Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Godzilla is Certified Fresh

Plus, Million Dollar Arm is likeable but very predictable.

by | May 16, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the king of the monsters (Godzilla, starring Aaron Taylor-Johnson and Elizabeth Olsen) and an ambitious sports agent (Million Dollar Arm, starring Jon Hamm and Aasif Mandvi). What do the critics have to say?



Poor Godzilla. Decades of campy stomp-fests have transformed the once-mighty king of the monsters into a cuddly oaf. This new Godzilla is an attempt to imbue the franchise with more weight than the typical creature feature, and critics say the result is mostly successful, with fine performances and visually striking effects making up for a tendency toward ponderousness. When a nuclear power plant near Tokyo is damaged by a series of tremors, scientist Joe Brody (Bryan Cranston) believes the cause is something more ominous than an earthquake. Years later, Joe’s son Ford (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) realizes his father was right — a terrifying beast called the Muto has been causing the tremors, and only one giant lizard can stop it. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Godzilla takes a while to get going, but if you want to watch oversized creatures wreak havoc on big cities, the movie delivers the goods in a reasonably imaginative fashion. (Check out our video interview with Cranston, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we present a field guide to giant movie monsters.)

Million Dollar Arm


Who doesn’t love an underdog sports story — especially one that’s based on true events? Critics say Million Dollar Arm is as pleasant as a day at the ballpark, but don’t expect any curveballs or changeups from the script. Jon Hamm stars as J.B. Bernstein, a sports agent whose clientele is short on major league stars. SSo he travels to India and holds a contest to find two strong-armed cricket bowlers who have the stuff to become big-league pitchers. The pundits say Million Dollar Arm is well-crafted and likeable, but it’s pretty predictable, and the film makes only limited use of its setting. (Watch our video interview with the stars, and flip through our gallery of big stars in baseball uniforms.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Ai Weiwei: The Fake Case, a documentary about the celebrated Chinese artist and political activist, is at 100 percent.

  • The American Nurse, a doc that profiles a diverse range of healthcare workers, is at 100 percent.

  • God’s Horses, a drama about a group of childhood friends who are recruited by a terrorist organization, is at 100 percent.

  • A People Uncounted, a drama about a group of childhood friends who are recruited by a terrorist organization, is at 100 percent.

  • The Immigrant, starring Marion Cotillard and Joaquin Phoenix in a period drama about a young Polish woman seeking a fresh start in New York City who’s forced into prostitution, is at 83 percent.

  • Chinese Puzzle, starring Romain Duris and Audrey Tautou in a dramedy about a Frenchman who becomes lonely when his wife goes to New York for work, is at 83 percent.

  • The Discoverers, starring Griffin Dunne in a comedy about a dysfunctional family that finds itself in the midst of a Lewis and Clark historical reenactment, is at 82 percent.

  • A Short History Of Decay, a comedy about an aimless writer who returns to his hometown to care for his ailing parents, is at 75 percent.

  • Half of a Yellow Sun, starring Chiwetel Ejiofor and Thandie Newton in a drama about two sisters whose lives take very different paths in the early years of Nigerian independence, is at 58 percent.

  • Wolf Creek 2, a slasher sequel in which tourists are terrorized by a psychopath on the Australian Outback, is at 47 percent.

  • A Night In Old Mexico, starring Robert Duvall in a drama about an elderly rancher who makes a run for the border with his grandson in tow, is at 36 percent.

  • Don Peyote, starring Dan Fogler in a comedy about a soon-to-be-married-guy who goes on a drug-fueled investigation into doomsday prophesies, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

Hulu VOD miniseries Podcast Amazon Studios Acorn TV historical drama Britbox Paramount Network leaderboard SXSW 2022 ABC Musical sitcom USA SundanceTV spider-man Holidays australia sequels Tags: Comedy Apple TV+ Classic Film comic book movies First Reviews Stephen King VH1 Brie Larson Columbia Pictures Bravo Biopics trophy spanish language Best Actor The Purge jamie lee curtis kong Avengers renewed TV shows science fiction popular venice heist movie Best Director Fox Searchlight TIFF The CW ghosts Epix TV renewals adenture Paramount Plus jurassic park ABC Family PaleyFest Neflix BAFTA Showtime Election concert romance diversity ratings comedies HBO Go BET Awards women Black Mirror Polls and Games game of thrones Fall TV CBS All Access Nat Geo Tarantino harry potter TCA 2017 Premiere Dates mockumentary Funimation supernatural remakes Disney streaming service Geeked Week Walt Disney Pictures Shudder Freeform Black History Month Rock Rom-Com disaster PlayStation independent Kids & Family summer preview 72 Emmy Awards FXX Teen National Geographic know your critic blaxploitation dreamworks Extras name the review TCA Awards directors worst new zealand quibi 21st Century Fox Winter TV Paramount 2017 MCU Esquire Rocky Sundance TV breaking bad talk show YA FOX scorecard festivals Super Bowl toronto Ellie Kemper justice league nfl Calendar NBC Watching Series TNT Amazon Sony Pictures legend VICE james bond summer TV preview golden globes Turner vampires rotten movies we love period drama Best Actress Superheroe A&E CBS Netflix OneApp young adult TV Land sag awards strong female leads aapi biography Broadway Sneak Peek political drama finale Lucasfilm Dark Horse Comics OWN LGBT Apple sopranos Countdown Superheroes comic book movie Film action-comedy scary movies boxoffice Crackle Exclusive Video cancelled Comics on TV Mary Tyler Moore Rocketman Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Instagram Live cancelled television hispanic heritage month The Walking Dead South by Southwest Film Festival Indigenous DGA latino FX target Red Carpet telelvision 79th Golden Globes Awards E! black YouTube Red Comic-Con@Home 2021 Binge Guide Hear Us Out new york Pop TV Warner Bros. series spanish reviews RT21 superman Tokyo Olympics technology king arthur Lionsgate psychological thriller live event mission: impossible children's TV WarnerMedia 45 Alien nature archives Opinion X-Men boxing American Society of Cinematographers Disney Channel TV movies teaser GIFs saw Hallmark obituary Oscar MGM genre Starz Mindy Kaling Universal wonder woman aliens godzilla binge ABC Signature robots indiana jones universal monsters versus cars Syfy revenge APB discovery Holiday PBS news critic resources MTV book basketball Writers Guild of America true crime HBO joker MSNBC olympics Disney ID TV Valentine's Day Pet Sematary obi wan vs. docuseries Apple TV Plus comics canceled TV shows composers Baby Yoda travel IFC 71st Emmy Awards 2015 television YouTube Premium reboot 24 frames video SDCC fresh screen actors guild prank 93rd Oscars Trailer Certified Fresh halloween cops criterion black comedy NBA Pride Month E3 HBO Max Shondaland cooking Reality Competition A24 batman psycho 90s halloween tv hollywood Toys best comic spinoff marvel comics satire marvel cinematic universe 2019 San Diego Comic-Con RT History Travel Channel The Arrangement razzies BBC One foreign dogs Thanksgiving Family Oscars thriller DC Universe what to watch anthology screenings dramedy blockbusters Cosplay italian AMC Plus Interview TLC stand-up comedy films dexter kaiju football Discovery Channel Country social media king kong Star Trek cinemax Song of Ice and Fire New York Comic Con Ghostbusters Trophy Talk dark child's play adventure AMC 4/20 classics hidden camera japanese Star Wars Celebration stoner japan 2018 rotten The Witch dragons Hallmark Christmas movies zombies cancelled TV shows documentaries Netflix Christmas movies Fantasy hispanic CMT cancelled TV series scene in color film series IFC Films Anna Paquin emmy awards Christmas Wes Anderson Native docudrama Pacific Islander Fargo GoT IMDb TV Cartoon Network mob elevated horror The Walt Disney Company Disney Plus Fox News Legendary 20th Century Fox SXSW Summer Academy Awards hist Star Wars Turner Classic Movies high school scene in color series TBS Photos Focus Features rt labs 2016 Logo Television Critics Association romantic comedy gangster CNN tv talk Spring TV broadcast Winners south america transformers WGN asian-american scene in color Comic Book Nickelodeon free movies live action blockbuster History Drama lord of the rings crime thriller ITV Masterpiece 007 rt archives facebook superhero debate Heroines suspense a nightmare on elm street Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 73rd Emmy Awards Set visit movies streaming Grammys USA Network DC streaming service Image Comics Universal Pictures mutant TruTV Spike Vudu fast and furious TCA Winter 2020 Comedy Central streaming movies deadpool serial killer award winner BET Awards Food Network natural history FX on Hulu adaptation die hard Hollywood Foreign Press Association Prime Video documentary Adult Swim laika Mary poppins new star wars movies critics green book cats spy thriller slasher Marvel Television book adaptation Box Office rt labs critics edition Crunchyroll President french trailers BBC stop motion monster movies 1990s casting Ovation golden globe awards scary Marathons Mudbound interviews mcc police drama movie kids Animation Trivia See It Skip It Nominations comic books Captain marvel toy story canceled Emmys Best and Worst Film Festival Infographic Lifetime crossover NYCC Tomatazos El Rey unscripted Tubi posters franchise Amazon Prime 99% Pixar crime Cannes Endgame zero dark thirty Women's History Month Pirates Creative Arts Emmys ViacomCBS Reality space 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Awards Tour chucky sports animated Marvel Studios Spectrum Originals parents Sony video on demand art house Arrowverse Musicals Pop HFPA TV One Action Marvel Tumblr First Look game show Paramount Pictures comiccon sequel LGBTQ worst movies twilight spider-verse anime Year in Review war Music TCM Horror 2021 dc YouTube BBC America christmas movies based on movie international Peacock crime drama Elton John theme song medical drama Video Games Sci-Fi Character Guide singing competition rom-coms Amazon Prime Video streamig Mary Poppins Returns TCA politics cults 2020 Mystery Western cartoon richard e. Grant Martial Arts Quiz summer TV pirates of the caribbean witnail target scene in color DirecTV nbcuniversal Sundance Now Chernobyl slashers all-time Disney+ Disney Plus doctor who dceu 94th Oscars zombie royal family Sundance spain ESPN festival DC Comics Emmy Nominations indie feel good The Academy Comedy werewolf Best Picture biopic CW Seed Schedule GLAAD Television Academy Lifetime Christmas movies