Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Side Effects is Certified Fresh

Plus, Identity Thief is criminally short on laughs.

by | February 7, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a woman on the edge (Side Effects, starring Rooney Mara and Channing Tatum); a shameless fraudster (Identity Thief, starring Melissa McCarthy and Jason Bateman), and some hotshot pilots (Top Gun, starring Tom Cruise and Val Kilmer). What do the critics have to say?

Side Effects

81%

Steven Soderbergh claims that Side Effects will be the last theatrical film he directs. Critics say that if that’s the case, he’s crafted a heck of a swan song in this sleek, mysterious thriller. Rooney Mara stars as a young woman suffering from depression after her husband (Channing Tatum) is released from prison. She turns to a psychiatrist (Jude Law) who prescribes her an antidepressant that he’s being paid to pitch, but soon she’s reeling from the drug’s adverse effects. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Side Effects is twisty, elegantly shot, and suspenseful, one that offers further proof of Soderbergh’s ability to elevate genre material to new heights. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Law’s best-reviewed movies.)

Identity Thief

19%

Melissa McCarthy has established herself as a scene-stealing supporting player, and critics say in Identity Thief she proves she has the goods to be a leading lady. Unfortunately, they also say she and co-star Jason Bateman can’t save the film from its rambling, aimless script. McCarthy stars as an identity thief whose posh lifestyle is being financed by a financial services drone (Bateman), who tracks her down but soon finds himself in over his head. The pundits say Identity Thief‘s laughs are attributable to McCarthy and Bateman, who labor mightily to create a framework for the movie’s undisciplined plotline. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of impostors and identity thieves.)

Top Gun: An IMAX 3D Experience

58%

Upon its release in 1986, Top Gun was a massive success, one that made Tom Cruise a superstar, spawned a hit soundtrack, and inspired an uptick in enlistments into the Navy. It’s getting an IMAX 3D rerelease this week, so a new generation can see what all the fuss was about. Suffice to say, the critics were largely split, with many praising the film’s aerial footage while finding its characters to be pretty one-dimensional.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Oscar 99% 24 frames See It Skip It Crunchyroll Hallmark Christmas movies 94th Oscars YouTube Premium Fall TV Election Holidays space animated news Chilling Adventures of Sabrina all-time elevated horror Red Carpet Calendar SXSW Sundance Now spinoff Star Wars Celebration name the review golden globe awards summer preview Drama Mary poppins Dark Horse Comics scary movies book adaptation stand-up comedy new york HFPA Comedy Central Action hispanic Universal 2017 mutant Syfy Reality Competition TV Land natural history spider-verse cinemax Cartoon Network Apple TV Plus reboot LGBTQ Baby Yoda dreamworks werewolf kids Photos DirecTV Neflix kaiju Grammys hist Lucasfilm ESPN ViacomCBS cops live action political drama zero dark thirty rt labs critics edition best rt labs Awards ID asian-american Paramount Network Superheroes TCA archives Martial Arts Sundance TV Holiday sequel posters GoT children's TV Vudu CNN Trivia trailers CMT chucky 2016 Britbox MSNBC Netflix miniseries Shudder richard e. Grant comic books USA Comic-Con@Home 2021 FX on Hulu hollywood Mudbound parents BET Travel Channel Disney streaming service films DC streaming service mission: impossible independent APB Shondaland lord of the rings australia foreign aliens new star wars movies Writers Guild of America comic book movie godzilla renewed TV shows directors period drama Binge Guide American Society of Cinematographers AMC black Film Festival canceled TV shows IFC Films Anna Paquin screen actors guild broadcast medical drama Super Bowl 90s National Geographic Ghostbusters franchise scorecard YA ABC Family Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt scene in color film series Paramount 79th Golden Globes Awards award winner WarnerMedia indie TV ABC Signature DC Comics sports Hear Us Out stop motion ghosts rt archives docudrama Tokyo Olympics streaming movies Emmys Year in Review remakes book scene in color series jurassic park 2015 Sundance Lifetime Christmas movies Animation Sony international adventure Watching Series know your critic RT21 sopranos Chernobyl Black Mirror PlayStation fast and furious talk show crossover trophy olympics new zealand Ovation japan dexter Starz Exclusive Video Musicals king kong game of thrones TCM zombies BAFTA satire The Walking Dead Kids & Family Film superhero Biopics critic resources FXX Brie Larson live event TIFF joker Spectrum Originals twilight Warner Bros. OWN TBS adenture gangster TLC Acorn TV legend Music 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards IMDb TV robots ITV psychological thriller television Spring TV supernatural MTV deadpool NBC vampires 2021 DGA SundanceTV Captain marvel Adult Swim Alien Best Actress romance 21st Century Fox spanish composers Thanksgiving 45 debate Rocketman spain football PaleyFest Spike green book Lionsgate marvel cinematic universe MGM YouTube Red CBS Summer rotten movies we love Comic Book Freeform crime E3 Discovery Channel Television Academy Esquire 1990s laika BBC One Comics on TV Marvel 72 Emmy Awards batman SDCC genre high school teaser First Look popular Rock witnail Winter TV discovery Amazon Prime Video 007 Sci-Fi slashers Mary Tyler Moore crime thriller IFC Amazon BBC action-comedy spy thriller streaming unscripted Fargo child's play interviews latino cartoon Pet Sematary festival Best and Worst Interview screenings Mystery VICE The Walt Disney Company streamig Epix travel Fox Searchlight movie SXSW 2022 slasher blockbusters History TV One docuseries Sony Pictures VH1 Character Guide Native marvel comics Nominations 20th Century Fox Bravo historical drama Video Games king arthur Heroines Wes Anderson criterion anime Arrowverse basketball Black History Month Polls and Games Nickelodeon casting sag awards sequels reviews worst movies The CW hispanic heritage month prank Rom-Com Pop Television Critics Association toronto Fox News dramedy feel good universal monsters stoner A&E emmy awards serial killer comic book movies Legendary Turner Classic Movies Pride Month USA Network Box Office young adult Superheroe ratings dc Amazon Prime The Purge Mindy Kaling a nightmare on elm street dark FX royal family cults cancelled television Extras based on movie Tumblr WGN Paramount Pictures HBO Go Avengers cooking Reality YouTube Trailer Geeked Week Apple TV+ monster movies obi wan Best Actor Certified Fresh video Marvel Studios Sneak Peek thriller Tarantino Hollywood Foreign Press Association french police drama comics Fantasy rom-coms razzies Trophy Talk Peacock Oscars comiccon south america AMC Plus RT History concert canceled mockumentary saw target justice league documentary A24 President Christmas facebook DC Universe Hulu Nat Geo Academy Awards quibi Comedy TNT romantic comedy Pirates singing competition spanish language suspense toy story Winners strong female leads dragons Stephen King telelvision Tomatazos finale diversity Horror Creative Arts Emmys Premiere Dates die hard game show LGBT transformers tv talk CBS All Access San Diego Comic-Con boxing Focus Features New York Comic Con Broadway cats festivals halloween TV movies Elton John video on demand target scene in color Prime Video christmas movies psycho Podcast summer TV Cosplay BBC America social media Disney Channel South by Southwest Film Festival Walt Disney Pictures OneApp Food Network disaster cancelled leaderboard comedies Tags: Comedy Pixar Pop TV dogs Mary Poppins Returns MCU free movies VOD Song of Ice and Fire vs. series black comedy Pacific Islander Indigenous HBO 2020 rotten GLAAD BET Awards PBS Disney+ Disney Plus Emmy Nominations Toys blaxploitation Best Director harry potter zombie art house adaptation classics Endgame Disney Universal Pictures doctor who Logo versus 73rd Emmy Awards science fiction politics italian Hallmark Image Comics Opinion Awards Tour nature obituary dceu Paramount Plus Disney Plus kong FOX crime drama venice The Academy TruTV binge pirates of the caribbean documentaries 4/20 Western revenge Turner sitcom Star Wars Instagram Live heist movie HBO Max theme song ABC Marvel Television Country mob Rocky breaking bad Masterpiece blockbuster Lifetime summer TV preview true crime women cancelled TV shows GIFs TCA 2017 Set visit wonder woman nfl Infographic Cannes The Arrangement Netflix Christmas movies CW Seed First Reviews fresh Showtime Ellie Kemper Schedule cancelled TV series golden globes hidden camera boxoffice jamie lee curtis what to watch E! Marathons mcc james bond Countdown 71st Emmy Awards Apple Teen japanese X-Men comic NBA 93rd Oscars worst scene in color Star Trek 2019 Quiz Family indiana jones The Witch biopic Valentine's Day Musical Funimation spider-man 2018 biography Tubi nbcuniversal TV renewals war NYCC halloween tv Crackle superman movies technology Amazon Studios critics scary Columbia Pictures El Rey Best Picture Classic Film aapi TCA Winter 2020 Women's History Month anthology cars TCA Awards