Critical Consensus: Superheroes vs. the Supernatural

by | July 7, 2005 | Comments

This week’s wide releases share a concern for the agonies of the modern family. How does a single mother cope with leaky faucets that are harbingers of doom? How does a family of superheroes deal with its newfound powers and its place in an oversaturated media environment? How will the fraternity (and sorority) of movie critics respond to these dilemmas?

The comic/superhero genre has seen something of a resurgence lately. There’s the exhilaration of the "Spider-Man" films, the dark grittiness of "Batman Begins," the stylistic delights of "Sin City," and even the domestic woes of a super family in "The Incredibles." So where does that leave the "Fantastic Four?" In the dust, according to critics. The creation myth of Marvel’s oldest super-posse is, at 29 percent, less than, um, fantastic. The bar has been raised, and this silly throwback, with its lack of depth and clumsy script, is short on firepower. In fact, it’s one of the most poorly reviewed superhero movies of recent years. And that doesn’t help Jessica Alba, who stars as the Invisible Woman, as her Average Tomatometer is at 40 percent.

Scary dwelling? Check. Spooky child? Check? J-horror pedigree? Check. A-list credits in B-list material? Check. All of the hallmarks of recent horror cinema converge in "Dark Water," starring Jennifer Connelly as a woman who picks out an apartment with so much flooding it begs the question: can you get back your damage deposit if the supernatural is involved? This remake of the Japanese thriller of the same name is headed down the drain with the critics; at 45 percent on the Tomatometer, the scribes say this flick contains spooky atmospherics but is a bit too dull to be truly scary. And it doesn’t compare with "The Ring," still the critical high watermark in Hollywood’s recent glut of J-horror rehashes. Nor does it rise above Connelly’s Average Tomatometer of 65 percent.

Other American J-horror Flicks:
73% – The Ring (2002)
20% – The Ring 2 (2005)
39%- The Grudge (2004)

Other Recent Superhero Movies:
84% – Batman Begins (2005)
7% – Elektra (2005)
93% – Spider-Man 2 (2004)
97% – The Incredibles (2004)
79% – Hellboy (2004

Tag Cloud

zombies GIFs Awards Tour Comedy crime thriller Tarantino Shondaland ESPN Pixar FXX singing competition Shudder boxoffice Mary poppins Superheroes Nat Geo Disney Cosplay police drama mockumentary Universal golden globes Apple Cannes biography kids Extras YouTube Red Quiz Binge Guide Horror MSNBC streaming DirecTV cooking Film psycho Interview History Kids & Family Reality Tomatazos HBO Max TCM TV Land spider-man supernatural Podcast Countdown Mindy Kaling Starz Showtime VICE Animation Red Carpet Awards miniseries TIFF Syfy USA Network Spike war The Arrangement Disney Channel Country Rom-Com SDCC dc Certified Fresh Star Wars 20th Century Fox disaster theme song strong female leads 2019 Best and Worst comiccon binge Video Games Lucasfilm Disney streaming service composers Premiere Dates Black Mirror Columbia Pictures green book OWN PBS Amazon Prime movies Logo Comic Book discovery TBS VH1 serial killer award winner Freeform Opinion Stephen King thriller Britbox Super Bowl Bravo Amazon Prime Video medical drama Oscars adventure Paramount dragons Ovation Fantasy Nominations festivals Winners YA Marathons BBC America Rocketman San Diego Comic-Con BET Adult Swim Thanksgiving based on movie political drama Emmys Nickelodeon game show finale IFC Films Christmas Summer crossover Pirates Superheroe Pop crime Amazon ITV Drama Warner Bros. American Society of Cinematographers LGBT Ghostbusters The CW animated Acorn TV CW Seed Captain marvel Crackle El Rey what to watch Sony Pictures tv talk spy thriller DC Universe dceu Holidays toy story Netflix The Witch IFC Tumblr zombie GoT Song of Ice and Fire Mystery MTV DGA See It Skip It ABC space cinemax unscripted true crime Paramount Network Dark Horse Comics Music Sundance elevated horror Winter TV adaptation Grammys Character Guide President 007 vampires Trophy Talk Election NBC TNT USA GLAAD ABC Family SXSW 2017 Photos 2015 Comedy Central TCA Marvel RT History Epix spinoff PaleyFest Toys anthology Rocky 45 cars Sneak Peek social media Brie Larson politics science fiction Polls and Games NYCC harry potter Musicals LGBTQ WGN Walt Disney Pictures Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dramedy TV 2018 CNN Schedule First Look Mary Tyler Moore Teen Martial Arts Western Chilling Adventures of Sabrina justice league mutant Lionsgate Family period drama travel hist 24 frames Watching Series BBC Reality Competition Spring TV docudrama Rock nature quibi ratings Fox News technology FX Pride Month anime comic casting cats CBS All Access Spectrum Originals Food Network Sci-Fi zero dark thirty richard e. Grant CBS Valentine's Day 21st Century Fox Masterpiece revenge television Set visit aliens WarnerMedia Infographic Film Festival children's TV E3 book TruTV Writers Guild of America cops Trailer 2016 Elton John X-Men facebook Mudbound blaxploitation SundanceTV cults E! DC streaming service HBO ghosts Box Office Sundance Now Comics on TV teaser A&E sports Mary Poppins Returns National Geographic Lifetime RT21 psychological thriller Women's History Month historical drama Esquire Action transformers Pet Sematary series Ellie Kemper Vudu Chernobyl Calendar Emmy Nominations diversity TCA 2017 Trivia Heroines robots CMT sitcom doctor who DC Comics Star Trek Anna Paquin crime drama New York Comic Con MCU AMC talk show Biopics Creative Arts Emmys FOX romance sequel Hulu Musical jamie lee curtis APB TLC YouTube Premium Fall TV Year in Review natural history Cartoon Network witnail