Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Prometheus is Certified Fresh

Plus, Madagascar 3: Europe's Most Wanted proves that third time's the charm.

by | June 8, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an alien resurrection (Prometheus, starring Noomi Rapace and Michael Fassbender) and an incredible journey (Madagascar 3: Europe’s Most Wanted, with voice work from Ben Stiller and Jada Pinkett Smith). What do the critics have to say?



More than three decades after Alien helped to usher in a new era in sci-fi cinema, Ridley Scott heads back to the cosmos for the ambitious Prometheus. And critics say that while this quasi-prequel to Alien lacks the focus and brutal efficiency of Scott’s 1979 classic, it’s well acted, visually stunning, and filled with big ideas. After unearthing evidence that Earth was visited by an ancient alien race, a group of scientists (led by Noomi Rapace) venture to a distant planet, hoping to discover the origins of mankind. What they find there, however, is far less friendly than they hoped. The pundits say that the Certified Fresh Prometheus often introduces more philosophical concepts than it can deal with, but it possesses a haunting visual grandeur and compelling performances — particularly Michael Fassbender as a fastidious android. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Scott’s best-reviewed movies.)

Madagascar 3: Europe’s Most Wanted


In spite of the middling critical response to its first installment, the Madagascar franchise has evolved into that rarest of beasts: a film series that improves with each new outing. Critics say Madagascar 3: Europe’s Most Wanted is the best of the bunch, a funny, visually sophisticated animated treat for the whole family. This time, our animal pals depart Africa to return to the Central Park Zoo in New York. However, they get blown off course and end up in Europe, eventually hitching a ride with a traveling circus in order to avoid an obsessive animal control officer. The pundits say Madagascar 3 has a pretty thin plot, but it’s so colorful, briskly paced, and deftly animated that you probably won’t notice.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Safety Not Guaranteed, a comedy about the search for the man who placed a mysterious classified ad announcing plans for a journey through time, is at 94 percent.
  • Paul Williams Still Alive, a documentary on the post-fame life of the Grammy-winning songwriter, is at 92 percent.
  • The Italian import Corpo Celeste, a drama about a 13-year-old girl who embarks on a spiritual quest prior to her confirmation, is at 85 percent.
  • Todd SolondzDark Horse, starring Justin Bartha and Selma Blair in a dark comedy about a hostile slacker who awkwardly courts a psychologically damaged woman, is at 75 percent.
  • Lola Versus, starring Greta Gerwig in a comedy about a recently-jilted bride-to-be who attempts to adjust to single life, is at 45 percent.
  • Bel Ami, starring Robert Pattinson and Uma Thurman in a period drama about a man of modest means who climbs Paris’ social ladder by seducing powerful women, is at 31 percent.
  • Peace, Love, & Misunderstanding, starring Jane Fonda and Elizabeth Olsen in a dramedy about a woman in the midst of a personal crisis who takes her teenage childreen to meet their estranged hippy grandmother, is at 26 percent.

Tag Cloud

Rom-Com justice league streaming documentary NYCC Fantasy ABC Pirates See It Skip It Best and Worst MSNBC Holiday Tomatazos MCU ESPN critics spanish language zombie tv talk dceu based on movie satire 2020 stand-up comedy YA Comedy Central festivals BAFTA ID revenge TCA period drama cults ratings Acorn TV golden globes Nickelodeon mutant 4/20 Walt Disney Pictures Country Avengers twilight YouTube Red police drama worst movies Oscars Rock singing competition Pet Sematary finale thriller A&E festival CW Seed robots 20th Century Fox french Valentine's Day LGBT El Rey Television Academy comic books Film joker Tumblr rotten movies we love 2015 game show spinoff Teen Lionsgate television Black History Month sag awards cooking science fiction Quiz Biopics USA war Bravo RT21 richard e. Grant Mary poppins PBS Discovery Channel Classic Film elevated horror Brie Larson The Purge renewed TV shows BBC One Baby Yoda E3 Reality Competition Family The CW Captain marvel TCM Pop Pixar Ellie Kemper japanese Hallmark Christmas movies San Diego Comic-Con Netflix VOD south america Music slashers CMT Disney+ Disney Plus Elton John Disney Plus Action diversity children's TV American Society of Cinematographers MTV DirecTV Peacock HBO Go DC Comics dramedy HBO green book Red Carpet BBC FXX hispanic Shudder kids The Witch Sneak Peek 2016 docudrama doctor who spider-man stoner Nat Geo FOX child's play SXSW Amazon Prime social media Mudbound Marathons christmas movies name the review Kids & Family discovery Opinion game of thrones talk show crime thriller Rocketman TruTV sequels Podcast Infographic Super Bowl Comics on TV politics Arrowverse Masterpiece Amazon X-Men franchise documentaries FX italian chucky 72 Emmy Awards 007 Election screen actors guild dragons stop motion Awards Tour best sitcom Set visit Mystery latino mission: impossible romantic comedy HBO Max Esquire Photos nbcuniversal Christmas what to watch Trivia IFC Films ABC Family CBS Fox Searchlight Summer zero dark thirty Sundance TV all-time cancelled GoT Cosplay VICE venice Warner Bros. TCA Winter 2020 Showtime quibi Winners Interview Western RT History crime drama Watching Series Rocky Horror Sci-Fi anime Superheroes Star Wars archives cancelled TV series Countdown foreign 2018 versus Disney streaming service Mary Tyler Moore Spectrum Originals Calendar reboot WarnerMedia TBS Song of Ice and Fire teaser CNN TIFF transformers Musical Thanksgiving BET TV Land Awards Winter TV History comic medical drama 71st Emmy Awards Premiere Dates Travel Channel disaster VH1 Apple TV Plus independent TCA Awards composers movies asian-american indiana jones toy story die hard fast and furious canceled TV shows TLC Paramount New York Comic Con LGBTQ Extras anthology directors TCA 2017 Creative Arts Emmys DC streaming service breaking bad Holidays dc Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt AMC animated Heroines historical drama GLAAD Crunchyroll Crackle scary movies toronto Amazon Prime Video Ovation Schedule Lifetime Animation cops Spring TV ghosts nature political drama Food Network psychological thriller series book Mindy Kaling Fall TV Sundance video on demand 2019 Apple TV+ serial killer Chilling Adventures of Sabrina harry potter crime Amazon Studios Turner travel witnail Mary Poppins Returns natural history strong female leads reviews cats cinemax Cannes The Arrangement binge Shondaland biography universal monsters hollywood Sundance Now Freeform concert james bond Reality obituary dark Toys BET Awards true crime Funimation Superheroe SDCC 21st Century Fox Cartoon Network crossover Hulu Academy Awards OWN cartoon jamie lee curtis Epix blockbuster Turner Classic Movies aliens halloween comiccon Britbox Adult Swim comedies First Look deadpool Vudu First Reviews canceled space mockumentary Paramount Network DC Universe Logo Box Office Apple Anna Paquin Grammys Endgame Ghostbusters films 2017 Star Trek Comedy Video Games TV casting a nightmare on elm street Lifetime Christmas movies technology Pop TV A24 Polls and Games miniseries Dark Horse Comics black Spike GIFs supernatural Stephen King Hear Us Out Chernobyl football Disney Channel sequel PlayStation Disney Hallmark Nominations news worst video australia superhero Sony Pictures rotten romance IFC Emmys Trailer spanish Lucasfilm theme song Musicals Year in Review rt archives DGA Black Mirror batman cars APB movie TV renewals Drama spy thriller Writers Guild of America adventure boxoffice Marvel comics Character Guide E! screenings Pride Month NBC adaptation hist Tarantino sports criterion Binge Guide PaleyFest free movies Syfy The Walking Dead FX on Hulu vampires Netflix Christmas movies Universal Starz laika President remakes Columbia Pictures parents Television Critics Association 45 halloween tv Comic Book scorecard unscripted Marvel Television USA Network YouTube Premium CBS All Access werewolf OneApp Marvel Studios Trophy Talk cancelled TV shows cancelled television psycho spain award winner ITV nfl Certified Fresh Film Festival WGN National Geographic YouTube classics SundanceTV BBC America dogs Tubi blaxploitation 24 frames zombies emmy awards Fox News Martial Arts Emmy Nominations indie TNT The Academy facebook Women's History Month