Showdowns

Ridley Scott vs. James Cameron: Which Director Rules Sci-Fi Action?

The two influential directors who separately gave us Blade Runner, Gladiator, The Terminator, Alien and Aliens go head-to-head according to Tomatometer, box office, and more!

by | June 3, 2020 | Comments

It’s the first ever director face-off in our Vs. series, and it’s an epic battle between two of the most influential filmmakers of our time – especially when it comes to action and sci-fi cinema. In the one corner you have Sir Ridley Scott, the man who gave us Alien, Blade Runner, Gladiator, and… The Counselor. (Mean, we know.) In the other corner is James Cameron, the man who gave us Aliens, The Terminator, Titanic, and… Piranha II: The Spawning. (Really.) Which director comes out on top when it comes to box office, Tomatometer and Audience Score, influence, and more? Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis is crunching the numbers and making the big calls and, as ever, if you don’t agree with the verdict, let us know in the comments.


Thumbnail images by Everett Collection and ©Fox 2000 courtesy Everett Collection

Tag Cloud

DC Comics basketball Hallmark Christmas movies Red Carpet Logo Tubi President thriller Pixar natural history Comics on TV remakes zombies deadpool VH1 Teen french ESPN Turner Disney Plus miniseries cancelled TV shows sequel ABC Signature See It Skip It 90s movies Television Critics Association suspense quibi Sneak Peek TCA Winter 2020 jamie lee curtis ABC Family pirates of the caribbean Turner Classic Movies Countdown romance period drama Holiday reviews cancelled television Heroines Mary Tyler Moore National Geographic CNN X-Men based on movie Superheroe The Purge Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VICE hist saw Spring TV Emmys fast and furious TV Land teaser Song of Ice and Fire CBS dc Adult Swim streaming Masterpiece TLC Fall TV First Reviews concert harry potter History superhero Box Office adenture Netflix Christmas movies romantic comedy San Diego Comic-Con directors foreign 99% Ovation Crackle VOD canceled toronto child's play Disney Holidays Avengers Television Academy WGN docudrama Western unscripted First Look 72 Emmy Awards 2015 Watching Series 93rd Oscars Writers Guild of America Image Comics reboot sag awards Tokyo Olympics new star wars movies DC Universe A&E ViacomCBS rotten movies we love GLAAD what to watch Ghostbusters Pop TV razzies Opinion science fiction Dark Horse Comics Star Wars classics parents crime thriller SXSW vampires Captain marvel 2020 Esquire fresh The Walt Disney Company Ellie Kemper Paramount Network Trailer BBC Calendar hollywood Film Festival target NBA Hallmark telelvision USA Network stop motion Apple TV Plus sports Wes Anderson FXX breaking bad italian Film comic 4/20 Spike movie legend christmas movies comic books Starz olympics PlayStation politics godzilla Nat Geo kids spanish Star Trek DirecTV free movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina venice independent japanese anthology prank Showtime TNT Warner Bros. Tumblr blaxploitation new zealand universal monsters YouTube Premium Family facebook BBC One scorecard Mudbound 2016 nature a nightmare on elm street aapi lord of the rings book adaptation TV movies IFC Films japan spanish language mutant worst movies batman Awards war TCA Elton John cancelled TCA Awards TCM documentary latino Shondaland disaster SundanceTV heist movie zero dark thirty scene in color Election Mindy Kaling football TruTV screen actors guild El Rey Photos comedies chucky anime Spectrum Originals A24 spinoff Marvel new york Paramount Reality BAFTA streaming movies psychological thriller mission: impossible Extras game of thrones video ghosts Universal BET festival RT21 Set visit TV green book Pirates 2021 Syfy popular international Action HBO FOX rotten Binge Guide Paramount Plus IFC comiccon Country political drama ABC Tarantino sitcom Disney Channel Travel Channel Disney streaming service black 21st Century Fox ID 20th Century Fox supernatural finale The CW GoT robots psycho name the review Biopics television OneApp Quiz wonder woman high school dogs Marvel Studios Chernobyl Acorn TV Schedule E! Superheroes witnail TV One 71st Emmy Awards crime drama talk show Vudu Marvel Television aliens criterion archives Peacock Lucasfilm Drama rt archives Endgame australia Amazon Prime travel casting canceled TV shows biography monster movies 2017 Rom-Com versus E3 spider-man crossover know your critic films rom-coms Awards Tour marvel cinematic universe Lifetime Christmas movies Nickelodeon die hard technology Fox Searchlight mockumentary TCA 2017 police drama Mary Poppins Returns YouTube Red Freeform Emmy Nominations cults historical drama Kids & Family Comedy Black History Month OWN halloween news richard e. Grant NYCC diversity Pacific Islander Stephen King space joker Year in Review The Arrangement true crime Horror Fox News book Music CBS All Access medical drama game show Interview asian-american 1990s Mystery dramedy NBC Winter TV adaptation discovery Cannes Baby Yoda children's TV slashers nbcuniversal Pop blockbuster series Apple TV+ WarnerMedia Sony Pictures binge Comic-Con@Home 2021 Lifetime CMT cars Broadway ITV The Witch Rocky Oscars Infographic Mary poppins cancelled TV series boxoffice TBS Hulu Exclusive Video Arrowverse revenge elevated horror hidden camera BET Awards scary movies south america ratings Epix Lionsgate king kong superman USA Super Bowl halloween tv Food Network Women's History Month cops all-time Alien women GIFs YouTube tv talk Amazon Prime Video Amazon Studios TV renewals Best and Worst worst PaleyFest Polls and Games 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards American Society of Cinematographers franchise cats Classic Film dragons critics RT History Summer singing competition justice league APB Disney+ Disney Plus Cartoon Network Creative Arts Emmys kong 2018 Netflix Video Games golden globe awards trailers The Walking Dead twilight Hear Us Out Comic Book nfl Walt Disney Pictures renewed TV shows AMC Animation award winner New York Comic Con FX on Hulu Martial Arts SDCC MSNBC dceu dark Sundance TV Crunchyroll Valentine's Day stoner Certified Fresh comics video on demand Bravo live action Fantasy LGBTQ emmy awards toy story jurassic park docuseries Thanksgiving PBS Marathons indiana jones Sci-Fi blockbusters Discovery Channel theme song laika animated Rock BBC America DC streaming service 45 transformers cooking Pet Sematary serial killer FX HBO Max The Academy Character Guide documentaries Sundance Musical Christmas composers DGA Anna Paquin spy thriller hispanic 24 frames Winners spain crime festivals 007 MTV adventure Nominations stand-up comedy Pride Month Britbox sequels Funimation Brie Larson obituary Trophy Talk Podcast Shudder Grammys indie LGBT YA best Cosplay Toys Rocketman TIFF CW Seed Premiere Dates werewolf 2019 satire Tomatazos Comedy Central Amazon MCU cartoon Apple Sundance Now Black Mirror Columbia Pictures boxing zombie screenings doctor who Musicals HBO Go james bond Academy Awards Reality Competition kaiju Legendary social media strong female leads cinemax Trivia golden globes