Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Inglourious Basterds is Certified Fresh!

Plus, Shorts, Post Grad, and X Games 3D: The Movie come up short.

by | August 20, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Nazi killers (Quentin Tarantino‘s Inglourious Basterds, starring Brad Pitt), a magic rock (Shorts, starring William H. Macy and Leslie Mann), unemployment blues (Post Grad, starring Alexis Bledel and Michael Keaton), and extreme sports (X Games 3D: The Movie. What do the critics have to say?


Inglourious Basterds

Historians may have plenty of quibbles with Quentin Tarantino’s wild and wooly take on World War II. However, critics have fewer reservations on Inglourious Basterds, calling it an audacious, bravura piece of pulpy pop filmmaking. Brad Pitt stars as the leader of a group of Jewish soldiers who terrorize the Nazis and plot a brilliant plan to put an end to the Third Reich. Meanwhile, a German officer (Christopher Waltz) is hot on the Basterds’ trail. The pundits say Basterds may not be Tarantino at his peak, but it’s perhaps his most loving tribute to cinephilia yet, as well as a bracing, tense exercise in over-the-top action. Like most of Tarantino’s directorial efforts, Inglourious Basterds is Certified Fresh.



Director Robert Rodriguez has seamlessly moved between the worlds of violent adult-themed film (Sin City, From Dusk Till Dawn, Desperado) and more family-oriented fare (the Spy Kids franchise). After working with Quentin Tarantino on 2007’s B-movie tribute Grindhouse, Rodriguez returns this week with another whimsical children’s film, Shorts. In Shorts, an 11-year-old boy named Toe Thompson happens upon a magical rainbow-colored rock that grants wishes to anyone that holds it, and after it falls into the hands of the neighborhood grown-ups, Toe and his friends must band together to save the town from chaos. So far, while some critics have noted the film’s hyperkinetic pace and imaginative premise as strengths, others fail to see any underlying charm and feel the director’s enthusiasm is wasted. (Be sure to check out our interview with Rodriguez from Comic-Con, in which he talks about his own son’s involvement in the project.)


Post Grad

At a time when college graduates are having a tough time finding work, Post Grad seemingly benefits from timeliness. Unfortunately, critics say the film is less about our current economic situation and more about shopworn romantic comedy conventions. Alexis Bledel stars as a grad that has been beaten out of her dream job by her college rival, so she moves back in with her parents — and finds herself torn between two dudes. The pundits say Post Grad is listless and dull, squandering a solid cast that includes Jane Lynch, Michael Keaton, and Carol Burnett on a script that lacks much insight into the heady days of post-collegiate life, and worse, one that is woefully short on laughs.


X-Games 3D: The Movie

When the X Games held its first annual competition nearly 15 years ago, some dismissed it as a novelty act, while others clearly foresaw its potential to explode worldwide. Now a legitimate sporting event, the extreme sports exhibition has spawned several similar competitions and garnered coverage from the likes of ESPN and ABC Sports, so it’s only natural that the next step would be a feature-length documentary in 3D. X-Games 3D: The Movie mashes together a string of impossible stunts from the various events, sound bites from the biggest names, and a narrative voiceover by Emile Hirsch, but early critical response has been negative overall. Most are saying the film plays out like an extended commercial for the event, offering little beyond what one might find in a typical broadcast of the X-Games besides the novelty of 3D, and its appeal may extend no further than its built-in fans.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Netflix Christmas movies indie X-Men Summer scary movies television zombie HBO Max french casting south america Cartoon Network Nominations Emmy Nominations Turner kids Star Trek docuseries Superheroes book adaptation crime Mary Tyler Moore GoT jamie lee curtis Comedy Central TBS die hard Hear Us Out Hulu sitcom 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards psycho Tubi 21st Century Fox Cannes police drama golden globes dc Netflix international emmy awards reviews Musicals BBC Kids & Family 2020 Pacific Islander canceled TV shows CMT Emmys fresh superman binge genre miniseries DC streaming service nbcuniversal PaleyFest spider-man Lifetime Trophy Talk Universal concert Video Games Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt rotten hidden camera Paramount Network Showtime tv talk justice league razzies MSNBC Writers Guild of America Travel Channel Rock marvel cinematic universe Drama Photos Polls and Games comics SundanceTV History Neflix Discovery Channel Crackle 71st Emmy Awards Rocketman NBA Ellie Kemper Christmas comic books crossover Legendary biopic Classic Film cancelled TV shows Family natural history criterion archives breaking bad rt labs italian The Purge what to watch Premiere Dates Baby Yoda rotten movies we love young adult Song of Ice and Fire Watching Series Best and Worst VOD art house Dark Horse Comics Marvel Television 73rd Emmy Awards DirecTV boxing WarnerMedia YouTube 2016 name the review Reality Competition sag awards directors Avengers 90s elevated horror Year in Review politics Fargo Adult Swim teaser Nickelodeon 4/20 El Rey christmas movies aapi Lucasfilm black Pixar TCA Awards 72 Emmy Awards child's play dceu hist children's TV debate aliens prank best ViacomCBS anime NBC halloween tv toy story Columbia Pictures slashers marvel comics Awards venice E! Turner Classic Movies toronto vs. hispanic heritage month 2017 Prime Video Amazon Prime Esquire 2021 Musical Valentine's Day President mission: impossible National Geographic TLC Logo mob Black Mirror medical drama NYCC Sundance PlayStation TCM romantic comedy fast and furious live action Tarantino TruTV twilight Funimation Comedy heist movie Pirates green book trailers Cosplay Trailer deadpool First Look 1990s science fiction docudrama spanish sports BBC America disaster Spring TV zero dark thirty independent The Academy Superheroe diversity IFC Films APB franchise batman cancelled TV series USA Wes Anderson movie Rom-Com documentary Warner Bros. scorecard Academy Awards critics Film Mindy Kaling canceled Broadway Heroines worst leaderboard Comic Book romance Bravo sopranos ESPN Syfy rt labs critics edition finale dreamworks YouTube Premium First Reviews ABC Signature 45 Set visit Disney VH1 PBS cats Paramount Plus Image Comics Comic-Con@Home 2021 japan The Walt Disney Company sequel blaxploitation sequels Quiz streaming Schedule LGBT nature Certified Fresh transformers The Arrangement monster movies scary FX ABC unscripted royal family Country BET spain Pop TV facebook 2018 harry potter TCA 2017 American Society of Cinematographers crime thriller technology asian-american Shudder gangster cars free movies The Walking Dead latino composers OneApp jurassic park target indiana jones Stephen King scene in color posters Sci-Fi ghosts biography Mystery Television Academy TCA Winter 2020 king kong MCU cooking TV One RT History stop motion dogs book Paramount Awards Tour TV Land YouTube Red feel good versus New York Comic Con Amazon Prime Video kong all-time legend Reality Horror Lionsgate WGN 2015 cinemax olympics dragons social media Mary Poppins Returns reboot GIFs FX on Hulu travel Marvel series Fox News black comedy laika TV movies renewed TV shows Opinion BBC One Disney+ Disney Plus Box Office robots rom-coms dramedy TIFF Apple TV+ Sundance Now remakes IFC Creative Arts Emmys CNN Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 20th Century Fox popular Mary poppins revenge HBO Go Amazon Studios FOX football TCA Hollywood Foreign Press Association Television Critics Association AMC Plus hollywood Shondaland 24 frames Fantasy know your critic Britbox Nat Geo psychological thriller comiccon based on movie SXSW 93rd Oscars Disney Plus Women's History Month Epix Marathons universal monsters video Food Network pirates of the caribbean Calendar witnail Comics on TV spanish language blockbusters rt archives comic book movies stoner adenture halloween The Witch Extras Alien Teen king arthur a nightmare on elm street Infographic talk show nfl richard e. Grant Spectrum Originals award winner Fox Searchlight Grammys Captain marvel cartoon stand-up comedy Acorn TV thriller Crunchyroll The CW new zealand period drama Western Winter TV DGA mcc Sundance TV wonder woman cults CBS All Access LGBTQ singing competition joker critic resources adventure USA Network Anna Paquin Tags: Comedy Holiday Martial Arts screen actors guild anthology Arrowverse kaiju Holidays BET Awards live event Pet Sematary Brie Larson Music Lifetime Christmas movies SDCC Starz strong female leads Sony Pictures Trivia mockumentary mutant quibi Thanksgiving australia Animation festival VICE new star wars movies cancelled television ITV action-comedy Character Guide screenings Elton John HBO DC Universe high school comic book movie A24 Vudu Spike adaptation Tomatazos Winners streaming movies Chernobyl game of thrones Walt Disney Pictures San Diego Comic-Con Tokyo Olympics Pop spy thriller obituary AMC YA saw suspense TV Rocky A&E boxoffice TNT Universal Pictures chucky Apple TV Plus Mudbound golden globe awards Tumblr werewolf E3 news Endgame Action space political drama slasher films theme song supernatural ratings Freeform See It Skip It comedies Peacock ABC Family cops Amazon CBS movies Election Interview Countdown cancelled serial killer FXX godzilla women HFPA DC Comics james bond zombies video on demand Toys true crime Disney streaming service MTV historical drama 007 crime drama Film Festival Fall TV animated Hallmark Christmas movies satire 99% war dexter Black History Month trophy Hallmark classics Masterpiece japanese worst movies Pride Month Instagram Live telelvision parents blockbuster dark RT21 79th Golden Globes Awards lord of the rings doctor who Star Wars Exclusive Video ID Sneak Peek BAFTA documentaries Binge Guide Oscars OWN game show CW Seed Ovation Disney Channel IMDb TV Podcast hispanic Red Carpet discovery Apple spider-verse Super Bowl spinoff TV renewals foreign comic GLAAD Biopics Ghostbusters Marvel Studios basketball vampires superhero new york festivals 2019