Critics Consensus

Hardy Rises, but Venom Sinks Like a Brock

Plus, A Star Is Born is Certified Fresh.

by | October 4, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a persuasive PSA against the dangers of touching alien goo (Venom, starring Tom Hardy and Riz Ahmed) and a celestial body reincarnated (A Star Is Born, starring Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga). What are the critics saying?

Venom (2018) 30%

Filmmakers are always faced with a tricky balance when attempting to adapt comics properties — the reason these characters make such appealing targets for adaptations is that they’re well known to a built-in fanbase, but the source material is tough to film without taking into account decades of increasingly complex stories. That’s a big bugaboo with Venom, which seeks to bring a wildly popular Spider-Man anti-hero to the big screen without tackling wide swaths of his (admittedly quite weird) origin story — or even involving the friendly neighborhood wall-crawler at all. That isn’t impossible, but it’s definitely difficult, and unfortunately, critics say the folks behind this movie weren’t up to the task. Starring Tom Hardy as Eddie Brock, the down-on-his-luck journalist who finds himself unwillingly bonded with the titular bloodthirsty alien symbiote, Venom struggles to nail down its world-building elements while maintaining a tough tonal balance. It’s one part split personality comedy, one part brutal action thriller, and one part would-be superhero franchise starter — and unsurprisingly, reviews describe it as pretty much a complete mess. Fans of the character have been waiting years to see him get his proper cinematic due, but most of them will likely be left wanting after this.

A Star Is Born (2018) 90%

Last week’s updated Little Women didn’t exactly strike a chord with critics, but the pundits don’t always reject new versions of repeatedly remade movies. For our latest evidence, here’s A Star Is Born, which sees debuting director Bradley Cooper behind the lens for the latest take on a tale that first arrived in theaters in 1937 — and again in 1954, then yet again in 1976. You’d think there probably wouldn’t be much left to bring to the story, but this update proves that assumption delightfully wrong: critics say Cooper proves a deft hand in the director’s chair, and his chemistry opposite Gaga — whose own performance has prompted a chorus of cries echoing the film’s title — is more than enough to sell their characters’ Star-crossed romance all by itself. This project languished in development hell for years, but the extra time hasn’t hurt at all; reviews say the story of a struggling singer (Gaga) who falls in with a recording artist battling personal demons (Cooper) remains effortlessly absorbing in the right hands, and it’s in some excellent ones here. Expect to see a lot of sniffling patrons streaming out of A Star Is Born screenings this weekend — and don’t be surprised if this movie ends up being a big part of the conversation come awards season.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

technology what to watch comiccon SXSW ABC Family TCA social media Podcast Best and Worst Spike See It Skip It romance Paramount OWN Sundance Thanksgiving USA Lifetime Mindy Kaling Toys cats HBO Valentine's Day Extras political drama police drama spy thriller RT History San Diego Comic-Con 20th Century Fox TV Land Star Wars El Rey Year in Review war AMC Winter TV cults CW Seed Nat Geo 2016 Netflix mutant Mystery BBC composers BBC America American Society of Cinematographers SundanceTV blaxploitation Comedy Central Hulu Spring TV Pixar New York Comic Con Lionsgate Rocky Holidays adventure GLAAD hist MTV FX Awards Action APB Superheroes Walt Disney Pictures Watching Series ITV zombie zombies Amazon singing competition serial killer dramedy NYCC TruTV IFC Films LGBTQ VH1 Video Games TNT Epix Fox News psycho First Look Apple medical drama 2015 CMT WGN Biopics MSNBC Certified Fresh anime FXX Paramount Network Marathons Acorn TV Pop Horror diversity jamie lee curtis 2017 Shudder Character Guide Teen Polls and Games Comedy FOX TCM 24 frames Ghostbusters USA Network CBS Premiere Dates Lucasfilm Star Trek IFC Shondaland Reality dc Super Bowl History Comics on TV Syfy Writers Guild of America DirecTV Interview Kids & Family period drama crime X-Men GoT Britbox Opinion Food Network A&E Infographic festivals Adult Swim Esquire science fiction politics ABC Disney Sneak Peek Ovation Trailer Grammys Bravo CBS All Access VICE cops biography Freeform golden globes Comic Book Cartoon Network YouTube Premium Masterpiece 45 cooking Pirates NBC Emmys based on movie Calendar DC Comics Red Carpet supernatural E3 Drama travel TIFF sports PBS Set visit TLC DC streaming service unscripted Song of Ice and Fire Fall TV ESPN DC Universe Dark Horse Comics aliens cinemax Summer ratings President Tomatazos Martial Arts Sundance Now Fantasy thriller Box Office Crackle transformers Warner Bros. Winners Universal Logo Disney Channel Rock E! The Arrangement Schedule TV Showtime crossover streaming Sci-Fi Sony Pictures Ellie Kemper Superheroe historical drama Musical robots Country CNN 007 docudrama discovery Musicals National Geographic Rom-Com boxoffice crime drama Animation dceu Cosplay YA SDCC vampires Tumblr sitcom doctor who YouTube Red Nominations The CW 21st Century Fox BET justice league Trivia Nickelodeon crime thriller Marvel PaleyFest TBS Creative Arts Emmys Countdown Election Oscars GIFs Photos binge Music Mary Tyler Moore Christmas Starz Reality Competition talk show Western Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt finale Columbia Pictures TCA 2017 harry potter