Game of Thrones Season 8 or Avengers: Endgame?

If you could only watch one, which would it be?

by | April 11, 2019 | Comments

HBO, Marvel Studios
(Photo by HBO, Marvel Studios)

2019 is a big — no, a huge year for a couple of pop culture’s most beloved franchises. Over the past decade and change, the juggernaut Marvel Cinematic Universe has unleashed 21 blockbuster movies held together by a few common threads, and on April 26, one of those threads will come to a glorious, three-hour-long, action- and drama-filled conclusion in Avengers: Endgame. On the small screen, HBO struck Lannister gold when its adaptation of George R.R. Martin’s popular A Song of Ice and Fire fantasy novel series, Game of Thrones, debuted in 2011 and became a global hit. On April 14, the much anticipated eighth and final season premieres — it’s been over a year and a half since season 7! — and viewers are understandably eager to find out how the saga will end.

Thankfully, those of us who have followed along with both journeys haven’t been forced to choose between the two, barring any unforeseen circumstances, and most everyone who wants to see both Thanos and the Night King defeated should be able to do so. But what if you were forced to choose? What if you could only watch Avengers: Endgame or the final season of Game of Thrones? Which would you sacrifice, and which would you see? We had two RT staffers maker their case, and then you can vote below and make your case in the comments.

I Choose Game of Thrones

(Photo by HBO)

The Marvel movies are great entertainment, and I have a blast every time I go to see one, but I just don’t have the same kind of emotional investment in the Avengers that I do in the fates of Dany, Tyrion, Jon, and the Starks. Game of Thrones did such a spectacular job of taking each of them through their individual character arcs and then bringing them all back together again — and, in the case of Daenerys, introducing her to the others — that I just couldn’t not find out what happens to them. Robert Downey Jr., Chris Evans, and the other big players in the MCU who are done or close to done playing their roles will absolutely be missed, and their characters have been fun to watch, but their stories aren’t nearly as significantly intertwined as the characters’ stories in Game of Thrones are. Plus, we’re talking about seven-plus hours of storytelling in Thrones‘ final season; that’s more than double the length of Endgame, which is admittedly a long movie that will likely feature some definitive moments for the franchise… but that franchise will ultimately continue on. After season 8, Game of Thrones as we know it will be done, and no, the prequels do not count. At the end of the day, as sprawling as Game of Thrones has been at times, it’s still a more complete, more focused story than the MCU as a whole has been, so I’d be way more sad about missing the final season than I would be about missing Endgame.

I Choose Avengers: Endgame

Marvel Studios
(Photo by Marvel Studios)

We’ve never seen big-screen storytelling like we’ve gotten with Marvel’s literally game-changing “Cinematic Universe.” As a fan of the comics, it’s been thrilling to see some of their marquee characters brought to life with such style and craft by some of Hollywood’s brightest stars and best talents behind the camera. As a child, I never would have dreamed that a bunch of superheroes would rule the movies, but here we are, and the ride has been amazing. Robert Downey Jr., of course, turned out to be the perfect Tony Stark, and whatever else he does after this, he’ll forever be remembered for that role, so it’s unthinkable to me that I might miss his inevitable departure from the franchise. The same goes for Chris Evans’ Steve Rogers. Plus, I practically grew up with these characters, watching them on their individual journeys and cheering when they were allowed to share screen time. Marvel was also really smart about the way they seeded the Thanos storyline, beginning with his appearance in the first Avengers movie’s mid-credits stinger — remember that? — and leading all the way up to Avengers: Infinity War. This is the battle I’ve been waiting years to see, and I’m not about to miss it, not only because it promises to be an epic one for the ages, but also because it will probably serve as the swan song for some of Hollywood’s most beloved big-screen characters. Don’t get me wrong; I love Game of Thrones too, but I’ve invested over a decade of my life in these movies and these characters, and I am looking forward to Endgame like no other movie I can recall in recent memory.

Tag Cloud

Rock San Diego Comic-Con Mindy Kaling Showtime toy story FX Awards cults talk show dragons CBS MSNBC Fantasy HBO mockumentary police drama NBC docudrama IFC crime drama politics Disney Channel Action festivals crime thriller FOX VICE Vudu Comics on TV Winners MCU Sundance romance cooking See It Skip It The CW Masterpiece Columbia Pictures composers MTV Interview TV TNT 2016 robots Reality diversity National Geographic Freeform Walt Disney Pictures Star Wars Nickelodeon Lucasfilm sequel TruTV green book casting binge Sneak Peek PBS Infographic travel Sci-Fi Red Carpet APB Chilling Adventures of Sabrina finale animated unscripted CW Seed Thanksgiving Shondaland A&E Fox News 2018 teaser technology Spring TV supernatural YouTube Red Logo Lifetime Shudder 45 natural history Chernobyl Paramount Network 21st Century Fox strong female leads Mystery Election Cannes comiccon Starz NYCC hist ABC facebook Pride Month CBS All Access Holidays Adult Swim Rocky Marvel E! Teen witnail vampires Set visit Opinion Film Festival SDCC Schedule Star Trek anime First Look Quiz spinoff Mary Tyler Moore cops Comedy Central Drama Animation harry potter Amazon true crime Nat Geo SundanceTV medical drama Crackle Trophy Talk Premiere Dates disaster 2019 Tarantino Warner Bros. nature Ovation Certified Fresh Awards Tour Netflix boxoffice GoT richard e. Grant TBS dceu Oscars Black Mirror YouTube Premium transformers comic Tomatazos serial killer RT History psycho spy thriller Watching Series science fiction Box Office based on movie Extras Heroines LGBT war PaleyFest award winner Biopics Rocketman Universal Syfy IFC Films Amazon Prime miniseries 20th Century Fox TCA Pixar Mary Poppins Returns Pop spider-man GLAAD Creative Arts Emmys DirecTV Elton John Britbox Kids & Family zombie 24 frames jamie lee curtis dramedy streaming Superheroe Epix Photos Trivia CMT anthology cinemax Cosplay TCM FXX Mudbound space DC Comics E3 Comedy BET Comic Book social media Food Network political drama Apple Cartoon Network Summer VH1 Polls and Games Calendar TCA 2017 Year in Review Stephen King BBC BBC America golden globes Song of Ice and Fire Countdown CNN Emmys Hulu Super Bowl Dark Horse Comics Sundance Now Mary poppins television ESPN YA adaptation Western History Trailer historical drama Reality Competition Toys thriller Horror DC streaming service singing competition what to watch New York Comic Con 2017 OWN Martial Arts American Society of Cinematographers Acorn TV elevated horror ITV Podcast Ghostbusters X-Men Musical crime President aliens ratings adventure Disney Superheroes sitcom Video Games RT21 Christmas Nominations Valentine's Day biography DGA LGBTQ 007 Tumblr Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pet Sematary zombies Ellie Kemper Spike DC Universe Rom-Com Brie Larson El Rey justice league Best and Worst TV Land ABC Family theme song Musicals Sony Pictures Marathons Anna Paquin Country USA The Witch Winter TV Bravo GIFs Music blaxploitation Character Guide USA Network Women's History Month cats AMC TLC TIFF WGN 2015 Esquire game show Grammys Writers Guild of America Lionsgate dc discovery period drama Paramount Captain marvel Pirates crossover psychological thriller zero dark thirty The Arrangement doctor who Fall TV Spectrum Originals SXSW sports mutant