Ridley Scott vs. James Cameron: Which Director Rules Sci-Fi Action?

The two influential directors who separately gave us Blade Runner, Gladiator, The Terminator, Alien and Aliens go head-to-head according to Tomatometer, box office, and more!

by | June 3, 2020 | Comments

It’s the first ever director face-off in our Vs. series, and it’s an epic battle between two of the most influential filmmakers of our time – especially when it comes to action and sci-fi cinema. In the one corner you have Sir Ridley Scott, the man who gave us Alien, Blade Runner, Gladiator, and… The Counselor. (Mean, we know.) In the other corner is James Cameron, the man who gave us Aliens, The Terminator, Titanic, and… Piranha II: The Spawning. (Really.) Which director comes out on top when it comes to box office, Tomatometer and Audience Score, influence, and more? Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis is crunching the numbers and making the big calls and, as ever, if you don’t agree with the verdict, let us know in the comments.

Thumbnail images by Everett Collection and ©Fox 2000 courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Photos sequels Toys TCA 2017 medical drama comics Spike casting free movies Mystery 45 MCU indiana jones remakes transformers king kong Teen WarnerMedia Shondaland Country Podcast cancelled TV series Tomatazos Mary poppins television cats 2018 emmy awards FOX romantic comedy Lifetime Christmas movies Endgame TV Ovation Turner Classic Movies strong female leads ratings Hallmark black USA Network Marathons Sundance Now DC Universe war The Walt Disney Company Video Games CMT Adult Swim fresh The Walking Dead Best and Worst Britbox finale golden globes A&E Interview Trophy Talk Discovery Channel Pop First Reviews golden globe awards Countdown APB french Amazon Studios Tubi Paramount Plus Turner Travel Channel IFC slashers Netflix Christmas movies YA YouTube Premium rotten movies we love video on demand BET Awards Film Festival Schedule Disney Summer Amazon Prime christmas movies sports VICE President Infographic BAFTA reboot disaster dragons unscripted Calendar Spring TV DGA deadpool DC Comics Lifetime satire richard e. Grant Rocketman 2015 Reality classics TIFF Nickelodeon GoT worst movies NBC Reality Competition chucky revenge E3 LGBT independent Thanksgiving Tarantino indie blaxploitation Writers Guild of America teaser biography technology Vudu docuseries archives 2017 science fiction talk show Disney Channel festivals ABC Signature composers vampires directors Avengers nfl 2016 die hard Star Wars Ghostbusters Amazon 24 frames TCA Awards supernatural crime Lionsgate facebook docudrama Black Mirror BBC DC streaming service OWN comic books theme song halloween screenings Election USA reviews Anna Paquin Comics on TV tv talk HBO Max stand-up comedy cancelled television Musical spanish language Marvel Studios social media nbcuniversal TV renewals game show scorecard hispanic 72 Emmy Awards Lucasfilm LGBTQ Binge Guide space Trailer rotten Emmys Disney streaming service CBS anime movie 99% TCA documentary what to watch joker Box Office mission: impossible football Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Baby Yoda blockbusters kaiju breaking bad Apple jurassic park james bond New York Comic Con Musicals MTV VH1 Television Critics Association Pixar Brie Larson Rocky Chilling Adventures of Sabrina werewolf spanish screen actors guild cars Warner Bros. elevated horror Apple TV Plus popular Tumblr First Look Fox News singing competition Song of Ice and Fire Quiz Food Network Alien comedies batman BBC One PlayStation ViacomCBS Winners Hallmark Christmas movies Holidays sag awards TLC RT History Logo Comedy Central telelvision Trivia Creative Arts Emmys franchise 007 psycho Winter TV Esquire Premiere Dates AMC Kids & Family Bravo HBO Go serial killer Mindy Kaling Funimation period drama miniseries Emmy Nominations El Rey ID superhero women crossover Comic Book Year in Review Spectrum Originals police drama Pirates historical drama scary movies Star Trek The Academy justice league Crunchyroll Set visit boxing Freeform 2020 series psychological thriller universal monsters superman movies Stephen King Sundance TV CNN Fox Searchlight worst halloween tv diversity BET zombies binge toy story travel Mudbound CW Seed rt archives canceled TV shows Epix best Dark Horse Comics south america book Awards FXX The Arrangement Superheroes dc japanese crime drama Sneak Peek godzilla Showtime TruTV Polls and Games Disney+ Disney Plus Sci-Fi Fantasy GIFs TCA Winter 2020 adventure renewed TV shows FX on Hulu FX Family Women's History Month sequel anthology pirates of the caribbean kong Music Broadway YouTube Red Pride Month Netflix Western Syfy 20th Century Fox toronto canceled children's TV Masterpiece Martial Arts Grammys Arrowverse cinemax Action SDCC natural history ABC hollywood Academy Awards 21st Century Fox cancelled TV One sitcom RT21 Holiday Mary Tyler Moore TCM hist Cannes Ellie Kemper video cooking zombie Oscars Marvel Marvel Television comiccon adaptation X-Men game of thrones thriller TV Land zero dark thirty spider-man Nominations true crime National Geographic Crackle Disney Plus 2021 OneApp DirecTV CBS All Access italian Rock Watching Series IFC Films Cosplay documentaries dceu streaming all-time robots parents PaleyFest Rom-Com Paramount Network quibi witnail criterion Sony Pictures nature critics A24 The CW australia San Diego Comic-Con Hear Us Out Certified Fresh laika Sundance foreign SXSW 4/20 doctor who Apple TV+ Christmas Acorn TV a nightmare on elm street news obituary Biopics fast and furious asian-american Starz mutant stop motion Pop TV GLAAD political drama Drama Cartoon Network cults Legendary films American Society of Cinematographers trailers 2019 stoner Black History Month green book Classic Film Paramount ABC Family cartoon History Character Guide dark concert Hulu Opinion ESPN Nat Geo Shudder romance E! MSNBC Red Carpet Television Academy latino Amazon Prime Video Film comic ITV PBS discovery Animation animated prank monster movies Heroines Valentine's Day dogs Pet Sematary Horror twilight Walt Disney Pictures 71st Emmy Awards mockumentary Extras NYCC Exclusive Video crime thriller TBS The Purge TNT 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards WGN HBO See It Skip It Universal harry potter Fall TV Captain marvel name the review child's play based on movie spinoff versus cops Columbia Pictures spy thriller The Witch Comedy kids blockbuster Peacock razzies rom-coms festival Superheroe award winner Elton John SundanceTV venice cancelled TV shows BBC America hidden camera Chernobyl dramedy boxoffice aliens Mary Poppins Returns YouTube Super Bowl Awards Tour ghosts VOD jamie lee curtis spain politics