Critics Consensus

Dumbo Is Visually Impressive but Falls a Little Flat

Plus, season 1 of What We Do in the Shadows is Certified Fresh, Hotel Mumbai is appropriately intense, and The Beach Bum is alright, alright, alright.

by | March 28, 2019 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a Disney remake (Dumbo, starring Michael Keaton and Colin Farrell), real-life terror (Hotel Mumbai, starring Dev Patel and Armie Hammer), a destructive deadbeat (The Beach Bum, starring Matthew McConaughey and Isla Fisher), and a change of heart (Unplanned, starring Ashley Bratcher). What are the critics saying?


Dumbo (2019) 47%

In case you haven’t been paying attention these past few years, Disney has gone full steam ahead with a plan to reimagine their library of classic animated fare as live-action films. The results, as expected, have been somewhat mixed, but 2019 is shaping up to be a big year for the endeavor, with remakes of The Lion King, Aladdin, and this week’s big release, Dumbo. Directed by Tim Burton (who also helmed the studio’s do-over of Alice in Wonderland), the film stars an impressive ensemble that includes Michael Keaton, Eva Green, Colin Farrell, Danny DeVito, and Alan Arkin, almost all of whom have worked with Burton before. Of course, the star of the show is the titular elephant, gloriously rendered in CGI, whose unlikely gift of flight (thanks to his oversized ears) makes him an instant celebrity and draws the attention of a circus owner with potentially dark secrets. Unfortunately, despite a handful of magical moments and a wealth of eye-popping visuals, critics say the new Dumbo pales in comparison to the original, and its narrative embellishments don’t quite do enough to make up the difference. That said, the film is earnest in its intentions, and if there’s anyone who can sympathize with the plight of an outcast, it’s Tim Burton, so it’s not all bad news here.


Hotel Mumbai (2019) 75%

It’s rather difficult to make a film about a real-life terrorist attack that doesn’t devolve into outright exploitation, particularly if you’re trying to wring thrills out of the experience for your moviegoing audience. Fortunately, most critics feel that Hotel Mumbai does a pretty respectable — and respectful — job. In November of 2008, 10 Islamic terrorists from Pakistan opened fire in multiple public locations in Mumbai, India, scattering panicked citizens and tourists across the city. Some of them ended up at the historic Taj Mahal Palace Hotel, where the attackers managed to find their way inside and continue the carnage. Hotel Mumbai stars Dev Patel, Armie Hammer, Nazanin Boniadi, Jason Isaacs, and legendary Indian actor Anupam Kher as various employees and guests of the hotel, who banded together in hopes of surviving the ordeal, and critics say the film succeeds in putting viewers in their shoes. At points, it’s almost too effective, and it can be a difficult watch for some, but it makes for a fairly harrowing experience, even if some of the fictionalized elements aren’t particularly well-considered.


The Beach Bum (2019) 55%

Harmony Korine has been making audiences feel icky and weird ever since he wrote Larry Clark’s Kids in 1995, but it wasn’t until 2013’s Spring Breakers that he had anything close to what one might call “mainstream success.” That movie benefited from the star power of James Franco, Selena Gomez, and Vanessa Hudgens, and for his follow-up, Korine has recruited Oscar winner Matthew McConaughey to make everyone feel kind of icky and weird all over again. The Beach Bum centers on a poet named Moondog who spends his time on Florida beaches drinking, doing drugs, and bedding women. He can do this because, despite his raggedy appearance, he’s earned something of a small fortune from his writing, but when he decides to reunite with his wife to attend their daughter’s wedding, he quickly proves why he doesn’t belong in polite society. Critics say the film comes with Korine’s unique stylistic flair, and star McConaughey seems born to play Moondog, but there a few too many plot detours and, despite the brazen hedonism on display, it all feels uncharacteristically — and even, at times, tiresomely — tame. There are certainly wacky moments to enjoy, but Korine’s films have never appealed to a particularly wide audience, so it’s likely to please those who know what they’re getting into and puzzle everyone else.


Unplanned (2019) 40%

In this week’s second film based on true events, we have the sophomore directorial effort of Cary Solomon and Chuck Konzelman, who might be best known as the writers/producers of the God’s Not Dead franchise. Here, they tell the story of Abby Johnson (played by Ashley Bratcher), a one-time director of a Planned Parenthood clinic who, after witnessing an abortion, dramatically shifted her perspective and became an ardent anti-abortion activist. We would love to tell you what the critics think of Unplanned, but it wasn’t widely screened for critics, which of course means it’s time for you to guess the Tomatometer!


What’s New on TV

What We Do in the Shadows: Season 1 (2019) 94%

Delightfully absurd and ridiculously fun, What We Do in the Shadows expands on the film’s vampiric lore and finds fresh perspective in its charming, off-kilter cast to create a mockumentary series worth sinking your teeth into.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Slut in a Good Way (Charlotte a du fun) (2019) , a coming-of-age film about three teenage girls working their first summer jobs, is at 100%.
  • Diane (2019) , a drama about an aging woman attempting to reconcile her past, is at 96%.
  • Working Woman (2019) , about a young mother and wife who returns to the workplace and struggles with her newfound success, is at 95%.
  • A Vigilante (2019) , starring Olivia Wilde as a woman who punishes abusive husbands as she hunts for her own abusive ex, is at 93%.
  • Screwball (2019) , a documentary look at the performance-enhancing drug scandal that struck American baseball in 2014, is at 91%.
  • The Brink (2019) , a documentary about Steve Bannon’s role in the 2018 U.S. midterm elections, is at 83%.

Tag Cloud

Fantasy YA ABC canceled Box Office sequel Captain marvel adventure LGBT VH1 VICE Superheroes SDCC Extras zero dark thirty robots PBS Disney Channel Apple TV+ 2015 ghosts Apple TV Plus Syfy breaking bad Paramount TCM Turner Classic Movies hispanic video technology streaming strong female leads spinoff transformers NYCC Lifetime casting christmas movies crossover Family cinemax mutant 20th Century Fox biography CNN game of thrones Pet Sematary Star Wars Kids & Family Spring TV Vudu award winner TCA 2017 Cannes thriller cartoon First Look Freeform zombie Mary poppins BBC anime DC Universe TruTV natural history Fall TV Teen USA Sony Pictures free movies movies Emmy Nominations Bravo Disney streaming service New York Comic Con Photos Rocketman rotten movies we love Nickelodeon Awards Tour Trophy Talk Amazon Prime foreign Christmas YouTube Crunchyroll cancelled TV shows Polls and Games MCU TV renewals comic Set visit ABC Family Turner Nat Geo social media 2016 theme song series romance TLC Marathons latino YouTube Red Arrowverse Cosplay CBS screenings travel war Toys miniseries Binge Guide MTV zombies Winter TV Sneak Peek Star Trek Red Carpet Premiere Dates TIFF Television Academy south america green book Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt slashers Lionsgate Rom-Com E! 2017 Schedule Ellie Kemper composers Disney+ Disney Plus political drama Mystery Biopics Oscars The CW Chernobyl Watching Series richard e. Grant Stephen King batman Sundance docudrama psychological thriller serial killer SXSW LGBTQ Best and Worst Spike RT21 A&E spy thriller cars disaster crime thriller History Sci-Fi El Rey Comics on TV Thanksgiving Hallmark Christmas movies TNT San Diego Comic-Con Amazon Logo tv talk Opinion aliens WGN television See It Skip It elevated horror DC Comics Hulu Marvel psycho HBO Chilling Adventures of Sabrina festivals comiccon Amazon Prime Video Marvel Studios Ghostbusters Grammys renewed TV shows space Horror Character Guide Drama 71st Emmy Awards cancelled Rock Columbia Pictures Ovation blockbuster CBS All Access period drama National Geographic Trivia Netflix Christmas movies Creative Arts Emmys Mary Tyler Moore Epix Fox News Trailer Walt Disney Pictures toy story facebook BET Rocky Pop 007 Tomatazos halloween Reality USA Network Crackle spanish language witnail Mary Poppins Returns Song of Ice and Fire 2018 kids The Purge cancelled TV series Adult Swim Dark Horse Comics Infographic book TCA medical drama Paramount Network GLAAD discovery TBS Calendar X-Men SundanceTV Pride Month harry potter cats GIFs romantic comedy nature Holidays Music dramedy RT History Tumblr IFC Films FXX Britbox Mindy Kaling Awards Brie Larson NBC Masterpiece animated American Society of Cinematographers Starz IFC GoT children's TV Valentine's Day Tarantino ESPN Pirates OWN teaser Podcast WarnerMedia Certified Fresh game show indie sitcom Esquire anthology binge Lifetime Christmas movies Food Network Comedy crime drama Anna Paquin cooking Hallmark hist Mudbound YouTube Premium Interview HBO Max President Election dceu Country Women's History Month quibi 21st Century Fox canceled TV shows unscripted Video Games doctor who what to watch cults Writers Guild of America boxoffice stand-up comedy diversity First Reviews cancelled television Elton John Summer FOX Western blaxploitation ITV Quiz dragons joker Universal spain Winners Marvel Television Nominations 45 The Witch adaptation Black Mirror Pixar Film Festival historical drama The Walking Dead finale E3 Disney Plus FX APB cops talk show golden globes Heroines Holiday Martial Arts Comedy Central CW Seed Showtime science fiction Musical mockumentary DC streaming service sports Cartoon Network Animation Apple Sundance Now supernatural Classic Film Action Musicals Lucasfilm crime PaleyFest TV Land Year in Review independent CMT vampires police drama 2019 Disney Comic Book Emmys versus Countdown 24 frames Shudder Shondaland politics Superheroe based on movie true crime A24 The Arrangement ratings BBC America spider-man TV revenge Acorn TV Super Bowl AMC werewolf comics Spectrum Originals singing competition DGA Reality Competition DirecTV MSNBC dc Warner Bros. justice league Netflix Film jamie lee curtis Peacock