Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Side Effects is Certified Fresh

Plus, Identity Thief is criminally short on laughs.

by | February 7, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a woman on the edge (Side Effects, starring Rooney Mara and Channing Tatum); a shameless fraudster (Identity Thief, starring Melissa McCarthy and Jason Bateman), and some hotshot pilots (Top Gun, starring Tom Cruise and Val Kilmer). What do the critics have to say?

Side Effects


Steven Soderbergh claims that Side Effects will be the last theatrical film he directs. Critics say that if that’s the case, he’s crafted a heck of a swan song in this sleek, mysterious thriller. Rooney Mara stars as a young woman suffering from depression after her husband (Channing Tatum) is released from prison. She turns to a psychiatrist (Jude Law) who prescribes her an antidepressant that he’s being paid to pitch, but soon she’s reeling from the drug’s adverse effects. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Side Effects is twisty, elegantly shot, and suspenseful, one that offers further proof of Soderbergh’s ability to elevate genre material to new heights. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Law’s best-reviewed movies.)

Identity Thief


Melissa McCarthy has established herself as a scene-stealing supporting player, and critics say in Identity Thief she proves she has the goods to be a leading lady. Unfortunately, they also say she and co-star Jason Bateman can’t save the film from its rambling, aimless script. McCarthy stars as an identity thief whose posh lifestyle is being financed by a financial services drone (Bateman), who tracks her down but soon finds himself in over his head. The pundits say Identity Thief‘s laughs are attributable to McCarthy and Bateman, who labor mightily to create a framework for the movie’s undisciplined plotline. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of impostors and identity thieves.)

Top Gun: An IMAX 3D Experience


Upon its release in 1986, Top Gun was a massive success, one that made Tom Cruise a superstar, spawned a hit soundtrack, and inspired an uptick in enlistments into the Navy. It’s getting an IMAX 3D rerelease this week, so a new generation can see what all the fuss was about. Suffice to say, the critics were largely split, with many praising the film’s aerial footage while finding its characters to be pretty one-dimensional.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

child's play venice green book popular VH1 hist Cartoon Network video ABC Signature superhero twilight Classic Film Pixar OWN kong 1990s live action gangster MCU Awards X-Men Quiz romantic comedy Best and Worst foreign godzilla Ellie Kemper BBC One Women's History Month Set visit biography Film VOD 71st Emmy Awards Fox News best Calendar debate tv talk Adult Swim rt labs Superheroes Emmys Disney streaming service true crime harry potter blockbusters game of thrones Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt news Trophy Talk Pirates Certified Fresh IFC Films boxing Nat Geo Shondaland Paramount Network Universal films The Academy Freeform die hard Hallmark MTV TV VICE Mary poppins Infographic scene in color 2017 game show dragons composers crime science fiction DC Universe Hallmark Christmas movies marvel cinematic universe critics political drama CMT batman mission: impossible disaster halloween cults TCA Awards Amazon Studios romance El Rey The Arrangement aapi TCA Winter 2020 Countdown First Look joker Amazon Prime Video blockbuster obituary doctor who Election heist movie crime thriller universal monsters documentaries critic resources scorecard crime drama dogs Sci-Fi young adult marvel comics nbcuniversal TCA 2017 rotten movies we love Song of Ice and Fire Paramount Plus series Spectrum Originals casting remakes jurassic park rt labs critics edition concert DirecTV Columbia Pictures dramedy royal family Disney adventure American Society of Cinematographers Netflix pirates of the caribbean Podcast Pop olympics DC Comics ESPN cartoon Amazon christmas movies USA Network Reality social media Premiere Dates comic Syfy Awards Tour screenings spinoff The Purge Fantasy natural history Year in Review Pop TV cars TV renewals Marathons international Sony Pictures rotten Television Academy spanish language Dark Horse Comics sag awards Arrowverse Marvel Studios serial killer south america Crunchyroll CBS All Access TLC RT21 festival BET Awards scary movies Comics on TV comic books CW Seed TV Land ghosts Vudu Teen 20th Century Fox Hulu festivals Lifetime Christmas movies BET BBC versus television cats Disney Plus Biopics name the review Apple TV Plus GLAAD richard e. Grant facebook Tarantino Video Games australia strong female leads Disney Channel kaiju legend National Geographic latino HBO Max werewolf based on movie franchise Warner Bros. psychological thriller Super Bowl The Witch talk show book streaming movies TruTV GoT 2021 blaxploitation book adaptation vampires king arthur king kong YouTube Premium Stephen King war Nominations Peacock stand-up comedy basketball Wes Anderson YouTube Red indie TV movies feel good zombies football E! Hear Us Out monster movies Paramount 007 YA unscripted 2018 razzies LGBT biopic Christmas Food Network quibi Drama Red Carpet Exclusive Video mcc Black Mirror New York Comic Con james bond psycho Shudder jamie lee curtis hollywood spider-man telelvision Country revenge Legendary comics black rt archives fresh Spring TV miniseries elevated horror zombie adenture 93rd Oscars Nickelodeon Apple Martial Arts Opinion all-time WGN mockumentary sitcom kids deadpool Sundance Binge Guide transformers Lifetime Family suspense GIFs worst Britbox TV One YouTube PlayStation japanese Rock 72 Emmy Awards Musicals TIFF finale 2015 Comic Book RT History Cosplay stoner anthology adaptation dceu A24 WarnerMedia thriller movie Broadway Mary Poppins Returns Turner breaking bad CNN 99% satire new star wars movies robots Lucasfilm 21st Century Fox period drama spain Apple TV+ independent canceled screen actors guild documentary ViacomCBS Photos docuseries Writers Guild of America TCM animated Academy Awards hispanic heritage month ABC HBO Go Character Guide Box Office FOX zero dark thirty Winter TV cancelled TV shows classics archives laika dc Heroines Watching Series Travel Channel Sundance Now chucky rom-coms Marvel Television high school Tumblr teaser toronto Brie Larson saw Music 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards cops Ovation Ghostbusters CBS reboot Elton John First Reviews aliens Discovery Channel The Walt Disney Company emmy awards comedies dark slashers golden globe awards fast and furious SDCC Rom-Com Logo Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Alien wonder woman Acorn TV HBO golden globes Pet Sematary Fox Searchlight Turner Classic Movies witnail Thanksgiving Fall TV APB Comedy Central canceled TV shows award winner History posters renewed TV shows technology DGA movies Creative Arts Emmys ITV Marvel NBA OneApp Endgame San Diego Comic-Con target Tokyo Olympics supernatural toy story children's TV Winners sports know your critic action-comedy criterion Toys Oscars space parents Star Trek Showtime 45 asian-american a nightmare on elm street TCA 2019 discovery streaming Mindy Kaling FX prank Masterpiece Bravo comic book movies medical drama Trailer docudrama 90s TBS DC streaming service cinemax Reality Competition Holiday hidden camera NYCC diversity Film Festival mutant 4/20 Funimation The Walking Dead FX on Hulu SXSW See It Skip It Black History Month 24 frames Captain marvel comiccon Extras Avengers anime Tomatazos cancelled cooking comic book movie trailers Mudbound FXX BAFTA 2020 superman ratings nature Baby Yoda worst movies Anna Paquin PBS Horror Comedy Cannes slasher japan cancelled television 73rd Emmy Awards Trivia Musical stop motion Rocketman indiana jones Netflix Christmas movies Pride Month The CW Sundance TV Amazon Prime Grammys new york Mary Tyler Moore Image Comics spy thriller Television Critics Association historical drama new zealand AMC ID Sneak Peek crossover Chernobyl Superheroe hispanic video on demand dexter NBC what to watch boxoffice lord of the rings LGBTQ singing competition Polls and Games E3 theme song halloween tv PaleyFest directors Comic-Con@Home 2021 nfl Pacific Islander MSNBC Starz sequel reviews free movies police drama Schedule 2016 sequels BBC America Lionsgate President spanish politics women TNT Crackle Action Epix travel ABC Family Western Emmy Nominations Interview Mystery Animation Kids & Family justice league Holidays binge italian Summer Valentine's Day Walt Disney Pictures A&E cancelled TV series Esquire USA Rocky french Disney+ Disney Plus Star Wars SundanceTV Tubi IFC Spike