfilm spider-man YA Pixar 20th Century Fox social media Universal Starz Trailer 007 Women's History Month Mindy Kaling Premiere Dates The Arrangement zero dark thirty ABC Calendar GoT GIFs elevated horror historical drama Musicals streaming Horror Marvel Comedy Central toy story crime thriller Food Network MSNBC golden globes Esquire Showtime Dark Horse Comics CBS cinemax Syfy Reality Competition 2017 Acorn TV adventure green book Holidays Comics on TV Country Cosplay Freeform Elton John theme song transformers VH1 Pet Sematary hist ratings cults Spring TV History Martial Arts crime Valentine's Day police drama Anna Paquin 2019 Chernobyl Winter TV Action AMC war based on movie psycho Marathons talk show Mary Poppins Returns FX Mystery Super Bowl thriller Election 21st Century Fox Pirates cats SundanceTV Lifetime Winners nature Paramount Superheroes Britbox CMT serial killer Box Office Crackle SXSW Sci-Fi sequel Columbia Pictures sports VICE strong female leads comic Bravo Western zombies FOX Trivia Ellie Kemper Animation Opinion OWN science fiction PaleyFest National Geographic Cannes discovery Nominations The CW Set visit Hulu Musical Fantasy Video Games Certified Fresh dragons finale anthology Thanksgiving Reality Summer A&E TV Sundance TV Land justice league Adult Swim spinoff BBC Awards Tour IFC Films Black Mirror Amazon Schedule Netflix diversity Rock Mary poppins Tomatazos composers Emmys spy thriller what to watch Pop Drama YouTube Premium DC Universe Writers Guild of America GLAAD DGA true crime Shudder crossover Vudu Mary Tyler Moore TLC Watching Series ESPN medical drama Star Trek El Rey Grammys President Pride Month Teen cops adaptation Amazon Prime technology FXX HBO aliens facebook Brie Larson USA Star Wars Toys Comic Book Lionsgate APB harry potter game show First Look See It Skip It Podcast USA Network cooking Ghostbusters TIFF Spectrum Originals BBC America New York Comic Con MCU DirecTV Heroines TCA unscripted Extras Mudbound CBS All Access festivals DC Comics Fox News RT History Nat Geo 2016 Polls and Games WGN Disney Channel comiccon TCM Emmy Nominations crime drama Fall TV Superheroe singing competition disaster docudrama biography Shondaland Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sneak Peek Best and Worst LGBT Ovation Masterpiece richard e. Grant CW Seed mutant IFC animated psychological thriller boxoffice Film Festival SDCC television Stephen King political drama Character Guide CNN PBS Infographic Walt Disney Pictures Captain marvel zombie doctor who