Ordinary Joe Star James Wolk Specializes in Characters Leading Double Lives — This Time There Are 3

The upcoming drama series follows a man offered different life paths — and what happens when he takes each of them.

by | July 23, 2021 | Comments

What would your life be like now if you made one different decision 10 years ago? It’s a question that could keep someone up at night, but it’s also the premise behind upcoming NBC drama Ordinary Joe. Premiering September 20, the series stars Mad Men and Watchmen’s James Wolk as three different versions of one man — all because he was late to his college graduation 10 years ago and was then presented with three different options that would result in different career paths and relationships.

In one, Joe Kimbreau becomes a successful and famous musician and is married to Natalie Martinez’s Amy. In another, he’s a nurse and partnered with Elizabeth Lail’s Jenny. In the third, he’s single and joins the family business as a NYPD officer. In all of these scenarios, Joe’s life results in different issues and conflicts — not just for him, Amy, and Jenny, but also for his best friend Eric (Charlie Barnett) and his family.

With the release of the trailer, we spoke with Wolk about the series and thoughts of lives less traveled.

James Wolk

(Photo by Chris Delmas/AFP via Getty Images)

Whitney Friedlander for Rotten Tomatoes: You’re playing three versions of the same person. Does that make it harder than just playing three different characters?

James Wolk: In some ways, it is more challenging because you can’t just go and create three different characters. You have to really think about, in a nuanced way, how someone’s life can change in 10 years. So it’s basically creating the same backstory from birth until 21. And then everyone takes a divergent road.

Obviously, costumes and makeup play a part in this. But does that also affect your posture, your cadence, etc.?

Yeah, absolutely. All three versions of this guy are so different, right? You have the rock star, who is super confident versus the nurse, who’s down on his luck. I think that’s a posture thing, for sure — just the way we hold ourselves when we’re feeling really confident versus when we’re feeling down on our luck. And then the cop, who’s to me is kind of like a big kid. So he’s just kind of like a big Labrador. Wardrobe help big time. There’s wigs. there’s a beard expert that came in and hand-laid that beard for each for each time I was rock star …

Ordinary Joe key art

(Photo by NBC Entertainment)

The musician character, naturally, performs a lot and the police officer sings in the pilot. You can sing. But do you play the guitar and the piano?

I sing, but I sing to my kids: my four-year-old and my two-year-old. So what you hear is my voice. I do play guitar. But they did bring in a guitar aficionado to really play it. That is me singing. That is me playing guitar. And when you hear it in the mix, you’re hearing the guitars, but you’re getting my voice because my guitar skills are like that of a camp counselor. I can play, like, Cats in the Cradle and a couple of songs around the fire. I don’t have rock-star technique.

And there was a great vocal coach in Chicago. I haven’t sung seriously since high school when I used to do high school musicals. And they brought in this guy and he was amazing. He added two notes to the top of my register that I never thought I could hit.

In all versions of this, Joe is successful. He’s a really good nurse. He’s an extremely successful musician. He’s a really good cop. Was that interesting? Were there conversations about having a Joe who wasn’t doing well in his career?

It’s interesting. Nurse Joe is down on his luck, but it’s with his marriage. They all have their thing [that’s not going well] like, in their show, his marriage isn’t going well. Music Joe: he’s always wanted to be a dad. It appears in the pilot that his dad passed away on 9/11 and there’s a whole backstory that will come out as the series goes on. I think, he has always wanted to replicate that father-son relationship. For him, he and his wife deal with infertility. With Cop Joe, he never moved on with his life. He froze in time; he has Peter Pan syndrome. So they all have something that’s eating at all of them.

You keep calling them Music Joe or Cop Joe. Is that what you call them on set or are there nicknames for them?

We should get nicknames for them.

MAD MEN, James Wolk

(Photo by Jaimie Trueblood / © AMC / Courtesy: Everett Collection)

This isn’t the first time you’ve played characters with a sort-of double life. You did the short-lived series Lone Star. And even your character on Mad Men, Bob Benson (pictured), had a sort of double life because he was a gay man living in the closet. Is there something that draws you to these characters?

Subconsciously, I’m attracted to that duality. I think that I’m someone who went on this path to become an actor. But prior to this, I had so many different interests. I was attracted to that script because I felt like I had a lot of ways I wanted to go at 21 — like vastly different ways. Like grad school. Or did I want to pursue acting? Or did I want to stay in my hometown of Michigan? Or did I want to go to New York?

Each one of those choices would have led me to completely different paths. I’m married with two kids now. And I’m in love with my wife, and I have these two amazing kids. Had I made a different choice, the probability is that I would have a totally different family. So that concept is really interesting to me.

And then along those lines, Lone Star and Bob Benson: just the idea of the faces we show versus who we really are inside? It also interests me.

Ordinary Joe premieres at 10 p.m. September 20 on NBC.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Amazon Comics on TV Tubi TV One Nickelodeon Tomatazos sitcom canceled game show Reality 45 E3 BBC classics biography superman Emmy Nominations Lifetime NYCC TV Land nbcuniversal Sneak Peek HBO Max prank transformers RT21 spinoff Countdown 99% Acorn TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Ellie Kemper king arthur live action Video Games FXX Family The Purge nfl documentary screen actors guild Character Guide critics Esquire 73rd Emmy Awards Exclusive Video animated Amazon Prime breaking bad YouTube Fox Searchlight scorecard crime drama rt archives Holidays ViacomCBS DC streaming service new star wars movies Certified Fresh Box Office cinemax Disney streaming service DirecTV Film wonder woman TV renewals Brie Larson Year in Review adenture supernatural political drama Warner Bros. video strong female leads kids LGBTQ foreign aliens Hear Us Out cancelled television satire dogs Grammys Apple TV+ Walt Disney Pictures Showtime 2020 Marathons diversity Pirates CW Seed Sundance Now finale movie Pixar 4/20 dark Rocky Premiere Dates BBC America godzilla directors The Walt Disney Company Star Trek fresh all-time The Witch Epix elevated horror Spike children's TV OWN Disney+ Disney Plus worst movies Netflix Captain marvel laika aapi See It Skip It Horror Binge Guide sag awards parents book Star Wars Turner GIFs rt labs young adult San Diego Comic-Con VOD game of thrones Infographic basketball Universal video on demand Writers Guild of America A24 TCA Awards tv talk Awards Tour binge spanish language know your critic thriller Comedy Central Animation action-comedy Reality Competition The Walking Dead toronto Shondaland Sundance TV OneApp pirates of the caribbean USA Network YouTube Premium kaiju mutant Disney Channel critic resources olympics Quiz ID Disney Plus Marvel Mystery cats Stephen King Women's History Month hispanic heritage month black BET Awards FOX romantic comedy harry potter Lionsgate Calendar anime Paramount Network japanese golden globes screenings festival adaptation HBO Go Britbox dc disaster hidden camera comic book movies renewed TV shows latino LGBT Film Festival ABC Family miniseries rotten Mary Tyler Moore Mindy Kaling Shudder Peacock MCU 2019 Adult Swim Disney The Academy blaxploitation Comic-Con@Home 2021 Extras Academy Awards comedies TLC mcc die hard comics X-Men Ghostbusters 21st Century Fox VH1 halloween tv trailers women Paramount chucky romance blockbusters twilight Lifetime Christmas movies italian Tarantino boxing Comic Book canceled TV shows new zealand series 2017 Alien crossover Red Carpet CBS All Access Best and Worst Starz suspense National Geographic Watching Series Marvel Television Sony Pictures DGA streaming Marvel Studios indiana jones target scene in color Musicals independent Sundance saw Classic Film Legendary feel good period drama AMC Photos docudrama Trailer Martial Arts stand-up comedy ABC science fiction jamie lee curtis justice league FX on Hulu Masterpiece 93rd Oscars singing competition Pacific Islander 20th Century Fox stop motion GoT social media MTV richard e. Grant Chilling Adventures of Sabrina comic book movie natural history Lucasfilm Bravo Mary poppins Emmys popular 2018 Wes Anderson golden globe awards Anna Paquin ABC Signature composers royal family 71st Emmy Awards joker teaser TBS child's play First Reviews hollywood Trophy Talk PBS mission: impossible Biopics TNT Nat Geo cars TV witnail Mudbound Trivia war documentaries Polls and Games Western christmas movies robots TruTV franchise stoner Christmas razzies Winners First Look Discovery Channel news Awards Amazon Prime Video zombies blockbuster President archives 1990s Thanksgiving venice YA comiccon Kids & Family SundanceTV reviews a nightmare on elm street Freeform festivals History australia crime thriller rt labs critics edition cooking sports name the review YouTube Red 72 Emmy Awards TCA debate 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards versus ESPN Mary Poppins Returns Crunchyroll slashers The Arrangement Superheroe Comedy Paramount Plus CMT Oscars criterion 90s Winter TV marvel cinematic universe IFC Films remakes TIFF dragons Crackle concert Syfy TCA 2017 toy story CNN cancelled TV series RT History BBC One new york Hulu 2021 Country japan Rocketman Food Network Broadway boxoffice FX cops movies DC Universe ratings BAFTA rom-coms rotten movies we love unscripted spider-man Chernobyl spy thriller universal monsters international cancelled Spring TV DC Comics American Society of Cinematographers Columbia Pictures CBS medical drama ghosts Podcast Rock Fall TV biopic marvel comics A&E heist movie BET Hallmark Christmas movies doctor who Funimation best psycho Pop TV asian-american Television Critics Association Fantasy based on movie Fox News Teen hispanic Valentine's Day SDCC slasher psychological thriller book adaptation scary movies Logo Travel Channel television Endgame french gangster Tokyo Olympics cartoon WGN GLAAD HBO politics Schedule comic books 007 streaming movies talk show ITV Set visit Summer police drama Election Amazon Studios sequels theme song obituary Cosplay superhero travel Action king kong Music Pop USA free movies Drama revenge indie Netflix Christmas movies Dark Horse Comics discovery Vudu Ovation what to watch sequel TCA Winter 2020 jurassic park fast and furious Interview Tumblr lord of the rings cancelled TV shows Superheroes SXSW emmy awards reboot Sci-Fi Black Mirror Baby Yoda Avengers mockumentary crime El Rey E! Opinion dramedy monster movies VICE NBA Creative Arts Emmys Black History Month Pet Sematary Musical Image Comics high school TV movies Elton John halloween deadpool quibi vampires spain 2015 casting MSNBC james bond dceu werewolf football Apple TV Plus IFC Super Bowl facebook Pride Month cults Holiday anthology serial killer award winner south america PaleyFest worst batman Nominations telelvision Heroines New York Comic Con Song of Ice and Fire docuseries Cannes PlayStation comic nature Arrowverse 24 frames films Rom-Com spanish true crime 2016 historical drama legend Television Academy Toys The CW Cartoon Network adventure space NBC zero dark thirty hist TCM posters APB dexter Spectrum Originals Hallmark zombie technology green book Turner Classic Movies WarnerMedia kong Apple