Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Side Effects is Certified Fresh

Plus, Identity Thief is criminally short on laughs.

by | February 7, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a woman on the edge (Side Effects, starring Rooney Mara and Channing Tatum); a shameless fraudster (Identity Thief, starring Melissa McCarthy and Jason Bateman), and some hotshot pilots (Top Gun, starring Tom Cruise and Val Kilmer). What do the critics have to say?



Side Effects

82%

Steven Soderbergh claims that Side Effects will be the last theatrical film he directs. Critics say that if that’s the case, he’s crafted a heck of a swan song in this sleek, mysterious thriller. Rooney Mara stars as a young woman suffering from depression after her husband (Channing Tatum) is released from prison. She turns to a psychiatrist (Jude Law) who prescribes her an antidepressant that he’s being paid to pitch, but soon she’s reeling from the drug’s adverse effects. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Side Effects is twisty, elegantly shot, and suspenseful, one that offers further proof of Soderbergh’s ability to elevate genre material to new heights. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Law’s best-reviewed movies.)



Identity Thief

19%

Melissa McCarthy has established herself as a scene-stealing supporting player, and critics say in Identity Thief she proves she has the goods to be a leading lady. Unfortunately, they also say she and co-star Jason Bateman can’t save the film from its rambling, aimless script. McCarthy stars as an identity thief whose posh lifestyle is being financed by a financial services drone (Bateman), who tracks her down but soon finds himself in over his head. The pundits say Identity Thief‘s laughs are attributable to McCarthy and Bateman, who labor mightily to create a framework for the movie’s undisciplined plotline. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of impostors and identity thieves.)



Top Gun: An IMAX 3D Experience

54%

Upon its release in 1986, Top Gun was a massive success, one that made Tom Cruise a superstar, spawned a hit soundtrack, and inspired an uptick in enlistments into the Navy. It’s getting an IMAX 3D rerelease this week, so a new generation can see what all the fuss was about. Suffice to say, the critics were largely split, with many praising the film’s aerial footage while finding its characters to be pretty one-dimensional.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

dramedy adaptation Cosplay slashers indie award winner Infographic nfl Reality E! Drama Marvel Amazon BET Awards 21st Century Fox Disney streaming service Marathons Star Wars television Toys Elton John Podcast Nat Geo toy story Film Festival El Rey MSNBC diversity RT21 Rocketman scorecard Year in Review 007 mockumentary Tubi Travel Channel Country Star Trek ABC Family Columbia Pictures BBC America Reality Competition HBO Calendar 2019 USA Dark Horse Comics thriller Paramount Network psychological thriller cats Stephen King Winners Crunchyroll 2017 The Walking Dead Cannes children's TV screenings CMT die hard Baby Yoda MCU name the review harry potter Sneak Peek Film strong female leads doctor who cars Endgame Disney TCA Awards AMC streaming Classic Film Mindy Kaling Polls and Games cartoon comiccon Spring TV Rom-Com Horror tv talk elevated horror Pop Academy Awards animated spain Superheroes period drama crime drama christmas movies Martial Arts Quiz Captain marvel Comedy Summer travel Video Games Musicals USA Network Hulu CNN asian-american satire Holiday indiana jones Epix Action Fantasy Certified Fresh Apple HBO Go venice Food Network true crime DC Universe quibi Trailer witnail Sony Pictures Awards Tour LGBT HBO Max serial killer Nominations psycho YA war MTV CBS Discovery Channel A24 Set visit Biopics CW Seed Apple TV Plus docudrama romantic comedy sports Mudbound dragons zombie Television Critics Association Binge Guide Television Academy sequels reviews CBS All Access Peacock Arrowverse FX Acorn TV worst movies critics zombies green book documentaries zero dark thirty chucky Best and Worst Lucasfilm space sag awards toronto game show news twilight Animation casting OWN cancelled TV series rotten Character Guide First Reviews FXX BET Black Mirror mission: impossible NYCC Britbox Showtime Masterpiece Amazon Prime WGN historical drama stand-up comedy Musical Chilling Adventures of Sabrina documentary Spectrum Originals VH1 Marvel Studios renewed TV shows Hallmark Vudu Ovation DirecTV political drama dark worst films romance Valentine's Day Lifetime 24 frames 71st Emmy Awards anthology blockbuster spider-man stoner LGBTQ 2020 hispanic crossover SDCC The Witch BBC One composers based on movie boxoffice SXSW Heroines laika BBC Interview cancelled television video Shondaland Women's History Month teaser Awards Rocky IFC cooking TIFF concert New York Comic Con cops Anna Paquin Fall TV Tomatazos dceu comics DGA werewolf TruTV latino TV Land discovery Sci-Fi disaster jamie lee curtis YouTube APB foreign Song of Ice and Fire 2016 Trophy Talk Syfy obituary GIFs cancelled Walt Disney Pictures FX on Hulu police drama best SundanceTV Comics on TV vampires spy thriller Hallmark Christmas movies child's play Amazon Prime Video 4/20 biography cinemax golden globes Family Kids & Family dogs Pet Sematary Netflix Christmas movies TCA 2017 TNT OneApp scary movies classics Grammys Emmys book Brie Larson richard e. Grant Western Apple TV+ screen actors guild anime reboot Lionsgate Trivia Sundance Now Pride Month Holidays Ghostbusters spinoff ITV YouTube Red crime Universal Rock ABC all-time Avengers A&E ratings Ellie Kemper rotten movies we love 72 Emmy Awards Warner Bros. comedies hist Emmy Nominations universal monsters Shudder cults canceled TV shows Mystery medical drama series Sundance stop motion Box Office 2015 TCM spanish language Premiere Dates TV ESPN crime thriller singing competition Adult Swim talk show game of thrones Crackle technology TCA Winter 2020 Fox News PaleyFest Pop TV justice league natural history politics unscripted TV renewals History dc Extras Freeform Starz Mary Tyler Moore breaking bad theme song Oscars comic football science fiction The Arrangement halloween RT History Hear Us Out WarnerMedia Photos Mary Poppins Returns Teen Turner Classic Movies FOX Netflix The CW Black History Month IFC Films franchise social media YouTube Premium Lifetime Christmas movies Thanksgiving Writers Guild of America Creative Arts Emmys The Purge sitcom Watching Series batman sequel TCA Sundance TV TBS revenge Disney Channel Turner aliens nature Logo Schedule adventure free movies facebook Bravo binge PBS Red Carpet Esquire DC streaming service GoT transformers Christmas Pirates VOD mutant hollywood See It Skip It south america NBC Tumblr emmy awards TLC independent Disney Plus 2018 Tarantino Pixar joker kids Paramount Election VICE cancelled TV shows what to watch San Diego Comic-Con X-Men nbcuniversal Mary poppins Disney+ Disney Plus DC Comics Chernobyl Comic Book Superheroe parents Funimation 45 GLAAD movie Music Cartoon Network blaxploitation robots supernatural a nightmare on elm street American Society of Cinematographers PlayStation festivals versus finale Super Bowl Countdown First Look Opinion criterion fast and furious ghosts remakes directors Amazon Studios Nickelodeon Winter TV National Geographic Comedy Central movies festival Spike canceled Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt miniseries BAFTA video on demand President Marvel Television superhero E3 20th Century Fox