Total Recall

Definitive Seth Rogen Performances

In this week's Total Recall, we look back at the roles that helped define the Neighbors 2: Sorority Rising star's career.

by | May 18, 2016 | Comments

With this weekend’s Neighbors 2: Sorority Rising, Seth Rogen continues a busy year that started with Kung Fu Panda 3 and will find him returning to theaters in just a few short weeks with the animated Sausage Party. In honor of all that activity — and a filmography that’s grown by leaps and bounds over the last decade — we decided to dedicate this week to taking a fond look back at some of the hardworking Mr. Rogen’s best-loved efforts. It’s time for Total Recall!

Freaks and Geeks 100%

Unlike a lot of actors who end up starring in films or TV shows about high school students, Rogen was still just a teenager when he responded to the casting call for Judd Apatow’s Freaks and Geeks. It turned out to be a fateful decision: landing the role of Ken Miller on the sadly short-lived series led to a productive friendship with Apatow, who offered Rogen a role in his follow-up show, Undeclared, and then absorbed him into his so-called comedic “frat pack” after that series also met an untimely end. For Rogen fans who want an early look at the future star in his formative years, Freaks and Geeks and Undeclared offer a glimpse of what was to come — and for the rest of us, it’s just really entertaining television.

Watch Trailer

The 40 Year Old Virgin (2005) 85%

The R-rated comedy went through some lean years in the 1990s and early 2000s, but by the middle of the decade, studios were willing to bet on grown-ups wanting to laugh again, and Judd Apatow — and, in turn, Seth Rogen — gave them plenty to laugh at, starting with 2005’s The 40-Year-Old Virgin. Rogen plays second fiddle here, appearing as a pot-smoking friend and co-worker to Steve Carell’s titular paragon of chastity, but this is no ordinary supporting role — not only does he get some of the movie’s most memorable lines (including a particularly quote-friendly exchange with Paul Rudd’s character), but he earned a production credit on the film, showing some of the behind-the-scenes acumen that has helped make him more of a budding mogul than your average 26-year-old movie star. Whether or not people went to see it for Rogen, The 40-Year-Old Virgin was a huge hit, making more than $175 million at the box office, and critics enjoyed it too: The Globe and Mail’s Jason Anderson spoke for many of his peers when he wrote, “If only losing it was so good for everybody.”

Watch Trailer

Knocked Up (2007) 89%

Two years after helping Steve Carell break a 40-year streak of sexual inactivity, Seth Rogen played a character on the verge of a different sort of threshold — namely, fatherhood — in Knocked Up. The movie also presented a career Rubicon of sorts for Rogen; after playing a secondary character in Virgin, he moved into the ranks of unconventional comedic leading men with Knocked Up, starring opposite Katherine Heigl as the ambition-deficient half of a couple thrown together by the unplanned results of a one-night stand. It was Rogen’s fourth project with Judd Apatow, and the basic, seemingly effortless likability that the director had seen in his star since their Freaks and Geeks days resonated with audiences — to the tune of nearly $220 million in box office receipts — and helped earn Knocked Up some of the best reviews of the year. Salon’s Stephanie Zacharek was one of the many critics who found it Fresh, praising what she saw as “a picture that refuses to fetishize either the ability to conceive or the significance of our place in the universe once we’ve done so.”

Watch Trailer

Superbad (2007) 88%

It isn’t at all uncommon for high school buddies to daydream about growing up and making it big together — or for aspiring screenwriters to pen their first scripts before they’re old enough to vote. Most of them don’t have the patience to nurture an idea for over a decade, or the luck necessary to take your idea to the box office — but that’s exactly what Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg did with Superbad. Of course, it didn’t hurt having a pair of leads as buzz-friendly as Jonah Hill and Michael Cera, or being able to introduce Christopher Mintz-Plasse as the one and only McLovin — but Superbad‘s real strength lies in the way Rogen and Goldberg’s sweetly funny script blends honest moments with gross-out gags and absurdist humor (including a surreal extended cameo from Rogen and Bill Hader as a pair of spectacularly incompetent police officers). At 87 percent on the Tomatometer, Superbad received no shortage of love from critics like Roger Ebert, who pronounced it “A four-letter raunch-a-rama with a heart.”

Watch Trailer

Pineapple Express (2008) 68%

After channeling the spirit of the 1980s teen comedy for Superbad, Rogen and his screenwriting partner revisited another of the decade’s favorite genres for Pineapple Express: the action buddy comedy. It was marketed as a stoner comedy, and while it certainly contained a fair amount of weed-themed humor, Express was essentially an homage to such squabbling-friends-in-peril classics as Stir Crazy and Running Scared — although it bears pointing out that none of those movies had the benefit of a brief, spectacularly profane appearance by Ed Begley, Jr. Critics weren’t unanimous in their support of the $101 million hit, which starred Rogen and James Franco as a ganja-loving process server and his dealer on the run from a lunatic crimelord — and the theme song, sadly, did not result in a “Back in Time”-sized hit for Huey Lewis — but most scribes agreed with TIME’s Richard Corliss, who deemed Express “A comedy that brings a nicely deflating note of realism to action-film mayhem, as well as being one of the few drug movies you don’t have to be high to enjoy.”

Watch Trailer

50/50 (2011) 93%

Cancer, generally speaking, isn’t all that funny. So kudos to screenwriter Will Reiser for finding the humor in his own diagnosis — and then using the experience as the grist for 50/50, a dramedy about a pair of best pals (played by Rogen and Joseph Gordon-Levitt) whose relationship is irrevocably altered after one of them learns he has cancer. Director Jonathan Levine’s deft handling of the story’s tonal shifts keeps the movie from straining for laughs or straying into mawkish territory, while Rogen offers able support for Gordon-Levitt as the best friend of a guy who’s fighting for his life. “What ensues is Beaches meets Pineapple Express,” wrote Mary Elizabeth Williams for Salon. “Which, I’ve got to tell you, is pretty much what living with cancer is like.”

Watch Trailer

Take This Waltz (2012) 79%

Although he’ll probably always be best known for his comedic roles, Rogen’s a fine dramatic actor when given the opportunity. Case in point: 2012’s Take This Waltz, a quiet look at domestic ennui from director Sarah Polley. Here, Rogen stars as Lou Rubin, a guy whose seemingly idyllic marriage to freelance writer Margot (Michelle Williams) is knocked off its axis after she finds herself drawn to their neighbor (Luke Kirby). “In the end,” wrote Michael O’Sullivan for the Washington Post, “it’s a story of misplaced faith. In what? Not love exactly, but in the rush of infatuation, and the illusion that this feeling can be maintained, indefinitely, without crashing.”

Watch Trailer

This Is the End (2013) 83%

We’ve seen plenty of movies about the end of civilization, but they’ve all focused on the apocalyptic problems of ordinary people while neglecting to imagine what those last few days on earth might be like for celebrities. Enter This Is the End, which imagines what it might be like if disaster struck Los Angeles while James Franco was hosting a house party. Featuring Franco, Rogen, Jay Baruchel, Jonah Hill, Craig Robinson, and Danny McBride — among plenty of others — playing fictionalized (and generally obnoxious) versions of themselves, it combines a fresh take on the apocalyptic comedy with the fun of watching movie stars make fun of themselves. As J.R. Jones argued for the Chicago Reader, “Their big joke is to literalize the Book of Revelations, but snaking around this is a biting contempt for the entertainment business, their own bad movies, and the social privilege these confer.”

Watch Trailer

Neighbors (2014) 73%

Neighbors is built from an assortment of parts that will be instantly familiar to anyone who’s ever seen a snobs-vs.-slobs R-rated comedy — yet the sum total works anyway, thanks to the efforts of director Nicholas Stoller and an overall charming cast. Rogen and Rose Byrne star as Mac and Kelly Radner, homeowners who decide to fight back after their lives are made miserable by the occupants of the frat house next door (led by Zac Efron), setting off a suburbanite battle that manages to gleefully offend while remembering to keep its characters somewhat identifiably human. As Betsy Sharkey put it for the Los Angeles Times, “This raunchy unrooting of a settled suburban idyll exposes the considerable angst of emerging adulthood with a kind of scatological fervor designed to elicit oodles of inappropriate laughs.”

Watch Trailer

Steve Jobs (2015) 85%

During the years following Steve Jobs’ death in 2011, the market was flooded with all manner of product devoted to analyzing the life and career of the Apple co-founder — to the point that, when Steve Jobs arrived in 2015, it might have seemed to many filmgoers like just another rehash of an already overfamiliar story. Which is unfortunate, because aside from its bad timing, this Danny Boyle-directed biopic has a lot going for it — including a script by Aaron Sorkin and an ace ensemble cast led by Michael Fassbender and supported by Kate Winslet, Jeff Daniels, and (as Jobs’ fellow Apple founder Steve Wozniak) Seth Rogen. “The dialogue crackles with wit, anger, and passion,” wrote James Berardinelli for ReelViews. “By matching Sorkin’s words with Boyle’s style and Fassbender’s talent, Steve Jobs has hit the trifecta.”

Watch Trailer

  • Gentle Robot

    1-10. Dirty Randy

  • Chris Hubble

    I would have added The Interview just because of the controversy it stirred up.

  • Dback

    He and Streisand play off each other beautifully as mother and son in “The Guilt Trip” even if the script is formulaic.

  • Jack Dee

    Zack and Miri is so underrated. Better than that garbage Pineapple Express, which is neither funny, nor stoner.

    Anyway, he is good for ensemble stuff, but he is not leading man material, like James Woods.

  • TomNewYorker

    My Top 10 favorite Seth Rogen Movies are

    1-Knocked Up
    2-Funny People
    3-Zack & Miri Make a Porno
    5-This Is The End
    6-Pineapple Express
    8-Observe & Report
    10-The Night Before

  • Noah Shepard

    I probably would have replaced Neighbors with The Interview. Just because how big that controversy was.

  • Marc Valenzuela

    I say Paul should’ve made the cut on this list (even though it was only a voice-over role for Rogen). It had witty humor provided by both him and British funny guys Simon Pegg and Nick Frost.

Tag Cloud

Video Games all-time anime PBS documentaries Women's History Month Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt scary movies Ovation war 21st Century Fox First Look TV renewals hispanic casting best TCM Countdown composers Music Trophy Talk Tarantino festivals Film Television Academy black docudrama 72 Emmy Awards social media Tubi 45 FX on Hulu theme song teaser scorecard Fall TV telelvision GoT chucky stand-up comedy Netflix Christmas movies zero dark thirty ESPN award winner Year in Review ID FOX E3 cancelled crossover a nightmare on elm street Funimation psychological thriller spy thriller 71st Emmy Awards fast and furious canceled TV shows Watching Series Ghostbusters TCA Awards video on demand Musicals cancelled TV shows ViacomCBS binge quibi period drama worst movies indiana jones Election SDCC video game of thrones blockbusters BET Awards godzilla X-Men Thanksgiving stop motion justice league directors Apple TV Plus Tumblr Pirates Baby Yoda 2021 Mary Poppins Returns rom-coms Nat Geo dogs Schedule Stephen King dceu cinemax SundanceTV Warner Bros. CW Seed Extras toronto movie OneApp dc natural history police drama Epix dragons streaming movies book Creative Arts Emmys Mary poppins Shondaland rotten Paramount Network VH1 cops spain zombie zombies facebook TNT Arrowverse Infographic space docuseries Oscars Acorn TV comic books See It Skip It History Sundance Now MCU El Rey Trivia Reality joker Britbox Mindy Kaling Summer worst trailers satire Pacific Islander HBO Photos Horror finale DC Comics Paramount Plus Logo Walt Disney Pictures RT21 Superheroe adaptation Ellie Kemper foreign Syfy Certified Fresh dark political drama Exclusive Video 24 frames 007 GLAAD live action talk show Sneak Peek green book series spanish jamie lee curtis technology comedies Anna Paquin The Witch Columbia Pictures based on movie south america archives discovery Comedy sequel unscripted sag awards halloween New York Comic Con DC Universe mockumentary spider-man Writers Guild of America Winners Podcast Sci-Fi transformers Chilling Adventures of Sabrina boxing psycho BBC America strong female leads universal monsters Comedy Central Tomatazos Classic Film boxoffice stoner Alien TV Land Travel Channel Western A24 Food Network revenge President Fox News hist Amazon Prime Video E! game show 93rd Oscars Disney streaming service cats Amazon Prime Peacock adventure Turner Classic Movies Sundance TV Valentine's Day Comic Book BBC Avengers WGN Endgame CBS new york Pixar Star Wars king kong cartoon Starz AMC Television Critics Association kaiju scene in color TV movies new star wars movies Vudu breaking bad Disney asian-american films Awards renewed TV shows Martial Arts anthology emmy awards lord of the rings Black Mirror remakes 20th Century Fox Disney+ Disney Plus criterion Netflix classics international Pet Sematary Marvel Studios IFC Films Academy Awards Marathons Lifetime Freeform Holidays tv talk cancelled television football italian Spectrum Originals aliens Drama ghosts laika halloween tv diversity Brie Larson Mary Tyler Moore slashers Lucasfilm 2020 Universal Nickelodeon superhero Family Character Guide TCA Winter 2020 2018 Kids & Family screenings nature Box Office parents ABC Hear Us Out politics Masterpiece Fox Searchlight Superheroes The Walking Dead Disney Channel RT History golden globe awards movies christmas movies Comics on TV documentary hidden camera aapi Action Binge Guide TCA crime drama japanese YouTube Red sitcom venice kids Pop TV Rocketman medical drama DC streaming service Trailer Christmas LGBTQ ITV Cosplay Awards Tour The Walt Disney Company FX reviews marvel cinematic universe children's TV true crime sports Biopics rt archives Rom-Com Quiz IFC MSNBC Super Bowl Legendary TruTV TV One Country die hard heist movie BBC One rotten movies we love Discovery Channel Amazon Studios pirates of the caribbean romantic comedy Bravo golden globes science fiction BET elevated horror cooking Turner Disney Plus 2017 HBO Go PaleyFest TLC Esquire Toys Calendar Grammys Broadway The Purge historical drama sequels what to watch werewolf crime Rock TV Red Carpet Cartoon Network USA obituary YA BAFTA television Mudbound Best and Worst Pride Month Spring TV SXSW fresh OWN 2016 First Reviews Star Trek concert Reality Competition ABC Signature comiccon LGBT monster movies cars cults child's play prank blaxploitation jurassic park james bond Rocky disaster VICE razzies women Winter TV TBS Emmys San Diego Comic-Con Musical travel Apple TV+ Cannes spanish language doctor who festival Interview french Adult Swim book adaptation reboot Paramount free movies The Arrangement comic APB witnail FXX hollywood Showtime USA Network Fantasy 2015 Hulu The Academy latino know your critic American Society of Cinematographers crime thriller batman Apple Animation romance Chernobyl Black History Month animated target MTV Hallmark NYCC new zealand mutant critics TIFF 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards GIFs biography 99% Captain marvel richard e. Grant Holiday Set visit Opinion twilight Film Festival spinoff comics harry potter indie Premiere Dates Nominations Hallmark Christmas movies Emmy Nominations Amazon CNN Pop mission: impossible DGA A&E independent Polls and Games serial killer saw australia cancelled TV series Crackle The CW Elton John CMT Spike kong Image Comics high school ratings Marvel Television toy story Heroines streaming YouTube Premium Dark Horse Comics canceled Marvel CBS All Access National Geographic blockbuster 2019 NBC supernatural TCA 2017 WarnerMedia name the review dramedy popular miniseries Shudder HBO Max Sony Pictures DirecTV YouTube VOD Song of Ice and Fire 4/20 ABC Family PlayStation Lifetime Christmas movies singing competition Crunchyroll nfl versus Teen franchise robots nbcuniversal vampires Mystery thriller news Lionsgate deadpool superman screen actors guild Sundance