Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Bucket Gets Kicked, The Orphanage is Certified Fresh, In the Name of the King Not Screened

Also: Kite Runner flies reasonably high, Veggietales fairly tasty, First Sunday has sinned.

by | January 10, 2008 | Comments

This week
at the movies, we’ve got two wild and
crazy guys (The Bucket
, starring
Jack Nicholson
and Morgan Freeman),
pious crooks (First Sunday, starring
Ice Cube and
Tracy Morgan), botanical
buccaneers (The Pirates Who Don’t Do Anything: A Veggietales Movie),
haunted expatriates (The
Kite Runner
), tormented mothers (The
), and Uwe Boll (In
the Name of the King: A Dungeon Siege Tale
, starring
Jason Statham
and Burt
). What do the critics have to say?

How can a
movie directed by Rob Reiner and starring
Jack Nicholson and Morgan Freeman
possibly fail? If, say critics, it has a really contrived, sappy script, which
is the problem with
The Bucket List
Nicholson and Freeman star as a couple of sixtysomethings who, after discovering they each have terminal
illnesses, team up to do all the living they can in the time they have left —
in the form of skydiving and tattoo-getting, among other things. Pundits say the
two stars give it their all, but they’re undercut by a predictable plot that
overdoses on schmaltz. At 44 percent on the Tomatometer, Bucket probably
shouldn’t top your list.

"I never would’ve put strip solitaire on my list."

Ice Cube


Tracy Morgan
are talented people. Unfortunately, critics say their despite
their combined ability to generate intermittent chuckles, they’re unable to save

First Sunday. The film is a tale of two incompetent crooks who contrive a
plot to rob the local house of worship. However, their plan goes awry rather
quickly, and the pair has a crisis of faith. Pundits say First Sunday has
its moments, but it’s ultimately undone by a script that lacks nuance and
consistency; others aren’t buying the sentimentality of the last act. At 25
percent on the Tomatometer, First Sunday might need to do penance.

Ice Cube in the first Sunday the Friday after next.

Fear not,

The Pirates Who Don’t Do Anything: A Veggietales Movie
no plank-walking, keel-hauling, or bottles of rum. But guess what? Critics say
it’s clever enough to keep you entertained. The latest in Christian animation’s
most venerable franchise since
Davey and Goliath
, Pirates follows
the comic misadventures of Larry the Cucumber, Mr.
Lunt and Pa Grape, as they are transported from their humdrum lives back in time
to the days of William Kidd — and trouble on the high seas. Pundits say while Pirates,
may be several cuts below
, it’s sweet and inoffensive, with a
positive message and some good laughs.
At 67 percent on the Tomatometer,
this Pirates‘ life may not be for everyone, but at least it won’t make
you want to mutiny.

"We’re off to see the Eggplant Wizard!"

Khaled Hosseini
‘s novel


Kite Runner
drew widespread praise for its tale of
youngsters living through a tumultuous period in Afghani history. And critics
say Marc Forster’s big-screen adaptation does a reasonably good job of
translating the book’s sweep — while still taking some liberties. Kite
stars Zekiria Ebrahimi and
Ahmad Khan Mahmoodzada as two youngsters who survive both the Soviet invasion and the rise
of the Taliban — albeit with some pretty heavy emotional baggage. The scribes
say Forster gets some great performances from his child actors, and captures the
visual beauty of the war-torn land. But some say the film doesn’t quite have the
same impact as the novel, dialing up some of the big emotions while skimping on
nuance. Still, at 65 percent on the Tomatometer, this Kite flies
reasonably high. (Check out our interviews
here and

"Take dictation, please. Possible candidates for kite flying

If you
feel the fine art of cinematic suspense has drowned in a sea of gore, critics
say you’re in for a treat with

The Orphanage
. Produced by
Guillermo del Toro, The Orphanage follows Laura (Belén
) and Carlos (Fernando Cayo) , the adoptive parents of Simon (Roger
Príncep), an orphan suffering from HIV. The boy has a host of imaginary friends,
and what he says about them starts sounding pretty sinister. The scribes say
Juan Antonio Bayona‘s film is loaded with dread and spooky atmospherics, but it
also succeeds as a heart-wrenching psychological portrait. At 85 percent on the
Tomatometer, The Orphanage is Certified Fresh. (Check out our interview
with Bayona and screenwriter Sergio Sanchez
here and our review from Cannes

"Oh, crap, I didn’t mean to screen Manos, the Hands of

Yes, Uwe
Boll, everyone’s favorite critical pariah, has a new movie out:

In the Name of the King: A Dungeon Siege Tale
. No it wasn’t screened for critics. But
what did you expect, given the fact that the man’s career Tomatometer is at five
percent? Critics don’t really dig him, especially the one he knocked out. Dungeon

Jason Statham
Ray Liotta,
Leelee Sobieski,

, and
Matthew Lillard in a tale of a regular guy who must do battle with beasts
conjured by an evil sorcerer; swordplay no doubt ensues. Hey kids, stop laying
siege to that dungeon and guess the Tomatometer! (And read our [qualified]
defense of Mr. Boll’s work in this week’s Total Recall.)

Just pretend it’s your agent, Jason.

opening this week in limited release:

  • Liberty Kid
    , a drama about the
    after-effects of 9/11 on several blue-collar New Yorkers, is at 100 percent on
    the Tomatometer.

  • Hong Sang-soo‘s
    Woman on the Beach
    , a subtle rom-com
    about a filmmaker with writer’s block, is at 94 percent.

  • The Business of
    Being Born
    , a documentary about several couples and their experiences with
    childbirth, is at 71 percent.

  • The Turkish import
    Times and Winds
    a deceptively simple tale of three youngsters coming of age in a small village,
    is at 73 percent.

It looks like Anne Geddes is going in a more avant garde direction.

props to
tabascoman77, both for boldly announcing that
One Missed Call

would end up at zero percent on the Tomatometer, and for his excellent taste in
hot sauce. Personally, I like the garlic Tabasco, but that’s just me.

Morgan Freeman Movies:
93% — Gone Baby Gone (2007)
42% — Feast of Love (2007)
24% — Evan Almighty (2007)
62% — 10 Items or Less (2006)
52% — Lucky # Slevin (2006) 

Uwe Boll
4% — BloodRayne (2006)
1% — Alone in the Dark (2005)
4% — House of the Dead (2003)
11% — Blackwoods (2002)

Tag Cloud

CNN 2018 period drama Awards dragons Creative Arts Emmys ITV Reality doctor who Summer Logo composers Martial Arts docudrama Shudder Awards Tour unscripted casting DC streaming service A&E Red Carpet YA Heroines Black Mirror Character Guide YouTube Red Lifetime FX TV Land political drama TLC PaleyFest Tarantino aliens comic Starz Infographic Ghostbusters Nat Geo cults talk show Emmys FXX Podcast APB sitcom natural history facebook historical drama transformers Epix miniseries President CW Seed Animation Paramount Network thriller Star Trek Elton John Super Bowl TruTV American Society of Cinematographers Comic Book disaster Chernobyl politics Shondaland Bravo Showtime CMT Pirates Western Disney Channel ESPN Pride Month Biopics Captain marvel travel supernatural Music WGN social media MSNBC SDCC SundanceTV Christmas Brie Larson Sneak Peek Nickelodeon Horror crime drama The Arrangement cops mutant Trophy Talk 2017 Sci-Fi Crackle IFC PBS TCA 2017 TNT DC Comics MTV Paramount ABC RT History Song of Ice and Fire robots Comedy Central television 21st Century Fox Syfy discovery E3 Netflix Premiere Dates X-Men hist History zombie crossover Calendar The CW theme song Polls and Games Spring TV OWN Emmy Nominations finale singing competition elevated horror Rocketman anthology The Witch spider-man Rocky E! 45 vampires cinemax Musicals psycho BBC America TIFF 2019 FOX Quiz science fiction comiccon New York Comic Con Food Network Tomatazos Cosplay Photos GIFs El Rey Musical police drama Women's History Month game show Fall TV Pet Sematary DC Universe BBC LGBTQ Fox News jamie lee curtis CBS All Access Anna Paquin strong female leads space crime thriller ABC Family Disney serial killer Tumblr Pop Reality Competition First Look Superheroe witnail biography cooking Video Games sports GLAAD Cannes Countdown VICE true crime ratings DGA BET See It Skip It Interview 2015 Mudbound Ellie Kemper Lionsgate Certified Fresh Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Stephen King Star Wars Schedule Opinion Drama teaser zero dark thirty NYCC Marathons cats Mary Poppins Returns what to watch 20th Century Fox award winner Best and Worst blaxploitation Superheroes animated Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Spike crime dramedy Amazon Prime mockumentary Oscars USA Network Warner Bros. based on movie Winter TV Columbia Pictures Set visit 24 frames Nominations Pixar San Diego Comic-Con DirecTV Year in Review Trailer RT21 Hulu AMC spinoff dceu Valentine's Day toy story binge streaming CBS Apple Amazon psychological thriller National Geographic SXSW war Acorn TV Thanksgiving technology sequel green book NBC medical drama TCM Extras Kids & Family Adult Swim Film Festival Vudu Box Office Comedy anime Rock Grammys Mystery WarnerMedia Winners adventure Trivia Cartoon Network Teen richard e. Grant 007 Britbox Election TBS harry potter LGBT YouTube Premium TCA Esquire Toys boxoffice Action adaptation Mindy Kaling HBO USA Sundance Now Dark Horse Comics Masterpiece golden globes VH1 Sony Pictures spy thriller 2016 Holidays justice league Spectrum Originals romance Fantasy Lucasfilm zombies diversity Walt Disney Pictures Ovation Writers Guild of America dc Watching Series Marvel Universal IFC Films nature Country Freeform Rom-Com TV GoT Mary poppins Comics on TV Sundance Mary Tyler Moore HBO Max MCU festivals