Robert De Niro vs. Al Pacino: Who Wins Our Epic Actor Battle?

We're crunching the numbers to see which actor-gangster is the bestfella.

by | November 27, 2019 | Comments

Robert De Niro reunites with Al Pacino this month in Martin Scorsese’s The Irishman, the epic and Certified Fresh new Netflix gangster flick. The two actors – who last shared the screen in Michael Mann’s Heat – have been getting plenty of Oscar buzz for the movie in which Pacino plays infamous Teamster leader Jimmy Hoffa and De Niro plays his right-hand man, Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran. If either wins big this awards season, they will be adding to an already heaving trophy shelf. But who between Pacino and De Niro is the ultimate king of the big screen? We’re looking to settle that question by looking at their Tomatometer scores, box office performance, iconic roles, and one wild card category. Did we get it right? Let us know in the comments. (Yes, we’re talking to you.)

The Irishman is currently available on Netflix. 


The Irishman (2019)

Adjusted Score: 124315%
Critics Consensus: An epic gangster drama that earns its extended runtime, The Irishman finds Martin Scorsese revisiting familiar themes to poignant, funny, and profound effect.
Synopsis: In the 1950s, truck driver Frank Sheeran gets involved with Russell Bufalino and his Pennsylvania crime family. As Sheeran climbs... [More]
Directed By: Martin Scorsese

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Black History Month twilight miniseries WarnerMedia golden globes The Walt Disney Company streaming movies 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards comic books 2021 IFC Films universal monsters psychological thriller BET Awards medical drama venice nfl SDCC gangster suspense comics halloween cooking Pet Sematary Creative Arts Emmys directors spider-verse Acorn TV natural history cops true crime spider-man cartoon king arthur Ellie Kemper golden globe awards Shondaland Turner Classic Movies BBC One space Amazon Studios spanish language dceu Pride Month PlayStation Premiere Dates FXX adenture rotten movies we love docudrama Interview Adult Swim reviews Red Carpet kong ABC Mystery marvel comics ViacomCBS The CW 45 cinemax foreign Universal Pictures mockumentary name the review adventure Image Comics Martial Arts NYCC Mindy Kaling GIFs Apple TV Plus sequels festival 20th Century Fox Pirates Star Trek laika crossover classics Warner Bros. parents adaptation Rom-Com sitcom Mary poppins summer TV 2015 Amazon Prime American Society of Cinematographers RT History 90s thriller Tomatazos binge blockbuster social media spain Paramount Plus Brie Larson Musicals 2016 AMC E3 psycho Pop Western halloween tv worst emmy awards Tumblr Teen war vampires Sundance Now Cosplay RT21 dogs First Reviews screenings 72 Emmy Awards japanese children's TV OWN transformers TBS YouTube Red ID justice league Film Sundance cars ESPN criterion broadcast Funimation black comedy El Rey Mary Poppins Returns hidden camera Comedy movies mutant documentaries Biopics sag awards scene in color series series stand-up comedy technology toronto scene in color romantic comedy archives Pixar Tubi Reality Competition disaster Lionsgate The Academy Paramount rt labs critics edition Focus Features game of thrones posters Grammys free movies The Walking Dead richard e. Grant quibi Best Director telelvision YA ghosts LGBT trophy book theme song Disney Plus Spectrum Originals Paramount Network Discovery Channel 24 frames rt archives batman San Diego Comic-Con Black Mirror best 1990s Drama fast and furious japan italian A24 movie Character Guide Marvel cancelled TV series PaleyFest jurassic park zombie game show Comic Book Broadway Winter TV Watching Series asian-american Ovation TCA 2017 Marvel Studios Box Office 94th Oscars docuseries popular Kids & Family dexter cancelled feel good Hallmark Christmas movies superhero legend HBO Go Spring TV Holiday Fall TV Photos police drama robots Elton John CBS breaking bad 71st Emmy Awards genre Summer Tarantino Star Wars live event Oscar Best Actor Rock anthology TV One Trailer Food Network reboot south america Sony Pictures superman satire GLAAD biopic what to watch Polls and Games leaderboard Britbox Rocketman Country unscripted Epix scary based on movie Peacock Pacific Islander Neflix comic book movie Countdown DC streaming service DirecTV Valentine's Day HFPA worst movies TV films E! Action Apple james bond indiana jones olympics politics Netflix Christmas movies obi wan kaiju YouTube BAFTA indie marvel cinematic universe TIFF news football blaxploitation Best and Worst Video Games CNN new york 007 TNT slashers Arrowverse Baby Yoda young adult Comic-Con@Home 2021 all-time 2020 Super Bowl 2019 X-Men Apple TV+ Starz BBC USA Network The Purge Emmys Opinion AMC Plus aapi Avengers documentary Toys streamig Pop TV First Look Disney+ Disney Plus debate Fox Searchlight heist movie vs. spy thriller Freeform deadpool Schedule historical drama boxoffice Sundance TV target scene in color supernatural zombies TCA Winter 2020 Vudu Writers Guild of America chucky Alien critics werewolf Captain marvel animated scary movies Holidays aliens blockbusters Crunchyroll action-comedy The Arrangement TV renewals Shudder godzilla independent TCA Animation Legendary Superheroes Paramount Pictures stoner Set visit Horror witnail dreamworks Women's History Month Tags: Comedy Superheroe versus kids comic book movies ratings Awards History Extras Election period drama Wes Anderson Music Disney Channel Academy Awards pirates of the caribbean spanish Nat Geo teaser YouTube Premium die hard Television Academy screen actors guild Turner SundanceTV canceled TV shows harry potter finale VICE DGA spinoff australia Certified Fresh DC Comics video scene in color film series Reality discovery Universal child's play Lifetime Showtime 79th Golden Globes Awards Endgame Thanksgiving sequel monster movies Chernobyl TLC dark black Binge Guide TruTV Netflix basketball Sci-Fi Emmy Nominations rt labs Disney MGM Exclusive Video razzies Hulu OneApp Marathons crime Infographic Comics on TV Film Festival FX on Hulu french romance Rocky Walt Disney Pictures Logo 2017 NBA obituary dragons Amazon Prime Video Hear Us Out biography a nightmare on elm street Indigenous Awards Tour high school President SXSW 2022 Fargo Television Critics Association king kong MSNBC 99% sopranos latino DC Universe saw wonder woman casting 93rd Oscars singing competition Musical MTV cancelled television VOD hollywood IMDb TV CW Seed CMT CBS All Access Spike renewed TV shows TV movies See It Skip It tv talk slasher hist cults Amazon WGN 2018 doctor who scorecard hispanic stop motion Family 4/20 HBO Max Trophy Talk green book TCA Awards Trivia Hollywood Foreign Press Association sports serial killer Geeked Week comic franchise Winners women Esquire award winner Best Picture Ghostbusters SXSW interviews Calendar joker summer TV preview MCU NBC GoT Crackle National Geographic Lifetime Christmas movies zero dark thirty Masterpiece TV Land streaming travel remakes revenge television science fiction Fantasy 21st Century Fox mob ITV Anna Paquin FX cancelled TV shows toy story trailers USA rom-coms A&E hispanic heritage month royal family talk show Lucasfilm Disney streaming service Year in Review Hallmark art house festivals diversity Stephen King New York Comic Con target Cartoon Network nature mission: impossible Instagram Live comedies prank TCM FOX live action critic resources anime LGBTQ strong female leads jamie lee curtis Star Wars Celebration Heroines concert international The Witch boxing Fox News Bravo BET APB lord of the rings video on demand PBS Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ABC Family Nominations know your critic Podcast Best Actress Nickelodeon cats Syfy Comedy Central Cannes crime thriller BBC America canceled South by Southwest Film Festival new zealand 73rd Emmy Awards christmas movies nbcuniversal dc Dark Horse Comics Marvel Television rotten Columbia Pictures Quiz Mary Tyler Moore new star wars movies crime drama fresh summer preview Oscars Prime Video Tokyo Olympics political drama IFC Classic Film comiccon Christmas Mudbound dramedy elevated horror ABC Signature Travel Channel VH1 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sony book adaptation Native composers mcc Sneak Peek HBO facebook Song of Ice and Fire