Robert De Niro vs. Al Pacino: Who Wins Our Epic Actor Battle?

We're crunching the numbers to see which actor-gangster is the bestfella.

by | November 27, 2019 | Comments

Robert De Niro reunites with Al Pacino this month in Martin Scorsese’s The Irishman, the epic and Certified Fresh new Netflix gangster flick. The two actors – who last shared the screen in Michael Mann’s Heat – have been getting plenty of Oscar buzz for the movie in which Pacino plays infamous Teamster leader Jimmy Hoffa and De Niro plays his right-hand man, Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran. If either wins big this awards season, they will be adding to an already heaving trophy shelf. But who between Pacino and De Niro is the ultimate king of the big screen? We’re looking to settle that question by looking at their Tomatometer scores, box office performance, iconic roles, and one wild card category. Did we get it right? Let us know in the comments. (Yes, we’re talking to you.)

The Irishman is currently available on Netflix. 


The Irishman (2019)

Adjusted Score: 123820%
Critics Consensus: An epic gangster drama that earns its extended runtime, The Irishman finds Martin Scorsese revisiting familiar themes to poignant, funny, and profound effect.
Synopsis: In the 1950s, truck driver Frank Sheeran gets involved with Russell Bufalino and his Pennsylvania crime family. As Sheeran climbs... [More]
Directed By: Martin Scorsese

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

2021 james bond foreign TCA 2017 Disney streaming service laika dogs spider-man Countdown Funimation Black History Month Disney Channel Acorn TV IMDb TV mockumentary Nominations independent young adult debate feel good halloween basketball black Classic Film APB comic books Music Comic-Con@Home 2021 werewolf Captain marvel USA Network RT History HBO Max Brie Larson Rocketman CMT Logo anime unscripted Creative Arts Emmys The Academy Fox News ITV new star wars movies scorecard 99% Star Wars aapi Lifetime zombie USA supernatural talk show Awards Tour Mary Tyler Moore anthology a nightmare on elm street MTV cancelled Rom-Com video japanese Nickelodeon Mary poppins docudrama 2018 Calendar french Disney Plus Teen Sundance Now live action deadpool miniseries IFC zero dark thirty ghosts lord of the rings FX on Hulu gangster Bravo cats 2019 hist action-comedy Opinion Winter TV E3 best Mindy Kaling MSNBC Set visit telelvision AMC Musical Endgame 21st Century Fox Fox Searchlight CW Seed teaser book crossover Cartoon Network high school Star Trek japan Marvel canceled TV shows singing competition Syfy 1990s Chilling Adventures of Sabrina sag awards parents Hallmark Christmas movies Best and Worst Mudbound marvel cinematic universe critic resources Britbox Women's History Month Nat Geo all-time Family travel festivals Interview Shudder WGN Mystery Pop TV Summer TCA Winter 2020 Pride Month LGBTQ Ovation Chernobyl tv talk Comics on TV medical drama Image Comics scary movies comedies finale Lifetime Christmas movies DC Comics See It Skip It pirates of the caribbean Animation Spectrum Originals Television Academy RT21 Trophy Talk war ViacomCBS DC streaming service Year in Review Superheroe The Walking Dead critics aliens TCA series cinemax TruTV reboot vs. San Diego Comic-Con renewed TV shows rotten movies we love classics child's play hidden camera boxoffice historical drama disaster Paramount Plus saw crime thriller Fargo Mary Poppins Returns know your critic psycho Marathons MCU rt archives Crunchyroll Fall TV Lucasfilm Cannes Comic Book Holiday Spike Sundance TV revenge theme song films Grammys dark women WarnerMedia cartoon Superheroes comics CNN Photos Amazon NBA razzies nfl Adult Swim rt labs news latino Infographic rt labs critics edition dc Turner mcc game of thrones First Reviews olympics zombies king kong Tubi Universal Pictures hollywood legend comic book movies monster movies video on demand robots Marvel Studios streaming movies die hard TV Land canceled television Television Critics Association The Witch Hallmark Travel Channel HBO Go obituary NYCC twilight Pirates transformers indie king arthur PaleyFest Tarantino Sundance Pacific Islander halloween tv GLAAD TV renewals HBO BBC universal monsters Writers Guild of America Netflix reviews space TNT BET Awards CBS All Access Martial Arts TCM free movies what to watch children's TV ID Sony Pictures blockbuster The Arrangement cars Oscars 2017 trophy LGBT IFC Films TV One Exclusive Video The Purge GoT spanish language versus stop motion jamie lee curtis hispanic heritage month award winner mob live event Quiz cooking Avengers Comedy sports Holidays joker superman Black Mirror OWN south america 2016 quibi directors Warner Bros. Polls and Games 24 frames book adaptation Ellie Kemper justice league 71st Emmy Awards suspense Amazon Studios YouTube Red Sneak Peek Elton John worst movies adenture prank cancelled TV series NBC Columbia Pictures Amazon Prime Video Tomatazos natural history satire romance BET crime biography 72 Emmy Awards Wes Anderson screen actors guild asian-american boxing discovery football Reality composers spanish based on movie vampires Box Office facebook technology cancelled TV shows Character Guide First Look GIFs Paramount Network BBC America Pixar documentaries TCA Awards Freeform Hulu Valentine's Day adaptation black comedy royal family Food Network sopranos Arrowverse Western scary scene in color YA richard e. Grant Pet Sematary Schedule Shondaland 90s Netflix Christmas movies Baby Yoda kong TV movies screenings Epix 93rd Oscars Rocky kids VH1 stoner strong female leads Sci-Fi Hear Us Out comic Fantasy Certified Fresh golden globe awards PBS Emmy Nominations slashers History new york political drama Thanksgiving New York Comic Con Disney+ Disney Plus green book Toys Video Games trailers 45 Apple TV+ sitcom slasher Podcast President Peacock crime drama genre Esquire chucky Red Carpet National Geographic dramedy Drama posters CBS Cosplay Discovery Channel YouTube toy story 007 indiana jones Vudu Premiere Dates game show golden globes Neflix Comedy Central Masterpiece ABC Country christmas movies Academy Awards Ghostbusters romantic comedy casting Paramount jurassic park batman dexter animated Crackle VOD The Walt Disney Company thriller witnail Extras Kids & Family AMC Plus heist movie BAFTA social media TIFF Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dceu Stephen King nbcuniversal dreamworks target Disney 20th Century Fox TLC Starz OneApp nature cancelled television biopic FX SXSW Biopics comiccon australia sequels Trivia period drama DGA blaxploitation Apple TV Plus mission: impossible rom-coms FXX Song of Ice and Fire venice dragons Super Bowl Musicals X-Men popular Showtime spinoff Tumblr PlayStation Apple E! El Rey festival cops Film 2015 Film Festival 73rd Emmy Awards serial killer elevated horror ABC Signature Reality Competition criterion blockbusters toronto Awards spider-verse Anna Paquin Binge Guide 4/20 rotten hispanic Legendary Marvel Television DC Universe leaderboard movie art house spy thriller wonder woman A&E Winners marvel comics DirecTV Election police drama ESPN name the review spain Amazon Prime italian Turner Classic Movies VICE diversity Action docuseries Rock binge godzilla FOX Universal Heroines Dark Horse Comics mutant sequel comic book movie fresh breaking bad Trailer new zealand American Society of Cinematographers politics international Emmys concert The CW harry potter movies Pop remakes YouTube Premium TBS worst science fiction archives true crime SDCC psychological thriller A24 streaming Instagram Live cults Broadway SundanceTV Horror documentary superhero emmy awards ABC Family Lionsgate BBC One fast and furious TV Spring TV doctor who 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards adventure stand-up comedy 2020 kaiju Tokyo Olympics ratings Alien Christmas Walt Disney Pictures Watching Series franchise