Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Super 8 is Certified Fresh

Plus, Judy Moody is kind of a bummer, and Midnight in Paris is Certified Fresh.

by | June 10, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a close encounter (Super 8, starring Kyle Chandler and Elle Fanning), a quest for fun (Judy Moody and the NOT Bummer Summer, starring Jordana Beatty and Heather Graham), and a Gallic nostalgia trip (Midnight in Paris, starring Owen Wilson and Rachel McAdams). What do the critics have to say?

Super 8


With films like Jaws and Close Encounters of the Third Kind, Steven Spielberg altered the cinematic landscape by combining B-movie thrills with sophistication and emotional heft. Now, with Spielberg producing, J.J. Abrams tries something similar with Super 8, and critics say it’s a both an expert homage to old-school 1970s proto-blockbusters and an exciting, heartfelt thrill-ride in its own right. Super 8 is the tale of a group of youngsters who, while filming a homemade movie, witness a horrific train crash. When the citizens of their small town become unnerved by a series of unexplained disappearances, the kids begin to suspect the crash might not have been an accident — and it may have unleashed something unworldly upon their sleepy community. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Super 8 pulls off the neat trick of being both suspenseful and poignant, with strong performances and an uncanny sense of the story-driven power of Spielberg’s early classics. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Spielberg’s best productions.)

Judy Moody and the NOT Bummer Summer


It’s an old adage, but it’s one that bears repeating: sometimes, what works on the page falls flat on the screen. Take Judy Moody and the NOT Bummer Summer, for example: critics say this kiddie comedy — based upon the bestselling books by Megan McDonald — is an exercise in overblown whimsy that’s so manic it never slows down long enough to charm. Judy Moody is the tale of a precocious eight-year-old (played by Jordana Beatty) forced to spend the summer with her eccentric Aunt Opal (Heather Graham) when her parents and best friends leave town. But Judy’s got a plan, in the form of a checklist of adventures that, if achieved, count for “thrill points.” The pundits say that little kids might find some laughs in Judy Moody, but their parents and older siblings probably won’t; despite the good efforts of a game cast, the movie is hyper and noisy, with a plot that’s more a series of zany vignettes than a cohesive story.

Midnight in Paris


Even at this late stage of his career, Woody Allen is capable of wringing a few surprises out of his trademark formula. Critics say Midnight in Paris is a treat for Allen’s fans and romantics alike, a comedy about wish fulfillment that’s magical and touching. Owen Wilson stars as an aspiring novelist who, on a trip to Paris with his fiancée, is transported back to the city’s Jazz Age, sharing drinks with Salvador Dali, getting advice from Ernest Hemingway, and finding romance with a beautiful scenester (Marion Cotillard). But is our hero’s idealized 1920s Paris all that it’s cracked up to be? And is his fantasy incompatible with the real world? The critics say the Certified Fresh Midnight in Paris is a delight, with terrific performances from an all-star cast (particularly Wilson as Allen’s onscreen surrogate) and a dreamy sweetness that’s both funny and lovely.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • One Lucky Elephant, a documentary about a man’s attempt to move an adult circus pachyderm to a more natural environment, is at 100 percent.
  • The Trip, starring Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon in a largely improvised comedy about a pair of foodies on a jaunt across the English countryside, is at 85 percent.
  • Viva Riva!, a Congolese crime drama about a small-time hustler looking to make a big score without running afoul of the underworld, is at 83 percent.
  • Bride Flight, a drama about three Dutch women immigrating to New Zealand whose lives intersect with a fellow immigrant, is at 80 percent.
  • TrollHunter, a horror/comedy about a group of Norwegian film students who discover a terrifying mythic beast, is at 77 percent.
  • Road To Nowhere, a drama about a woman cast in a true crime film that shares many similarities with the victim she’s portraying, is at 71 percent.
  • Just Like Us, doc about a Middle Eastern tour of a group standup comedians, is at 67 percent.
  • Reversion, a meditative sci-fi drama about a woman with a mutation that doesn’t allow her to process time, is at 43 percent.

Tag Cloud

MTV Nickelodeon ITV Fantasy Writers Guild of America Rock Disney TV Dark Horse Comics Summer E3 Teen Acorn TV dramedy zombies The Arrangement Country Biopics ABC Family Lionsgate CW Seed GLAAD Sneak Peek Paramount unscripted Sundance Now Comedy SXSW spy thriller Sony Pictures APB comiccon Musical Oscars Toys PaleyFest E! YA Set visit singing competition GIFs Esquire GoT Freeform Rocky Opinion President Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VICE 2016 Syfy travel Marvel police drama Crackle Mary Tyler Moore streaming composers crime Ellie Kemper BBC Adult Swim FOX First Look discovery Winter TV Fall TV 2015 20th Century Fox supernatural Cartoon Network The CW TruTV PBS Star Trek Western 45 zombie historical drama Reality Competition History Tumblr binge Fox News Photos CBS American Society of Cinematographers sports sitcom Year in Review finale Shondaland docudrama Watching Series IFC Films Premiere Dates TCA Box Office Columbia Pictures Netflix politics See It Skip It Holidays Marathons Disney Channel Thanksgiving ESPN romance Best and Worst cooking Mystery Showtime USA Masterpiece Food Network Superheroe 24 frames NBC NYCC Sundance FXX National Geographic Grammys DC streaming service war Extras Reality Pixar WGN DirecTV crime thriller Super Bowl dceu TV Land Amazon Nominations Election technology Paramount Network CNN Action USA Network BBC America Cosplay VH1 Bravo social media political drama Pop cats cinemax Music Spike ratings TNT TBS Trivia YouTube Red Winners 007 Mindy Kaling Calendar Horror Comedy Central aliens Spring TV Martial Arts biography Awards LGBTQ X-Men Universal Lifetime Ovation Starz Interview science fiction Countdown FX Star Wars Creative Arts Emmys Apple Hulu Emmys talk show SDCC Schedule Superheroes Musicals El Rey Animation medical drama TIFF Pirates 2017 Sci-Fi based on movie Polls and Games Valentine's Day Christmas Nat Geo diversity OWN Drama IFC DC Universe CBS All Access Certified Fresh what to watch transformers Walt Disney Pictures Podcast TCM 21st Century Fox Lucasfilm BET ABC serial killer Tomatazos Infographic MSNBC Britbox TCA 2017 Warner Bros. Trailer crossover cops crime drama Character Guide Video Games CMT RT History cults AMC golden globes period drama Logo TLC HBO boxoffice justice league SundanceTV robots psycho vampires harry potter festivals thriller Comic Book Red Carpet DC Comics A&E Kids & Family Ghostbusters dc hist Rom-Com adventure