Don't Look Up First Reviews: Armageddon With a Brain

Critics say Adam McKay's latest satire is a bit heavy-handed and hits too close to home, but it succeeds on the strength of its reliable A-list cast and some genuinely funny gags.

by | December 8, 2021 | Comments

From Adam McKay, the Oscar-winning filmmaker who gave us Anchorman and The Big Short, comes an all-star ensemble disaster flick with a satirical bent. Don’t Look Up follows a pair of scientists (played by Leonardo DiCaprio and Jennifer Lawrence) who discover an enormous comet heading towards Earth but can’t convince enough of the planet to care.

According to the first reviews, the movie itself is a near miss, but a good enough hit in the laughs and casting departments, particularly when it comes to Meryl Streep as the President of the United States. Even many of the negative takes offer praises for the performances and much of McKay’s jokes, though everyone agrees the situation of the comedy is too familiar right now.

Here’s what critics are saying about Don’t Look Up:

Is Don’t Look Up essential viewing?

This is the star-studded, scabrous, scathing political and social satire the world needs right now. – James Croot,

A popcorn movie about climate change that will hopefully have an impact like the one the characters are warning everyone about. – Germain Lussier,

Don’t Look Up is one of the best pictures this year. – Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

Wasted time isn’t merely the function of McKay’s ultra-depressing farce, it’s also the central focus of a film that begs viewers to do something better with the time they have left. – David Ehrlich, IndieWire

Does it hit too close to home?

It is extremely believable that if this same situation occurred, and it could, the results would be the same. And that is scary. – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Don’t Look Up has the misfortune of being too prophetic. – David Ehrlich, IndieWire

The commentary is disturbingly relevant but so funny that the audience can still enjoy watching it. – Nicole Ackman, Your Money Geek

Meryl Streep in Don't Look Up

(Photo by Niko Tavernise/Netflix)

Will Adam McKay fans enjoy it?

Don’t Look Up is, by far, the strongest, most searing piece of cinema writer/director Adam McKay has put before us. – Douglas Davidson, Elements of Madness

I would easily consider Don’t Look Up to be my favorite of McKay’s films. – Nicole Ackman, Your Money Geek

Adam McKay’s satire about our current facts-averse political divide and incompetent government is his best yet. – Nathaniel Rogers, The Film Experience

McKay detractors won’t be converted, but fans of his flicks are in for another smart and vicious treat. – Joey Magidson, Awards Radar

How does it compare to other disaster movies?

Don’t Look Up is a better movie than those of that ilk. – Bill Goodykoontz, Arizona Republic

The film is the ultimate disaster movie, timely in its subject matter and ambitious in its execution. – Mae Abdulbaki, Screen Rant

Don’t Look Up is essentially Deep Impact played for yuks, Armageddon if it had a brain. – Ian Freer, Empire Magazine

As executed, Don’t Look Up plays like the leftie answer to Armageddon. – Peter Debruge, Variety

Does it work as satire?

In his political wheelhouse, McKay’s satire feels both too funny to be true and spot-on. – Ian Freer, Empire Magazine

Don’t Look Up is likely to go down as this generation’s Dr. Strangelove. – James Croot,

Dr. Strangelove it ain’t. – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

It feels less like satire and more like an unfortunate prediction for how America would handle a situation like this. – Nicole Ackman, Your Money Geek

Cate Blanchett and Tyler Perry in Don't Look Up

(Photo by Niko Tavernise/Netflix)

How funny is it?

Laugh out loud hysterical. – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Don’t Look Up might be the funniest movie of 2021. – Mick LaSalle, San Francisco Chronicle

Genuinely much funnier than McKay’s other prestige films, if chiefly due to excellent comedic performances. – Ethan Vestby, The Film Stage

The film is often very amusing – perhaps proving that McKay is still at his best as a director of straightforward comedy. – Peter Cremona, Radio Times

Never hilarious. It’s simply consistently amusing. – Sean Mulvihill, FanboyNation

Will you feel other things as you watch it?

I was in a mixture of shock and horror until I was, ultimately, in tears. – Douglas Davidson, Elements of Madness

This McKay film is more than its punchline. There’s real heart here. – Robert Daniels, Inverse

Don’t Look Up sure takes you on an emotional journey. – Andrew Webster, The Verge

McKay can’t decide whether he wants to amuse or upset us. – Peter Debruge, Variety

Leonardo DiCaprio in Don't Look Up

(Photo by Niko Tavernise/Netflix)

How is Leonardo DiCaprio?

It’s not the most impressive work he’s ever done, but it’s a reminder that he can excel in a role that downplays his movie-star charisma. – Nicole Ackman, Your Money Geek

Another reminder that he ought to do more comedies. – Nathaniel Rogers, The Film Experience

It’s an Oscar-worthy performance for DiCaprio! – Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

DiCaprio seemingly should have a good shot [at] Best Actor. – Joey Magidson, Awards Radar

What about the rest of the ensemble cast?

This movie is stacked with talent… everyone brings it. – Andrew Webster, The Verge

One of the best ensemble casts ever… on the same level as It’s A Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World. – Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

There’s not a bad performance in the movie, and it really proves that Adam McKay is one of the better actors’ directors working today. – Sean Mulvihill, FanboyNation

If there were Oscars given for casting (sort it, Academy), Francine Maisler would be a shoo-in for the 2022 gong. – Ian Freer, Empire Magazine

Meryl Streep and Mark Rylance in Don't Look Up

(Photo by Niko Tavernise/Netflix)

Are there any standouts?

Streep is a riot as a clueless President, while [Jonah] Hill steals every scene he is in. – Pete Hammond, Deadline

The MVP though is Mark Rylance…a transformative performance that sees Rylance steal every scene he’s in, and it’s a testament to him that however weird it gets, it still feels horrifyingly authentic. – Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

The cast is nothing short of sensational, with Mark Rylance, as a Steve Jobs-like tech genius who plans to profit from the comet, particularly brilliant. – James Mottram, South China Morning Post

Hopefully this will be the first of many film collaborations for Streep and Rylance, because they’re a scrumptious combo. – Charlotte O’Sullivan, London Evening Standard

Melanie Lynskey is low-key brilliant.David Ehrlich, IndieWire

Does it go on a bit too long?

It stretches on perhaps a little too long — the movie clocks in at nearly two and a half hours — but the journey Don’t Look Up takes viewers on is mesmerizing. – Andrew Webster, The Verge

While the middle of the film drags a bit, it is able to keep the audience engaged with its fast-paced dialogue and editing. – Nicole Ackman, Your Money Geek

This ensemble cast is so good at what they do, that they propel the story forward and keep the pacing going so that it never really drags. – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

Will you want to see it more than once?

Don’t Look Up is a film that only improves with each viewing. I’ve seen it twice now and it gets better each time. – Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

Nightmare Alley is in theaters on December 10, 2021 and streaming on Netflix on December 24, 2021.

Thumbnail image by Niko Tavernise/Netflix

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

mcc Calendar YouTube Netflix Universal archives SXSW Travel Channel breaking bad Pop TV Stephen King telelvision revenge asian-american political drama PaleyFest E3 batman Syfy rom-coms Baby Yoda Paramount Pictures adenture Pride Month Pet Sematary Peacock Red Carpet Sci-Fi blaxploitation Epix Podcast Marvel comics game of thrones documentary discovery elevated horror police drama Paramount critic resources Avengers Academy Awards fresh BET Awards Pixar Premiere Dates new zealand aapi streaming movies green book reviews gangster television japan Cosplay saw wonder woman Fargo Star Wars royal family Character Guide Nickelodeon king kong Tubi Binge Guide Schedule A&E new york 93rd Oscars Cannes Mary Poppins Returns Comic Book halloween tv sopranos zombies VOD Extras DGA franchise satire dragons adaptation Watching Series Nominations YouTube Premium Spectrum Originals werewolf scorecard remakes scary movies rotten TV movies kaiju 2021 jamie lee curtis Star Trek suspense foreign TNT Best Actor tv talk National Geographic Set visit The Purge Winners sag awards french Masterpiece summer TV preview interviews hispanic heritage month DC Comics YouTube Red New York Comic Con popular docudrama chucky SundanceTV Disney Channel TCA Winter 2020 Starz WGN diversity documentaries GLAAD cancelled TV series spy thriller nbcuniversal critics FX on Hulu movies Mindy Kaling The Walking Dead The Academy 71st Emmy Awards Hallmark Christmas movies Amazon Prime spanish trailers Drama legend Logo History Animation target Spring TV twilight E! Tarantino AMC Plus supernatural President Quiz Television Academy ABC Family toronto Rocketman Arrowverse Disney streaming service Women's History Month dexter hidden camera biography First Reviews Broadway Black History Month films know your critic Neflix 2017 sequels Acorn TV FX based on movie CBS Apple razzies sitcom travel OWN The Walt Disney Company crossover cults Best and Worst X-Men Sundance TV 45 Hear Us Out Anna Paquin HBO Max latino Biopics Sony comedies Television Critics Association cars Disney+ Disney Plus PlayStation posters Focus Features Rocky romance comic books Disney CMT ITV stop motion Vudu justice league Lucasfilm Marvel Studios Sneak Peek Creative Arts Emmys war Thanksgiving ghosts Pirates all-time Shondaland TV romantic comedy Fox Searchlight 21st Century Fox Lifetime Christmas movies cats vampires Disney Plus Comedy Central directors MCU USA harry potter james bond Spike Britbox Emmys DirecTV rt archives Cartoon Network indie Box Office biopic WarnerMedia Best Director HBO Go PBS superhero Amazon Prime Video GIFs video on demand HBO movie action-comedy women Heroines TLC hollywood Christmas 73rd Emmy Awards parents disaster VH1 cartoon crime thriller science fiction vs. Summer halloween kids Infographic psycho Rom-Com Lionsgate emmy awards Marathons Funimation Photos live event Certified Fresh anime BBC America NBC scene in color Best Picture mockumentary hist TBS FOX The CW ID live action Tumblr fast and furious what to watch stand-up comedy basketball series Oscars 20th Century Fox golden globes First Look toy story Martial Arts DC streaming service The Witch unscripted 2015 natural history Nat Geo Universal Pictures ratings Exclusive Video Family venice Best Actress 2016 robots australia Oscar LGBT Pacific Islander black comedy Alien dramedy japanese Valentine's Day A24 screenings rt labs versus Trophy Talk Action renewed TV shows prank Marvel Television Instagram Live psychological thriller BBC children's TV cancelled Holidays streaming die hard 79th Golden Globes Awards Comedy theme song quibi ESPN jurassic park lord of the rings genre Toys Mudbound Mystery south america concert Amazon Studios canceled Sundance Now 99% cinemax 24 frames Discovery Channel OneApp Wes Anderson teaser Reality Competition animated SXSW 2022 Musicals APB comiccon El Rey Fox News rotten movies we love NYCC name the review a nightmare on elm street Walt Disney Pictures art house YA Film Festival free movies Film Star Wars Celebration adventure Trailer news cops Lifetime streamig obituary sports TCA IFC Classic Film summer TV docuseries Legendary Apple TV+ Year in Review AMC 72 Emmy Awards Fantasy Comic-Con@Home 2021 CBS All Access 2020 kong deadpool child's play SDCC TV Land BET worst Black Mirror Image Comics Awards summer preview blockbusters laika marvel comics international Trivia composers The Arrangement Holiday Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TV One Rock South by Southwest Film Festival Tomatazos LGBTQ Crackle Mary Tyler Moore boxing facebook boxoffice canceled TV shows dceu trophy Esquire politics Ellie Kemper screen actors guild worst movies Super Bowl ABC crime drama dogs singing competition doctor who independent MTV Polls and Games TCM true crime Election BAFTA Emmy Nominations mob richard e. Grant reboot Apple TV Plus Comics on TV San Diego Comic-Con obi wan Endgame zombie Freeform Winter TV space 90s football Paramount Network black sequel golden globe awards MGM Opinion Grammys Amazon nfl Showtime book adaptation 2019 MSNBC RT History TCA 2017 rt labs critics edition spider-verse leaderboard cooking TIFF slashers Video Games talk show video Elton John dark ABC Signature Dark Horse Comics USA Network Fall TV Sony Pictures Netflix Christmas movies stoner 2018 BBC One Ovation transformers TCA Awards DC Universe spinoff heist movie dreamworks best hispanic 1990s 4/20 criterion FXX historical drama Ghostbusters Superheroe comic American Society of Cinematographers medical drama blockbuster Hallmark Pop CNN new star wars movies witnail period drama anthology festivals spain Awards Tour TruTV Countdown Shudder dc Hulu spider-man Captain marvel Chernobyl comic book movies Superheroes binge Warner Bros. classics Horror Tags: Comedy debate zero dark thirty IFC Films Adult Swim Turner Classic Movies Musical Interview Paramount Plus monster movies VICE young adult Western indiana jones olympics Music christmas movies See It Skip It feel good miniseries universal monsters CW Seed Teen mission: impossible cancelled TV shows game show casting Crunchyroll technology king arthur aliens Turner 94th Oscars Kids & Family high school festival Reality 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Sundance marvel cinematic universe finale crime award winner social media Tokyo Olympics scary Country NBA slasher Columbia Pictures Hollywood Foreign Press Association thriller RT21 TV renewals cancelled television 007 nature italian mutant spanish language superman pirates of the caribbean Bravo book broadcast Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Song of Ice and Fire joker Mary poppins comic book movie serial killer Brie Larson strong female leads Food Network IMDb TV GoT Prime Video HFPA godzilla ViacomCBS Writers Guild of America