Showdowns

Ridley Scott vs. James Cameron: Which Director Rules Sci-Fi Action?

The two influential directors who separately gave us Blade Runner, Gladiator, The Terminator, Alien and Aliens go head-to-head according to Tomatometer, box office, and more!

by | June 3, 2020 | Comments

It’s the first ever director face-off in our Vs. series, and it’s an epic battle between two of the most influential filmmakers of our time – especially when it comes to action and sci-fi cinema. In the one corner you have Sir Ridley Scott, the man who gave us Alien, Blade Runner, Gladiator, and… The Counselor. (Mean, we know.) In the other corner is James Cameron, the man who gave us Aliens, The Terminator, Titanic, and… Piranha II: The Spawning. (Really.) Which director comes out on top when it comes to box office, Tomatometer and Audience Score, influence, and more? Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis is crunching the numbers and making the big calls and, as ever, if you don’t agree with the verdict, let us know in the comments.


Thumbnail images by Everett Collection and ©Fox 2000 courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Creative Arts Emmys Cosplay HBO Go Interview DC streaming service Academy Awards Opinion DGA Hallmark Superheroe MSNBC Mary Tyler Moore black nfl cars The Academy tv talk Crackle aliens cancelled TV series Western Fantasy Winners classics Spectrum Originals cooking Super Bowl sequels TNT chucky casting sag awards nbcuniversal movie Awards Sundance Now nature Comics on TV scary movies BET cinemax Infographic SXSW National Geographic New York Comic Con Kids & Family Hallmark Christmas movies Marvel halloween tv zombie LGBTQ Summer halloween Extras comiccon war superhero werewolf Animation HBO Max screenings Pop TV space jamie lee curtis TV renewals social media Grammys Toys Winter TV comedies theme song Logo facebook mission: impossible FX 20th Century Fox disaster zombies parents Star Wars true crime anime LGBT films Alien cops SDCC hollywood natural history blaxploitation Pop video on demand Photos stoner crime thriller comic serial killer game show venice Action Character Guide christmas movies Music Mudbound Best and Worst Walt Disney Pictures YA Nominations travel AMC Rom-Com Disney+ Disney Plus Marathons IFC Sundance TV Drama Spring TV dc green book ABC Family Tomatazos ABC politics The CW comics animated worst USA Network Avengers Dark Horse Comics WarnerMedia E3 harry potter IFC Films Mystery Apple Reality book Nickelodeon Pirates DC Universe Showtime comic books romantic comedy spider-man Election Lionsgate Baby Yoda Podcast Trivia justice league deadpool boxing 24 frames Pixar Tubi Biopics Emmys OneApp Horror Crunchyroll franchise transformers foreign Tarantino Heroines historical drama Chernobyl Red Carpet kids A&E dceu diversity 71st Emmy Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt indiana jones documentaries CMT biography First Reviews spy thriller See It Skip It CBS Hulu Musicals italian reviews versus movies 2018 Fall TV Apple TV Plus discovery YouTube blockbuster Calendar mockumentary Classic Film Rocketman hist A24 Certified Fresh unscripted Lifetime james bond Amazon Studios BBC die hard Anna Paquin Sundance Ovation ID child's play all-time Valentine's Day canceled TV shows OWN Quiz political drama reboot rotten movies we love TLC elevated horror sitcom Comedy Central BBC America YouTube Premium Apple TV+ APB stand-up comedy MCU Captain marvel series 2017 ITV sequel Year in Review thriller The Arrangement criterion Stephen King canceled Trailer Oscars concert Television Academy Women's History Month Superheroes adaptation slashers 2015 Teen X-Men Travel Channel TV Disney El Rey Britbox NBC streaming E! critics Amazon Prime Video breaking bad Sneak Peek Awards Tour Rock batman San Diego Comic-Con cancelled TV shows Shudder PaleyFest Elton John TV Land Comic Book ratings remakes The Walking Dead Chilling Adventures of Sabrina FXX romance 007 singing competition WGN Black Mirror Vudu universal monsters BAFTA Amazon Sci-Fi 21st Century Fox Star Trek Turner festival Marvel Television Amazon Prime what to watch HBO revenge USA Musical best french Adult Swim DirecTV spanish language name the review Starz fresh cats Film Festival Song of Ice and Fire Schedule Fox Searchlight VICE GoT Marvel Studios obituary emmy awards Mindy Kaling TCM cartoon Ghostbusters docudrama based on movie strong female leads Trophy Talk toronto miniseries Lucasfilm independent Syfy asian-american Arrowverse Television Critics Association Martial Arts Paramount psychological thriller football Hear Us Out fast and furious Film scorecard The Witch spinoff Turner Classic Movies Lifetime Christmas movies south america Disney Plus Fox News twilight police drama Disney streaming service richard e. Grant YouTube Red CBS All Access Christmas video Cannes documentary VH1 television spanish Food Network Writers Guild of America festivals Rocky Cartoon Network teaser rotten RT21 CW Seed Funimation finale stop motion free movies Endgame Netflix The Purge Countdown Discovery Channel 45 TCA cults Watching Series Mary poppins quibi Acorn TV dogs directors NYCC Tumblr Reality Competition mutant Box Office vampires crime drama latino Peacock Epix TCA 2017 toy story worst movies BET Awards Thanksgiving Esquire Warner Bros. 4/20 TruTV Mary Poppins Returns binge TBS award winner Polls and Games renewed TV shows Masterpiece Emmy Nominations game of thrones DC Comics witnail sports period drama Family japanese SundanceTV VOD Holidays children's TV GIFs doctor who Video Games 2016 golden globes dark Freeform Premiere Dates indie 99% BBC One TIFF Disney Channel Pride Month PlayStation FOX boxoffice Comedy crime dramedy Nat Geo Ellie Kemper joker Bravo Columbia Pictures psycho ghosts supernatural hispanic Paramount Network 2019 australia CNN Binge Guide President a nightmare on elm street Netflix Christmas movies anthology dragons History PBS composers GLAAD FX on Hulu Universal spain Sony Pictures American Society of Cinematographers laika ESPN Set visit zero dark thirty Pet Sematary Spike Brie Larson talk show First Look adventure RT History cancelled technology archives crossover Shondaland TCA Awards TCA Winter 2020 robots news rt archives Country MTV 2020 72 Emmy Awards Holiday Black History Month medical drama satire science fiction cancelled television screen actors guild