Showdowns

Ridley Scott vs. James Cameron: Which Director Rules Sci-Fi Action?

The two influential directors who separately gave us Blade Runner, Gladiator, The Terminator, Alien and Aliens go head-to-head according to Tomatometer, box office, and more!

by | June 3, 2020 | Comments

It’s the first ever director face-off in our Vs. series, and it’s an epic battle between two of the most influential filmmakers of our time – especially when it comes to action and sci-fi cinema. In the one corner you have Sir Ridley Scott, the man who gave us Alien, Blade Runner, Gladiator, and… The Counselor. (Mean, we know.) In the other corner is James Cameron, the man who gave us Aliens, The Terminator, Titanic, and… Piranha II: The Spawning. (Really.) Which director comes out on top when it comes to box office, Tomatometer and Audience Score, influence, and more? Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis is crunching the numbers and making the big calls and, as ever, if you don’t agree with the verdict, let us know in the comments.


Thumbnail images by Everett Collection and ©Fox 2000 courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

Best Actress movie MGM Amazon Studios Red Carpet SXSW Comics on TV new york Tokyo Olympics See It Skip It Brie Larson werewolf Lucasfilm classics First Reviews aliens halloween PlayStation Women's History Month hispanic heritage month mcc video on demand Calendar hidden camera American Society of Cinematographers El Rey Podcast Best and Worst adaptation Rom-Com DC streaming service new star wars movies Year in Review psycho quibi obi wan sequels Trophy Talk joker Nominations Extras cancelled TV shows spinoff Emmys Marvel Studios A&E south america Horror Legendary zombies cinemax dexter Action Hear Us Out USA based on movie cancelled TV series criterion Turner Classic Movies posters sitcom a nightmare on elm street Spectrum Originals facebook TCM Martial Arts marvel comics canceled TV shows documentaries 93rd Oscars Baby Yoda docuseries Broadway laika comic book movie rt labs critics edition Teen The CW Election NYCC spanish language finale Toys OWN Drama king kong ITV TruTV cats venice anime Sundance TV Apple TV Plus Amazon Song of Ice and Fire ABC Signature streaming movies 2018 99% australia zero dark thirty Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Crunchyroll fast and furious Thanksgiving Columbia Pictures BBC nbcuniversal Dark Horse Comics golden globe awards Tags: Comedy stop motion rt archives hollywood TV Land Funimation TV One Musical Disney Channel YouTube Premium crime 2020 Netflix Christmas movies streamig Pop Fall TV adventure NBA japan The Walt Disney Company sequel dogs Mindy Kaling GoT VH1 Wes Anderson hispanic discovery genre Television Critics Association comics elevated horror series BET game show Premiere Dates TCA Winter 2020 Infographic kids BBC America Creative Arts Emmys witnail game of thrones Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt LGBT Schedule Box Office debate Hallmark Holidays Turner transformers 73rd Emmy Awards TV renewals PBS Binge Guide BAFTA young adult travel die hard Neflix christmas movies TIFF MCU Tumblr X-Men Syfy romantic comedy Pixar Best Picture Animation 2017 Nickelodeon TBS godzilla miniseries indiana jones franchise Fox News comic Holiday mob telelvision Watching Series obituary Britbox basketball Mary Tyler Moore gangster scene in color canceled cooking Star Wars Television Academy high school comiccon Pet Sematary 2021 television Kids & Family twilight critics jurassic park Avengers 72 Emmy Awards zombie space Amazon Prime Comic Book leaderboard Fantasy video Walt Disney Pictures ABC Family E3 universal monsters pirates of the caribbean Certified Fresh doctor who SundanceTV vampires Super Bowl directors WarnerMedia cops heist movie toy story foreign Western science fiction Travel Channel medical drama Rocky HBO WGN richard e. Grant Black History Month french breaking bad black comedy rotten movies we love CBS All Access romance dramedy natural history ratings History Esquire target vs. IFC CBS superhero YouTube Red 94th Oscars biography National Geographic psychological thriller Writers Guild of America fresh political drama justice league 90s mutant rom-coms book adaptation TV streaming Superheroes Epix kaiju festivals action-comedy children's TV hist latino Classic Film toronto 45 reboot unscripted crime drama stand-up comedy blockbuster IMDb TV binge ghosts IFC Films 20th Century Fox Emmy Nominations cancelled Rocketman Warner Bros. Film Sundance Now supernatural superman SXSW 2022 docudrama dragons cars Starz new zealand The Arrangement Masterpiece Discovery Channel spider-verse Shondaland documentary saw Paramount Network wonder woman slashers FXX BBC One nature Biopics japanese 21st Century Fox Spring TV Apple TV+ marvel cinematic universe The Walking Dead mockumentary AMC Plus all-time women trophy social media screen actors guild monster movies FX LGBTQ Best Actor YouTube New York Comic Con rotten critic resources Cosplay spider-man live event HBO Max cults San Diego Comic-Con boxoffice TCA TCA 2017 politics President nfl Lifetime Christmas movies Alien Showtime sag awards ESPN Paramount Plus Interview book Hollywood Foreign Press Association theme song worst MSNBC Marvel Television Rock DC Universe TCA Awards festival Pirates black Pride Month name the review prank Netflix teaser DirecTV satire composers Marathons green book Apple 4/20 YA sports art house Countdown cartoon SDCC ID The Witch Winners Instagram Live Image Comics Mary poppins royal family Vudu Trailer Logo Academy Awards asian-american films 71st Emmy Awards scary movies TV movies feel good 1990s Polls and Games Photos Heroines Disney Pacific Islander CW Seed TNT Comic-Con@Home 2021 serial killer suspense live action DGA anthology football GIFs Set visit Oscar PaleyFest international First Look Comedy Central FOX news Christmas Ovation Peacock slasher halloween tv Arrowverse VICE king arthur olympics Elton John true crime spy thriller reviews robots historical drama know your critic parents popular italian Reality Chernobyl RT History DC Comics E! Mary Poppins Returns Awards Tour casting Grammys lord of the rings Winter TV Exclusive Video Trivia 2015 crossover The Purge comic books blaxploitation technology Star Trek Amazon Prime Video Pop TV remakes Comedy archives Acorn TV Cannes best FX on Hulu AMC Mudbound 2016 stoner talk show Bravo emmy awards Universal Pictures CNN 24 frames mission: impossible Fargo razzies harry potter HBO Go child's play Captain marvel Reality Competition crime thriller Character Guide Crackle Paramount Universal screenings OneApp versus spain what to watch Awards A24 tv talk police drama Musicals Adult Swim james bond Cartoon Network The Academy Hulu Best Director MTV Freeform deadpool award winner Stephen King strong female leads spanish war singing competition Sneak Peek HFPA Disney+ Disney Plus USA Network renewed TV shows diversity GLAAD Tomatazos scorecard 79th Golden Globes Awards NBC 2019 sopranos ViacomCBS Fox Searchlight South by Southwest Film Festival Marvel Sci-Fi adenture dreamworks Summer Oscars 007 revenge worst movies TLC Opinion independent Disney streaming service Lifetime blockbusters cancelled television Valentine's Day Sony Pictures CMT rt labs RT21 BET Awards kong thriller trailers Prime Video comedies dark Endgame movies scary Tubi disaster Country Food Network ABC Shudder golden globes 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Ghostbusters Sundance Mystery Hallmark Christmas movies Quiz chucky free movies concert Video Games Disney Plus boxing Family Music jamie lee curtis dceu animated aapi batman Lionsgate period drama VOD Black Mirror APB Tarantino Nat Geo comic book movies dc Ellie Kemper Spike Anna Paquin indie legend Superheroe Film Festival biopic